New York City Council
Committee on Criminal Justice
Mar 08, 2024
·
10:00 AM
6 hr 37 min
Summary
A hearing on Fiscal 2025 preliminary budget focusing on criminal justice, focused on budgets for the Department of Probation and the Department of Correction. Discussions include alternatives to incarceration, inconsistencies in agency testimony, increased youth incarceration rates, staffing levels and overtime concerns at DOC, and plans for Rikers Island's closure by 2027. Features testimony from the NYC Department of Probation, Department of Correction, Board of Correction, community and advocacy groups, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Sandy Nurse Opens Fiscal 2025 Preliminary Budget Hearing on Criminal Justice
Council Member Sandy Nurse chairs the Fiscal 2025 preliminary budget hearing on criminal justice, focusing on budget proposals and their alignment with closing Rikers Island. - Nurse welcomes participants, including …
0:00:38
·
9 min
Juanita Holmes, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Probation, on the Department's Contributions, Challenges, and Future Plans
Juanita Holmes outlines the Department of Probation's strategies for alternatives to incarceration, efforts to combat gun violence, and plans to support vulnerable populations. - Holmes discusses the Department of Probation's …
0:15:41
·
17 min
What DOP services are underutilized and how many participants attended the Arches program in the last year?
The Deputy Commissioner agrees to provide details on participation in the Arches program, indicating ongoing analysis of service utilization and participation levels. - The Arches program was adjusted from operating …
0:33:29
·
77 sec
What are the reasons for underutilization of the NYC Department of Probation’s programs and what steps are being taken to improve engagement?
The NYC Department of Probation identifies lack of engagement and compliance as major issues in program utilization, introducing virtual reality as a solution. - Participants' low compliance and engagement levels …
0:34:48
·
173 sec
How are credible messengers integrated, and what is the approach to probation program compliance?
The New York City Department of Probation integrates credible messengers into their programs and seeks to avoid penalizing noncompliance strictly to encourage participation. - Credible messengers are being trained and …
0:37:41
·
61 sec
Why was the Impact program canceled, and what services are affected?
The Impact program was canceled because it was never utilized, lacked awareness among deputy commissioners, had no clients, yet incurred $300,000 in administrative fees for staffing without getting off the …
0:38:43
·
3 min
What kinds of analysis did the department conduct to determine whether programs with overlapping services are redundant? Were cost/benefit analyses involved?
Commissioner Juanita Holmes reveals that no cost benefit analysis is conducted for evaluating programs; the decision to cancel the Next Steps program was based on lack of performance indicators, not …
0:42:24
·
98 sec
Are there success indicators described in the contracts for New York City Department of Probation's programs?
Council Member Sandy Nurse questions the absence of defined success indicators in the contracts for programs managed by the New York City Department of Probation and expresses interest in reviewing …
0:44:01
·
103 sec
What improvements are observed with the policy mandating probation officers to carry firearms?
Commissioner Juanita Holmes highlights the enforcement, rather than improvements, of the firearms carry policy for probation officers, emphasizing safety and proactivity. - Holmes clarifies she did not implement the policy …
0:46:26
·
80 sec
What data exists on injuries or fatalities during probation officers' inspections, and has there been a mandate for firearm carrying?
Commissioner Holmes confirms there have been no line-of-duty deaths among probation officers, with some non-life-threatening injuries reported, and discusses the firearms carrying policy. - No line-of-duty deaths have been reported …
0:47:46
·
72 sec
Are probation officers required to carry firearms during all duties, and is consideration given to requests for non-uniformed appearances without firearms?
Probation officers have the flexibility to cover their firearms and use locked boxes for security to create a comfortable environment, amidst discussions on their attire and armed presence. - Probation …
0:48:59
·
118 sec
Why hasn't Neighborhood Opportunity Network (NeON) launched and has an RFP been issued for it?
The Department of Probation explains that Neighborhood Opportunity Network (NeON) hasn't launched because the issued RFP received no responses, and they are now targeting specific vendors. - An RFP for …
0:50:58
·
53 sec
What support is available for homeless New Yorkers on probation?
The Department of Probation identifies 300 homeless individuals on probation and collaborates with third-party facilities for housing and programs. - 55 of the homeless probationers are specifically identified for further …
0:52:06
·
92 sec
What are the impacts of closing state correctional facilities on the Department of Probation and Rikers' population?
Juanita Holmes acknowledges that closing state correctional facilities may increase community supervision needs and necessitates a larger probation workforce. - Holmes is planning for a larger Department of Probation workforce …
0:53:39
·
102 sec
How does the salary impact the hiring and retention of non-supervisory probation officers?
Commissioner Juanita Holmes states that while hiring non-supervisory probation officers is not hindered by salary concerns due to a smooth hiring process and high candidate enthusiasm, salary does affect staff …
0:55:22
·
57 sec
How does the NYC Department of Probation address gun violence and support individuals involved?
