New York City Council
Committee on Sanitation and Solid Waste Management
Nov 20, 2024
·
10:00 AM
3 hr 6 min
Summary
A hearing on waste containerization efforts in New York City, focusing on the Department of Sanitation's plans for citywide implementation, including:
- New requirements for businesses and residential buildings
- A pilot program for large on-street containers
- The expansion of curbside composting
Discussions covered implementation challenges, costs, and concerns from Business Improvement Districts (BIDs), as well as environmental considerations and related legislative proposals.
Features testimony from the Department of Sanitation (DSNY), Business Improvement Districts (BIDs), environmental advocates, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Julie Won introduces the hearing on waste containerization
Council Member Julie Won opens the hearing by introducing herself as the chair of the council's committee on contracts. She explains that the hearing will examine the city's efforts to …
0:00:00
·
16 sec
Positive impact of containerization efforts on reducing rat problems
Council Member Julie Won expresses strong support for containerization efforts, highlighting their positive impact on reducing the rat problem in New York City. She commends the leadership of the commissioner …
0:00:16
·
25 sec
Overview of major contracts related to waste containerization
Council Member Julie Won provides an overview of several major contracts related to waste containerization in New York City. She highlights the scale and complexity of these contracts, reflecting the …
0:00:42
·
123 sec
Concerns about containerization requirements affecting Business Improvement Districts
Council Member Julie Won expresses concerns about how DSNY's new containerization requirements affect Business Improvement Districts (BIDs). She highlights the challenges these organizations face in adapting to the new requirements …
0:02:46
·
64 sec
Financial impacts of containerization on communities and property owners
Council Member Julie Won addresses the financial impacts of new containerization requirements on communities and property owners in New York City. She emphasizes that these administrative decisions have real-world consequences …
0:03:52
·
51 sec
Closing remarks and acknowledgments for the containerization hearing
Council Member Julie Won concludes her opening statement with closing remarks and acknowledgments. She emphasizes the importance of examining procurement issues and ensuring that contracting strategies support effective implementation of …
0:04:44
·
48 sec
Introduction and overview of DSNY's recent initiatives
Commissioner Jessica Tisch introduces herself and her team from the Department of Sanitation (DSNY) at a City Council hearing. She sets the stage for discussing DSNY's recent initiatives and the …
0:07:03
·
30 sec
Historical context of NYC's trash containerization efforts
Commissioner Tisch provides historical context for NYC's efforts to containerize trash, highlighting the long-standing need for improvement and recent progress. - Mentions that containerization efforts have been 'decades in the …
0:07:34
·
30 sec
Recent changes to waste set-out times and commercial waste bin requirements
Commissioner Tisch details recent changes to waste management practices in NYC, focusing on set-out times and commercial waste bin requirements. - Describes the change in legal set-out time for waste …
0:08:04
·
61 sec
New residential containerization mandate for buildings with 1-9 units
Commissioner Tisch introduces the new residential containerization mandate for smaller residential buildings in NYC, marking a significant change in waste management for these properties. - Explains that buildings with 1 …
0:09:06
·
35 sec
Official NYC bin program and its benefits
Commissioner Tisch details the official NYC bin program, highlighting its features, benefits, and the public response to its introduction. - Describes the official NYC bin as allowing for standardized mechanical …
0:09:41
·
78 sec
Empire Bins program for larger residential buildings
Commissioner Tisch introduces the Empire Bins program, a new initiative for containerizing trash from larger residential buildings in NYC. - Describes Empire Bins as European-style stationary on-street containers for use …
0:10:59
·
76 sec
Universal curbside composting program
Commissioner Tisch introduces the universal curbside composting program, highlighting its accessibility and success across New York City. - Describes the program as allowing all New Yorkers to set out food …
0:12:16
