New York City Council
Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection
Oct 09, 2024
·
10:00 AM
5 hr 9 min
Summary
A hearing on:
- Intro 991-B, the Safe Hotels Act, which aims to create a licensing requirement for hotels in NYC and implement new safety and worker protection measures.
- Intro 970, which requires licensing for massage therapy businesses.
Discussions focused on:
- Combating human trafficking.
- Improving worker safety.
- Giving the city more oversight of problematic hotels.
- The economic impacts on the hotel industry.
Key provisions include:
- Requiring panic buttons for workers.
- Human trafficking training.
- Restrictions on subcontracting.
- Setting standards for cleaning and safety.
Debates centered on:
- The potential effects on small/independent hotels.
- Worker experiences with unsafe conditions and exploitation by subcontractors.
- Balancing worker protections with business concerns.
Features testimony from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP), hotel industry representatives, labor unions, anti-trafficking groups, hotel workers, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Menin introduces the hearing on hotel licensing
Council Member Julie Menin, chair of the committee on consumer and worker protection, welcomes attendees to the hearing on proposed Intro 991-B for licensing hotels and Intro 970 for licensing …
0:02:04
·
41 sec
Overview of New York City's thriving tourism industry
Council Member Menin provides an overview of New York City's tourism industry, highlighting its significance as an economic driver for the city. She presents statistics on visitor numbers, spending, and …
0:02:45
·
30 sec
Rising hotel-related complaints and safety concerns in New York City
Council Member Menin highlights the increasing number of hotel-related complaints and safety issues in New York City. She emphasizes the need for the proposed bill to address these concerns. - …
0:03:17
·
36 sec
Worker protections proposed in the hotel licensing bill
Council Member Menin details specific worker protections included in the proposed hotel licensing bill. These measures aim to improve safety and working conditions for hotel employees. - Requirement for panic …
0:03:53
·
64 sec
Addressing human trafficking concerns in New York City hotels
Council Member Menin highlights the issue of human trafficking in hotels and outlines measures in the proposed bill to combat this problem. - New York ranks 4th in the nation …
0:04:57
·
35 sec
Licensing hotels and amendments to the proposed bill
Council Member Menin explains the importance of licensing hotels and discusses the process of amending the proposed bill based on stakeholder feedback. - Licensing hotels is presented as an effective …
0:05:33
·
66 sec
Addressing concerns of employer pressure on workers regarding the legislation
Council Member Menin addresses reports of employers pressuring workers to participate against their will in public rallies related to the proposed legislation. - Reports have been received about workers being …
0:06:39
·
22 sec
Introduction to Intro 970 on licensing massage therapy businesses
Council Member Menin introduces Intro 970, which proposes licensing requirements for massage therapy businesses to combat human trafficking and illicit activities. - Massage therapy businesses are frequently used as covers …
0:07:02
·
43 sec
Hearing conduct instructions and transition to opening statements
Council Member Menin provides instructions for orderly conduct during the hearing and prepares to transition to opening statements from other council members. - Emphasis on conducting the hearing in an …
0:07:46
·
43 sec
Council member Krishnan introduces himself and praises NYC's hotel industry
Council Member Shekar Krishnan introduces himself as the representative of Jackson Heights, Elmhurst, and part of Woodside in Queens. He highlights the importance of hotels to NYC's tourism industry and …
0:08:32
·
25 sec
Council member Krishnan highlights problems in the hotel industry
Council Member Krishnan addresses the serious issues present in some parts of the hotel industry, including worker exploitation and criminal activity. He emphasizes that these problems make hotels less safe …
0:08:57
·
25 sec
Council member Krishnan expresses support for the Safe Hotels Act
Council Member Krishnan declares his support for the Safe Hotels Act, introduced by Council Member Julie Menin. He emphasizes the need for this legislation to address issues in the hotel …
0:09:23
·
34 sec
Council member Krishnan emphasizes the importance of licensing and regulation
Council Member Krishnan stresses the importance of licensing and regulation across various industries, including hotels. He argues that these measures are crucial for protecting workers and ensuring the success of …
0:09:57
·
28 sec
Council member Krishnan addresses sex trafficking in unlicensed hotels
Council Member Krishnan highlights the alarming issue of sex trafficking in unlicensed hotels and massage parlors. He shares personal observations from his district and emphasizes how this criminal activity affects …
0:10:27
·
62 sec
Council member Krishnan emphasizes worker protections and public safety
Council Member Krishnan underscores the importance of the Safe Hotels Act in protecting workers and ensuring public safety. He highlights his responsibility to his constituents, many of whom are hotel …
0:11:30
·
45 sec
Council member Krishnan expresses support for Intro 970 on licensing massage parlors
Council Member Krishnan briefly discusses and expresses support for Intro 970, which aims to license massage parlors. He draws parallels between the issues in unlicensed hotels and unlicensed massage parlors. …
0:12:17
·
34 sec
Council member Krishnan concludes with acknowledgments and expressions of support
Council Member Krishnan concludes his statement with acknowledgments and expressions of support for the Safe Hotels Act, his colleagues, labor organizations, and hotel workers. He reaffirms his commitment to fighting …
0:12:52
·
54 sec
Council Member Lynn Schulman expresses support for Intro 991-B, citing issues with the Umbrella Hotel in Queens
Council Member Lynn Schulman of District 29 in Queens expresses strong support for Intro 991-B, which would require licensing for hotels in New York City. She cites the problematic history …
0:13:52
·
