New York City Council
Committee on Hospitals
Oct 29, 2024
·
01:00 PM
4 hr 1 min
Summary
A hearing on the effects of hospital closures on community needs in New York City, focusing on the potential closures of Mount Sinai Beth Israel in Manhattan and SUNY Downstate Medical Center in Brooklyn.
Discussions centered on:
- The impact of closures on healthcare access, particularly for low-income and minority communities
- Disparities in hospital bed availability across boroughs
- The need for community input in closure decisions
- The financial challenges facing hospitals
The hearing also addressed concerns about emergency care, maternal health services, and specialty care accessibility.
Features testimony from the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, NYC Health + Hospitals, state legislators, healthcare professionals, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Narcisse introduces the hospital closure hearing
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse, Chair of the Hospital Committee, opens the hearing on hospital closures and community needs. She introduces herself and her colleagues, setting the context for the day's …
0:01:05
·
24 sec
The critical role of accessible healthcare and neighborhood hospitals
Council Member Narcisse emphasizes the importance of accessible and reliable healthcare for New Yorkers, highlighting the crucial role of neighborhood hospitals in providing continuous care. - Stresses the need for …
0:01:30
·
45 sec
Council Member Narcisse's nursing background and the significance of Sunny Downstate
Council Member Narcisse shares her personal experience as a registered nurse and emphasizes the critical importance of Sunny Downstate Medical Center to the Brooklyn community. - Recalls protesting for funding …
0:02:16
·
81 sec
The far-reaching consequences of hospital closures on communities
Council Member Narcisse outlines the wide-ranging impacts of hospital closures on patients, healthcare professionals, and communities, drawing from her experience as a registered nurse. - Discusses the challenges patients face …
0:03:38
·
106 sec
Examining the potential closures of Mount Sinai Beth Israel and Sunny Downstate Medical Center
Council Member Narcisse addresses the specific cases of potential hospital closures at Mount Sinai Beth Israel and Sunny Downstate Medical Center, emphasizing their historical significance and impact on the community. …
0:05:27
·
50 sec
Advocating for proactive measures to prevent hospital closures
Council Member Narcisse calls for collaborative efforts to prevent future hospital closures and protect communities from becoming healthcare deserts. She emphasizes the need to address specific health needs of affected …
0:06:20
·
64 sec
Hearing objectives and acknowledgments of staff and colleagues
Council Member Narcisse concludes her opening remarks by stating the hearing's objectives and acknowledging the contributions of staff members and fellow council members. - Thanks committee staff for their hard …
0:07:26
·
60 sec
Council Member Lynn Schulman addresses the impact of hospital closures in New York City
Council Member Lynn Schulman, Chair of the NYC Council Committee on Health, delivers remarks on the critical issue of hospital closures in New York City. She highlights the impending closure …
0:08:29
·
3 min
Council Member Carlina Rivera addresses concerns over Mount Sinai's closure of Beth Israel Hospital
Council Member Carlina Rivera expresses deep concern over Mount Sinai's decision to close Beth Israel Hospital, highlighting the potential negative impact on healthcare access for Manhattan residents. She emphasizes the …
0:12:31
·
136 sec
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams addresses healthcare crisis and hospital closures in New York City
Jumaane Williams, Public Advocate of New York City, delivers remarks on the ongoing healthcare crisis, focusing on hospital closures and their impact on communities of color. He highlights the strain …
0:15:07
·
3 min
Introduction and overview of NYC Health Department's role in hospital closures
Dr. Michelle Morse, Interim Health Commissioner and Chief Medical Officer of the NYC Health Department, introduces the hearing on the effects of hospital closures on community needs in New York …
0:19:25
·
69 sec
Structural racism as a root cause of hospital closures
Dr. Morse identifies structural racism as a fundamental cause of hospital closures and health inequities in New York City. She emphasizes that these closures are not an unfortunate side effect …
0:20:36
·
87 sec
Racial segregation in NYC's healthcare system