·
35 sec
Commercial organic waste separation and proposed updates
Commissioner Tisch addresses the current state of commercial organic waste separation in NYC and proposes updates to align with the city's commitment to compostable waste diversion. - References Local Law …
0:12:52
·
38 sec
Commercial Waste Zone system implementation and enforcement
Commissioner Tisch provides an update on the implementation of the Commercial Waste Zone system in NYC, highlighting its progress and enforcement efforts. - Announces that full implementation of the first …
0:13:31
·
113 sec
Response to pre-considered introduction on Empire Bins expansion
Commissioner Tisch strongly supports the pre-considered introduction sponsored by Council Member Hudson, which aims to facilitate the expansion of the Empire Bins program beyond the pilot district. - Emphasizes that …
0:15:25
·
51 sec
Response to Intro 57 on increased penalties for cleanliness offenses
Commissioner Tisch expresses strong support for Intro 57, sponsored by Council Member Osei, which aims to increase penalties for repeat cleanliness offenders. - Emphasizes the importance of making repeat offenders …
0:16:17
·
18 sec
Response to Intro 498 on waste collection from community gardens
Commissioner Tisch expresses support for Intro 498, sponsored by Chair Abreu, which requires DSNY to collect waste from community gardens. - Notes that DSNY already provides this service to community …
0:16:36
·
18 sec
Response to Intros 698 and 781 on composting and food scrap drop-offs
Commissioner Tisch provides contrasting responses to Intros 698 and 781, both sponsored by Council Member Nurse, regarding composting and food scrap drop-offs. - Strongly supports Intro 781, which expands composting …
0:16:54
·
96 sec
Response to Intro 949 on containerization at large buildings
Commissioner Tisch addresses Intro 949, sponsored by Public Advocate Williams, which calls for containerization of waste at certain large buildings. - Acknowledges that containerization is the right idea, but states …
0:18:31
·
31 sec
Response to pre-considered introduction on city agency trash containerization
Commissioner Tisch addresses the pre-considered introduction sponsored by Chair Abreu regarding trash containerization for city agencies. - Acknowledges the important goal of containerizing city agency trash - Explains that DSNY's …
0:19:03
·
44 sec
Response to pre-considered introduction on bin reimbursement program
Commissioner Tisch addresses the pre-considered introduction sponsored by Council Member Salaam, which proposes a reimbursement program for property owners who purchase the official NYC bin. - Reminds the council that …
0:19:47
·
100 sec
Response to Intro 1108 on enforcement of cleanliness violations in public spaces
Commissioner Tisch addresses Intro 1108, sponsored by Council Member Menin, which aims to close a loophole in DSNY enforcement authority for cleanliness violations in public spaces. - Praises the bill …
0:21:28
·
41 sec
Response to Resolution 284 on mandatory composting at SUNY and CUNY campuses
Commissioner Tisch briefly addresses Resolution 284, introduced by Council Member Nurse, which calls for mandatory composting at SUNY and CUNY campuses. - Expresses support for the resolution, calling it a …
0:22:09
·
15 sec
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams introduces legislation for waste containerization in large buildings
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams introduces Intro 0949 of 2024, which requires buildings with 100 or more units to provide containers for refuse. He discusses the benefits of this legislation in …
0:22:42
·
3 min
Discussion of Intro 2746 and Empire Bins for waste containerization
Council Member Abreu and Commissioner Tisch discuss Intro 2746, agreeing on the use of Empire Bins where appropriate and the need for trash containerization elsewhere. They commit to working together …
0:26:19
·
25 sec
Inquiry about businesses using on-street containers for high volumes of waste
Council Member Abreu inquires about the possibility of businesses using on-street containers for high volumes of waste. Commissioner Tisch explains why this is not currently contemplated, citing challenges with commercial …
0:26:44
·
162 sec
Types of buildings using off-street containers and loading docks
Council Member Abreu asks about the types of buildings that typically use off-street containers and loading docks for refuse collection. Commissioner Tisch explains that these are primarily used by very …
0:29:27
·
34 sec