3 min
Council Member Julie Menin presents evidence of hotel safety issues and crime statistics
Council Member Julie Menin presents visual evidence and statistics highlighting safety concerns in New York City hotels. She describes images showing unsanitary working conditions, violence, and provides alarming crime statistics …
0:16:59
·
86 sec
Council Member Moya advocates for Intro 970 to address illegal massage businesses
Council Member Francisco Moya provides context and urgently advocates for Intro 970, a bill he introduced to combat the proliferation of illegal massage businesses in New York City, particularly in …
0:18:26
·
3 min
Council Member Shaun Abreu expresses support for Intro 991-B, the Hotel Safe Act
Council Member Shaun Abreu voices his support for Intro 991-B, the Hotel Safe Act, emphasizing the need for improved safety in hotels for both patrons and workers. He highlights the …
0:22:01
·
53 sec
Introduction and overview of the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection
Commissioner Vilda Vera Mayuga introduces herself and provides an overview of the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP). She highlights the department's role in protecting consumers and workers, as …
0:23:28
·
76 sec
Importance of the hotel industry and DCWP's regulatory role
Commissioner Mayuga emphasizes the importance of the hotel industry to New York City's economy and outlines DCWP's role in regulating the industry. - The hotel industry contributes $74 billion to …
0:24:45
·
47 sec
Recent hotel-related legislation and its impact
Commissioner Mayuga discusses recent hotel-related legislation, including Local Law 99 of 2020 and Local Law 104 of 2021, and their impacts on hotel workers and consumers. - Local Law 99 …
0:25:33
·
106 sec
Overview of Introduction 991-B and DCWP's general recommendations
Commissioner Mayuga provides an overview of Introduction 991-B, which would create a new licensing requirement for hotels, and outlines DCWP's general recommendations for effective licensing. - Introduction 991-B aims to …
0:27:20
·
89 sec
Recommendations on subcontracting restrictions and consumer protections
Commissioner Mayuga offers specific recommendations for Introduction 991-B, focusing on subcontracting restrictions and additional consumer protections. - DCWP supports restrictions on subcontracting to protect workers' rights and working conditions - …
0:28:50
·
103 sec
Enforcement considerations and resource needs
Commissioner Mayuga addresses enforcement considerations, resource needs, and licensing fees related to the implementation of Introduction 991-B. - DCWP will work with city hall, OMB, and the council on securing …
0:30:34
·
43 sec
Introduction 970 on massage parlor licensing
Commissioner Mayuga briefly addresses Introduction 970 related to massage parlor licensing, noting that DCWP has not had sufficient time to review the proposal in detail. - The proposal was added …
0:31:18
·
62 sec
Support for hotel licensing bill and discussion on subcontracting restrictions
Council Member Julie Menin expresses support for the hotel licensing bill and discusses the importance of subcontracting restrictions with Commissioner Vilda Vera Mayuga. The discussion focuses on how subcontracting can …
0:32:22
·
92 sec
Increase in consumer complaints and potential underreporting to DCWP
Council Member Julie Menin inquires about the doubling of consumer complaints to DCWP regarding hotels in the past 5 years and discusses the potential underreporting of issues to the agency. …
0:33:55
·
64 sec
DCWP's research and interactions with other cities on hotel licensing
Council Member Julie Menin inquires about DCWP's interactions with other cities that license hotels, and DCWP representatives discuss their research and plans for engaging with other municipalities. - DCWP has …
0:34:59
·
69 sec
Worker protection aspects of the hotel licensing bill
Council Member Julie Menin and DCWP representatives discuss the worker protection aspects of the hotel licensing bill, including panic buttons and safety measures for hotel employees. - The bill includes …
0:36:09
·
117 sec
Public safety concerns and DCWP's focus on the licensing scheme
Council Member Julie Menin raises public safety concerns related to hotels, citing the Umbrella Hotel case and alarming crime statistics. DCWP representatives discuss their focus on the licensing scheme and …
0:38:07
·
171 sec
License transferability and addressing human trafficking in hotels
DCWP representatives discuss concerns about license transferability and propose ways to address human trafficking issues within the hotel licensing framework. - DCWP recommends against easy transferability of hotel licenses to …
0:40:58
·
83 sec
Consumer protection against junk fees in hotels
Council Member Julie Menin and DCWP representatives discuss the agency's recommendation to add consumer protections against junk fees, such as resort and amenity fees, in the hotel licensing bill. - …
0:42:21
·
105 sec
Impact of hotel licensing on single room occupancy (SRO) tenants
Council Member Gale A. Brewer raises concerns about how the proposed hotel licensing would affect single room occupancy (SRO) hotels with permanent tenants, particularly on the west side of the …
0:44:08
·
99 sec
Concerns about subcontractors and protecting hotel workers
Council Member Gale A. Brewer expresses concern about hotels opposing the legislation and the potential impact on subcontracted workers. She asks how to ensure workers don't lose their jobs while …
0:45:48
·
175 sec
Addressing resort fees and improving consumer protection in hotels
Council Member Gale A. Brewer inquires about how to address the issue of resort fees in hotels, which she describes as 'outrageous.' She asks whether this would be addressed through …
0:48:43
·
110 sec
Concerns about hotel costs and competition from New Jersey
Council Member Gale A. Brewer expresses concerns about the high cost of accommodations in New York City and its impact on tourism. She highlights the problem of visitors choosing to …
0:50:33
·
27 sec
Council Member Menin clarifies worker retention law
Council Member Julie Menin clarifies information about the worker retention law in response to a previous question from Council Member Brewer. She explains that the law, passed by the council …
0:51:01
·
26 sec