Dr. Morse describes the stark racial segregation in New York City's healthcare market and its implications for hospital closures and health inequities. She explains how this segregation is maintained and …
0:22:03
·
60 sec
Implementation of the Healthcare Accountability and Consumer Protection Act
Dr. Morse outlines the New York City Health Department's efforts to implement the recently passed Healthcare Accountability and Consumer Protection Act (Local Law 78 of 2023). She describes the department's …
0:23:05
·
75 sec
Accountability tools for hospitals to address health inequities
Dr. Morse discusses specific tools that can help hospitals and healthcare systems hold themselves accountable for addressing racial and health inequities. She provides an example from Illinois to illustrate how …
0:24:21
·
39 sec
Tax exemptions and community benefits of nonprofit hospitals
Dr. Morse discusses the substantial tax exemptions received by nonprofit hospitals and the expectation that they provide community benefits in return. She highlights concerns about some hospitals not meeting their …
0:25:01
·
59 sec
Importance and challenges of safety net hospitals
Dr. Morse emphasizes the critical role of safety net hospitals in providing essential services and promoting health equity, while also highlighting the unique challenges they face due to the structure …
0:26:00
·
143 sec
State-level proposals to support safety net hospitals
Dr. Morse outlines several state-level proposals that the New York City Health Department supports to address persistent funding gaps for safety net hospitals and improve healthcare equity. - Advocates for …
0:28:24
·
59 sec
Impact of hospital closures on emergency department overcrowding
Dr. Morse discusses how hospital closures contribute to increased overcrowding and extended wait times in emergency departments, particularly affecting safety net hospitals. - Explains that some safety net hospitals have …
0:29:24
·
24 sec
Effect of hospital closures during the COVID-19 pandemic
Dr. Morse highlights the specific impact of hospital closures during the COVID-19 pandemic, emphasizing how these closures exacerbated existing healthcare inequities and led to preventable deaths. - References research on …
0:29:48
·
44 sec
Conclusion: Hospital closures as a consequence of structural racism and policy failures
Dr. Morse concludes her testimony by emphasizing that hospital closures are a direct consequence of structural racism and represent failures in health policy and institutional responsibility. - Thanks the council …
0:30:32
·
32 sec
Health trends in Lower Manhattan and Downtown Brooklyn
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about notable health trends requiring inpatient services in Lower Manhattan and Downtown Brooklyn over the past two years. Dr. Michelle Morse explains that the state …
0:31:26
·
3 min
Concerns about hospital closures and emergency department visits in Manhattan
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse expresses alarm about hospital closures and their potential impact on healthcare capacity, especially in light of possible future pandemics or epidemics. She then inquires about the …
0:34:30
·
89 sec
Hospital closure process and the role of state vs. city health departments
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about the hospital closure process in New York and the involvement of the city's Department of Health. Dr. Michelle Morse explains the roles of state …
0:36:00
·
152 sec
Health equity impact of hospital closures and department awareness
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse raises concerns about the health equity impact of hospital closures, particularly in the context of a state hospital closing near a city hospital. Dr. Michelle Morse …
0:38:35
·
108 sec
Wait times and patient prioritization in Manhattan emergency departments
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about wait times for emergency department visits in Manhattan hospitals. Dr. Laura Iavicoli explains the general approach to patient prioritization and capacity scaling in emergency …
0:40:25
·
84 sec
Increase in patient visits to NYC hospitals and potential impact of closures
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about increases in patient visits to Bellevue Hospital and Kings County Hospital, and whether these increases can be attributed to the closures of Beth Israel …
0:41:50
·
95 sec
Experience with standalone emergency departments
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about experiences with running standalone emergency departments and their effectiveness in meeting community needs. Both Dr. Michelle Morse and Dr. Laura Iavicoli respond to this …
0:43:26
·
62 sec
Impact of San Vincent Hospital closure on neighboring hospitals