Hamilton Heights shared on-street container pilot program monitoring and challenges
Council Member Abreu inquires about the monitoring, cleaning, and maintenance of shared bins during the Hamilton Heights pilot program. Commissioner Tisch explains that DSNY staff handled these duties and discusses …
0:30:02
·
108 sec
Discussion of the 2023 waste containerization study and potential expansion of collection schedules
Council Member Abreu asks about the findings of the 2023 waste containerization study regarding the need to double refuse collection in some areas. Commissioner Tisch clarifies that the initial report …
0:31:51
·
115 sec
Projected costs for the fleet needed for on-street container implementation
Council Member Abreu inquires about the projected costs for the fleet and bins needed for citywide containerization. Commissioner Tisch and Deputy Commissioner Antonelli provide details on the cost of automated …
0:33:47
·
160 sec
Plans for dealing with snow and extreme weather events with on-street containers
Council Member Abreu asks about plans for managing on-street containers during snowstorms and other extreme weather events. Commissioner Tisch outlines the strategies in place to address these concerns. - Commissioner …
0:36:30
·
110 sec
Viability of containerization in different NYC neighborhoods and updated assessments
Council Member Abreu inquires about the challenges of implementing containerization in certain NYC neighborhoods, referencing previous studies. Commissioner Tisch clarifies that the initial reports have been updated, and the current …
0:38:22
·
60 sec
Discussion of container contract costs for Manhattan Community Board 9
Council Member Julie Won inquires about the container contract costs for Manhattan Community Board 9. Commissioner Jessica Tisch clarifies that the $7 million contract equates to roughly $700,000 per year …
0:39:23
·
28 sec
Explanation of Empire Bin distribution model in Manhattan Community Board 9
Commissioner Jessica Tisch explains the Empire Bin distribution model for Manhattan Community Board 9. The model includes automatic assignment for larger buildings and an opt-in option for medium-sized buildings. - …
0:39:51
·
59 sec
Inquiry about potential expansion of containerization program to other community boards
Council Member Julie Won inquires about the possibility of expanding the containerization program to other community boards if there are unused funds. Commissioner Jessica Tisch explains that expansion is not …
0:40:50
·
76 sec
Discussion of implementation timeline and warning period for wheelie bin requirements
Council Member Julie Won inquires about the implementation timeline and warning period for the wheelie bin requirements. Commissioner Jessica Tisch provides details on the timeline and approach. - The mandate …
0:42:06
·
52 sec
Statistics on warnings and summonses issued for non-compliance
Commissioner Jessica Tisch provides statistics on warnings and summonses issued for non-compliance with containerization rules. - A total of 60,000 warnings and summonses have been issued combined - Breakdown: 34,000 …
0:42:57
·
41 sec
Legal authority for DSNY to impose fines on BIDs for non-compliance
Commissioner Jessica Tisch explains DSNY's legal authority to impose fines on Business Improvement Districts (BIDs) for non-compliance with containerization rules. - The law department advised that DSNY may impose fines …
0:43:42
·
61 sec
Explanation of different phases of the 'trash revolution' implementation
Commissioner Jessica Tisch outlines the different phases of the 'trash revolution' implementation for containerization in New York City. - Phase 1: Businesses, starting with food-related businesses, then chain stores, and …
0:44:43
·
71 sec
Timeline for publishing rules regarding BID compliance with containerization
Commissioner Jessica Tisch provides information on the timeline for publishing rules regarding BID compliance with containerization. - The rules have just been approved by the law department - They will …
0:45:54
·
31 sec
Discussion on mandating containerization for BID refuse and comparison with business compliance
Commissioner Jessica Tisch discusses the plan to mandate containerization for BID refuse, comparing it to existing business compliance requirements. - BIDs will need to comply with the same rules as …
0:46:25
·
174 sec
Concerns about BIDs' responsibility for pedestrian trash and associated costs
Council Member Julie Won raises concerns about BIDs' responsibility for pedestrian trash and associated costs, particularly for smaller BIDs. Commissioner Jessica Tisch addresses these concerns. - The new requirements mainly …