Council Member Chris Banks expresses strong support for hotel licensing bill to combat illegal activities
Council Member Chris Banks voices his strong support for Intro 991-B, emphasizing its importance in combating illegal activities in hotels within his district. He highlights how the bill will address …
0:51:29
·
114 sec
Introduction and overview of questions for DCWP
Council Member Amanda Farías introduces a series of questions for the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) officials regarding various aspects of the proposed hotel licensing bill. She acknowledges …
0:53:32
·
37 sec
Discussion on economic impact of hotels on local economy
Council Member Farías inquires about the breakdown of the $74 billion economic impact of hotels on the local economy, specifically asking for details on revenue generated by small, medium, and …
0:54:12
·
10 sec
Overview of complaints received under Local Law 99
Council Member Farías inquires about the statistics and breakdown of complaints received under Local Law 99. Commissioner Vilda Vera Mayuga provides information on the number and nature of hotel-related complaints …
0:54:22
·
82 sec
Patterns in consumer complaints about hotels
DCWP officials discuss the patterns they've observed in consumer complaints about hotels. They explain how they identify patterns, investigate bad actors, and highlight the most prevalent types of complaints they …
0:55:44
·
178 sec
DCWP's role in regulating sex trafficking in hotels
Council Member Farías inquires about DCWP's role in regulating or managing patterns of sex trafficking in hotels. Commissioner Vilda Vera Mayuga clarifies that DCWP does not handle these issues directly. …
0:58:42
·
24 sec
Timeline for researching other municipalities' hotel licensing practices
Council Member Farías inquires about DCWP's timeline for researching hotel licensing practices in other municipalities and providing feedback to the council. Carlos Ortiz from DCWP responds with their plans and …
0:59:10
·
79 sec
Complaints about digital check-in and front desk personnel
Council Member Farías inquires about complaints received regarding the lack of front desk personnel or difficulties with digital check-in at hotels. Melissa Iachan from DCWP responds to the query. - …
1:00:29
·
35 sec
Enforcement, revocation, and shutdown procedures for hotels
Council Member Farías inquires about the procedures for enforcing regulations, revoking licenses, and shutting down hotels, particularly concerning the impact on employees. DCWP officials explain their current practices and concerns …
1:01:05
·
3 min
Resource requirements and hiring freeze impact on DCWP
Council Member Farías inquires about the resource requirements for implementing Intro 991 and the impact of the hiring freeze on DCWP. Commissioner Vilda Vera Mayuga explains the agency's current situation …
1:04:35
·
102 sec
Direct employment requirements in licensing
Council Member Farías inquires whether DCWP has any other licenses that currently require direct employment. Melissa Iachan from DCWP provides a clear response. - DCWP confirms that they currently do …
1:06:17
·
23 sec
Potential impact on outer borough hotels and workers
Council Member Farías inquires about the potential impact of the proposed licensing requirements on outer borough hotels, workers, and small businesses. Carlos Ortiz from DCWP responds to these concerns. - …
1:06:40
·
80 sec
Brief discussion of Intro 970 related to massage therapy businesses
Council Member Farías briefly inquires about Intro 970, which relates to massage therapy businesses. Commissioner Vilda Vera Mayuga provides a short response, followed by concluding remarks. - Farías asks if …
1:08:00
·
42 sec
Testimony by Brendan Griffith, Chief of Staff of New York City Central Labor Council, on the Safe Hotels Act
Brendan Griffith, representing the New York City Central Labor Council, testifies in strong support of the Safe Hotels Act. He emphasizes the importance of the hotel industry to the city's …
1:10:32
·
143 sec
Testimony by David Weil, Professor at Brandeis University and Harvard Kennedy School, on Hotel Subcontracting and Worker Protections
David Weil, a professor and former US Department of Labor official, testified on the impacts of subcontracting in the hotel industry and expressed support for the proposed hotel licensing bill. …
1:13:15
·
160 sec
Testimony by Keisha Sutton-James, Deputy Manhattan Borough President, Manhattan Borough President's Office on Hotel Licensing Bill
Keisha Sutton-James, representing Manhattan Borough President Mark Levin, testified in support of Intro 991-B, which would require licensing for hotels in New York City. She emphasized the bill's potential to …
1:16:07
·
172 sec
Testimony by Tariqua Morrison, Deputy General Counsel and Director of Intergovernmental Affairs from Queens Borough President's Office on Safe Hotels Act
Tariqua Morrison, representing Queens Borough President Donovan Richards, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasizes the importance of the tourism industry to New York City and the …
1:19:02
·
131 sec
Julie Menin acknowledges previous testimony and prepares for questions
Council Member Julie Menin thanks the previous speaker for their testimony and support from the borough president. She then prepares to ask questions to two individuals, Brendan Griffith and Mr. …
1:21:13
·
10 sec
Julie Menin questions Brendan Griffith about wage theft and subcontracting
Council Member Julie Menin asks Brendan Griffith from the New York City Central Labor Council about wage theft, subcontracting, and working conditions. Griffith explains the issues with subcontracting and its …
1:21:24
·
54 sec
Julie Menin questions Mr. Weil about the impact of subcontracting ban on wages
Council Member Julie Menin asks Professor David Weil about the potential impact of the subcontracting ban on wages for hotel workers. Weil explains the expected positive effects of the ban …
1:22:19
·
81 sec
Julie Menin concludes the current panel and calls the next one
Council Member Julie Menin wraps up the current panel discussion and transitions to the next panel of speakers. She calls out names for the upcoming panel and provides instructions for …
1:23:43
·
60 sec
Testimony by Sarah Bratko, Vice President & Policy Counsel of American Hotel And Lodging Association (AHLA) on Intro 991-B