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about the impacts of San Vincent Hospital's closure in 2010 on neighboring hospitals and patient care in the West Village community. She specifically asks about …
0:44:30
·
22 sec
General effects of hospital closures on communities and surrounding hospitals
Dr. Michelle Morse and Dr. Laura Iavicoli discuss the general impacts of hospital closures on communities and surrounding hospitals. They explain that closures lead to ripple effects, forcing community members …
0:44:55
·
90 sec
Concerns about King's County Hospital and potential closure of SUNY Downstate
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse expresses concerns about the current overcrowding at King's County Hospital and the potential impact of SUNY Downstate's closure. She highlights specific issues related to maternal health …
0:46:25
·
32 sec
State health department's role in planning for hospital closures
Dr. Michelle Morse explains the state health department's responsibility in planning for hospital closures and mitigating their impacts. Council Member Narcisse expresses concerns about the need for early planning and …
0:47:00
·
115 sec
Support for hospitals and preventing closures
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about what New York State and the city council can do to support hospitals and prevent further closures. Dr. Michelle Morse and Dr. Laura Iavicoli …
0:49:00
·
119 sec
Personal experiences and concerns about hospital closures in Brooklyn
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse shares her personal experiences as a registered nurse and expresses deep concerns about hospital closures in Brooklyn. She emphasizes the importance of addressing health inequities and …
0:51:02
·
103 sec
Pandemic's impact on hospital financial performance and patient care
Dr. Michelle Morse discusses the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on hospitals' financial performance and patient care. She highlights the challenges faced by hospitals, particularly those serving uninsured or underinsured …
0:52:50
·
79 sec
Changes in healthcare delivery and the impact of telehealth services
Dr. Michelle Morse and Dr. Laura Iavicoli discuss the changes in healthcare delivery, with a particular focus on the rise of telehealth services. Council Member Mercedes Narcisse expresses support for …
0:54:13
·
153 sec
Strengthening the hospital workforce
Dr. Michelle Morse and Dr. Laura Iavicoli discuss initiatives and programs aimed at strengthening the hospital workforce in New York City. They highlight various recruitment and training programs implemented by …
0:56:46
·
115 sec
Anticipated impacts of Beth Israel closure on H+H hospitals
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about the anticipated impacts of Beth Israel's closure on H+H hospitals and affiliated health centers. Dr. Laura Iavicoli responds, explaining the current assessment process. - …
0:58:46
·
52 sec
Potential changes at Kings County Hospital if SUNY Downstate reduces services
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about potential changes at Kings County Hospital if SUNY Downstate reduces services. Dr. Laura Iavicoli responds, explaining the ongoing assessment and preparation process. - Health …
0:59:43
·
65 sec
Concerns about SUNY Downstate's kidney transplant program
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse raises concerns about the potential closure of SUNY Downstate's kidney transplant program, the only one in Brooklyn. Dr. Laura Iavicoli and Dr. Michelle Morse discuss the …
1:00:51
·
98 sec
Impact of potential changes at SUNY Downstate on medical education and training
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about the potential impact of changes at SUNY Downstate on medical education and training for students in various health-related fields. Dr. Michelle Morse responds, explaining …
1:02:30
·
142 sec
Assembly member González-Rojas addresses inequity in hospital bed distribution across NYC boroughs
Assembly member Jessica González-Rojas highlights the significant disparity in hospital bed distribution between Queens and Manhattan. She expresses concern about the lack of lessons learned from the COVID-19 pandemic and …
1:05:29
·
3 min
Discussion on potential staffing changes at Bellevue to accommodate Beth Israel closure
Council Member Schulman inquires about the staffing changes Bellevue would need to make to accommodate the estimated rise in patient levels if Beth Israel closes. Laura Iavicoli responds on behalf …
1:08:37
·
46 sec
Discussion on early engagement in hospital closure processes and H+H workforce initiatives
