New York City Council
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure
Dec 11, 2024
·
10:00 AM
8 hr 21 min
Summary
A hearing on proposed e-bike legislation, including:
- Intro 606: Requiring licensing and registration of e-bikes
- Intro 1131: Creating a task force to study street safety improvements for e-bikes
- Resolution 224: Calling on NY State to pass legislation on commercial e-bike licensing
Discussions focused on:
- Improving safety and accountability for e-bike riders
- Concerns about implementation costs and potential discriminatory enforcement
- Alternative solutions such as better infrastructure and app regulation
- Balancing safety with transportation access
Features testimony from the Department of Transportation (DOT) and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Brooks-Powers asks Commissioner to finish testimony after technical difficulties
Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers briefly addresses technical difficulties and requests the Commissioner to continue their testimony. - Acknowledges patience due to technology issues - Asks the Commissioner to finish …
0:11:56
·
9 sec
NYC DOT Commissioner Rodriguez Testifies on E-bike Legislation
(NOTE: The beginning of this meeting's recording is not available, and Commissioner Rodriguez's is cut short.) Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez of the NYC Department of Transportation testified on proposed legislation regarding …
0:12:05
·
103 sec
Introduction of e-scooter pilot program discussion
Council Member Brooks-Powers initiates a discussion about the e-scooter pilot program in NYC, particularly focusing on its implementation in Southeast Queens. She references the city council's enactment of local law …
0:13:49
·
52 sec
Lessons learned from e-scooter pilot program phases
Commissioner Rodriguez and Assistant Commissioner Carry discuss the lessons learned from the first two phases of the e-scooter pilot program and their implementation in the current phase 3 in eastern …
0:14:42
·
116 sec
Community reception of e-scooter program in eastern Queens
Assistant Commissioner Carry discusses the reception of phase 3 of the e-scooter share program in eastern Queens and how DOT is addressing community concerns. - The program has seen robust …
0:16:39
·
117 sec
Measurement of micromobility access in NYC neighborhoods
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about how DOT measures that 70% of city residents have access to bike or scooter share in their neighborhoods. Commissioner Rodriguez and Deputy Commissioner Beaton explain …
0:18:39
·
57 sec
Community feedback and calls for operational pause of e-scooter program
Council Member Brooks-Powers asks about how DOT incorporated community feedback when implementing the e-scooter program, particularly in light of calls for an operational pause. Commissioner Rodriguez responds to these concerns. …
0:19:41
·
145 sec
Safety concerns related to e-scooter parking on sidewalks and streets
Council Member Brooks-Powers raises concerns about safety hazards created when e-scooters are left on sidewalks and streets. Commissioner Rodriguez and Assistant Commissioner Carry discuss DOT's response to these concerns. - …
0:22:07
·
84 sec
DOT's accountability measures for e-scooter program vendors
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about DOT's efforts to hold e-scooter program vendors accountable for safety issues. Commissioner Rodriguez responds to these concerns. - DOT is working with the Department of …
0:23:52
·
62 sec
Transition to other council members' questions
Council Member Brooks-Powers concludes her questioning and transitions to allow other council members to ask their questions. - Brooks-Powers acknowledges she has more questions but will pause to allow others …
0:24:57
·
47 sec
Council Member Holden questions DOT officials on e-bike safety and data collection
Council Member Robert F. Holden expresses concerns about e-bike safety and questions DOT officials on their lack of precise data regarding traffic law compliance by e-bike riders. The DOT representatives, …
0:25:44
·
4 min
Council Member Chi Ossé questions DOT officials on potential e-bike legislation implementation
Council Member Chi Ossé engages in a Q&A session with DOT Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez and Deputy Commissioner Eric Beaton regarding the potential implementation and effects of proposed e-bike legislation. The …
0:29:55
·
163 sec
Council Member Brewer questions Commissioner Rodriguez on e-bike safety measures and data sharing
Council Member Gale A. Brewer engages in a Q&A session with DOT Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, discussing various aspects of e-bike safety, regulation, and data sharing. Brewer inquires about support for …