0:49:19
·
172 sec
Inquiry about potential grants to help BIDs with containerization costs
Council Member Julie Won inquires about potential grants to help Business Improvement Districts (BIDs) with containerization costs. Commissioner Jessica Tisch addresses the question and expresses willingness to explore options. - …
0:52:11
·
109 sec
Addressing concerns about illegal dumping and enforcement strategies
Council Member Julie Won raises concerns about illegal dumping and enforcement strategies, particularly in relation to BIDs. Commissioner Jessica Tisch explains the approach to enforcement and addressing these issues. - …
0:54:01
·
165 sec
Discussion on allowing businesses with high waste volumes to use on-street containers
Council Member Julie Won inquires about the possibility of allowing businesses with high waste volumes to use on-street containers instead of smaller wheelie bins. Commissioner Jessica Tisch explains the current …
0:56:47
·
70 sec
Description of buildings typically using off-street containers and loading docks
Council Member Julie Won asks about the types of buildings that typically use off-street containers and loading docks for their refuse collection. Commissioner Jessica Tisch provides a brief description. - …
0:57:57
·
25 sec
Clarification on DSNY's trash receptacle service policy
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about DSNY's policy on servicing non-DSNY issued receptacles, such as Victor Stanley Bins, under the new agreement. Commissioner Jessica Tisch clarifies that there are no …
0:58:40
·
28 sec
Overview of Manhattan Community Board 9 Stationary On Street Container Pilot Program
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about the Manhattan Community Board 9 Stationary On Street Container Pilot Program. Commissioner Jessica Tisch provides details on the program's timeline and requirements for buildings …
0:59:08
·
80 sec
Opt-in process for buildings with 10-30 dwelling units
Council Member Abreu and Commissioner Tisch discuss the opt-in process for buildings with 10-30 dwelling units in the Manhattan Community Board 9 pilot program. Tisch provides details on the timeline …
1:00:28
·
46 sec
Responsibilities for maintaining cleanliness around stationary containers
Council Member Abreu and Commissioner Tisch discuss the responsibilities for maintaining cleanliness around the stationary on-street containers in the Manhattan Community Board 9 pilot program. Tisch clarifies the roles of …
1:01:15
·
140 sec
Inclusion of NYCHA complexes in the pilot program
Council Member Abreu inquires about the inclusion of two major NYCHA complexes, Manhattanville Houses and Grant Houses, in the Manhattan Community Board 9 pilot program. Commissioner Tisch confirms their inclusion …
1:03:34
·
37 sec
Council Member Menin questions Commissioner Tisch on proposed Intro 1108 regarding enforcement in public spaces
Council Member Julie Menin questions Commissioner Jessica Tisch about the proposed Intro 1108, which would give the Department of Sanitation authority to enforce cleanliness rules in public spaces managed by …
1:04:12
·
116 sec
Council Member Abreu questions DSNY on container contracts and building coverage
Council Member Shaun Abreu questions DSNY Commissioner Jessica Tisch and other officials about the contract for on-street containers and the coverage of a proposed bill for building containerization. The discussion …
1:06:14
·
3 min
Council Member Restler's appreciation for DSNY's work on street cleaning
Council Member Lincoln Restler opens by expressing gratitude to Chair Abreu and Chair Juan for holding the hearing. He then praises Commissioner Tisch and the Department of Sanitation for their …
1:09:35
·
40 sec
Discussion on potential expansion of containerization to lower density areas
Council Member Restler inquires about the possibility of expanding the contour bin model to lower density areas, such as brownstone communities with 1-4 family homes. Commissioner Tisch responds positively to …
1:10:18
·
135 sec
Addressing concerns about containerization for non-profits and schools
Council Member Restler raises concerns about non-profits and yeshivas facing challenges with the new containerization model. Commissioner Tisch clarifies the Department's stance and offers solutions for these institutions. - Tisch …
1:12:33
·
90 sec
Discussion on bin sizes for residential units
Council Member Restler brings up concerns about bin sizes for 1-9 residential units, particularly for brownstones with built enclosures that can't accommodate larger bins. He inquires about the possibility of …
