The citymeetings.nyc logo showing a pigeon at a podium with a microphone.

citymeetings.nyc

Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

TESTIMONY

Testimony by Hunter Walker on Stellar Management's Zoning Variance Application for 341 10th Street

1:46:33

·

3 min

Hunter Walker, a lifelong Brooklynite, urges the subcommittee to reject Stellar Management's application for a zoning variance on his block. He criticizes the company's proposal, citing concerns about affordable housing and misrepresentation of facts. Additional points include:

  • Walker disputes Stellar's claims about the number of affordable units and their affordability levels.
  • He expresses concern about Stellar's track record with affordable housing requirements.
  • Walker criticizes Stellar's characterization of the current site conditions and their proposed improvements.
Hunter Walker
1:46:33
Excellent.
1:46:34
To the esteemed members of the sub committee, my name is Hunter Walker.
1:46:38
I'm a lifelong Brooklynite who grew up on 10th Street starting in the eighties and lives there today.
1:46:43
I've come before you to urge you to reject stellar management's application for zoning variance on my block.
1:46:48
There are so many reasons to say no to stellar, and they've made so many false statements, 2 minutes barely covers it.
1:46:53
I'm gonna do my best.
1:46:54
Our city is in the midst of an affordable housing crisis.
1:46:57
Stellar has been a major enemy of affordable housing.
1:47:00
Deleted versions of the company's website boast about the fact that stellar quote built its track record on repositioning of middle income housing.
1:47:08
How has that repositioning of affordable housing played out?
1:47:12
Well, in 2019, a housing court judge found that stellar falsely inflated renovation costs to overcharge tenants and destabilize affordable units.
1:47:20
That business model has involved turning former Mitchellama buildings into high priced rentals.
1:47:24
That includes 341 Tenth Street.
1:47:27
Those rents you are also shocked to see are being charged by stellar right now.
1:47:31
This business model has pushed many friends and neighbors I grew up with.
1:47:35
As they've sought a variance to build 2 new towers next to that building, Stellar created a website 34110.com, that purports to dispel quote unquote myths about this project.
1:47:45
In reality, the site is filled with the kind of false claims that stellar is known for.
1:47:49
I was gratified counselwoman Avila has raised questions about the levels of affordability, but I have questions about the more basic math here.
1:47:57
Stellar site claims, quote, 60% of all units on the property will be affordable.
1:48:02
It variously promises both a 106 2277 affordable apartments, of which, quote unquote, 64 to 90 oh, the the assessment they actually filed says it's just 64 to 96.
1:48:14
The math is simple.
1:48:15
64 to 96 out of 319 is about 20 to 30%.
1:48:20
Part of the reason that we don't know how affordable this will actually be is that stellar admits in their own writing that they have not submitted a final plan here.
1:48:28
We need a final plan with guaranteed affordability because this company has always done what they can to sneak out of affordable housing requirements.
1:48:36
I also just wanna point out that, you know, what I'm gonna say
Tiffany Cabán
1:48:39
is that so much your time has expired.
Kevin Riley
1:48:44
You can finish up.
1:48:45
Go ahead on 2.
Hunter Walker
1:48:47
Okay.
1:48:47
Perfect.
1:48:48
You know, they've highlighted the poor conditions at the site as a reason.
1:48:52
For having this new development.
1:48:54
They've described, quote unquote, uninviting walls and underutilized space.
1:48:59
I am a disparaged to upset to see my block disparaged like that.
1:49:03
But b, I'm upset that, you know, stellar is is claiming that their own mismanagement is what needs improvement.
1:49:13
As some folks have pointed out, this quote unquote, new park THAT THEY'RE GOING TO BUILD.
Kevin Riley
1:49:17
Reporter:
Hunter Walker
1:49:19
THEY'RE ACTUALLY LOCKED AWAY FROM THE RESIDENTS.
1:49:22
AS THE COUNCIL WOMAN SAID, STELLAR should have been treating their tenants well from the beginning.
1:49:28
And on that note, I just want to say it's clear that 5th Avenue Committee is their preferred partner for a a community benefits agreement.
1:49:36
The leadership of 5th Avenue Committee was here today with Stellar.
1:49:39
They've backed this proposal from day 1.
1:49:41
This is an organization with 1,000,000 in corporate Thank
Kevin Riley
1:49:43
you, Oscar.
Hunter Walker
1:49:44
Thank you.
1:49:45
Okay.
1:49:45
Because I have text from an email showing 5th Avenue Committee threatening the 341 President Trump.
Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.