The citymeetings.nyc logo showing a pigeon at a podium with a microphone.

citymeetings.nyc

Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

Q&A

Request for additional documentation on Mastro's cases against the city

0:30:41

·

147 sec

Council Member Keith Powers inquires about additional documentation requested from Randy Mastro regarding his past cases against the city. Mastro commits to providing more information but notes potential limitations due to no longer having access to old files.

  • Powers asks for final dispositions and citations for past cases
  • Mastro agrees to provide the requested information, going back to his early career
  • Mastro acknowledges the possibility of unintentionally omitting some cases from his 40-year career
Keith Powers
0:30:41
I wanna ask I wanna ask a few questions related to some information that you provided to us upfront before the hearing.
0:30:48
We had asked you to provide to answer some questions, pre pre hearing questions, You provide some documentation, and we had asked for some additional documentation.
0:30:59
Before that, we asked you to provide a list of all instances in which you have represented a client in a cause of action against the city, the name of the client, a summary of the cause of action, and the final disposition of the matter.
0:31:09
We received a list of clients and calls of action, but I don't believe we'd receive the rest of the information.
0:31:15
I wanted to ask if you're planning to update that information to us, and if so, what a timeline for that would
UNKNOWN
0:31:21
be.
0:31:21
K.
Randy Mastro
0:31:24
Mister chair, I I I did supplement the responses.
0:31:28
You asked me to go back in my career any any case I ever had representing a client against the city.
0:31:35
I went back to the the late eighties, early nineties when I represented, you know, Roland Eens, a black newspaper delivery man, who'd been falsely arrested for criminal trespass in the lobby of a building because white tenants complained against him, and I got him acquitted.
0:31:52
And I thought I provided all of that information going back over the course of my career, but to the extent there's any additional information you would like me to provide, I will definitely do that.
0:32:02
I am an open book.
Keith Powers
0:32:04
I think I think we had asked for some information related to the final disposition of those matters and citations to the final decision.
0:32:10
I don't think we had received that.
0:32:12
So are you committing that you will provide that to us after the hearing?
Randy Mastro
0:32:15
I'm committing, I will do that.
0:32:16
It's all a matter of public record.
0:32:18
I did give the names of the cases.
0:32:19
And over the past 10 years, any cases I brought against the city, I I provided that detailed information, but I will go back to my my days as a young pupboy and give you every detail.
Keith Powers
0:32:31
Got it.
0:32:32
Are there any cases to your full knowledge that you that should be on the list that you haven't provided to us?
Randy Mastro
0:32:39
Again, I I left my former law firm 2 years ago and joined King And Spalding.
0:32:45
So I don't have access to my old files.
0:32:47
So I was going on memory and I made that clear.
UNKNOWN
0:32:50
Sure.
Randy Mastro
0:32:50
So it is possible that that there would have been one or more that I didn't recall over a 40 year career.
0:32:57
I intended to be complete, but it is possible that there are others, and I'd be happy
Keith Powers
0:33:01
But I think the correct way to to your knowledge.
Randy Mastro
0:33:03
To my yeah.
0:33:04
To best of my recollection.
UNKNOWN
0:33:05
Okay.
Randy Mastro
0:33:06
I I mean, I think I listed over 20 cases.
Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.