New York City Council
Committee on Environmental Protection, Resiliency and Waterfronts
Sep 18, 2024
·
01:00 PM
3 hr 56 min
Summary
A hearing on proposed changes to NYC's Citizens Air Complaint Program and related legislation.
Discussions focused on:
- Intro 941, which would modify the program's structure and incentives
- Intro 5, aimed at improving language accessibility
- Intro 291, proposing increased penalties for idling violations
- Intro 747, establishing a code of conduct for citizen complainants
Key issues included the program's effectiveness in reducing air pollution, concerns about abuse and fraud, industry perspectives on due process, and the balance between citizen enforcement and program integrity.
Features testimony from the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), citizen participants in the program, industry representatives, environmental and health advocates, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Gennaro's introduction and opening remarks
Council Member James F. Gennaro, Chair of the Committee on Environmental Protection, Resiliency, and Waterfronts, opens the hearing with introductory remarks. He acknowledges the delay due to a previous committee …
0:00:47
·
15 sec
Overview of the hearing topic and legislation to be discussed
Council Member Gennaro provides an overview of the hearing's purpose, which is to discuss civilian enforcement of air and noise codes, and introduces the legislation to be considered during the …
0:01:03
·
24 sec
Idling and its impact on air quality and public health
Council Member Gennaro explains the negative effects of idling gasoline and diesel-powered vehicles on air quality and public health, particularly focusing on criteria air pollutants and ozone formation. - Idling …
0:01:28
·
75 sec
Overview of the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Council Member Gennaro provides an overview of the Citizens Air Complaint Program, established in 2019 to improve enforcement of the city's anti-idling provisions. - The program allows New Yorkers to …
0:02:45
·
45 sec
Issues with the current Citizens Air Complaint Program
Council Member Gennaro outlines several problems with the current Citizens Air Complaint Program, highlighting the need for improvements to address abusive behavior and fraudulent submissions. - Some complainants have engaged …
0:03:30
·
62 sec
Details of proposed Introduction 941
Council Member Gennaro explains the key provisions of his proposed bill, Introduction 941, which aims to reform the Citizens Air Complaint Program. - The bill would allow DEP to remove …
0:04:33
·
36 sec
Repeat violations by companies and Introduction 291
Council Member Gennaro addresses the issue of companies repeatedly violating idling laws and introduces Introduction 291, which proposes increased penalties for repeat offenders. - Large companies like Con Edison, Amazon, …
0:05:09
·
61 sec
Brief overview of Introductions 5 and 291
Council Member Gennaro briefly introduces two additional bills: Introduction 5 and Introduction 291, sponsored by other council members. - Introduction 5, sponsored by Council Member Avilés, aims to address concerns …
0:06:11
·
12 sec
Civilian enforcement of the noise code
Council Member Gennaro addresses the issue of civilian enforcement of the noise code, discussing previous hearings and problems identified with the current system. - A hearing in October of the …
0:06:24
·
44 sec
Introduction of proposed bill 747
Council Member Gennaro introduces his proposed bill, Introduction 747, which aims to establish a code of conduct for civilian noise complainants. - Introduction 747 is sponsored by Council Member Gennaro …
0:07:09
·
22 sec
Acknowledgments and recognition of staff and council members
Council Member Gennaro concludes his remarks by acknowledging staff members and recognizing other council members present at the hearing. - He thanks various committee staff members, including policy analysts, legislative …
0:07:31
·
90 sec
Council Member Avilés discusses environmental justice and language access in her district
Council Member Alexa Avilés expresses support for Intro 5, which aims to improve language access for the Citizens Air Complaint Program. She highlights the environmental justice issues in her district …
0:09:02
·
133 sec
Council Member Julie Menin introduces legislation to increase penalties for idling vehicles
Council Member Julie Menin addresses the issue of air quality in New York City, highlighting the city's high ranking in asthma-related problems. She introduces Intro 291, which aims to increase …
0:11:21
·
146 sec
Introduction and background of DEP Commissioner Rohit T. Aggarwala