Sarah Bratko from the American Hotel And Lodging Association (AHLA) expresses concerns about Intro 991-B, acknowledging improvements in version B but stating it would still have devastating impacts on the …
1:24:44
·
107 sec
Testimony by Jagruti Panwala, Hotel Owner and Member of Board of Directors of American Hotel and Lodging Association, on Intro 991-B
Jagruti Panwala, a hotel owner and board member of the American Hotel and Lodging Association, testified against Intro 991-B, arguing that it would negatively impact small hotel businesses in New …
1:26:35
·
121 sec
Testimony by Jerry Kremer, Former New York State Assembly Member, on Intro 991-B
Jerry Kremer, a former New York State Assembly Member, testified in opposition to a portion of Intro 991-B, specifically the requirement for a collective bargaining agreement to obtain a city …
1:28:50
·
135 sec
Testimony by Trupti Patel, Hotel Owner on Intro 991-B
Trupti Patel, a hotel owner, testified about her family's journey in the hotel business and expressed concerns about the impact of Intro 991-B on small, family-owned hotels. She emphasized the …
1:31:09
·
130 sec
Testimony by Purvi Panwala, Hotel Owner and Member of American Hotel and Lodging Association, on Intro 991-B
Purvi Panwala, a second-generation hotelier and member of the American Hotel and Lodging Association, testified in opposition to Intro 991-B. She emphasized the challenges faced by small, minority-owned hotels and …
1:33:23
·
130 sec
Clarification on collective bargaining agreement requirements
Council Member Julie Menin clarifies that the bill does not require a collective bargaining agreement (CBA). She explains the actual language of the bill regarding CBAs. - The bill does …
1:35:33
·
26 sec
Clarification on subcontracting ban exemptions
Council Member Julie Menin provides clarification on the subcontracting ban in the bill, highlighting changes made after stakeholder meetings. - The subcontracting ban was narrowed - Exemptions were added for …
1:35:59
·
28 sec
Conclusion and calling the next panel
Council Member Julie Menin concludes her remarks and calls the next panel of speakers. - She thanks the current speakers for their testimony - She calls forward the next panel …
1:36:28
·
61 sec
Testimony by Marion Kendall, Co-chair of New York State Anti-Trafficking Coalition and Founder of Thrive, on the Safe Hotels Act
Marion Kendall, representing the New York State Anti-Trafficking Coalition and Thrive, testified in support of the Safe Hotels Act, emphasizing its importance in combating human trafficking within the hospitality industry. …
1:37:32
·
152 sec
Testimony by Christian Eduardo, Advocate for Human Trafficking Prevention, on the Safe Hotel Act
Christian Eduardo, a survivor of human trafficking, testifies in support of the Safe Hotel Act. He shares his personal experience of being trafficked and emphasizes the role hotels play in …
1:40:09
·
129 sec
Testimony by Ruoxi Chen, Program Manager of Garden of Hope, on the Safe Hotels Act
Ruoxi Chen, Program Manager of Garden of Hope, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act, highlighting the dangers faced by human trafficking survivors in hotels. She emphasizes the urgent …
1:42:22
·
130 sec
Testimony by Elizabeth Saka, Administrator of Anti-Human Trafficking at Covenant House New York (CHNY) on the Safe Hotels Act
Elizabeth Saka, representing Covenant House New York, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasizes the importance of the bill in combating human trafficking and protecting vulnerable individuals, …
1:44:36
·
121 sec
Testimony by Hemal Patel, Business Owner from NYC Hospitality Industry
Hemal Patel, a small business owner in the NYC hospitality industry, expresses strong opposition to Intro 991-B, citing concerns about its impact on small, independent, and minority-owned hotels. He argues …
1:48:06
·
136 sec
Testimony by Bradley Burwell, Executive Vice President at Colliers, on Intro 991-B
Bradley Burwell, Executive Vice President at Colliers, testifies against Intro 991-B, warning of significant negative impacts on New York City's hospitality real estate sector. He argues that the bill would …
1:50:26
·
127 sec
Testimony by Preyas Patel, Northeast Regional Director of Asian American Hotel Owners Association (AAHOA)
Preyas Patel, representing the Asian American Hotel Owners Association (AAHOA), strongly opposes the proposed hotel licensing bill. He argues that the bill primarily serves union interests, unfairly bans subcontractors, and …
1:52:36
·
126 sec
Testimony by Sandy Patel, Business Owner/Representative from NYC Hospitality Industry on Intro 991-B
Sandy Patel, representing hotel owners in New York City, testifies in strong opposition to the proposed hotel licensing bill, Intro 991-B. He argues that the bill, while presented as a …
1:54:50
·
164 sec
Testimony by Michael Paglialonga, Representative from Littler Mendelson P.C. on Intro 991-B
Michael Paglialonga, representing Littler Mendelson and the Workplace Policy Institute, testified against Intro 991-B, highlighting legal flaws in the bill. He argued that the bill is preempted by federal law, …
1:57:39
·
146 sec
Council member addresses changes made to the bill based on lender feedback
Council Member Julie Menin explains the changes made to Intro 991-B in response to feedback from lenders and the hotel industry. She highlights the removal of service disruption as grounds …
2:00:14
·
56 sec
Testimony by Carmen Polanco, Hotel Worker, on Working Conditions in New York City Hotels
Carmen Polanco, a hotel worker in New York City, testified in support of the Safe Hotels Act (Intro 991-B). She shared her experiences working for a staffing agency, describing dangerous …
2:02:56
·
7 min
Testimony by Hotel Worker on Hotel Safety and Human Trafficking
A hotel worker with 6 years of experience, testified about the lack of training and safety measures in hotels regarding human trafficking. She described her experiences of witnessing suspicious activities …
2:12:54
·
84 sec
Testimony by Paula Rodriguez, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotels Act
Paula Rodriguez, a hotel worker, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act despite the risk of losing her job. She describes the poor working conditions and exploitation she faces …
2:16:02
·
74 sec
Testimony by Mukesh Patel, Member of New York Minority Hotel Association and Asian American Hotel Owners Association