0:32:38
·
4 min
Council Member Marmorato raises concerns about e-scooter program in Northeast Bronx
Council Member Kristy Marmorato expresses strong concerns about the e-scooter program in her Northeast Bronx district, citing safety issues, violations, and lack of accountability from the operating company. Commissioner Ydanis …
0:37:00
·
4 min
Council Member Paladino expresses concerns over e-bike and scooter regulations
Council Member Vickie Paladino strongly criticizes the current state of e-bike and scooter usage in NYC, emphasizing safety concerns and the need for stricter regulations. Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez responds by …
0:41:09
·
4 min
Clarifying the definition of legal motorized vehicles
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse seeks clarification on the definition of legal motorized vehicles, specifically asking if it includes motorized wheelchairs. The DOT representatives are uncertain and offer to follow up …
0:45:58
·
44 sec
Discussion on licensing requirements for commercial and personal e-bike use
Council Member Narcisse inquires about potential differences in licensing for commercial and personal e-bike use. Commissioner Rodriguez clarifies the focus on e-bikes and explains the DOT's position on licensing and …
0:46:42
·
61 sec
Exploring registration fees and costs for the proposed e-bike program
Council Member Narcisse inquires about the potential fees for e-bike registration and the estimated costs for setting up and operating the registration program. DOT Assistant Commissioner Rick Rodriguez provides some …
0:47:44
·
60 sec
Law enforcement training for distinguishing between vehicle types
Council Member Narcisse raises a question about the need for law enforcement training to differentiate between bicycles, electric bikes, and motorized vehicles. Commissioner Rodriguez provides a brief response on enforcement …
0:48:52
·
26 sec
Addressing safety concerns regarding e-bike and e-scooter speeds
Council Member Narcisse raises concerns about the dangerous speeds of motorized scooters on city streets. Commissioner Rodriguez acknowledges these concerns and outlines the DOT's approach to improving safety for all …
0:49:19
·
89 sec
Council Member Restler questions DOT on e-bike safety and registration effectiveness
Council Member Lincoln Restler engages in a heated discussion with DOT Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez about e-bike safety and the effectiveness of proposed registration measures. Restler emphasizes the higher danger posed …
0:50:52
·
4 min
Council Member Ariola challenges DOT Commissioner on e-bike safety and regulation
Council Member Joann Ariola strongly criticizes the Department of Transportation's stance on e-bike regulation, citing safety concerns and popular support for stricter measures. She argues for the necessity of registration, …
0:55:31
·
4 min
Council Member Rivera acknowledges DOT's efforts and expresses community concerns
Council Member Carlina Rivera opens by thanking the Department of Transportation for their presence and responsiveness. She highlights the importance of creating safer streets and mentions several initiatives in her …
1:00:03
·
52 sec
Discussion on examples of e-bike registration efforts and their impact
Council Member Rivera inquires about examples of similar registration efforts and their impact on safety and ridership. Commissioner Rodriguez responds briefly, mentioning unsuccessful attempts in other cities. - Rivera asks …
1:00:55
·
27 sec
Commissioner Rodriguez highlights DOT's achievements in bike lane construction
Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez emphasizes New York City's leadership in implementing bike infrastructure, particularly protected bike lanes. - Highlights that NYC built 32 protected bike lanes last year - Claims this …
1:01:22
·
38 sec
Council Member Rivera raises concerns about implementing e-bike registration
Council Member Rivera expresses concerns about the feasibility of implementing an e-bike registration program and asks about DOT's capacity to manage such a program. - Highlights the differences between Manhattan …
1:02:00
·
66 sec
DOT's perspective on enforcing e-bike regulations without registration
Commissioner Rodriguez addresses Council Member Rivera's concerns about enforcing e-bike regulations, stating that registration is not necessary for enforcement. - Rodriguez asserts that NYPD doesn't need licenses to enforce current …
1:03:07
·
18 sec
Assistant Commissioner Carry explains enforcement efforts and cites examples from other cities
Assistant Commissioner Will Carry provides a detailed explanation of current enforcement efforts and cites examples from other cities regarding e-bike registration systems. - Confirms that NYPD can enforce e-bike regulations …