Commissioner Rohit T. Aggarwala introduces himself and provides context for the hearing on the Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP). He emphasizes that the goal is to reduce vehicle emissions, not …
0:14:31
·
99 sec
Overview of New York City's progress in air quality improvement
Commissioner Aggarwala presents an overview of New York City's significant progress in improving air quality over the past two decades. - Reports a 60% decline in PM2.5 and a 40% …
0:16:11
·
75 sec
Impact of air pollution on environmental justice neighborhoods
Commissioner Aggarwala discusses the disproportionate impact of air pollution on environmental justice (EJ) neighborhoods in New York City. - Identifies specific EJ neighborhoods like the South Bronx, Harlem, North Shore …
0:17:27
·
26 sec
DEP's efforts to implement air quality laws and reduce vehicle emissions
Commissioner Aggarwala outlines the Department of Environmental Protection's efforts to implement air quality laws and reduce vehicle emissions in New York City. - Highlights accelerated phase-out of number 4 heating …
0:17:55
·
94 sec
Overview of the Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP)
Commissioner Aggarwala provides an overview of the Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP) and its role in reducing vehicle emissions. - Explains that the CACP allows civilians to report potential idling …
0:19:30
·
84 sec
Growth and challenges of the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Commissioner Aggarwala discusses the significant growth of the Citizens Air Complaint Program and the challenges that have arisen as a result. - Reports an increase in complaints from 9,000 in …
0:20:56
·
102 sec
Shortcomings of the current Citizens Air Complaint Program design
Commissioner Aggarwala introduces the shortcomings in the design of the Citizens Air Complaint Program that have become apparent as the program has grown. - Indicates that the bills being discussed …
0:22:39
·
11 sec
Importance of electrification and anti-idling devices
Commissioner Aggarwala emphasizes the importance of electrification and anti-idling devices as solutions to reduce vehicle emissions and idling. - Explains that most trucks are designed to keep engines running for …
0:22:51
·
154 sec
CACP's failure to improve air quality in environmental justice communities
Commissioner Aggarwala addresses the Citizens Air Complaint Program's failure to significantly improve air quality in environmental justice (EJ) communities. - Presents maps showing that most complaints are issued in wealthier …
0:25:26
·
87 sec
Issues with the current air code and enforcement
Commissioner Aggarwala outlines several issues with the current air code that hinder effective enforcement of idling violations. - Highlights imprecise or conflicting provisions in the air code that lead to …
0:26:55
·
91 sec
Unprofessional behavior and fraud in the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Commissioner Aggarwala addresses issues of unprofessional behavior and fraud among some participants in the Citizens Air Complaint Program. - Highlights the lack of time limits for complaint submissions, leading to …
0:28:27
·
122 sec
Need for a code of conduct for Citizens Air Complaint Program participants
Commissioner Aggarwala emphasizes the need for a code of conduct for participants in the Citizens Air Complaint Program to address harassment and ensure program integrity. - Describes instances of harassment …
0:30:31
·
3 min
Discussion of proposed legislation and recommendations
Commissioner Aggarwala discusses the proposed legislation (Intros 5, 291, 747, and 941) and offers recommendations for improvements to the Citizens Air Complaint Program. - Supports the intent of all four …
0:34:03
·
4 min
Council Member Gennaro's opening remarks and acknowledgment of testimony
Council Member James F. Gennaro opens the session by thanking the commissioner for their comprehensive testimony. He acknowledges the presence of other council members and expresses his intention to limit …
0:38:26
·
68 sec
Discussion on reduction of air pollutants and health impacts
Council Member Gennaro highlights the significant reduction in air pollutants (PM2.5 and NO2) mentioned in the commissioner's testimony and its correlation with reduced asthma-related emergency room visits. - Emphasizes a …
0:39:38
·
102 sec
Growth of the Citizens Air Complaint Program and complaint process
Council Member Gennaro inquires about the exponential growth of the Citizens Air Complaint Program, noting an increase from 9,000 to over 100,000 violations. He seeks clarification on the complaint submission …
0:41:20
·
100 sec
DEP's role in reviewing and pursuing violations
Commissioner Aggarwala explains DEP's role in the complaint review process, including their authority to decide on the validity of complaints and the timelines involved. - DEP has 45 days to …