The New York City Department of Probation focuses on individuals involved in gun violence by providing specialized supervision, vocational training, and addressing their fundamental needs. - Dedicated branches are established …
0:56:20
·
3 min
How is the policy on probation officers carrying firearms discussed and justified?
The conversation explores the enforcement and necessity of probation officers carrying firearms, highlighting a re-evaluation of the policy after two decades. - Jumaane Williams questions the message sent by equating …
0:59:43
·
6 min
How does the New York City Department of Probation gather feedback from young people ?
The New York City Department of Probation uses surveys to gather feedback from young people and is introducing a new technology platform called Mobile DOP to enhance communication and program …
1:07:33
·
4 min
Why was the STEPs program without evaluations and success indicators in the RFP, and why is attendance considered a valid metric?
Council Member Althea Stevens expresses concern over the STEPs program's RFP lacking evaluations and success indicators, emphasizing the importance of even minimal metrics like attendance for engaging hard-to-reach youth. - …
1:11:35
·
141 sec
Did the NYC Department of Probation direct staff to issue violations for youth not attending school or working?
Commissioner Juanita Holmes clarifies that there was no directive to issue violations to youth for not attending school or working, and emphasizes on solution-oriented programming. - Holmes dispels the claim …
1:14:05
·
130 sec
Why are more children being sent to juvenile detention under Mayor Adams' tenure, and what role does the Department of Probation (DOP) play?
The number of children in detention has doubled under Mayor Adams' tenure, raising concerns about the Department of Probation's (DOP) role in this increase. - Lincoln Restler highlights the increase …
1:16:42
·
101 sec
Why are funds being cut from alternative to incarceration programs, leading to increased expenditure on youth incarceration?
Council Member Lincoln Restler questions Commissioner Juanita Holmes about budget cuts to alternative to incarceration programs and the subsequent increase in youth incarceration costs. - Council Member Restler raises concerns …
1:18:24
·
5 min
What are the future plans for the terminated 'Next Steps' and 'Impact' programs by the Department of Probation?
The Department of Probation terminated 'Next Steps' and did not launch 'Impact', while exploring alternatives and realizing the potential for reevaluation. - 'Next Steps' contract was not renewed, and 'Impact' …
1:24:23
·
177 sec
What are the program budget figures for future fiscal years and why is there a decrease?
The budget for agency programs in upcoming fiscal years exhibits a reduction, but funds are reallocated to maintain program funding levels. - For FY 2024, the budget is $21,400,000; it …
1:27:31
·
54 sec
What is the recidivism rate for young people and adults in NYC according to the Department of Probation?
The recidivism rates provided by the Department of Probation (DOP) for young people and adults are 27% and 20.29% respectively. - Young people have a recidivism rate of 27%. - …
1:28:25
·
23 sec
What percentage of New York City Department of Probation’s caseload are NYCHA residents, and what programs are provided to prevent them from entering the criminal justice system?
The New York City Department of Probation discusses the provision of programs for NYCHA residents to prevent them from entering the criminal justice system but commits to providing detailed information …
1:28:49
·
151 sec
What are the new needs for staffing and programs at the Department of Probation (DOP)?
The Department of Probation (DOP) requires additional staff and programming to manage increased caseloads effectively. - Currently, the DOP operates with 423 probation officers, down from 694 in 2019. - …
1:31:20
·
64 sec
What are the goals for reducing recidivism and what support is needed?
The NYC Department of Probation aims for a 50% reduction in recidivism, acknowledging the challenge and necessity for structured programs and support. - Commissioner Holmes states a realistic goal is …
1:32:24
·
57 sec
How is the Department of Probation collaborating with other agencies for youth programs, and what is the overlap of youth participation across these programs?
Council Member Althea Stevens queries about the collaboration between the Department of Probation and other agencies regarding program offerings for youth, emphasizing the need for holistic planning and tracking of …
1:33:50
·
4 min
Council Member Sandy Nurse opens panel discussion on the Department of Corrections
Council Member Sandy Nurse inaugurates a panel discussion with the new Department of Corrections Commissioner. - Nurse begins by suggesting introductions to understand the backgrounds and reasons for the participants’ …
1:57:29
·
36 sec
Council Member Adrienne E. Adams' remarks on Department of Corrections
Council Member Adrienne E. Adams welcomes new Department of Correction Commissioner, Lynelle McGidley, and emphasizes the need for a safer environment in city jails. - Adams celebrates McGidley's appointment and …
1:58:15
·
154 sec
Lynelle Maginley-Liddie, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Correction on Comprehensive Plans and Budget for Fiscal Year 2025
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie presents the New York City Department of Correction's preliminary budget for fiscal year 2025, emphasizing reform and a humane approach. - Discusses agency's vision and leadership team's …
2:01:55
·
15 min
What is the Department of Correction's vision for prioritizing budgetary resources in addressing staff management, violence, safety, and transitioning to borough-based jails?