Council Member Schulman emphasizes the importance of early engagement in hospital closure processes and inquires about H+H's ability to hire more staff. Laura Iavicoli responds with information on H+H's workforce …
1:09:22
·
83 sec
Discussion on Mount Sinai's financial commitment to Bellevue's expansion
Council Member Schulman inquires about the financial details of Mount Sinai's commitment to expand Bellevue's emergency and psychiatric department services as a condition for Beth Israel's closure. Laura Iavicoli provides …
1:10:46
·
66 sec
Discussion on limitations and referral processes of urgent care centers
Council Member Schulman inquires about the limitations of urgent care centers and their referral processes. Dr. Michelle Morse provides general information about urgent care facilities. - H+H and NYC Health …
1:11:53
·
94 sec
Discussion on increased reliance on urgent care clinics and H+H's virtual express care services
Council Member Schulman inquires about trends in urgent care usage and H+H's plans for urgent care services. Dr. Morse and Laura Iavicoli provide information on current services and data availability. …
1:13:27
·
95 sec
Discussion on 24/7 operation of urgent care centers and impact on emergency department visits
Council Member Schulman inquires about the prevalence of 24/7 urgent care centers and their potential impact on emergency department visits. Dr. Morse provides limited information and emphasizes the differences between …
1:15:03
·
75 sec
Discussion on Mount Sinai's urgent care operations after Beth Israel closure
Council Member Schulman questions the sufficiency of Mount Sinai's required 3-month operation of a 24/7 urgent care clinic following Beth Israel's closure. H+H representatives respond with information about their own …
1:16:18
·
48 sec
Discussion on potential closure of Mount Sinai's Eye and Ear Infirmary and its impact
Council Member Schulman inquires about the ability of Bellevue or the Roberto Clemente Gotham Health Center to absorb patients if Mount Sinai's Eye and Ear Infirmary closes. H+H and Health …
1:17:07
·
51 sec
Discussion on health equity assessment process and state health department's role
Council Member Schulman inquires about the health equity assessment process conducted by the state health department and its interaction with the NYC Health Department. Dr. Morse explains the Certificate of …
1:17:59
·
114 sec
Discussion on lack of required consultation with NYC DOH for hospital closures
Council Member Schulman explores the issue of the New York State Department of Health not being required to consult with or share information with the NYC Department of Health and …
1:19:53
·
61 sec
Discussion on significant healthcare access issues in New York City
Council Member Rivera asks about the most significant healthcare access issues in New York City. Dr. Michelle Morse responds by outlining seven main areas driving life expectancy loss in the …
1:21:05
·
101 sec
Lessons learned about healthcare infrastructure from the COVID-19 pandemic
Council Member Rivera inquires about the most important lessons regarding healthcare infrastructure in New York City learned from the pandemic. Dr. Morse and Dr. Iavicoli provide insights from their experiences …
1:22:47
·
126 sec
Council Member Rivera's remarks on hospital closures and healthcare access
Council Member Rivera expresses concern about the impact of hospital closures on healthcare access and emergency services, particularly in light of the information provided about healthcare needs and pandemic lessons. …
1:24:53
·
88 sec
Discussion on the efficacy of standalone emergency rooms in urban environments
Council Member Rivera inquires about the efficacy of standalone emergency rooms in urban environments, noting that previous doubts about their effectiveness have been challenged by positive outcomes. - Rivera mentions …
1:26:22
·
53 sec
Council members discuss accommodating Senator Myrie's statement
Council members engage in a procedural discussion about allowing Senator Myrie to make a statement regarding downstate, which is in his district. They try to balance this request with the …
1:27:16
·
145 sec
Impact of hospital closure on mental health services
Council Member Carlina Rivera inquires about the impact of losing a full-service hospital on mental health treatment capabilities. Dr. Michelle Morse from the NYC Health Department responds, explaining the potential …
1:29:42
·
65 sec
Concerns about gap in hospital services due to MSPI closure
Council Member Carlina Rivera expresses concerns about the gap in hospital services that will be created by the closure of Mount Sinai Beth Israel (MSPI). Laura Iavicoli from NYC Health …
1:30:48
·
105 sec
Council Member Narcisse expresses concerns over hospital closures and calls for comprehensive planning
