The citymeetings.nyc logo showing a pigeon at a podium with a microphone.

citymeetings.nyc

Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Bruce Hain, Member of the Public, on MTA's QueensLink Project

3:09:38

·

167 sec

Bruce Hain, a self-proclaimed rail transportation planner from Queens, criticizes the MTA's approach to the QueensLink project and other rail projects. He argues that the current plans are inefficient and unnecessarily expensive.

  • Hain claims the MTA spent $800 million on a consultant study for the Rockaway Beach branch that proposes demolishing several buildings
  • He suggests an alternative plan connecting to the Long Island Railroad for increased capacity
  • Hain intends to file a written testimony with pictures illustrating the buildings that would need to be removed under the current plan
Bruce Hain
3:09:38
my name is Bruce Hain.
3:09:41
I live in Queens, and I consider myself to be the foremost, rail, transportation planner of my generation because you see I'm not up against very much.
3:09:54
And I think to a very large degree, this is intentional intentional.
3:10:02
It's been going on for a long time.
3:10:05
If you look at California High Speed Rail, you'll see, they they built a whole new line.
3:10:16
It's it's 6 miles longer than, it's a 111 miles.
3:10:22
It's 6 miles longer than the 105 mile line that was built in 18 70, which has a 50 mile tangent, perfect for high speed rail.
3:10:32
It should have been anyway, you know, and they spend $3,000,000,000 on it when they already had the right of way, a better right of way, a straighter right of way.
3:10:43
It's circuitous, and it's gonna be too expensive to run.
3:10:47
Anyway, the MTA spent $800,000,000 on their discussion of, on their their, the the consultant Mhmm.
3:11:03
Sistra to to look at, the the Rockaway Beach branch, and it was supposed to be comprehensive.
3:11:15
And then based on that, you paid more see, but that study shows, it it runs the line through about 8 buildings.
3:11:31
There are 6 townhouses.
3:11:34
There are there's a 9 story building.
3:11:37
They've all gotta come down if you're gonna do it the way Sistra planned it.
3:11:42
So I intend to, file, a written thing, and I hope that if it's in, Windows, Windows format that, a picture pictures can be included too, because I I point to the buildings that, need to be taken out to do it this way.
3:12:06
I've I've, planned an alternate for
Selvena N. Brooks-Powers
3:12:08
Thank you, sir.
Bruce Hain
3:12:09
The subway, but the way to do it is connected to the Long Island Railroad.
3:12:14
That way you have capacity.
Selvena N. Brooks-Powers
3:12:17
Thank you, sir.
Bruce Hain
3:12:20
Sorry to get so confused.
3:12:21
I don't know.
3:12:22
These things are too short to say it.
3:12:24
No problem.
Eric Dinowitz
3:12:25
Thank you
Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.