The New York City Department of Correction outlines strategies for staffing, violence reduction, and programming as part of prioritizing budgetary resources. - Strategies include deploying staff efficiently, reducing overtime and …
2:18:38
·
13 min
What are the recognized needs from the population based on programming sessions and how is the Department of Correction addressing them?
The New York City Department of Correction is expanding programs based on the population's request for more transitional planning, enrichment activities, and services. - Transitional planning is identified as a …
2:32:30
·
159 sec
How does the NYC Department of Correction plan to address supervision issues amid Captain rank vacancies?
The NYC Department of Correction is implementing robust training for Captains and ensuring 24/7 coverage to mitigate supervision issues due to many Captain rank vacancies. - The department is evaluating …
2:35:10
·
117 sec
What is the current ratio of captains to officers?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie acknowledges not having the current ratio of captains to officers available but commits to providing it later. - Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie is unable to provide the current …
2:37:07
·
10 sec
What is the desired ratio for the New York City Department of Correction?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie of the New York City Department of Correction does not have the desired ratio information at the time of inquiry. - Council Member Adrienne E. Adams asks …
2:37:18
·
7 sec
Has the Department of Correction planned changes to accommodate the new law banning solitary confinement?
The Department of Correction is currently reviewing the new guidance from the federal monitor in accordance with the law department. - The department is actively working with the law department …
2:38:00
·
30 sec
Why are there no changes in the capital commitment plan for 2024-2028 despite Borough-based jail project delays and cost increases?
Assistant Commissioner Alex Maldonado explains that the Department of Design and Construction oversees the budget and schedule for Borough-based jail projects, hence their details are not reflected in the capital …
2:38:36
·
65 sec
Should questions about updated commitments in the executive plan be directed to the Department of Design and Construction (DDC)?
Alex Maldonado confirms that questions regarding updates to commitments in the executive plan should be directed to the DDC. - Council Member Adrienne E. Adams questions if inquiries about the …
2:39:43
·
12 sec
How is the administration ensuring borough-based jails capital projects are completed on time, within budget, and legally?
The administration collaborates with partner agencies and establishes an internal transition team to ensure borough-based jails capital projects are delivered efficiently and compliantly. - Collaboration with lead partner agencies including …
2:39:57
·
33 sec
What is the design completion status for the Brooklyn Borough Jail?
The design for the Brooklyn Borough Jail is approximately 50% complete. - Assistant Commissioner Alex Maldonado indicates the project is midway through the design phase. - Renderings of the Brooklyn …
2:40:31
·
17 sec
Has a staffing analysis been conducted for the jail based on current designs?
A staffing analysis for the Brooklyn jail is planned to be completed in the next month now that the design development has reached approximately 50%. - The question about staffing …
2:40:48
·
25 sec
Are you aware that there's been a missed deadline this week to report on court transportation stats?
Lynelle Maginley-Liddie, the Commissioner of the New York City Department of Correction, was not aware of a missed deadline but committed to addressing the issue immediately. - Lynelle Maginley-Liddie commits …
2:41:42
·
13 sec
How is mental illness addressed in NYC jails, and what is the relationship between mental illness and violence among the inmate population?
Upon intake into NYC jails, individuals undergo an assessment by clinicians to discuss any mental health issues, which determines their appropriate housing and treatment, with a focus on addressing the …
2:42:18
·
7 min
What percentage of violent offenders are associated with mental health issues?
The NYC Department of Corrections does not have immediate statistics on the percentage of violent offenders associated with mental health issues but promises to acquire the information. - Council Member …
2:50:17
·
28 sec
Why does the New York City Department of Correction's budget show stable growth despite operational challenges?
The Department of Correction plans to maintain a stable budget through savings from operating below authorized headcount and reducing overtime. - The department's budget remains relatively flat year over year. …
2:50:49
·
71 sec
When will the budget reflect new units of appropriation added at adoption?
The budget already reflects the council's requested realignment, including new units of appropriation. - The budget has been adjusted as per the council's request. - New units of appropriation are …
2:52:14
·
24 sec
Why are staff allocated to a decommissioned jail, and is the 307 staff number accurate?
Staff are maintained at a decommissioned jail for fire watch and to prevent the building from becoming a blight, but the accuracy of the 307 staff number is in question. …
2:52:59
·
67 sec
Why does the preliminary plan show a budgeted headcount of 1111 staff for AMKC despite its closure?
The council member inquires about the budgeted headcount for AMKC, a now-closed facility, and requests clarification on the staff allocations. - The preliminary plan includes a budgeted headcount of 1111 …
2:54:06
·
85 sec
Why are there fewer assigned headcounts in Brooklyn and Manhattan compared to the Bronx despite their higher case loads?
Council Member Sandy Nurse questions the rationale behind the distribution of headcounts across boroughs, highlighting the discrepancy in assigned individuals despite case load differences. Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie promises to investigate …
2:55:32
·
51 sec
Why does the budget allocate 122 training academy staff, including 110 officers, at a cost of $13 million?