1:14:03
·
99 sec
Explanation of operational details for mechanized garbage pickup
Council Member Restler seeks clarification on the operational details of mechanized garbage pickup, particularly for smaller buildings using wheelie bins. Commissioner Tisch explains the two options available to sanitation workers. …
1:15:42
·
94 sec
Council Member Bottcher discusses containerization progress and implementation challenges with DSNY officials
Council Member Erik D. Bottcher commends DSNY Commissioner Jessica Tisch on the progress made in containerization efforts and discusses implementation challenges, particularly for small building owners. The conversation covers compliance …
1:17:22
·
4 min
Confirmation of DSNY collection from Clean Curbs containers
Council Member Julie Won seeks confirmation from DSNY about collecting bags from containers in the Clean Curbs program. Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman confirms that DSNY will continue to collect from …
1:22:05
·
18 sec
DSNY's flexibility in pickup schedules for BIDs
Council Member Julie Won inquires about DSNY's commitment to specific pickup schedules for BIDs. Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman explains DSNY's need for flexibility in collection schedules while maintaining communication with …
1:22:23
·
30 sec
DSNY's policy on accepting BID bags at facilities
Council Member Julie Won inquires about DSNY's willingness to accept bags from BIDs at DSNY garages and from private carters hired by BIDs. Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman discusses potential options …
1:22:53
·
41 sec
Container site selection and specifications for BIDs
Council Member Julie Won asks about the process of selecting container sites, notifying adjacent property owners, and container specifications. Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman provides information on DSNY's approach to these …
1:23:35
·
46 sec
Addressing implementation challenges for BID containerization
Council Member Julie Won raises questions about various implementation challenges for BID containerization, including areas with bus or bike lanes, container approval backlogs, and situations where BIDs may struggle to …
1:24:44
·
69 sec
Resources, service levels, and timeline concerns for BID containerization
Council Member Julie Won inquires about resources for small BIDs, potential changes in DSNY service levels, and timeline concerns for BID compliance with containerization requirements. Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman addresses …
1:25:53
·
99 sec
Delivery status of wheelie bins for 1-9 unit properties
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about the progress of wheelie bin deliveries for 1-9 unit properties. Joshua Goodman from DSNY provides statistics on bin orders and deliveries, explaining that about …
1:27:42
·
134 sec
Timeline for bin delivery and enforcement
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about the timeline for bin delivery in relation to the start of enforcement. Joshua Goodman from DSNY explains the warning period and potential risks of …
1:29:58
·
29 sec
Marketing efforts for bin orders
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about ongoing marketing efforts to ensure people are ordering their bins. Joshua Goodman from DSNY outlines their comprehensive approach to spreading awareness. - DSNY is …
1:30:27
·
20 sec
Clarification on recycling bin requirements
Council Member Shaun Abreu seeks clarification on recycling bin requirements, particularly after 2026. Joshua Goodman from DSNY provides important details about the rules for recycling containers. - After June 1, …
1:30:48
·
112 sec
Bin size options and considerations
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about the possibility of offering larger bin sizes, specifically 55-gallon and 60-65 gallon options. Joshua Goodman from DSNY explains the considerations and potential future offerings. …
1:32:40
·
40 sec
Discretionary fund purchases for residential wheelie bins
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about the possibility of using council members' discretionary funds to purchase residential wheelie bins to provide to constituents for free. - Joshua Goodman from DSNY …
1:33:21
·
10 sec
Bin delivery logistics
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about the logistics of bin delivery from the manufacturer to New York City residents. Joshua Goodman from DSNY provides details on the process. - Otto, …
1:33:32
·
57 sec
Stolen bin reporting process