0:43:01
·
61 sec
DEP's authority to dismiss complaints
Council Member Gennaro seeks clarification on DEP's authority to dismiss complaints and the options available to complainants if their complaint is dismissed. Deputy Commissioner Lubin provides insights into the process. …
0:44:02
·
104 sec
Council Member Gennaro's concluding remarks on program aspects and Intro 941
Council Member Gennaro wraps up the discussion by expressing his views on various aspects of the Citizens Air Complaint Program and related legislation. He shows agreement with the commissioner on …
0:45:46
·
177 sec
Language accessibility challenges in the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Council Member Avilés inquires about the accessibility of the Citizens Air Complaint Program for non-English speakers. Commissioner Aggarwala explains that while instructions and forms are available in multiple languages, complaints …
0:48:46
·
109 sec
User interface challenges in the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Council Member Avilés highlights significant user interface issues with the Citizens Air Complaint Program portal, emphasizing that it is not user-friendly and presents barriers for submission. She stresses the need …
0:50:38
·
111 sec
Proposed 15-minute idling allowance for school buses
Council Member Avilés questions the proposed 15-minute idling allowance for school buses, seeking evidence for its necessity and potential health impacts. Commissioner Aggarwala explains the rationale behind the proposal and …
0:52:29
·
3 min
Concerns about multiple buses idling in front of schools
Council Member Avilés raises concerns about multiple buses idling for extended periods in front of schools, often without children on board. Commissioner Aggarwala addresses the challenges in enforcement due to …
0:56:08
·
89 sec
Electrification efforts for school buses
Council Member Avilés inquires about DEP's role in pursuing and ensuring the electrification of the school bus fleet. Commissioner Aggarwala outlines current initiatives and progress in this area. - DEP …
0:57:38
·
82 sec
Legislation on electric school bus implementation
Council Member Gennaro provides information about a bill passed in 2021 that sets requirements for electric school buses in New York City. - The bill, passed at the end of …
0:59:00
·
88 sec
Mitigation plans for collective impacts of idling near schools
Council Member Avilés inquires about the city's plans to mitigate the collective impacts of idling, particularly near schools. Council Member Gennaro responds by explaining the comprehensive approach being taken through …
1:00:28
·
87 sec
Timeline for improving language accessibility of the complaint system
Council Member Avilés asks about the timeline and milestones for improving language accessibility of the Citizens Air Complaint Program. Commissioner Aggarwala provides a brief response. - The commissioner offers to …
1:01:55
·
40 sec
Number and deployment of DEP air and noise enforcers
Council Member Gennaro inquires about the number of DEP air and noise enforcers in the field and their deployment strategy. Commissioner Aggarwala and Deputy Commissioner Lubin provide information on the …
1:02:36
·
72 sec
Challenges faced by DEP inspectors and limitations of current enforcement methods
Commissioner Aggarwala and Deputy Commissioner Lubin explain the challenges faced by DEP inspectors and the limitations of current enforcement methods, particularly for mobile violations like idling vehicles. - DEP has …
1:03:48
·
4 min
Council Member Restler expresses appreciation for DEP's work
Council Member Lincoln Restler opens his remarks by expressing gratitude for the opportunity to speak and thanking Commissioner Aggarwala and the DEP team for their thoughtful testimony. He emphasizes his …
1:08:09
·
75 sec
Discussion on 5-day time limit for complaint submission and process streamlining
Council Member Restler expresses concerns about the proposed 5-day time limit for submitting idling complaints and inquires about potential streamlining of the submission process. Commissioner Aggarwala responds by discussing DEP's …
1:09:26
·
110 sec
Proposal to reduce complainant compensation and cap total revenue generated
Council Member Restler discusses the proposed reduction in the percentage of fines given to complainants and suggests implementing a cap on the total amount an individual complainant can generate in …
1:11:18
·
102 sec
Discussion on school bus idling regulations and electrification efforts
Council Member Restler discusses school bus idling regulations and electrification efforts, focusing on the NICE Bus company and their work in the 33rd Council district. He inquires about limiting idling …