The budget allocates 122 training academy staff, including 110 officers, at a cost of $13 million to provide ongoing training to all 6000 uniform staff members, not just recruits. - …
2:56:23
·
109 sec
How is the NYC Department of Correction addressing the impact of recent budget cuts on its programming and staff?
The NYC Department of Correction discusses the impact of recent budget cuts on programming and staff, outlining efforts to mitigate these effects and plans for the future. - The department …
2:58:12
·
5 min
What are the costs and benefits of new training and RFP programs for the Department of Corrections?
The New York City Department of Correction continues its staff training programs and introduces new education-focused initiatives costing $14 million. - Training is ongoing for the Division of Programs and …
3:03:17
·
3 min
Was there any engagement in conversations regarding new needs with pre-existing contract holders, and what are the planning phases for the $14 million grant?
The New York City Department of Correction clarifies that there have been no conversations about new needs with pre-existing contract holders and shares plans for the utilization of a recently …
3:06:50
·
68 sec
How is the NYC Department of Correction addressing service gaps and promoting program participation?
The NYC Department of Correction is implementing strategies to promote program participation, including advertising and assigning executive directors to lead program teams for improved operations and communication. - Advertising efforts …
3:07:59
·
148 sec
What are the current vacancy numbers within the Department of Corrections (DOC)?
The Department of Corrections (DOC) reports a total of 1153 vacancies, including both civilian and uniformed positions, as per the current plan. - Department of Corrections (DOC) has 220 civilian …
3:10:27
·
72 sec
What are the current statistics on chronic absences?
The Department of Corrections struggles to provide immediate statistics on chronic absences when questioned by a council member. - Deputy Commissioner Mala Srinivasan is unable to provide immediate details on …
3:11:40
·
69 sec
What are the current strategies for addressing chronic absences among NYC Department of Corrections staff?
The NYC Department of Corrections has implemented strategies to significantly reduce chronic staff absences, achieving an 80% reduction. - Currently, 362 staff members are reported as out sick, with 200 …
3:12:48
·
3 min
Is the NYC Department of Correction considering childcare facilities for employees with different shift patterns?
The New York City Department of Correction is exploring the possibility of introducing childcare facilities for its employees, following a survey on staff needs. - Council Member Gale A. Brewer …
3:16:22
·
83 sec
How is the 98% compliance rate for court transportation calculated, and does it consider refusals?
The 98% compliance rate for court transportation includes individuals who refuse transport, attributing to the department’s collaboration with the Office of Court Administration (OCA) and the use of a tracking …
3:17:45
·
92 sec
Why might some individuals not want to go to court?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie suggests reasons vary for individuals' reluctance to attend court, including the desire to avoid case progression. - Commissioner suggests the reasons for refusing to attend court are …
3:19:17
·
23 sec
What is the budget for food in the correctional facility, and are there plans for in-house meal preparation?
The Department of Corrections' food budget is expected to rise to $23,000,000 due to increasing food prices and population. Deputy Commissioner Srinivasan discusses funding plans and the feasibility of in-house …
3:19:46
·
100 sec
How are meals prepared for court appearances and what efforts are being made towards scratch cooking in correctional facilities?
The NYC Department of Corrections provides meals for court appearances and is working towards scratch cooking, with training for cooks to begin in April. - Meals for court appearances include …
3:21:26
·
119 sec
What is the cost allocation for mental health staff in the correctional system?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie confirms that the cost for mental health staff in the correctional system is solely allocated under correctional health services. - Council Member Gale A. Brewer inquires about …
3:23:53
·
29 sec
How do NYC Department of Correction facilities monitor and address mental health challenges?
The NYC Department of Correction, in collaboration with Correctional Health Services, employs various mental health professionals and provides staff training, effectively addressing mental health challenges within the system. - Correctional …
3:24:22
·
165 sec
What is the current status and future plans for the Unionist consent decree?
The New York City Department of Correction is working towards terminating the Unionist consent decree, emphasizing efforts to ensure jails are safe and humane. - The Department recently resolved a …
3:27:07
·
66 sec
Has the New York City Department of Correction faced staff or resource shortages for programming and medical escorts?
The New York City Department of Correction acknowledges experiencing staff or resource shortages that have impacted the provision of escorts for medical appointments and programming activities. - Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie …
3:28:23
·
69 sec
How many facilities does a uniform warden oversee in the Department of Correction?
Assistant commissioners or wardens oversee all Department of Correction facilities, with no specific number of facilities mentioned for an individual warden. - Assistant commissioners of operations or wardens oversee the …
3:29:42
·
32 sec
What is the 6A program's process for selecting and reviewing individuals for potential early release?
First Deputy Commissioner Francis Torres explains the 6A program's process for reviewing and selecting individuals for potential early release, based on their criminal history, conduct, and needs. - The 6A …
3:30:34
·
129 sec
What is the number of reviewed women and gender nonconforming individuals?