1:03:25
·
94 sec
Council Member De La Rosa introduces herself and acknowledges DOT's efforts on battery safety
Council Member Carmen De La Rosa opens her remarks by thanking the DOT commissioner and acknowledging their efforts regarding the battery situation. She mentions that her district has the second-highest …
1:05:07
·
36 sec
Council Member De La Rosa addresses safety concerns for seniors and the community
Council Member De La Rosa emphasizes the importance of balancing workforce support with community safety, particularly focusing on the risks faced by seniors. - She shares an incident where a …
1:05:43
·
25 sec
Council Member De La Rosa discusses accountability measures and legislation
Council Member De La Rosa addresses the need for accountability in regulating e-bikes and micromobility devices, mentioning Council Member Holden's bill as a starting point for discussion. - She suggests …
1:06:08
·
41 sec
Council Member De La Rosa inquires about e-bike weight and safety data
Council Member De La Rosa raises a question about the relationship between e-bike weight and safety, particularly regarding mortality rates in collisions. DOT officials respond with information about weight limits …
1:06:49
·
100 sec
Council Member De La Rosa questions the effectiveness of accountability measures
Council Member De La Rosa challenges DOT's stance on accountability measures for e-bike and micromobility device users, drawing parallels to other traffic enforcement methods. - She points out the effectiveness …
1:08:30
·
53 sec
Debate on economic pressures and enforcement for delivery workers
Assistant Commissioner Rick Rodriguez and Council Member De La Rosa discuss differing views on the reasons for unsafe behavior among delivery workers and the role of enforcement. - Rodriguez emphasizes …
1:09:22
·
72 sec
Discussion on the growing popularity of cycling in New York City
Council Member Brooks-Powers and DOT officials discuss the significant increase in cycling in New York City since 1980, exploring reasons for its growing popularity and the impact on various communities. …
1:10:48
·
121 sec
Inquiry about cycling ridership patterns and data availability
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about specific cycling ridership patterns, focusing on weekday versus weekend usage. DOT officials provide information and discuss data availability. - Ridership is higher on weekdays, indicating …
1:12:51
·
36 sec
DOT's methods for monitoring cycling trends
DOT officials explain their comprehensive approach to monitoring cycling trends in New York City, using a combination of technologies and methods to gather data. - DOT uses automatic sensors to …
1:13:28
·
87 sec
Discussion on infrastructure investments to improve cycling safety
Commissioner Rodriguez discusses various infrastructure investments and initiatives aimed at improving cycling safety and promoting sustainable transportation in New York City. - DOT is widening bike lanes and built 32 …
1:14:56
·
121 sec
Introduction of council member's bill on e-bike safety and regulation
Council Member Brooks-Powers introduces her bill aimed at improving safety and regulation for e-bikes and other new modes of transportation. The discussion focuses on the bill's intent and DOT's response …
1:17:07
·
147 sec
DOT's considerations for regulating e-bikes and e-scooters
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about DOT's efforts to regulate e-bikes and e-scooters for safety and behavior on the road. Commissioner Rodriguez outlines DOT's approach to addressing these concerns. - DOT …
1:19:36
·
63 sec
Vision Zero data collection for e-scooter and e-bike violations
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about how Vision Zero captures data on e-scooter and e-bike violations. DOT officials explain the data collection process and enforcement efforts. - Vision Zero now incorporates …
1:20:40
·
3 min
Presentation and discussion of crash statistics for various vehicle types
DOT officials present year-to-date crash statistics for various vehicle types, including cars, mopeds, e-bikes, and e-scooters. Council Member Brooks-Powers seeks clarification on trends and comparisons to previous years. - Year-to-date …
1:24:39
·
109 sec
Effectiveness of red light and speed cameras
Council Member Holden questions Commissioner Rodriguez about the effectiveness of red light cameras and speed cameras. The Commissioner confirms that both types of cameras work effectively. - Red light cameras …
1:26:30
·
21 sec
Debate on licensing requirements for e-bikes
Council Member Holden criticizes the DOT's opposition to e-bike licensing, arguing that licensing would improve safety through better enforcement using existing camera technology. - Holden suggests that licensed e-bikes could …