1:13:01
·
79 sec
Council Member Restler's closing remarks on improving the citizen enforcement model
Council Member Restler concludes his remarks by acknowledging the good faith efforts to improve the Citizens Air Complaint Program and expressing his willingness to continue working on refining the proposed …
1:14:20
·
28 sec
Council Member Holden questions DEP on commercial vehicle idling enforcement
Council Member Robert Holden questions Deputy Commissioner Julie Lubin about enforcement issues related to commercial vehicle idling, particularly focusing on vehicles with out-of-state or non-commercial plates. They discuss potential changes …
1:15:34
·
3 min
Council Member Marmorato expresses appreciation for flood kit event
Council Member Kristy Marmorato expresses gratitude to Commissioner Bravo for the flood kit event held in her district. She highlights the positive reception from her constituents and encourages similar events …
1:19:05
·
21 sec
Explanation of Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP) reporting process
Commissioner Aggarwala explains the Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP) reporting process in response to Council Member Marmorato's inquiries about how her constituents can participate and get compensated. - The CACP …
1:19:27
·
136 sec
Discussion on false complaints in the CACP
Commissioner Aggarwala addresses Council Member Marmorato's question about false complaints in the Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP). - The number of false complaints is reported to be very small. - …
1:21:43
·
62 sec
Safety concerns and DEP's approach to threats against civilian reporters
Council Member Marmorato inquires about safety measures for civilian reporters in the Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP), and Commissioner Aggarwala explains the DEP's approach to handling threats and ensuring safety. …
1:22:46
·
83 sec
Council Member Gennaro's concluding remarks and transition to public testimony
Council Member James F. Gennaro concludes the session with remarks about the administration's attentiveness to the testimony and prepares for the transition to public testimony. - Gennaro emphasizes that the …
1:24:12
·
6 min
Testimony by Samara Swanston, Former NYC Council Legislative Attorney, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Samara Swanston, a former NYC Council Legislative Attorney, testifies in support of the Citizens Air Complaint Program and opposes Intro 941. She emphasizes the program's success and the need for …
1:35:23
·
124 sec
Testimony by Eric Goldstein, Representative from Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) on Citizens Air Complaint Program and Related Legislation
Eric Goldstein from NRDC testified on the importance of the Citizens Air Complaint Program and related legislation. He emphasized the need to enhance rather than end citizen enforcement provisions, expressing …
1:37:48
·
140 sec
Council Member Gennaro thanks Eric Goldstein for NRDC's contributions
Council Member James F. Gennaro expresses gratitude to Eric Goldstein for his long-standing contributions to the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC). Goldstein responds by thanking Gennaro for his leadership and …
1:40:08
·
23 sec
Testimony by Suhali Méndez, Policy and Legislative Coordinator at New York Lawyers for the Public Interest
Suhali Méndez, representing New York Lawyers for the Public Interest, testified in support of Introductions 5 and 291 while expressing concerns about Intro 941 regarding the Citizens Air Complaint Program. …
1:40:48
·
140 sec
Testimony by Wayne Arden, Chair of the Transportation Committee and Vice Chair of the New York City Executive Committee of Sierra Club on Anti-Idling Legislation
Wayne Arden, representing the Sierra Club, testified in support of Intro 291, which would increase idling penalties for trucks and buses. He emphasized the need for stricter penalties and enforcement …
1:43:24
·
123 sec
Testimony by Greg Smith Simon, Representative of Rise 2 Resilience Coalition
Greg Smith Simon, representing the Rise 2 Resilience Coalition, attempted to give testimony about resident reporting of flooding, which was off-topic for the hearing. Council Member James F. Gennaro interrupted …
1:45:34
·
69 sec
Testimony by Larry Zogby, President of RDS Same Day Delivery, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Larry Zogby, president of RDS Same Day Delivery, testified about the impact of the Citizens Air Complaint Program on his business operations. He highlighted issues with due process, access to …
1:48:51
·
125 sec
Testimony by Patrick Condren, Administrator of Bus4NYC Coalition
