The citymeetings.nyc logo showing a pigeon at a podium with a microphone.

citymeetings.nyc

Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

Q&A

CUNY's policy on identity concealment during on-campus activities

0:51:35

·

3 min

Council Member Dinowitz questions CUNY's policies regarding individuals wearing identity-concealing masks during on-campus activities or protests.

  • Chancellor Rodriguez reveals that CUNY has not established a specific policy regarding identity concealment
  • The discussion highlights that under existing rules, students engaging in on-campus activities must show ID if required
  • Dinowitz expresses concern about the practical challenges of enforcing ID checks during large gatherings or protests
Eric Dinowitz
0:51:35
I wanna talk about inside campus because that's completely the purview of the NYPD I mean, of, campus safety.
0:51:42
Correct?
0:51:42
You know what I mean?
0:51:43
Has CUNY established any policy regarding individuals wearing identity concealing masks during on campus activities or protests?
0:51:54
No.
0:51:55
Can you talk can you talk more about that?
0:51:57
Have you considered it?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:51:58
Well, I mean, any any student who's engaging in any behavior on our campuses under the Henderson rules needs to be able to show ID and identify themselves if required.
Eric Dinowitz
0:52:10
Have you but you haven't considered a masking policy?
0:52:14
Because very often, the complaints that happen, there isn't a campus safety officer to check people's ID.
0:52:21
And you know what?
0:52:22
Honestly, when you have a lot of kids, if their faces are concealed, it's a little daunting to go up to each one of them and get their ID.
0:52:29
And a lot of the information we have is from video.
0:52:33
But you have no plans to create a mask, policy at CUNY?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:52:40
We we that would I mean, we're a public university, so the threshold to be able to do that, might might might be complicated.
0:52:49
What we have told the campuses that since they can ask people to show ID and tell us who you are, that that's a way to be able to deal with any kind of concealment that you might have at any at any point.
Eric Dinowitz
0:53:00
But it would require an employee to go up the student and ask for identification.
0:53:06
And in the case that they don't show identification, what happens then?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:53:09
Well, and then they can be submitted to disciplinary action because they're breaking the Henderson rules.
Eric Dinowitz
0:53:15
How many times have you asked for ID?
0:53:17
Or how many times does the QED campus has asked for ID?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:53:19
I mean, you have to go campus by campus, but they do.
Eric Dinowitz
0:53:23
If they keep track of that?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:53:24
If the students if the students are engaging in disruptive behavior, you can go and ask for their ID.
Eric Dinowitz
0:53:31
Does that happen?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:53:32
Yes.
Eric Dinowitz
0:53:36
In speaking with students
David Wapner
0:53:37
Mhmm.
Eric Dinowitz
0:53:38
It does not appear to be their observations that that happens.
0:53:42
But but when a campus safety officer asks for ID, do they log it in any way?
0:53:47
Do they collect that information and share with you how many times they've actually had to do that?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:53:54
I mean, I guess it's logged in if the individual refuses to.
Eric Dinowitz
0:53:58
But I guess if they refuse to, they don't know who it is.
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:54:01
Well, they're but then but then then you get arrested.
Eric Dinowitz
0:54:05
Do has it happened?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:54:08
Well, so that it has happened and then it can be a deterrent to to what they're doing too.
Eric Dinowitz
0:54:12
I'm I'm gonna I'm, you know, I'm gonna guess no one has been arrested for failure to show identification on the CUNY campus.
0:54:20
I I find that very
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:54:22
I I I I I I failed to this degree.
0:54:24
It's one of the Henderson rules.
0:54:25
It's one of the things that is based on the in the code of conduct that you have to do that.
Eric Dinowitz
0:54:28
Right.
0:54:29
But do I I get the question.
0:54:30
Do you know how many students have been arrested for failure to show ID?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:54:33
I I don't have that number.
0:54:35
No.
0:54:35
Okay.
Eric Dinowitz
0:54:36
I've I I mean, if you're testifying that that is the process and those are things that happen, I think the committee deserves to know, does it happen or how often that happens per campus?
0:54:48
So there is besides relying on existing rules and interpretations of the Henderson rules, there is no specific policy regarding identity concealment.
0:54:59
Correct?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
0:55:00
No.
0:55:01
Okay.
Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.