TESTIMONY
Lo van der Volk, President of Carnegie Hill Neighbors, on Proposed Development's Violation of Community Planning Principles
1:27:38
·
139 sec
Lo van der Volk discusses the proposed development's disregard for New York City's traditional city planning principles and its impact on the community.
- Van der Volk represents Carnegie Hill Neighbors and addresses a development arising from the conversion of the Rupert brewery.
- Raises concerns about the violation of traditional planning principles: low buildings on side streets and tall buildings on avenues.
- The proposed development seeks a zoning change that would allow an unusually tall building, potentially the tallest in a 10-block radius, without offering public open space.
- Contrasts the proposed development with a 2016 example that managed to incorporate public open space alongside a tall structure.
Lo van der Volk
1:27:38
Thank you.
1:27:40
Join the analyst.
1:27:43
Am I on?
Kevin C. Riley
1:27:44
Yes.
1:27:44
You're on.
Lo van der Volk
1:27:45
Okay.
1:27:46
Thank you.
1:27:47
My name is Aloe Vanderhall, and I am president and speaking on behalf of Carnegie Hill Neighbors.
1:27:55
The the block front in question faces a 4 block development that arose out of the conversion of the Rupert brewery into residential buildings.
1:28:09
And while there are tall buildings in that in that four block area, they are interspersed with a lot of open space, which was the intent.
1:28:19
So that that is one of the frameworks.
1:28:23
The other concerns are threefold, which is that the massing in New York City has long observed low buildings in the side streets and tall buildings on the avenues.
1:28:39
And that principle is being violated here, and grossly so.
1:28:47
Also, the project seeks not just a zone zoning change from M 14, but it moves up the ladder to art.
1:28:57
Surpassing R8b, R8, R9, and landing at R10 with a 20% bonus.
1:29:06
It it then masses all the bulk it has in a way to keep the buildings for half its zoning a lot low, but bunches the massing so that we get in the eastern half, a building that is 484 feet tall.
1:29:25
Probably one probably the tallest in in a 10 block radius.
1:29:29
Call us building and a 10 block radius.
1:29:32
Further, it provides no usable public open space, as mentioned, and and was done And this is contrary to a recent example in 2016 at 205 East 90th.
1:29:47
Second Street, where a equally tall building was added along near the area.
UNKNOWN
1:29:52
Has expired.
1:29:53
Thank you.
Lo van der Volk
1:29:53
And with an open space.
1:29:56
Thank you.
← Previous Chapter
Michael Beacham, Yorkville Resident, on the Planned Development's Impact on Green Spaces and Community Facilities
Next Chapter →
Kevin Elkins, Union Representative for the New York City District Council of Carpenters, on Rezoning Impacting Construction Workers' Standards and Rights