Patrick Condren, representing the Bus4NYC Coalition, testified about the differences between buses and trucks in the context of idling regulations. He argued that buses should be treated differently due to …
1:51:37
·
129 sec
Testimony by Demos Demopoulos, Secretary Treasurer of Joint Council 16 of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters
Demos Demopoulos, representing the Teamsters Joint Council 16, testified against increasing penalties for idling infractions and urged for a reimagining of idling regulations and citizen complaints. He emphasized the impact …
1:54:16
·
138 sec
Testimony by Melissa Barbour, Assistant Director of Mechanical Contractors Association of New York
Melissa Barbour, representing the Mechanical Contractors Association of New York, presented survey results from their members regarding the Citizens Air Complaint Program. The testimony highlighted inconsistencies and challenges faced by …
1:56:40
·
127 sec
Council member emphasizes importance of specific bill feedback
Council Member Gennaro stresses the importance of stakeholders providing specific feedback on the proposed bills in their testimony. He explains that the most compelling testimonies address how the bills accomplish …
1:58:48
·
49 sec
Testimony by Zach Miller, Director of Metro Region Operations at Trucking Association of New York
Zach Miller, representing the Trucking Association of New York, testified about concerns with the Citizens Air Complaint Program. While not condoning unnecessary idling, he highlighted issues with the program's implementation …
2:00:01
·
125 sec
Council member addresses due process concerns in proposed bill
Council Member James F. Gennaro responds to concerns about due process in the Citizens Air Complaint Program. He highlights that his proposed bill (Intro 941) would mandate that accused parties …
2:02:06
·
19 sec
Testimony by Ryan O'Toole, Vice President of Walton Hauling
Ryan O'Toole, Vice President of Walton Hauling, testified about issues his company faces with the city's idling violation program. He highlighted problems with delayed summons, escalating fines for rental vehicles, …
2:02:29
·
123 sec
Testimony by Michael Streeter, Member of the Public, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Michael Streeter, a participant and champion of the idling program since 2019, testified about the program's effectiveness in reducing idling across New York City. He emphasized his role in recruiting …
2:07:34
·
131 sec
Testimony by Dr. Patrick Schnau, Pediatrician, on NYC's Citizens Air Complaint Program and Proposed Legislation
Dr. Patrick Schnau, a pediatrician and participant in the Citizens Air Complaint Program, testifies in support of Intros 5 and 291 while strongly opposing Intro 941. He argues that Intro …
2:09:57
·
133 sec
Testimony by Robin Warren, Advocate from New York Clean Air Collective
Robin Warren from the New York Clean Air Collective testifies about the importance of the Citizens Air Complaint Program and opposes Intro 941. She shares her personal experience with the …
2:12:24
·
143 sec
Council member extends time for advocate to complete testimony
Council Member James F. Gennaro extends the speaking time for Robin Warren, allowing her to complete her point about the Citizens Air Complaint Program. - Gennaro acknowledges that Warren's time …
2:14:49
·
60 sec
Testimony by Hayden Brockett, Volunteer from New York Clean Air Collective
Hayden Brockett, a volunteer from the New York Clean Air Collective, testifies in opposition to Intro 941, which proposes changes to the Citizens Air Complaint Program. He emphasizes the program's …
2:16:03
·
4 min
Testimony by Eileen Spinner, Member of the Public
Eileen Spinner testifies against Intro 941, arguing that it weakens the Citizens Air Complaint Program and makes it easier for companies to pollute. She emphasizes the program's effectiveness in reducing …
2:20:22
·
121 sec
Testimony by Patrick Hyland, Executive Director of Metropolitan Trucking Association, on Citizens Air Complaint Program and Idling Regulations
Patrick Hyland, Executive Director of the Metropolitan Trucking Association, testified on the challenges faced by trucking companies in New York City and their concerns regarding idling regulations. He emphasized the …
2:24:14
·
128 sec
Testimony by April McIver, Executive Director of the Plumbing Foundation City of New York, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
April McIver, representing the Plumbing Foundation City of New York, expressed support for efforts to mitigate emissions but raised concerns about the Citizens Air Complaint Program. She supported Intros 747 …
2:26:42
·
108 sec
Testimony by Felice Farber, Executive Director of Subcontractors Trade Association