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about the process for reporting stolen bins and the interagency coordination between DSNY and NYPD. Joshua Goodman from DSNY addresses these concerns and provides insights …
1:34:29
·
84 sec
Concerns about multiple bins on blocks
Council Member Shaun Abreu raises constituent concerns about having multiple bins (trash, recycling, organics) out on their blocks at any given time. Joshua Goodman from DSNY addresses these concerns and …
1:35:55
·
55 sec
Council Member Bottcher addresses BID concerns with DSNY Deputy Commissioner
Council Member Erik D. Bottcher expresses concerns from Business Improvement Districts (BIDs) in his district about the Department of Sanitation's (DSNY) containerization plans. He questions DSNY Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman …
1:36:51
·
3 min
Council member inquires about organics recycling compliance issues
Council Member Shaun Abreu raises concerns about buildings struggling to comply with organics recycling requirements despite their willingness. He mentions issues with smell, storage, and other complications. - Abreu's office …
1:40:10
·
46 sec
DSNY outlines outreach efforts and training programs for organics recycling
Joshua Goodman from DSNY details the department's outreach and training efforts for organics recycling implementation. - DSNY offers trainings and site visits for those requesting assistance - Over 900 people …
1:40:55
·
132 sec
Discussion on DSNY's coordination with community composting groups
Council Member Shaun Abreu inquires about DSNY's coordination with community composting groups for education and outreach. - DSNY has shared outreach materials with community groups - Plans for closer coordination …
1:43:09
·
50 sec
Concerns raised about tenant reporting and data on non-compliance warnings
Council Member Abreu expresses concerns about putting the responsibility on tenants to report lack of brown bins, and inquires about data on warnings issued by DSNY. - DSNY clarifies that …
1:43:59
·
143 sec
DSNY outlines enforcement plans for organics recycling compliance
Council Member Abreu inquires about DSNY's plans for enforcement after the warning period, particularly for large buildings. - Enforcement will be based on analysis of waste set out at the …
1:46:23
·
50 sec
DSNY's approach to assisting communities with building compliance
Council Member Abreu asks about DSNY's ability to assist communities where buildings are not allowing compliance with organic recycling requirements. - DSNY recommends using 311 to report non-compliant buildings - …
1:47:13
·
47 sec
Debate on DSNY's authority to inspect inside private buildings
Council Member Abreu and DSNY officials discuss the department's ability to inspect inside private buildings for recycling compliance. - DSNY clarifies that they don't have the authority to enter private …
1:48:01
·
47 sec
Clarification on the availability and distribution of free brown bins
Council Member Abreu seeks clarification on reports that DSNY has run out of free brown bins and discusses the current distribution policy. - DSNY explains that free bin distribution had …
1:48:49
·
177 sec
Protocol for handling frozen organic waste in brown bins
Council Member Abreu inquires about DSNY's protocol for handling organic waste that freezes and sticks to brown bins during cold weather. - DSNY First Deputy Commissioner Javier Lohan responds that …
1:51:47
·
32 sec
Council Member Julie Won questions DSNY on BID compliance and large building waste management
Council Member Julie Won raises concerns about Business Improvement Districts' (BIDs) ability to comply with new sanitation rules and inquires about waste management for large residential buildings. DSNY Deputy Commissioner …
1:52:25
·
131 sec
Testimony by Laura Rothrock, Co-chair of Sanitation Working Group at NYC BID Association, on Waste Containerization
Laura Rothrock, representing the NYC BID Association, testified about concerns regarding waste containerization requirements for Business Improvement Districts (BIDs). She highlighted the operational challenges and cost burdens that BIDs face …
1:56:59
·
131 sec
Testimony by Corey Coons, Senior Vice President of Operations at Hudson Square Business Improvement District, on Containerization Requirements
Corey Coons from the Hudson Square Business Improvement District (BID) expresses concerns about new containerization requirements in New York City. He highlights the potential financial and operational burdens these requirements …
1:59:37
·
129 sec