1:26:52
·
38 sec
Comparison of e-bike safety measures with Denmark
Council Member Holden cites Denmark's experience with e-bike licensing, highlighting significant reductions in deaths, injuries, and crashes. He criticizes the DOT for not considering this data and for their current …
1:27:30
·
84 sec
Request for data on dangerous locations for e-bike and e-scooter violations
Council Member Holden presses Commissioner Rodriguez for specific data on locations where e-bike and e-scooter violations are most prevalent. The Commissioner is unable to provide this information during the hearing. …
1:28:54
·
59 sec
Chair's request for additional information during the hearing
Council Member Brooks-Powers, acting as chair, requests that the DOT attempt to obtain the missing information about e-bike and e-scooter violation hotspots while the hearing is ongoing. - Brooks-Powers recognizes …
1:29:52
·
8 sec
Commissioner's stance on enforcement without licensing
Commissioner Rodriguez reiterates the DOT's position that licensing is not necessary for effective enforcement of e-bike and e-scooter regulations. - Rodriguez states that the DOT and NYPD can work together …
1:30:01
·
24 sec
Council member's concerns about reckless e-bike and moped usage
Council Member Brooks-Powers expresses concerns about the lack of regulation for e-bikes and mopeds, emphasizing the need for action to address safety issues. - Brooks-Powers stresses that inaction is not …
1:30:24
·
68 sec
Council Member Marmorato questions DOT officials on e-bike and e-scooter regulations and safety
Council Member Kristy Marmorato engages in a Q&A session with DOT Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez and other officials regarding e-bike and e-scooter regulations, safety concerns, and data sharing with law enforcement. …
1:31:32
·
3 min
DOT's implementation plan and cost estimates for Intro 606
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about DOT's plan to implement Intro 606, which would require licensing and registration of e-bikes. DOT officials explain the significant undertaking required, including: - Creation of …
1:34:54
·
97 sec
Debate on potential discriminatory aspects of e-bike licensing
Council Member Brooks-Powers and DOT officials discuss potential discrimination in e-bike licensing requirements. Key points include: - Commissioner Rodriguez expresses concern about discriminatory aspects if licensing targets only certain groups, …
1:36:32
·
38 sec
Enforcement challenges and strategies for e-bike safety
Council Member Brooks-Powers and DOT officials discuss the effectiveness of licensing in enforcing street safety rules for e-bikes and other micromobility devices. Key points include: - DOT believes current laws …
1:37:11
·
73 sec
Alignment of proposed legislation with Vision Zero goals
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about the alignment of the proposed legislation with the city's Vision Zero goals. DOT officials respond, highlighting: - Agreement that accountability and enforcement are part of …
1:38:26
·
47 sec
Vehicle registration at city vs. state level and DOT's proposed solutions
Council Member Brooks-Powers and DOT officials discuss Resolution 224 and whether vehicle registration should be handled at the city or state level. Key points include: - DOT suggests the appropriate …
1:39:14
·
100 sec
Comparison of commercial and non-commercial e-bike usage and associated issues
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about the differences between commercial and non-commercial e-bike usage and associated problems. DOT officials respond, highlighting: - The importance of distinguishing between different types of commercial …
1:40:54
·
84 sec
Crash statistics for micromobility devices in 2023 and 2024
Eric Beaton from DOT presents crash statistics for various micromobility devices, comparing 2023 and 2024 year-to-date data: - Moped crashes: 2,991 in 2024 YTD, compared to 3,594 in 2023 - …
1:42:19
·
62 sec
Cycling ridership data comparison for weekdays and weekends
Eric Beaton from DOT presents cycling ridership data for various locations in New York City, comparing weekday and weekend patterns: - Brooklyn Bridge: Average weekday 4,991 riders, weekend 3,470 riders …
1:43:21
·
74 sec
Startup and ongoing costs for implementing Intro 606
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about the specific startup and ongoing costs for implementing Intro 606. DOT officials provide details on the anticipated expenses: - Creation of a custom IT system …
1:44:35
·
115 sec
Potential fees and revenue projections for Intro 606