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse expresses concerns about hospital closures in light of the COVID-19 pandemic and calls for comprehensive planning and community engagement. Dr. Michelle Morse briefly responds about a …
1:32:34
·
115 sec
Testimony by Jo Anne Simon, Assembly Member from New York State Assembly, on the Local Input to Community Healthcare Act
Assembly Member Jo Anne Simon testifies about the Local Input to Community Healthcare Act, a bill passed in both houses awaiting the governor's signature. The act aims to improve the …
1:36:17
·
3 min
Testimony by Zellnor Myrie, State Senator from New York State Senate, on Hospital Closures and Community Health
State Senator Zellnor Myrie testified about the importance of safety net hospitals in communities and the negative impacts of hospital closures. He emphasized the need for transparency and community engagement …
1:39:56
·
3 min
Testimony by Gustavo Rivera, State Senator from New York State Senate, on Hospital Closures and Healthcare Access
State Senator Gustavo Rivera addresses the NYC City Council on the issues of hospital closures and healthcare access in New York. He emphasizes the need for community input in hospital …
1:43:09
·
3 min
Testimony by Katherine Demby, Chief of Staff from Office of State Senator Kristen Gonzales
Katherine Demby, representing State Senator Kristen Gonzales, testifies about the impact of hospital closures across New York City and the need to protect community hospitals and prioritize healthcare access for …
1:46:36
·
96 sec
Initial inquiry about the closing of Downstate Hospital
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse inquires about the planned closure of Downstate Hospital. State Senator Zellnor Myrie explains that they were informed about the closure during the week of Martin Luther …
1:48:12
·
42 sec
Concerns about investment in hospitals serving black and brown communities
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse expresses concern about the lack of investment in hospitals serving black and brown communities, particularly Downstate Hospital. She questions why these investments were not addressed during …
1:48:57
·
34 sec
The ongoing fight for Downstate Hospital and health care equity
State Senator Zellnor Myrie discusses the long-standing fight for Downstate Hospital and health care equity in New York City. He explains the challenges faced by the hospital, including its designation …
1:49:24
·
106 sec
Medicaid rates and chronic underfunding of safety net institutions
State Senator Gustavo Rivera discusses the persistent issue of underfunding safety net institutions across New York State. He explains that the problem extends beyond New York City and has been …
1:51:19
·
119 sec
Impact of COVID-19 on Downstate Hospital and community perception
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse, drawing from her experience as a nurse, discusses the impact of COVID-19 on Downstate Hospital and the challenges in rebuilding community trust. She emphasizes the need …
1:53:19
·
38 sec
Council Member Rita C. Joseph discusses SUNY Downstate's future with state representatives
Council Member Rita C. Joseph engages in a discussion with State Senator Zellnor Myrie and Assembly Member Jo Anne Simon about the future of SUNY Downstate Medical Center. They discuss …
1:54:05
·
3 min
Council members and state senators discuss hospital closure notifications and the LICH Act
Council members and state senators engage in a Q&A session about hospital closures, focusing on the lack of notifications and the potential impact of the LICH Act. They discuss the …
1:58:21
·
131 sec
Council Member Brooks-Powers addresses the impact of potential hospital closures
Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers opens the discussion by emphasizing the critical nature of potential hospital closures in New York City. She highlights the significant impact these closures could have …
2:00:45
·
55 sec
Discussion on the impact of hospital closures on trauma services and patient access
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about the city's assessment of potential hospital closures on trauma services and critical care access, particularly in underserved areas. Dr. Michelle Morse responds, explaining the health …
2:01:41
·
164 sec
Exploring alternatives to hospital closures and transition plans
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about potential alternatives to hospital closures, such as repurposing facilities for urgent care or specialized clinics. The health officials respond, explaining their limited involvement in such …
2:04:26
·
107 sec