First Deputy Commissioner Francisco Torres commits to follow-up on the inquiry regarding the number of reviewed women and gender nonconforming individuals. - Council Member Althea Stevens inquires about the number …
3:32:43
·
11 sec
Why hasn't the administration expanded the release process under the 6 day rule?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie explains that the Department is reviewing the use of the 6 day release process and remains in communication with the FTC about potential releases. - The council …
3:32:56
·
26 sec
Is the Department of Corrections supportive and committed to the therapeutic outpost units' investment and timeline?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie confirms the Department of Corrections' support and commitment to the project and its timeline. - Council Member Lincoln Restler inquires about the department's support and commitment towards …
3:34:07
·
24 sec
What percentage of Rikers Island’s population has serious mental health issues, and is it a record high?
The deputy commissioner for health affairs indicates 52-54% of Rikers Island's inmates have mental health issues, but he is uncertain if this is a record high. - The percentage of …
3:34:34
·
3 min
What measures are being implemented to ensure access to minimum standards in New York City correctional facilities?
The New York City Department of Correction is developing an audit protocol to ensure access to minimum standards, addressing urgent health and safety concerns. - The Department of Correction is …
3:37:47
·
68 sec
What is the policy for assessing Department of Correction (DOC) staff absence over 40 days?
The Department of Correction Commissioners discuss a new policy for evaluating officer absences exceeding 40 days due to chronic absenteeism. - Acknowledges the new policy addressing staff absences beyond 40 …
3:38:55
·
107 sec
What has been the change in the city-sentenced population at Rikers Island since the mayor took office, and what actions are taken to manage it?
The New York City Department of Correction (DOC) is regularly reviewing and assessing each case to use their authority to reduce unnecessary incarceration, responding to a threefold increase in the …
3:40:43
·
69 sec
Lincoln Restler criticizes the mayoral administration's decision to halt reentry programs for former inmates when the council offered to pay for it
Lincoln Restler criticizes the mayoral administration's decision to halt reentry programs for former inmates, emphasizing its detrimental aftermath. - Restler highlights that the council offered funding for reentry programming, which …
3:41:52
·
74 sec
What is the average duration individuals remain at Rikers after sentencing before transferring upstate?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie of the New York City Department of Correction does not have the data on hand regarding the duration inmates remain at Rikers Island post-sentencing, promising a follow-up. …
3:43:13
·
23 sec
What is the average duration individuals stay at Rikers after being found not competent to stand trial before transfer to state mental hospitals?
The Department of Correction needs to follow up with more data regarding the average duration individuals stay at Rikers Island after being found not competent to stand trial before their …
3:43:43
·
12 sec
Does the Department have updated operating plans and staffing analysis?
The New York City Department of Corrections uses an operating table of organization to determine staffing needs based on the number of persons in custody and facility infrastructure. - Council …
3:44:04
·
60 sec
What is the Smart Unit launched by the New York City Department of Correction?
The Smart Unit, already established by the New York City Department of Correction, functions as a schedule management and redeployment team. - The Smart Unit generates weekly schedules for facilities …
3:45:05
·
71 sec
How long has the smart unit been operational?
The smart unit has been operational for no more than a year. - Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie states the unit is fairly recent. - Assistant Chief Sherrie Rembert specifies the unit …
3:46:16
·
11 sec
Why is there a reduction in overtime funding for fiscal year 2024 despite historical underbudgeting?
The Department of Correction plans to reduce overtime funding for fiscal year 2024 by implementing initiatives to lower staffing needs and enhance savings through accruals. - Deputy Commissioner Mala Srinivasan …
3:46:30
·
64 sec
Is there a correlation between the increase in Personnel Services (PS) spending and the peg reducing Expenses and Personal Services (EPS) by $30,900,000, and the overtime reduction?
The council member receives an affirmative response to the inquiry about a correlation between increases in Personnel Services (PS) spending, a $30,900,000 peg reduction in Expenses and Personal Services (EPS), …
3:47:33
·
13 sec
What are the plans to incentivize staff for housing area work in correction facilities?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie indicates discussions are ongoing with the federal monitor about staffing incentives. - Discussions about incentivizing staff, including shift adjustments, are continuing. - A proposal on staffing incentives …
3:47:47
·
33 sec
What is being done to address the laundry issues in custody facilities?
Commissioner Lynelle Maginley-Liddie acknowledges challenges with laundry services in custody facilities and outlines steps to address them. - The Department of Correction is investigating the functionality of washers and dryers …
3:48:21
·
72 sec
What is the fiscal 2025 budget for laundry services in New York City jails?
The Deputy Commissioner agrees to provide details on the fiscal 2025 budget for laundry services in New York City jails. - Council Member Sandy Nurse inquires about the fiscal 2025 …
3:49:33
·
22 sec
What measures is the Department of Correction (DOC) implementing to prevent deaths in custody?