Felice Farber, representing the Subcontractors Trade Association, expressed concerns about the Citizens Air Complaint Program, particularly regarding due process, evidence accessibility, and the impact on the trucking industry. She urged …
2:28:40
·
134 sec
Testimony by Rocco J Lacertosa, CEO of New York State Energy Coalition
Rocco J Lacertosa, CEO of the New York State Energy Coalition (NYSEK), testified about concerns with the Citizens Air Complaint Program and its impact on NYSEK members who provide essential …
2:31:06
·
123 sec
Testimony by Ting Ting Wong, Substitute Teacher and Tutor from Brooklyn
Ting Ting Wong, a resident of Brooklyn and substitute teacher, testifies against Intro 941 and Intro 747, expressing concerns about the Citizens Air Complaint Program changes. She highlights the negative …
2:35:41
·
109 sec
Testimony by Eric Eisenberg on the Citizens Air Complaint Program and Related Legislation
Eric Eisenberg provided testimony in support of the Citizens Air Complaint Program and its positive impact on reducing air pollution and addressing climate change. He outlined the history of anti-idling …
2:39:45
·
135 sec
Testimony by Ryan Lokey, Amazon Delivery Driver
Ryan Lokey, an Amazon delivery driver, testified against Intro 941, arguing that the proposed changes to the Citizens Air Complaint Program would be ineffective and unfair. He highlighted issues with …
2:42:15
·
120 sec
Testimony by Rafil Kroll-Zaidi, Journalist and Participant in the CACP
Rafil Kroll-Zaidi, a journalist and participant in the Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP), testified about his experiences with the program and his concerns about proposed changes in Intro 941. He …
2:44:24
·
138 sec
Testimony by Hunter Severini, Resident of Lower Manhattan
Hunter Severini, a resident of Lower Manhattan who has reported thousands of air code violations, expresses support for Intros 5 and 291 while opposing Intros 747 and 941. Severini discusses …
2:46:49
·
125 sec
Testimony by Jonathan Robadu, Member of UCATS 3882, on the Citizens' Air Complaint Program
Jonathan Robadu, a member of the clerical union UCATS 3882, testifies about his experiences with the Citizens' Air Complaint Program since 2020. He emphasizes the program's importance in fighting for …
2:53:06
·
125 sec
Testimony by Leslie Brahm, Member of the Public, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Leslie Brahm, a resident of the Upper East Side, testified in support of the Citizens Air Complaint Program and urged the committee to maintain its effectiveness. She shared her experiences …
2:55:32
·
129 sec
Current stage of bills and purpose of the hearing
Council Member James F. Gennaro explains the current stage of the bills being discussed and the purpose of the hearing. He emphasizes that the bills have been written and are …
2:57:44
·
23 sec
Collaborative process in bill development
Council Member Gennaro describes the collaborative process that follows the initial hearing of bills. He explains how bills evolve and change before they are voted on. - Bills often change …
2:58:06
·
62 sec
Testimony by Peder Wessel on Citizens Air Complaint Program and Intro 941
Peder Wessel, a Manhattan resident with two small children, shares his positive experience with the Citizens Air Complaint Program and expresses concerns about Intro 941. He credits the program for …
2:59:13
·
132 sec
Testimony by Efraim Rosenbaum on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Efraim Rosenbaum, a participant in the Citizens Air Complaint Program since 2019, testifies about the program's effectiveness in reducing idling vehicles in New York City. He argues against proposed changes …
3:02:23
·
87 sec
Testimony by Larry Lee, Member of the Public, on Intro 941 and Air Quality
Larry Lee, a lifelong New Yorker, testifies against Intro 941, focusing on the proposed 5-day deadline for submitting complaints in the Citizens Air Complaint Program. He argues that this deadline …
3:04:03
·
3 min
Testimony by Duc Lee, Participant in Citizens Air Complaint Program
Duc Lee, a participant in NYC's Citizens Air Complaint Program, shared his personal experiences with air pollution in Vietnam and emphasized the importance of the program in maintaining clean air …
3:10:04
·
130 sec
Testimony by Grant Braam, Actuary and Citizen Air Complaint Program Participant
Grant Braam, an actuary and enthusiastic participant in the Citizens Air Complaint Program (CACP), testifies about his experiences with the program and his concerns about the proposed changes in Intro …
3:12:40
·
121 sec
Testimony by Aaron Jacobs, Teacher from New York City
Aaron Jacobs, a New York City teacher, testifies against Intro 941, arguing that it would weaken idling laws and negatively impact his students' health. He describes the current issues with …