Community engagement and transparency regarding potential hospital closures
Council Member Brooks-Powers asks about the city's efforts to provide transparent information to communities about potential hospital closures and gather feedback proactively. Dr. Michelle Morse responds by outlining the Health …
2:06:13
·
83 sec
Council Member Narcisse discusses kidney disease treatment and transplant services with health officials
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse engages in a discussion with health officials about kidney disease treatment and transplant services in New York City. She expresses concern about the potential closure of …
2:07:43
·
4 min
Testimony by Chatodd Floyd, Senior Vice President of Legislative Affairs at Greater New York Hospital Association (GNYHA) on Hospital Closures and Medicaid Funding
Chatodd Floyd from the Greater New York Hospital Association (GNYHA) testified about the financial struggles of hospitals in New York, emphasizing the need for increased Medicaid funding to prevent closures …
2:15:27
·
3 min
Testimony by Registered Nurse from SUNY Downstate Emergency Room on Hospital Closure Impact
A registered nurse from SUNY Downstate Emergency Room testifies about the critical importance of keeping the hospital open, emphasizing its role in serving the local minority community and providing specialized …
2:19:23
·
175 sec
Testimony by Madeline Villalba, Medical Student and Member of Commission on the Public Health System (CPHS) on Hospital Closures
Madeline Villalba, a medical student and member of the Commission on the Public Health System, testified about the potential negative impacts of hospital closures on communities, focusing on increased ambulance …
2:22:28
·
142 sec
Testimony by Judy Wessler, Retired Former Director & Co-founder of Commission on the Public's Health System (CPHS)
Judy Wessler, retired director of CPHS, testified about the ongoing issue of hospital closures in medically underserved, low-income, and often communities of color. She emphasized the worsening situation over the …
2:24:54
·
140 sec
Supporting hospitals and preventing closures
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse asks about ways New York state and the city council can support hospitals and prevent closures. Chatodd Floyd from GNYHA responds by highlighting the importance of …
2:27:16
·
45 sec
Pandemic impact on hospital finances
Council Member Narcisse inquires about the pandemic's impact on hospital financial performance. Chatodd Floyd explains the financial challenges hospitals have faced over the past 15 years and how they've worsened …
2:28:04
·
64 sec
Impact of delayed insurance payments on hospitals
Council Member Narcisse asks about the issue of delayed insurance payments. Chatodd Floyd explains the challenges hospitals face due to insurance denials and delayed payments. - Hospitals face numerous denials …
2:29:09
·
59 sec
Changes in healthcare delivery and impact on hospitals
Council Member Narcisse inquires about changes in healthcare delivery and their impact on the current hospital system. Chatodd Floyd describes the shift towards outpatient and community-based care. - There's a …
2:30:11
·
59 sec
Strengthening the hospital workforce
Council Member Narcisse asks about ways to strengthen the hospital workforce. Chatodd Floyd suggests several approaches to address workforce challenges. - Recommends removing restrictions on the workforce to encourage more …
2:31:11
·
53 sec
Discussion on hospital closures and innovations
Council Member Carlina Rivera engages in a discussion with Chatodd Floyd from GNYHA about hospital closures and innovations in healthcare delivery. They discuss the reasons behind hospital changes and the …
2:32:06
·
139 sec
Discussion on the LITCH Act and GNYHA's position
Council Member Carlina Rivera questions Chatodd Floyd about GNYHA's position on the LICH Act and their concerns about its potential impact on healthcare transformation efforts. - Rivera asks about GNYHA's …
2:34:28
·
119 sec
Discussion about past task force on hospital closings
Council Member Carlina Rivera inquires about a past task force on hospital closings, and Judy Wessler provides information about its history and outcomes. - Wessler shares details about the task …
2:36:28
·
165 sec
Testimony by Andrea Gordillo, Chairperson of Manhattan Community Board 3, on the Proposed Closure of Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital
Andrea Gordillo, Chairperson of Manhattan Community Board 3, testifies in opposition to the proposed closure of Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital. She emphasizes the vital role the hospital plays in …
2:40:13
·
162 sec
Testimony by Jesús Pérez, District Manager of Manhattan Community Board 6