The Department of Correction (DOC) outlines numerous actions and training initiatives aimed at preventing future deaths in custody. - DOC has increased training for officers in using NARCAN and CPR. …
3:50:11
·
3 min
How is the NYC Department of Corrections ensuring adequate staffing and adherence to protocols in jails?
The NYC Department of Corrections conducts thorough investigations after jail deaths, disciplines officers for not conducting meaningful tours, and runs an observation aid program to improve staffing and protocol adherence. …
3:53:21
·
98 sec
What details and concerns are raised regarding the tablets provided to incarcerated individuals, including their funding and privacy safeguards?
Council Member Gale A. Brewer inquires about the contract value, duration and privacy concerns regarding tablets provided to incarcerated individuals. The annual contract value with Securus is $5,400,000, ending at …
3:55:52
·
140 sec
How is the Department of Correction addressing issues with chemical agent use highlighted in a recent report?
The Department of Correction is currently reviewing a report on chemical agent use and plans to detail its response at an upcoming Board of Correction hearing. - The report documents …
3:58:20
·
97 sec
Are officers required to wear body worn cameras, and what actions are taken if they don't?
Officers are required to wear body worn cameras, and failure to do so is addressed as a training issue. - Council Member Sandy Nurse highlights a report showing fewer than …
3:59:58
·
34 sec
What is the cost of settling misconduct cases for FY23, and do any projections exist for FY24 and FY25?
The Department of Correction Commissioner, Lynelle Maginley-Liddie, does not have immediate access to financial data on settling misconduct cases for FY23. - Council Member Sandy Nurse asks about the financials …
4:00:34
·
32 sec
Is the Department of Correction's generator pollution project on Ryker's Island moving forward, and what are its budget and environmental impacts?
Deputy Commissioner Patrick Benn confirms the Department of Correction's generator pollution project on Ryker's Island is moving forward, but lacks specific budget details. - The project aims to remove pollution …
4:01:07
·
56 sec
Has the Department of Correction been in talks about transferring decommissioned buildings and vacant land to DCAS?
The NYC Department of Correction has not yet identified properties for transfer but continues to assess potential opportunities. - The Department of Correction is currently assessing properties for potential turnover. …
4:02:05
·
99 sec
Jasmine Georges-Yilla, Executive Director of the New York City Board of Correction, on Challenges and Resource Needs for Independent Oversight of Jail Conditions
Jasmine Georges-Yilla testifies on the critical role and resource constraints of the New York City Board of Correction in overseeing jail conditions. - Discusses the Board of Correction's mandate, achievements, …
4:19:08
·
11 min
What are the staffing needs for expanding monitoring hours in jails, and what is the budget for the additional staff?
The New York City Board of Correction requires 27 additional staff to expand its monitoring hours but lacks the necessary funding. - The board chair recommended increasing the board monitoring …
4:31:06
·
79 sec
Will the NYC Board of Correction need additional staff for monitoring the implementation of new solitary confinement laws?
The NYC Board of Correction confirms the need for additional staff to monitor the implementation and compliance of new solitary confinement laws. - Confirmation of the staff requirement links directly …
4:32:27
·
36 sec
What challenges are faced in filling positions at the New York City Board of Correction?
The New York City Board of Correction (BOC) faces staffing challenges due to a hiring freeze, impacting efforts to review medical documentations and HR needs. - The BOC aims to …
4:33:06
·
3 min
What recommendations has the New York City Board of Correction made to avoid unnecessary use of chemical agents at Rikers?
The NYC Board of Correction shared its recommendations for reducing unnecessary chemical agent use in jails, including training, monitoring, and policy revisions. - Recommendations include closely examining current chemical agent …
4:36:31
·
3 min
Why hasn't the New York City Board of Correction updated its sexual abuse and harassment reporting?