Mukesh Patel, representing small hotel owners, testified in opposition to Intro 991-B, citing concerns about its impact on small and minority-owned hotels. He argued that the bill's provisions, particularly the …
2:18:50
·
3 min
Testimony by Sheetel Patel on NYC Hotel Licensing Bill
Sheetel Patel, a female immigrant and small business owner, spoke against the proposed New York City hotel licensing bill. She expressed concerns about the potential negative impacts on small hotel …
2:22:38
·
70 sec
Testimony by Jeff Brosi, Owner/Operator of Rockaway Hotel, on Intro 991-B
Jeff Brosi, owner/operator of the Rockaway Hotel in Queens, testifies in opposition to Intro 991-B, focusing on the bill's restrictions on third-party contractors. He emphasizes the challenges of staffing a …
2:24:00
·
83 sec
Testimony by Representative of an NYC Hotel Company on the Safe Hotels Act
A representative of a NYC hotel company testifies against the Safe Hotels Act, arguing that it would significantly alter their business model and negatively impact their subcontractors. The speaker emphasizes …
2:25:27
·
162 sec
Testimony by Anudeep Gosal, Director of Hotel Advisory Group at Besen Partners
Anudeep Gosal, Director of the Hotel Advisory Group at Besen Partners, expresses opposition to the proposed hotel licensing bill, arguing that it will have negative effects on the hotel industry …
2:28:27
·
123 sec
Clarification on collective bargaining agreement in the bill
Council Member Julie Menin clarifies a point about the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) in relation to the proposed bill. She emphasizes that a CBA is not required under the bill, …
2:30:42
·
25 sec
Council Member Brewer questions impact of bill on hotel staffing
Council Member Gale A. Brewer addresses hotel owners, questioning the perceived negative impact of the new bill on the industry. She notes that the bill requires only a limited number …
2:31:07
·
51 sec
Hotel representative discusses staffing challenges and subcontracting
A hotel representative responds to Council Member Brewer's questions, explaining the complexities of staffing in the hotel industry. The representative emphasizes the importance of subcontracting and the varying staffing needs …
2:31:59
·
70 sec
Testimony by Richard Hurd, Professor Emeritus at Cornell University, on Hotel Industry Subcontracting
Richard Hurd, Professor Emeritus at Cornell University, testified about the need for legislation requiring hotels to directly employ core employees due to changes in the hotel industry structure. He emphasized …
2:33:59
·
145 sec
Testimony by Mark Bellamy, House Person at Margaritaville NYC
Mark Bellamy, a house person at Margaritaville NYC, testified in support of the Safe Hotels Act. He shared his personal experience transitioning from a subcontractor to a direct hotel employee, …
2:36:32
·
77 sec
Testimony by Hachao Yi, Hotel Worker on Hotel Worker Safety
Hachao Yi, a hotel worker with nearly 34 years of experience, testifies about the importance of panic buttons for hotel worker safety. She recounts personal experiences of encountering naked guests …
2:37:53
·
84 sec
Testimony by Hotel Worker on Safe Hotel Act
A hotel worker testifies in support of the Safe Hotel Act, sharing their personal experience of working for a subcontracting agency at a hotel in New York City. The worker …
2:39:22
·
114 sec
Testimony by Aretha Wareham, Resident of Queens and Member of Nissan Versco Civic Association
Aretha Wareham, a resident of Queens and member of the Nissan Versco Civic Association, testified in support of the proposed bill. She emphasized the need for safer communities, particularly in …
2:41:54
·
70 sec
Testimony by Larinda Hooks on Intro 970
Larinda Hooks, a resident of District 21 in Queens, testifies in support of Intro 970, emphasizing its importance for combating human trafficking and safeguarding public health in Queens. She urges …
2:43:21
·
48 sec
Testimony by Kristina Hinkson, President of New York State Society of Medical Massage Therapists (NYSSMMT)
Kristina Hinkson, President of the New York State Society of Medical Massage Therapists (NYSSMMT), testified in support of the bill with amendments. She highlighted the importance of massage therapy in …
2:44:21
·
148 sec
Testimony by Lucy Palacios, Licensed Massage Therapist and Member of Nismet
Lucy Palacios, a licensed massage therapist from Jackson Heights, testifies about the challenges faced by legitimate massage businesses and the prevalence of human trafficking in unlicensed establishments. She highlights the …
2:46:52
·
98 sec
Testimony by Terence Monahan, Former Chief of Department of NYPD, on Intro 991-B
Terence Monahan, former NYPD Chief of Department, testified against Intro 991-B, arguing that the bill's claims about crime and human trafficking in hotels are not based on accurate facts. He …
2:49:24
·
163 sec
Testimony by Barbara, Former Employee of an Outsourcing Company
Barbara, a former employee of an outsourcing company, shared her positive experience working for 5 years in a role that provided more than just employment. She emphasized the family-like environment …
2:52:16
·
70 sec
Testimony by Unknown Speaker on Outsourced Companies in the Hotel Industry
The speaker, an immigrant who arrived in the US in 2014, shares their positive experience with an outsourced company in the hotel industry. They emphasize how the company provided training, …
2:53:39
·
124 sec
Testimony by Oscar Lopez, Manager of Operations in the Hotel Industry
Oscar Lopez, a manager of operations in the hotel industry, expresses his opposition to the proposed bill (Intro 991-B). He shares his personal journey in the industry and argues that …
2:55:50
·
96 sec
Testimony by Christie on Hotel Subcontracting and Worker Training
Christie, a 20-year veteran of the hospitality industry, testifies about her experience working with hotel subcontractors and providing training to employees. She argues against the passing of the bill (presumably …
2:57:30
·
89 sec
Council member highlights public safety support for the bill
Council Member Julie Menin addresses public safety concerns by noting the support for the bill from key law enforcement entities. - Support comes from 5 district attorneys, the PBA, and …
2:59:02
·
14 sec
Testimony by Ilda Alvarez, Hotel Worker