Jesús Pérez, District Manager of Manhattan Community Board 6, testifies against the closure of Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, emphasizing its critical importance to the community and the potential negative …
2:42:58
·
121 sec
Testimony by Linda Charles, Nurse from Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital on Healthcare Accessibility in Downtown Manhattan
Linda Charles, a nurse with 34 years of experience in New York City, testifies about the importance of maintaining healthcare accessibility in Downtown Manhattan, particularly in light of the potential …
2:45:06
·
136 sec
Testimony by Jose Antonio Gonzales, Union Member from 1199 SEIU on Hospital Closures and Healthcare System Challenges
Jose Antonio Gonzales, a long-time employee of Mount Sinai Beth Israel and member of 1199 SEIU, testifies about the importance of hospitals in communities and the challenges facing the healthcare …
2:47:29
·
3 min
Testimony by Mark Rubin, Nurse at Mount Sinai Beth Israel, on Hospital Closures
Mark Rubin, a nurse at Mount Sinai Beth Israel, testifies about the critical importance of keeping Beth Israel hospital open. He emphasizes the devastating impact its closure would have on …
2:50:48
·
111 sec
Testimony by Amelia Wagner, Senior Health Policy Analyst at Community Service Society of New York, on Hospital Closures and Health Disparities
Amelia Wagner, representing the Community Service Society of New York, testified about the impact of hospital closures on vulnerable communities in New York City. She highlighted the organization's work in …
2:53:39
·
118 sec
Testimony by Stephanie Hammond Reckler, Member of the Public, on Hospital Expansion in New York City
Stephanie Hammond Reckler testifies against the proposed expansion of Lenox Hill Hospital, arguing that it's inappropriate to add more hospital capacity to an already well-served neighborhood while other areas lack …
2:55:43
·
130 sec
Testimony by Aixa Torres, Chairperson for Manhattan South District Council of Presidents of NYCHA, on the Closure of Beth Israel Hospital
Aixa Torres, representing NYCHA's Manhattan South District, testifies against the closure of Beth Israel Hospital, emphasizing its critical importance to the community and the potential negative impact on public housing …
2:58:00
·
3 min
Testimony by Renee Kinsella, longtime resident of Manhattan, on the closure of Mount Sinai Beth Israel
Renee Kinsella, a longtime Manhattan resident, strongly opposes the closure of Mount Sinai Beth Israel hospital. She shares her personal experiences with the hospital and expresses concerns about the community's …
3:01:10
·
128 sec
Testimony by Mbacke Thiam, Housing and Health Community Organizer from Center for Independence of the Disabled (CIDNY)
Mbacke Thiam, representing the Center for Independence of the Disabled (CIDNY), testified about the impact of closing Beth Israel Hospital on people with disabilities and the lack of their inclusion …
3:04:47
·
3 min
Testimony by Charline Ogbeni, Owner of Supporting Our Mothers Initiative
Charline Ogbeni, representing Supporting Our Mothers Initiative, advocates for the expansion of birth centers in New York City and the establishment of a donor milk bank. She highlights the need …
3:08:05
·
126 sec
Testimony by Jean Ryan, President of Disabled in Action of Metropolitan New York (DIA), on Hospital Closures and Healthcare Access
Jean Ryan, President of Disabled in Action of Metropolitan New York (DIA), testifies about the negative impacts of hospital closures on vulnerable populations, particularly seniors, sick people, poor people, and …
3:10:18
·
135 sec
Discussion on inadequacy of urgent care centers as hospital replacements
Council Member Lynn Schulman and Jean Ryan discuss the inadequacy of urgent care centers like CityMD as replacements for hospitals. They emphasize the importance of maintaining proper hospital care and …
3:12:33
·
46 sec
Testimony by Deborah Socolar, Healthcare Researcher and Access Advocate, on Hospital Closures and Healthcare Access
Deborah Socolar, a healthcare researcher and access advocate, testified about the importance of maintaining hospital capacity and the negative impacts of hospital closures. She emphasized lessons from the pandemic and …
3:14:18
·
3 min
Testimony by Mark Hannay, Director of Metro New York Health Care for All, on Hospital Access and Equity
Mark Hannay, Director of Metro New York Health Care for All, testifies on the importance of hospital access and equity across New York City. He criticizes state leadership for ceding …
3:17:32
·
160 sec
Testimony by Lois Uttley, Health Policy Advocate on Hospital Inequities in New York City
