The citymeetings.nyc logo showing a pigeon at a podium with a microphone.

citymeetings.nyc

Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

Q&A

Discussion on Zionism and Jewish identity

1:12:10

·

61 sec

Council Member Vernikov questions Chancellor Matos Rodriguez about his stance on Zionism as part of Jewish identity and whether anti-Zionism constitutes antisemitism. The chancellor provides nuanced responses, leading to some tension in the exchange.

  • Chancellor expresses that Zionism's importance to Jewish identity varies among individuals
  • Discussion on whether anti-Zionism equates to antisemitism
  • The exchange highlights the complexity of defining and addressing antisemitism in the academic context
Inna Vernikov
1:12:10
So that's a yes.
1:12:11
Okay.
1:12:12
And then do you accept the judge's findings that for many Jewish people, Zionism is a part of their Jewish identity?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
1:12:20
That's that's the judge's opinion.
1:12:22
So I So
Inna Vernikov
1:12:23
you agree with the judge's opinion?
1:12:24
Yes?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
1:12:25
I mean, my understanding from talking to Jewish students is that in many cases, it is, and in some, it isn't.
Inna Vernikov
1:12:30
So is that a yes?
1:12:31
You agree with the judge's opinion that Zionism is a core part of Jewish identity?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
1:12:36
Yes?
1:12:36
I think I think it depends on
Inna Vernikov
1:12:38
It's a yes or no.
1:12:39
It doesn't depend on anything.
1:12:40
That
Felix Matos Rodriguez
1:12:41
I cannot give you a yes or no answer.
Inna Vernikov
1:12:43
Okay.
1:12:44
Do you accept that anti Zionism constitutes antisemitism?
1:12:48
The judge put that in his report as well.
1:12:50
Is that a yes or no?
Felix Matos Rodriguez
1:12:51
If if anti Zionism leads to the discrimination, the harassment, and of Jewish, the
Inna Vernikov
1:12:57
That's not my question.
1:12:57
Yes.
1:12:58
That's not my question.
Felix Matos Rodriguez
1:13:01
Well, that's that's my answer.
Inna Vernikov
1:13:05
Does do you accept that anti Zionism is antisemitism?
UNKNOWN
1:13:08
I certainly can.
Inna Vernikov
1:13:09
It can.
1:13:09
It can.
1:13:11
Yes.
Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.