Ilda Alvarez, a hotel worker with over 40 years of experience, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasizes the importance of standing up for what's right and …
3:00:07
·
40 sec
Testimony by Jacqueline Figueroa, New York Worker
Jacqueline Figueroa, a New York worker from the Bronx, testified in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasized the importance of job safety for workers like herself and urged …
3:00:51
·
13 sec
Testimony by Rosa Saldana, Hotel Worker
Rosa Saldana, a hotel worker from the Dominican Republic, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasizes the importance of protecting workers in the tourist industry, particularly immigrants …
3:01:59
·
29 sec
Testimony by Trishana Brown, Hotel Worker on the Safe Hotels Act
Trishana Brown, a hotel worker, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act, sharing her experiences with subcontract agencies and the challenges she faced as a hotel worker. She describes …
3:03:09
·
159 sec
Testimony by Stella Tenzin, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotels Act
Stella Tenzin, a hotel worker and resident of Woodside, New York City, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act (Intro 991-B). She emphasizes the importance of the law for …
3:05:51
·
49 sec
Testimony by Jason Gamel, President/CEO of American Resort Development Association (ARDA) on Hotel Licensing Legislation
Jason Gamel, representing the American Resort Development Association (ARDA), testified about the potential impact of the hotel licensing legislation on the timeshare industry. He argued that timeshares should be exempted …
3:07:22
·
145 sec
Testimony by Raphael, Human Resource Director of a Subcontracting Company
Raphael, a Human Resource Director for a subcontracting company, testifies against Intro 991-B, arguing that it would negatively impact the opportunities his company offers to employees, particularly immigrants. He highlights …
3:09:56
·
109 sec
Testimony by Juan Chaudhong, Hotel Worker, on Proposed Hotel Licensing Bill
Juan Chaudhong, an LGBT immigrant from Colombia, testifies against the proposed hotel licensing bill. He shares his personal story of finding opportunities and acceptance working for a hotel company in …
3:11:49
·
138 sec
Testimony by Tatiana Vicolina, Hotel Worker from HHI Company
Tatiana Vicolina, an immigrant and LGBT asylum seeker from Russia, shares her positive experience working for HHI, a hotel housekeeping company. She expresses gratitude for the job opportunity and career …
3:14:10
·
121 sec
Testimony by Eugenia, Hotel Worker, on Intro 991-B
Eugenia, a hotel worker, shares her personal story as an immigrant who found stable employment through a subcontracting company. She expresses concern about the potential impact of Intro 991-B on …
3:16:16
·
108 sec
Council member clarifies misinformation about subcontracted workers
Council Member Julie Menin addresses misinformation given to a previous speaker about subcontracted workers losing their jobs. She clarifies that subcontracted workers must be offered their jobs at the same …
3:18:05
·
22 sec
Testimony by Eric Mosher, Lead Economist at Independent Budget Office (IBO), on Intro 991-B
Eric Mosher, Lead Economist at the Independent Budget Office (IBO), presents findings from a forthcoming IBO report on the potential impact of Intro 991-B (the Safe Hotels Act) on hotels …
3:19:40
·
150 sec
Testimony by Representative from Kew Gardens Civic Association on Hotel Safety Legislation
A representative from the Kew Gardens Civic Association testifies in support of proposed hotel safety legislation, citing a fatal incident at the Umbrella Hotel in Kew Gardens as evidence of …
3:24:18
·
146 sec
Q&A on potential impact of hotel licensing legislation
Council Member Julie Menin engages in a brief Q&A session with a representative from the Kew Gardens Civic Association about the potential impact of the proposed hotel licensing legislation. - …
3:26:45
·
81 sec
Testimony by Hotel Worker from Margaritaville NYC on Working Conditions and the Safe Hotel Act
A hotel worker from Margaritaville NYC shares their experience working for a subcontracting agency and the improvements they saw after the agency left. They advocate for passing the Safe Hotel …
3:32:25
·
49 sec
Testimony by Viviana Pereira, Hotel Worker on the Safe Hotels Act
Viviana Pereira, a hotel room attendant with 7 years of experience, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasizes the importance of safety protections for hotel workers, particularly …
3:34:20
·
78 sec
Testimony by Sonia Diliberta, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotels Act
Sonia Diliberta, a hotel worker with a union job, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasizes the importance of worker protections and urges the committee to vote …
3:37:13
·
35 sec
Testimony by Sonia Randolph, Hotel Worker, on the Hotel Safety Act
Sonia Randolph, a hotel worker in New York City, testified in support of the Hotel Safety Act. She shared her personal experience as an immigrant who achieved her American dream …
3:37:53
·
67 sec
Testimony by Rolando Randon Quintero, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotels Act
Rolando Randon Quintero, a hotel worker from Mexico, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. He shares his personal experience of building a life in New York City and …
3:39:02
·
62 sec
Testimony by Raisa Pujol, Hotel Worker (via Spanish Interpreter)
Raisa Pujol, a hotel worker and mother of six, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasizes the need for safety protections for hotel workers, particularly those working …
3:41:34
·
32 sec
Testimony by Eric Oasu, Hotel Worker on the Safe Hotels Act
Eric Oasu, a hotel worker, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act (Intro 991-B). He emphasizes that the law would provide common-sense protections for hotel workers and urges the …
3:42:09
·
51 sec
Testimony by Boris, Hotel Worker on Intro 991-B
Boris, a Russian asylum seeker and hotel worker, testifies against Intro 991-B, expressing concerns about its potential negative impact on his job and livelihood. He shares his personal journey of …
3:43:38
·
107 sec
Testimony by Richard Foster, Small Business Owner, on Intro 991-B
Richard Foster, a small business owner in the hotel subcontracting industry, testified against Intro 991-B, arguing that it would negatively impact small businesses while hiding behind the facade of safety …