Testimony by Dirk McCall de Palomá, Executive Director of Sunnyside Shines Business Improvement District (BID), on Waste Containerization
Dirk McCall de Palomá, Executive Director of Sunnyside Shines BID, testified about the challenges smaller BIDs face in implementing waste containerization proposals. He expressed concerns about funding, logistics, and the …
2:01:50
·
122 sec
Testimony by Tiera Mack, Executive Director of Pitkin Avenue Business Improvement District (BID)
Tiera Mack, Executive Director of the Pitkin Avenue BID in Brownsville, testifies against mandatory containerization for BIDs in commercial corridors. She outlines the BID's current sanitation efforts and budget, highlighting …
2:03:59
·
119 sec
Testimony by Jim Martin, Executive Director of Association of Community Employment (ACE), on Containerization Concerns
Jim Martin, Executive Director of ACE, testified about significant concerns regarding the planned rollout of containerization in NYC. He highlighted the potential negative impacts on ACE's operations, which provide supplemental …
2:07:05
·
149 sec
Testimony by Noah Sheroff, Executive Director of Bayside Village Business Improvement District (BID)
Noah Sheroff, Executive Director of Bayside Village BID, testified about the challenges that small BIDs face with the new waste containerization mandate. He highlighted the financial and operational difficulties that …
2:09:40
·
134 sec
Testimony by Matt Molloy, Sanitation Supervisor of Garment District Alliance on Intro 57 and Containerization
Matt Molloy, representing the Garment District Alliance, testified on Intro 57 and containerization efforts. While supporting containerized garbage in principle, he expressed strong objections to specific aspects of the bill …
2:12:00
·
158 sec
Testimony by Rebecca Poole, Director of Membership of The Council of New York Cooperatives & Condominiums, on Waste Containerization
Rebecca Poole, representing The Council of New York Cooperatives & Condominiums, testified on the challenges faced by their member buildings regarding waste containerization initiatives. While supporting the city's efforts to …
2:14:43
·
140 sec
Testimony by Scott Hobbs, Executive Director of The Village Alliance
Scott Hobbs, Executive Director of The Village Alliance, testifies about the challenges small Business Improvement Districts (BIDs) face with DSNY's proposed waste containerization mandate. He expresses support for cleaner streets …
2:17:56
·
111 sec
Testimony by Jeffrey LaFrancois, Executive Director of Meatpacking District Management Association on Trash Containerization
Jeffrey LaFrancois, representing the Meatpacking District Management Association, testifies about concerns regarding DSNY's proposal for mandatory trash containerization for BIDs. He argues that while containerization could be positive, the current …
2:19:51
·
132 sec
Testimony by Mark Dicus, Vice President of Operations and Planning at Fifth Avenue Association
Mark Dicus, representing the Fifth Avenue Association, expressed concerns about the implementation of DSNY's containerization efforts and their impact on Business Improvement Districts (BIDs). He highlighted the challenges of siting …
2:22:09
·
135 sec
Testimony by Matt Jozwiak, CEO and Founder of Rethink Food, on Food Waste Management
Matt Jozwiak, CEO and Founder of Rethink Food, testified on the issue of excessive food waste in New York City's institutional food system, particularly in city shelters. He emphasized the …
2:24:31
·
53 sec
Testimony by Christine Datz-Romero, Executive Director of Lower East Side Ecology Center, on Community Composting and Intro 698
Christine Datz-Romero, Executive Director of the Lower East Side Ecology Center, testifies in support of Intro 698, which clarifies the definition of organic waste drop-off sites. She emphasizes the importance …
2:26:15
·
130 sec
Testimony by David Goldberg, Principal of Streetplus Company, on Containerization Challenges for BIDs
David Goldberg, a principal at Streetplus Company, testifies about the challenges Business Improvement Districts (BIDs) face with the proposed garbage containerization efforts in NYC. While supporting the goal of a …
2:28:31
·
127 sec
Testimony by Sarah Penenberg, Political Coordinator at 32BJ SEIU, on Intro 2744 and Worker Safety in Waste Management
Sarah Penenberg from 32BJ SEIU testified about the impact of Intro 2744 on residential workers in New York City's property service sector. She emphasized the need for worker safety measures …
2:30:41
·
125 sec
Testimony by Samantha MacBride, Faculty Member at Baruch College