The New York City Board of Correction's delay in reporting sexual abuse and harassment is attributed to insufficient staffing. - The Board plans to restructure by moving the reporting under …
4:40:04
·
50 sec
Dalvanie Powell, President, United Probation Officers Association on Challenges Facing NYC Probation Officers
Dalvanie Powell discusses the significant impact of New York City's probation officers in the criminal justice system, focusing on their roles, qualifications, and challenges, especially regarding workforce reductions and salary …
4:43:34
·
4 min
Hannah May Powers on the Urgency of Closing Rikers Island and Addressing its Fiscal Inefficiencies
Hannah May Powers, representing the Office of the Brooklyn Borough President, argues for the closure of Rikers Island by 2027, citing financial inefficiencies and a humanitarian crisis. - Powers discusses …
4:48:26
·
161 sec
Amanda Berman on Continued Funding for Alternatives to Incarceration and Detention
Amanda Berman advocates for sustained support for alternatives to incarceration and detention, emphasizing their crucial role in public safety and cost reduction. - Berman represents the Center for Justice Innovation, …
4:51:13
·
3 min
Barbara Hamilton, Supervising Attorney of Incarcerated Client Services at Legal Aid, on Expanding Services in City Jails and the Need for Increased Programming
Barbara Hamilton testifies on the necessity of expanding legal aid services and increasing programming within city jails to support incarcerated individuals. - Hamilton highlights the obstacles faced by people in …
4:55:17
·
138 sec
Sebastian Solomon on the Need for Reallocating NYC's Incarceration Budget to Community-Based Safety Solutions
Sebastian Solomon emphasizes the importance of reallocating New York City's incarceration budget towards community-based safety solutions instead of overspending on jails and policing. - Solomon criticizes New York City's annual …
4:57:40
·
3 min
Member of the Public on the Medical Neglect and Systemic Abuses Faced by Incarcerated Individuals
A testimonial outlines the detrimental effects of the Department of Corrections' practices, including a case of fatal medical neglect and broader systemic abuses. - Provides an account of Mariahuda, whose …
5:02:23
·
3 min
Joanne De la Paz from Freedom Agenda on the High Cost of Incarceration and its Impact on Community Needs
Joanne De la Paz testifies on the financial and emotional burden of her sons' incarceration and the excessive spending on incarceration compared to community needs. - De la Paz shares …
5:06:13
·
3 min
Darren Mack, Co-Director of Freedom Agenda, on the Necessary Closure of Rikers Island and Reducing the Department of Correction Workforce
Darren Mack criticizes NYC's handling of Rikers Island closure and the misallocation of Department of Correction resources. - Darren Mack emphasizes the commitment to close Rikers Island by 2027, stating …
5:09:27
·
161 sec
Megan French-Marcelin, Senior Director of New York State Policy, Legal Action Center on Advocacy for Alternative to Detention/Incarceration Programs and Community Reinvestment
Megan French-Marcelin testifies on the importance of alternatives to detention and incarceration and the crucial need for additional City Council funding. - French-Marcelin represents The New York City ATI and …
5:12:15
·
3 min
Victor Herrera, Leader-Member of Freedom Agenda, on the Monetization of Human Life in Incarceration
Victor Herrera testified against the monetization of human life in incarceration, using his brother's case as an example. - Herrera highlights his brother's struggles with obtaining diversion due to systemic …
5:15:32
·
112 sec
Yonah Zeitz, Director of Advocacy at the Katal Center for Equity Health And Justice, on the Crisis at Rikers Island and the Urgency of Its Closure
Yonah Zeitz advocates for the immediate closure of Rikers Island, critiquing the high costs of incarceration and the mayor's budget allocations. - Zeitz highlights the fiscal irresponsibility of over $550,000 …
5:17:29
·
3 min
Jennifer Parish on the Failure to Invest in Preventative Services to Reduce Incarceration and its Impact on Mental Health
Jennifer Parish discusses the lack of investment in preventative services and its impact on mental health within the incarcerated population. - Parish criticizes the mayor's proposed budget for cutting funding …
5:21:14
·
3 min
David Long, Executive Director of Liberty Fund, on Seeking City Council Funding for Justice Reform Programs
David Long details the Liberty Fund's need for New York City Council funding to support its justice reform efforts and public safety initiatives. - Outlines the Liberty Fund's mission to …
5:25:41
·
3 min
Christopher Jeffries, Youth Advocate at Bronx Connect, on the High Costs and Ineffectiveness of Incarceration vs. Alternative to Incarceration Programs
Christopher Jeffries shares his firsthand account on how alternative to incarceration programs, like those at Bronx Connect, outperform traditional incarceration in terms of cost and effectiveness. - Jeffries contrasts the …
5:28:49
·
162 sec
Jay Edidin, Director of Advocacy at the Women's Community Justice Association, on Budget Impacts and Over-Incarceration of Women and Gender Expansive Individuals at Rikers Island
Jay Edidin criticizes the Adam Administration's expansion of jail beds for women and gender expansive people incarcerated at Rikers Island and the cuts to community services. - Edidin advocates for …
5:31:38
·
164 sec
Molly Bibby on the Importance of the Families Rising Program for Justice-Involved Young People
Molly Bibby testifies about the effectiveness of the Families Rising program in supporting justice-involved young people and combating budget cuts. - Bibby highlights the Families Rising program's role in reducing …
5:34:27
·
132 sec
Akiana Smith on the Impact of the Mayor's Budget on Incarcerated Women and Gender Expansive New Yorkers
Akiana Smith, Community and Court Navigator at the Women's Community Justice Association, delivers testimony on the negative impacts of the mayor's budget on incarcerated women and gender expansive New Yorkers, …
5:36:47
·
115 sec
Megan Carr on Rikers Island's Environmental and Carceral Injustices
Megan Carr testifies about the dual nature of injustices at Rikers Island, emphasizing its environmental and carceral aspects. - Carr highlights Rikers Island's construction on a landfill, leading to poor …
5:38:48
·
3 min
King Downing on the Impact of Program Budget Cuts on Criminal Justice and Incarceration
King Downing highlights the negative impact of program budget cuts on criminal justice and incarceration, based on his experience and data. - Downing, as the Director of Healing Justice for …
5:42:29
·
3 min
Prom Freedman on Addressing Systemic Injustices through Closing Rikers and Reparations
Prom Freedman, an organizer, reparationist, and American Freedman citizen, emphasizes the importance of closing Rikers Island and offering reparations and support for oppressed communities. - Freedman voices the perspective of …
5:46:54
·
3 min
Jason Alleyne on Exalt's Comprehensive Programs for Youth in the Criminal Justice System
Jason Alleyne outlines Exalt's approach to aiding youth involved in the criminal justice system through education, skill development, and paid internships to prevent recidivism. - Exalt has helped youth since …
5:50:06
·
3 min
Tiffany Sloan from From Punishment to Public Health at John Jay College on Transforming Public Safety through Public Health Initiatives
Tiffany Sloan advocates for transforming the public health and public safety infrastructure through the From Punishment to Public Health initiative. - Sloan emphasizes the need to shift focus from punitive …
5:53:34
·
165 sec
Member of the Public disrupts testimony
Alex Stein disrupts a NYC City Council meeting.