3:45:31
·
149 sec
Testimony by Dominic De Leon, Commercial Cleaning Company Owner, on Intro 991-B
Dominic De Leon, a small business owner of a commercial cleaning company, testifies against Intro 991-B, arguing that it would unfairly impact third-party vendors like his business and harm workers. …
3:48:02
·
155 sec
Clarification on subcontracted worker retention rights
Council Member Julie Menin clarifies misinformation about subcontracted workers' rights under the worker retention bill. - Subcontracted workers must be offered their jobs at the same or higher salary if …
3:50:40
·
36 sec
Testimony by Michael Angelo Savino, Hotel Worker
Michael Angelo Savino, a hotel worker and lifelong New Yorker, testifies in support of the Safe Hotel Act. He shares his personal experience as a union member for 28 years …
3:52:01
·
55 sec
Testimony by Judelina Santiago, Room Attendant from Lexington Hotel
Judelina Santiago, a room attendant, testified in support of the Safe Hotel Act, sharing her negative experiences working for a subcontracting agency. She described poor working conditions, including unpaid work …
3:53:00
·
104 sec
Testimony by Sabrina Dizamo, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotel Act
Sabrina Dizamo, a hotel worker, testifies in support of the Safe Hotel Act, sharing her negative experience working for a cleaning agency at a hotel. She describes unsanitary working conditions, …
3:54:47
·
139 sec
Testimony by Hotel Worker on Safe Hotels Act
A hotel worker testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act, sharing personal experiences of poor working conditions, inadequate supplies, and abusive management while employed through a subcontracting agency in …
3:57:09
·
3 min
Testimony by Elizabeth Sanchez, Hotel Worker on Hotel Licensing and Worker Protections
Elizabeth Sanchez, a hotel worker with 24 years of experience, testifies in support of hotel licensing and worker protections. She emphasizes the importance of union membership in providing fair compensation, …
4:00:27
·
95 sec
Testimony by Marcelo Lugo, Resident of Jackson Heights and Elmhurst
Marcelo Lugo, a long-time resident of Jackson Heights and Elmhurst, testifies in support of the bill to improve the quality of life in her neighborhood. She expresses concerns about the …
4:02:42
·
126 sec
Testimony by Eric, Hotel Worker
Eric, a hotel worker from the Bronx, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act, sharing a personal experience of being pepper sprayed at work to highlight the need for …
4:04:56
·
38 sec
Testimony by Benjamin Lu, Hotel Worker on the Safe Hotels Act
Benjamin Lu, a New York City hotel worker, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. He shares his experience working as an overnight housekeeper for a subcontracting agency at …
4:05:45
·
85 sec
Testimony by Isatta Bukoom, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotels Act
Isatta Bukoom, a New York City hotel worker, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act (Intro 991-B), emphasizing the importance of panic buttons for worker safety. She shares a …
4:09:40
·
137 sec
Testimony by Chandra Singh, Member of Hotel and Gaming Trades Council
Chandra Singh, a member of the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council, testified in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She shared her personal experience as a long-time hotel worker and …
4:12:00
·
57 sec
Testimony by Sudi Zhang, Hotel Worker, on Intro 991-B
Sudi Zhang, a hotel worker and immigrant from China living in Queens, testifies in support of Intro 991-B, emphasizing the importance of a safe working environment for hotel workers in …
4:13:00
·
47 sec
Testimony by Vanessa Aronson, Member of the Public, on Intro 991-B
Vanessa Aronson, a resident of the Upper East Side and a leader at a national nonprofit, expressed strong support for Intro 991-B, the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasized the importance …
4:14:24
·
120 sec
Testimony by Koju Okobe Okon, Hotel Worker
Koju Okobe Okon, a hotel worker from Ghana, testifies in support of the hotel safety act. He shares his positive experience working under an HTC CBA and urges the council …
4:16:41
·
81 sec
Testimony by Charles Safo, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotels Act
Charles Safo, a hotel worker in New York City, testified in support of the Safe Hotels Act, emphasizing the importance of basic safety protections for hotel workers. He urged the …
4:18:08
·
47 sec
Testimony by Tracy Bennett, Hotel Worker
Tracy Bennett, a hotel worker with 17 years of experience, provided brief testimony in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She urged the committee to pass the legislation to protect …
4:19:05
·
16 sec
Testimony by Emilia Yuez Yuanke, Hotel Worker
Emilia Yuez Yuanke, a hotel worker in New York City, testified in support of the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasized the importance of basic safety protections for hotel workers and …
4:19:25
·
36 sec
Testimony by Damian Lawrence, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotels Act
Damian Lawrence, a hotel worker with 12 years of experience, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. He emphasizes the importance of the law for hotel workers in New …
4:20:04
·
32 sec
Testimony by Rita Secic from North Staffing Group on Intro 991-B
Rita Secic, representing North Staffing Group, testified in opposition to Intro 991-B, the Safe Hotels Act. She emphasized her company's commitment to providing essential services in housekeeping while ensuring compliance …
4:21:24
·
87 sec
Testimony by Hotel Worker on Intro 991-B
A hotel worker with over 15 years of experience testifies against Intro 991-B, expressing concerns about job stability and potential hardships for employees and their families if the bill passes. …
4:23:00
·
40 sec
Testimony by Tracy Bennett, Hotel Worker
Tracy Bennett, a hotel worker, expresses gratitude for the opportunities provided by her employer and requests continued support for growth and professional development. - She mentions her career progression from …
4:23:42
·
37 sec
Testimony by Oksana, Representative of Subcontractor Cleaning Services, on Intro 991-B