Samantha MacBride, a faculty member at Baruch College, provided testimony on organic waste policy in New York City. She expressed support for several introductions with caveats and urged the council …
2:34:02
·
127 sec
Testimony by Magdamari Marcano, Resident of The Bronx Council District 15
Magdamari Marcano, a long-time resident of The Bronx, testified about concerns regarding the Department of Sanitation's trash containerization efforts to combat the rat problem in New York City. She raised …
2:36:15
·
3 min
Testimony by Niki Cross, Staff Attorney in the Environmental Justice Program at New York Lawyers for the Public Interest (NYLPI)
Niki Cross, representing NYLPI, testified in support of legislation aimed at reducing waste and improving organic waste management in New York City. They emphasized the importance of aggressive steps to …
2:39:48
·
136 sec
Testimony by Tim Laughlin, President of Lower East Side Partnership, on NYC Waste Containerization
Tim Laughlin, President of Lower East Side Partnership and co-chair of the NYC BID Association Sanitation Working Group, testifies about the need for better collaboration between the Department of Sanitation …
2:42:37
·
94 sec
Testimony by Maddie Baker, Operations Manager of Bryant Park Corporation and 34th Street Partnership Business Improvement Districts (BIDs)
Maddie Baker, representing Bryant Park Corporation and 34th Street Partnership BIDs, testified about the challenges and concerns regarding DSNY's containerization efforts. She acknowledged the goal of getting bags off the …
2:44:16
·
73 sec
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson, Member of the Public
Christopher Leon Johnson testifies about his concerns regarding the mandated bins for waste containerization in NYC. He agrees with Intro 57 but questions the requirement to buy specific bins from …
2:45:32
·
124 sec
Testimony by Mary Arnold, Representative of Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and Bronx Solid Waste Advisory Boards (SWABs) on Organic Waste Collection and Processing
Mary Arnold, representing multiple Solid Waste Advisory Boards, testified on Intro 498 regarding collecting organics from community gardens and Intro 698 clarifying the definition of organic waste drop-off sites. She …
2:48:29
·
128 sec
Testimony by Lateshia Peters, Representative of BK ROT
Lateshia Peters, representing BK ROT, a fossil fuel-free food waste hauling and composting service, testified in opposition to Intro 57 and in support of Intros 498, 698, and 284. She …
2:50:56
·
125 sec
Testimony by Lonnie Portis, New York City Policy Manager at WE ACT For Environmental Justice
Lonnie Portis from WE ACT For Environmental Justice testified on the importance of waste diversion and refuse reduction in New York City's containerization efforts. He emphasized the need for thoughtful …
2:53:12
·
128 sec
Testimony by Alia Soomro, Deputy Director for NYC Policy at New York League of Conservation Voters (NYLCV)
Alia Soomro from the New York League of Conservation Voters (NYLCV) testified in support of waste containerization efforts in NYC, emphasizing its environmental and quality of life benefits. She expressed …
2:55:35
·
140 sec
Testimony by Anna Sacks, Representative of Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Bronx Solid Waste Advisory Boards (SWABs)
Anna Sacks, representing the Solid Waste Advisory Boards of Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx, testified on various waste management issues and proposed legislation. She expressed opposition to Intro 57 …
2:58:00
·
127 sec
Testimony by Clare Miflin, Executive Director of Center For Zero Waste Design
Clare Miflin, Executive Director of the Center For Zero Waste Design, testified about the need for a comprehensive waste containerization plan in NYC. She expressed frustration with the Department of …
3:00:21
·
129 sec
Testimony by Camelia Tepelus, Executive Director of Morris Park Business Improvement District (BID)
Camelia Tepelus, Executive Director of Morris Park BID, expressed support for DSNY's containerization efforts while highlighting challenges faced by smaller BIDs in implementing the proposed changes. She emphasized the need …
3:02:47
·
123 sec
Testimony by Pedro Suarez, Executive Director of Third Avenue Business Improvement District (BID) on Containerization Challenges in the South Bronx
Pedro Suarez, Executive Director of the Third Avenue Business Improvement District (BID) in the South Bronx, testifies about the challenges of implementing containerization in his district. He cautions against underestimating …
3:04:57
·
99 sec