3:14:59
·
110 sec
Testimony by Small Business Owner and Program Participant on Citizens Air Complaint Program
A small business owner and participant in the Citizens Air Complaint Program for the past two years testified about the program's effectiveness in reducing idling in their neighborhood. They expressed …
3:17:13
·
109 sec
Testimony by Kevin McGee, Environmental Health and Safety Professional, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Kevin McGee, an environmental health and safety professional, testifies in support of the Citizens Air Complaint Program for reporting idling vehicles in NYC. He argues that the program is effective …
3:19:14
·
129 sec
Council member Gennaro inquires about Kevin McGee's daily walking distance
Council Member James F. Gennaro engages in a brief Q&A with Kevin McGee about his daily walking habits. McGee reveals he walks 12 to 15 miles a day, which Gennaro …
3:21:25
·
13 sec
Testimony by George Pakenham, Director of Idle Threat: Man on Emission, on Bill Intro 941 and Public Health
George Pakenham, director of the documentary "Idle Threat: Man on Emission," testifies against Bill Intro 941, emphasizing the importance of the Citizens Air Complaint Program for public health. He shares …
3:23:35
·
127 sec
Testimony by Andrew Van Brisker on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Andrew Van Brisker, a cancer survivor, provides emotional testimony against proposed changes to the Citizens Air Complaint Program. He emphasizes the importance of clean air laws and the effectiveness of …
3:27:05
·
128 sec
Testimony by Josh Bisker, Member of the Public, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program and Intro 941
Josh Bisker, a New Yorker with asthma and participant in the Citizens Air Complaint Program, strongly opposes Intro 941. He argues that the bill would significantly weaken the program's effectiveness …
3:29:21
·
133 sec
Testimony by Sarah O'Brien, Member of the Public
Sarah O'Brien, a 22-year-old who grew up in Queens and Staten Island, shares her personal experiences with the Citizens Air Complaint Program and opposes Intro 941. She describes how the …
3:31:41
·
120 sec
Testimony by Bryce Stack, Member of the Public, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Bryce Stack, a regular New Yorker and public sector union member, testified in support of the Citizens Air Complaint Program. He shared personal experiences with air pollution's health impacts and …
3:33:49
·
121 sec
Testimony by Gregory Gonzales, Member of the Public, on the Citizens Air Complaint Program
Gregory Gonzales, a father and former teacher, expresses strong support for the Citizens Air Complaint Program, emphasizing its importance in improving air quality, especially near schools. He urges the council …
3:35:57
·
115 sec
Testimony by Dan Rodriguez, Vice President of Public Affairs at Coach USA
Dan Rodriguez, representing Coach USA, requests a full exemption from the proposed bills related to idling restrictions. He argues that Coach USA already takes significant measures to reduce idling and …
3:38:06
·
148 sec
Council member questions Coach USA representative about exemption request
Council Member James F. Gennaro engages in a brief Q&A session with Dan Rodriguez from Coach USA. The council member seeks clarification on the company name and discusses the nature …
3:40:36
·
21 sec
Testimony by Ryan Snyder, Director of Government Relations at Truck Renting and Leasing Association (TRALA)
Ryan Snyder, representing the Truck Renting and Leasing Association (TRALA), testified about the negative impacts of New York City's Citizens Air Complaint Program on TRALA members and their customers. While …
3:42:23
·
123 sec
Testimony by Lewis Dubuque, Northeast Regional Vice President of National Waste And Recycling Association on Idling Fines for Private Refuse Haulers
Lewis Dubuque, representing the National Waste And Recycling Association, expresses opposition to increased idling fines for private refuse haulers in New York City. He argues that the citizen idling complaint …
3:45:29
·
132 sec
Testimony by Anne Diebel, Private Investigator, on Citizens Air Complaint Program
Anne Diebel, a private investigator from Brooklyn, testifies in opposition to Intro 941, which proposes changes to the Citizens Air Complaint Program. She shares her experience as a recent participant …
3:47:55
·
111 sec
Testimony by Ernest Welde, Member of the Public, on Citizens Air Complaint Program and Proposed Legislation
Ernest Welde, a participant in the Citizens Air Program since 2018, testifies against Intro 941 and in support of Intro 291-A. He shares his personal experience with asthma and argues …
3:50:36
·
123 sec