5:56:23
·
5 min
Batman on the Necessity of Support Programs for Black and Brown Youth
Batman advocates for the development of comprehensive support programs aimed at the liberation and empowerment of black and brown youth. - Highlighting the need for programs focusing on physical and …
6:01:41
·
4 min
Tanisha Grant, Executive Director of Parents Supporting Parents New York, on Family Separation Due to Unlawful Incarceration
Tanisha Grant testifies on the negative impacts of family separation caused by unlawful incarceration and advocates for funding to support families. - Grant describes the generational harm and vicious cycle …
6:06:25
·
125 sec
Ronald Day, Senior Vice President at The Fortune Society, on the Challenges and Needs of Reentry Programs
Ronald Day shares insights into the challenges facing reentry programs and the need for enhanced support and funding. - Day presents his perspective, based on personal experience and nine years …
6:08:39
·
158 sec
Daniele Gerard, Senior Attorney at Children's Rights, on Necessity of Closing Rikers Island and Funding Alternatives to Incarceration
Daniele Gerard discusses the urgent need for closing Rikers Island by 2027 and reallocating funds towards alternatives to incarceration and re-entry services. - Gerard highlights the excessive funding and dangerous …
6:11:26
·
176 sec
Kelly Grace Price on Budget Parity, Oversight in NYC's Correctional System, and Concerns over Female Incarceration
Kelly Grace Price highlights the need for budget parity, staff for oversight, and concerns over female incarceration rates in NYC's correctional system. - Price calls for budget parity within the …
6:14:41
·
3 min
Amanda Granger, Senior Director of Communications at CASES on the Efficacy and Funding Needs of Alternatives to Incarceration Programs
Amanda Granger, representing CASES, advocates for enhanced funding and acknowledgment of the Alternatives to Incarceration (ATI) programs' successes, particularly the Nathaniel Assertive Community Treatment program. - CASES focuses on alternatives …
6:18:13
·
166 sec
Eileen Maher, Union Leader and Social Worker, on the Failure of NYC's Department of Corrections and the Necessity of Closing Rikers Island
Eileen Maher, a union leader and social worker, delivers a compelling testimony on the critical need for the closure of Rikers Island and major reforms within the NYC Department of …
6:21:12
·
4 min
LuAnne Klauber, Vice President of Vocational Programs at Good Shepherd Services, on Community Programs for Vulnerable Youths
LuAnne Klauber discusses the importance of small community-based programs for vulnerable populations, emphasizing their essential role in supporting justice-involved or disconnected youths. - Klauber oversees programs funded by the Department …
6:25:59
·
3 min
Nicole Farrelly, Senior Mitigation Specialist at Osborn Association on Advocacy's Role in Supporting Indigent Clients and Alternatives to Incarceration
Nicole Farrelly testifies on the crucial role of advocacy and alternatives to incarceration for indigent clients, highlighting the success of the Osborne Association. - Farrelly outlines Osborne Association's funding requests, …
6:29:12
·
3 min
Lauren Stephens-Davidowitz, Staff Attorney at the Legal Aid Society, on Proposed Budget Cuts to the Board of Correction
Lauren Stephens-Davidowitz testifies against proposed budget cuts to the Board of Correction, underscoring the necessity of maintaining its funding for effective jail oversight. - Highlights the Board of Correction as …
6:32:35
·
127 sec
Peleya Patterson, Vice President of Justice Initiatives at Good Shepherd Services, on Proposed Cuts to Youth Justice Programs
Peleya Patterson discusses the negative impact of proposed budget cuts on youth justice programs in New York City. - Patterson represents Good Shepherd Services and testifies against the budget cuts …
6:34:52
·
112 sec