Oksana, representing a subcontractor cleaning services business, testified against Intro 991-B, arguing that it would negatively impact small businesses and the community they support. She emphasized the role of her …
4:24:25
·
112 sec
Testimony by Catalina Quitenilla, Hotel Worker
Catalina Quitenilla, a hotel worker with 20 years of experience, testified in support of the Hotel Safety Act. She emphasized the importance of safety measures for hotel workers, including panic …
4:28:07
·
51 sec
Testimony by Denise Mathieu, Hotel Worker on the Safe Hotel Act
Denise Mathieu, a 29-year veteran of the hotel industry, testifies in support of the Safe Hotel Act. She emphasizes the importance of safe working conditions for all hotel workers and …
4:29:03
·
36 sec
Testimony by Bernard Gail, Member of the Public
Bernard Gail, a member of the public who works in Times Square, urged the panel to consider the importance of protecting all workers, both union and non-union. He emphasized the …
4:29:43
·
91 sec
Testimony by Nicole Lewis, Hotel Worker
Nicole Lewis, a hotel worker with 29 years of experience, testifies in support of the hotel licensing bill. She emphasizes her hard work and urges the committee to pass the …
4:31:21
·
37 sec
Testimony by Lelon Webb, Security Officer at an NYC Hotel, on the Safe Hotels Act
Lelon Webb, a security officer with extensive public safety experience, strongly supports the Safe Hotels Act. He emphasizes the importance of safety for both hotel workers and guests in New …
4:32:02
·
65 sec
Testimony by Hotel Subcontractor Employee on Intro 991-B
A hotel subcontractor employee testifies against Intro 991-B, sharing their personal experience as a migrant who found employment through a subcontractor after struggling to find work in the hotel industry. …
4:33:48
·
82 sec
Testimony by Avenio Olivo, Hotel Worker, on Intro 991-B
Avenio Olivo, a hotel worker, testified against the proposed changes in Intro 991-B, arguing that third-party agencies already provide excellent service and support to hotel staff. He expressed concern about …
4:35:13
·
81 sec
Testimony by Kevin McQueen, Hotel Worker in New York City
Kevin McQueen, a hotel worker with 18 years of experience in New York City, testifies in support of the Safe Hotels Act. He emphasizes the importance of union representation in …
4:37:19
·
44 sec
Testimony by Lisbon Yelosa, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotel Act
Lisbon Yelosa, a hotel worker, testified in support of the Safe Hotel Act, sharing her personal experience with unsafe working conditions at a subcontracted agency in a Times Square hotel. …
4:39:50
·
70 sec
Testimony by Amelia Garcia, Hotel Worker
Amelia Garcia, a hotel worker in Manhattan, testifies against the proposed hotel licensing law, expressing concern about potential job loss and financial impact on her family. She emphasizes the importance …
4:42:43
·
119 sec
Testimony by Lionel Sanchez, Hotel Worker
Lionel Sanchez, a hotel worker in Manhattan, expressed satisfaction with his job environment and working conditions. He highlighted the friendly atmosphere, good relationships with coworkers and superiors, and the financial …
4:45:22
·
133 sec
Testimony by Byron Opasso, Hotel Worker
Byron Opasso, a hotel worker speaking through a Spanish interpreter, expresses satisfaction with his current job and concerns about the proposed law. He emphasizes the positive aspects of his work …
4:48:22
·
110 sec
Testimony by Nicole Bera, Hotel Worker
Nicole Bera, a hotel worker in Manhattan, expresses her positive experiences working in the hotel industry. She highlights the economic support, good work environment, and understanding bosses that have contributed …
4:50:45
·
80 sec
Testimony by Stephanie, Hotel Worker (via Spanish Interpreter)
Stephanie, a hotel worker speaking through a Spanish interpreter, expresses concern about a proposed new law that could affect her current job. She emphasizes the positive aspects of her current …
4:52:38
·
102 sec
Council member addresses misinformation about workers' rights
Council Member Julie Menin addresses misinformation being spread about workers' rights, specifically regarding subcontracted workers. She emphasizes the importance of workers knowing their rights and the need to stop the …
4:54:22
·
63 sec
Council member ensures resource availability and calls next panel
Council Member Julie Menin ensures that information about workers' rights will be made available in Spanish and calls for the next panel of speakers to come forward. - Requests council …
4:55:25
·
49 sec
Testimony by Yosairi Pereira, Housekeeper at The Freedom Hotel Town
Yosairi Pereira, a housekeeper at The Freedom Hotel Town, testified about the challenges faced by hotel workers during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. She highlighted the issues with eliminating daily …
4:56:40
·
95 sec
Testimony by Sahai Comecho, Hotel Worker, on Hotel Worker Safety
Sahai Comecho, a hotel worker in New York City, testified about the challenges and safety concerns faced by hotel workers, particularly women in housekeeping. She emphasized the need for better …
4:58:20
·
98 sec
Testimony by Carol Hamilton, Hotel Worker on the Hotel Safe Act
Carol Hamilton, a hotel worker in New York City, testifies in support of the Hotel Safe Act. She shares a story about a housekeeper who was attacked by a guest, …
5:00:06
·
126 sec
Testimony by Sabrina Dizamo, Hotel Worker, on the Safe Hotel Act
Sabrina Dizamo, a hotel worker in New York City for 34 years, testified in support of the Safe Hotel Act. She shared her personal story of immigrating from Trinidad and …
5:02:13
·
58 sec
Testimony by Kazi Hussain, Member of the Public
Kazi Hussain, an immigrant from Bangladesh, testified in support of protecting workers in the tourism industry. He shared his personal story of coming to America to provide a better life …
5:04:07
·
51 sec
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson on Intro 991-B
Christopher Leon Johnson testifies against Intro 991-B, accusing Council Member Julie Menin of pursuing the bill for personal political ambitions rather than genuine concern for hotel safety. He criticizes the …
5:05:30
·
124 sec
Testimony by Raul Rivera on Intro 991-B
Raul Rivera presents a critical testimony against Intro 991-B, also known as the Safe Hotel Act. He accuses the committee and its chair of abuse of power and engaging in …
5:07:41
·
97 sec