Lois Uttley, a health policy advocate with over 30 years of experience, warns about the worsening inequities in access to hospital care across New York City due to hospital closings. …
3:20:16
·
156 sec
Testimony by Sommer Omar, Attorney representing community plaintiffs in lawsuit to keep Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital open
Sommer Omar, an attorney representing community plaintiffs, testifies against the closure of Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital. She argues that nearby hospitals lack the capacity to absorb Beth Israel's patients, …
3:22:55
·
141 sec
Testimony by Dr. Kimberly Murdaugh, Physician and Advocate from Save Beth Israel and New York Eye & Ear Campaign
Dr. Kimberly Murdaugh, a physician and advocate for Save Beth Israel and New York Eye & Ear Campaign, testifies about the importance of Beth Israel Hospital and the potential impact …
3:26:08
·
137 sec
Testimony by Bruce Rosen, Member of the Public
Bruce Rosen testifies about the lack of adequate healthcare facilities in New York City, particularly in Queens. He expresses concern over the shortage of hospitals and medical schools, and criticizes …
3:28:39
·
156 sec
Testimony by Dr. Danielle Green, Executive Director of State and Local Public Health Initiatives at CUNY Graduate School of Public Health and Health Policy
Dr. Danielle Green provides testimony on public health initiatives, focusing on the needs of underserved communities and the importance of supporting safety net hospitals. She discusses data analysis, the changing …
3:32:15
·
151 sec
Discussion on hospital data metrics and analysis
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse engages in a Q&A session with Dr. Danielle Green about hospital data metrics and analysis. They discuss the recent analysis provided by Dr. Green's team and …
3:34:55
·
76 sec
Discussion on risks of hospital closures and community health impacts
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse and Dr. Danielle Green discuss the potential risks and impacts of hospital closures on communities, particularly focusing on Mount Sinai Beth Israel, Mount Sinai Eye and …
3:36:11
·
99 sec
Testimony by Jeanine Kylie, Member of Coalition to Save Beth Israel and New York Eye & Ear on the Litch Act and Mount Sinai's Management of Beth Israel Medical Center
Jeanine Kylie, a member of the Coalition to Save Beth Israel and New York Eye & Ear, urges the passing of the Litch Act and criticizes Mount Sinai's management of …
3:38:06
·
129 sec
Testimony by Mario Catano Henry, Member of New York Statewide Senior Action Council, on Hospital Closures in New York City
Mario Catano Henry, a member of the New York Statewide Senior Action Council, testified in opposition to the closing of another hospital in New York City. He emphasized the growing …
3:41:07
·
102 sec
Testimony by Cynthia Walker, Registered Nurse at SUNY Downstate Medical Center
Cynthia Walker, a registered nurse at SUNY Downstate Medical Center, testified about the importance of maintaining the hospital and its services for the Brooklyn community. She highlighted the hospital's crucial …
3:42:58
·
159 sec
Testimony by Tyler Weaver, Former EMT, on Hospital Closures and Ambulance Response Times
Tyler Weaver, a former EMT, testified about the impact of hospital closures on ambulance response times, sharing a personal tragedy and highlighting disparities in response times across NYC boroughs. He …
3:45:49
·
169 sec
Testimony by Darcy Dreyer, Director of March of Dimes, on Hospital Consolidation and Maternity Care
Darcy Dreyer, Director of March of Dimes, testified about the impact of hospital consolidations on maternity care in New York City. She highlighted the closure of maternity services in hospitals, …
3:48:45
·
125 sec
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson, Member of the Public, on Hospital Closures
Christopher Leon Johnson testifies against the closure of hospitals in New York City, emphasizing the importance of accessible healthcare and criticizing the motives behind these closures. He specifically mentions opposing …
3:51:02
·
150 sec
Testimony by Tanisha Grant on Healthcare Access and Hospital Closures
Tanisha Grant shares personal experiences highlighting issues in the New York City healthcare system, including long ER wait times and difficulty accessing primary care. She argues against hospital closures, especially …
3:53:40
·
129 sec
Testimony by Ben Wetzler, Resident of Stuyvesant Town, on Keeping Mount Sinai Beth Israel Open
Ben Wetzler, a resident of Stuyvesant Town, testifies in support of Council Member Rivera's resolution to keep Mount Sinai Beth Israel open. He emphasizes the importance of the hospital's full-service …
3:56:09
·
109 sec