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about potential fees and revenue projections for licenses and registrations under Intro 606. DOT officials respond: - Fees would be determined based on an administrative cost …
1:46:39
·
82 sec
Resource requirements for implementing Intro 1131 task force
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about the resource requirements for implementing the task force proposed in Intro 1131. DOT officials respond: - DOT does not anticipate requiring additional resources to implement …
1:48:04
·
44 sec
Council Member Holden corrects information on e-bike and e-scooter regulations
Council Member Robert F. Holden clarifies information about e-bike and e-scooter regulations in other cities, particularly Toronto. He criticizes the DOT for providing incorrect information and emphasizes the need for …
1:48:58
·
96 sec
Council Member Brooks-Powers questions DOT on staffing and budget for Intro 1131
Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers engages in a discussion with Eric Beaton from the Department of Transportation regarding the staffing and budget implications of Intro 1131. The conversation reveals a …
1:50:39
·
98 sec
Council Member Farías questions DOT on e-bike registration and impact on delivery workers
Council Member Amanda Farías inquires about the implementation costs of Intro 606, which calls for city-level e-bike registration, and expresses concerns about the potential disproportionate impact on low-wage delivery workers. …
1:52:18
·
3 min
Testimony by Brad Hoylman-Sigel, State Senator from New York State Senate, on E-bike Safety and Regulation
State Senator Brad Hoylman-Sigel testified on the importance of e-bike safety and regulation, highlighting the increasing presence of micromobility devices on NYC streets. He discussed state-level legislative efforts to address …
1:59:46
·
3 min
Testimony by Sindhu Bharadwaj, Representative for Brad Lander from New York City Comptroller's Office
Sindhu Bharadwaj, representing NYC Comptroller Brad Lander, presented findings from a report on street safety in the era of micromobility. The testimony supported Intro 1131 and offered recommendations to improve …
2:04:01
·
152 sec
Testimony by Robert Acevedo, Member of the Public, on E-Scooter Safety and Accessibility Concerns
Robert Acevedo, a wheelchair user, testified about safety and accessibility concerns related to e-scooters. He shared personal experiences of nearly being hit by an e-scooter and facing obstacles created by …
2:07:55
·
111 sec
Testimony by Mary Macukkin, Member of the Public, on E-Bike Registration
Mary Macukkin, a member of the public, testifies in strong support of Priscilla's law for e-bike registration. She shares her personal experience as an aging person with a disability who …
2:09:55
·
133 sec
Testimony by Rabbi Michael Miller, Member of the Public, on E-Bike Safety Concerns
Rabbi Michael Miller testifies about his personal experience as a victim of an e-bike accident, highlighting the dangers posed by reckless e-bike riders to pedestrians. He calls for comprehensive measures …
2:12:17
·
166 sec
Testimony by Philip Miatkowski, Interim Deputy Executive Director of Transportation Alternatives, on E-bike Legislation
Philip Miatkowski, representing Transportation Alternatives, expressed support for Intro 1131 and strong opposition to Intro 606 during his testimony. He argued that bike licensing is ineffective, costly, and potentially discriminatory, …
2:15:09
·
143 sec
Testimony by Janet Schroeder, Director and Cofounder of E-Vehicle Safety Alliance, on E-bike Safety and Regulation
Janet Schroeder, representing the E-Vehicle Safety Alliance, testifies in support of Priscilla's Law and addresses concerns about e-bike safety in New York City. She emphasizes the need for accountability and …
2:17:43
·
132 sec
Testimony by Andrew Fine, Vice President and Legislative Director of East 86th Street Association and New York City E-Vehicle Alliance
Andrew Fine, representing the East 86th Street Association and New York City E-Vehicle Alliance, testified in support of accountability measures for e-bike riders and criticized Transportation Alternatives for opposing such …
2:20:30
·
129 sec
Testimony by Pamela Manasseh, Cofounder of E-Vehicle Safety Alliance, on E-Bike Safety and Regulation
Pamela Manasseh, cofounder of the E-Vehicle Safety Alliance, provides emotional testimony about her personal experience as a victim of an e-bike accident and advocates for the passage of legislation requiring …
2:41:14
·
138 sec
Testimony by Sook Ling Lai, Retired Executive Director of Chinatown Head Start, on E-bike Regulation
Sook Ling Lai, retired Executive Director of Chinatown Head Start, testifies in support of "Priscilla's law" which would require license plates for all e-bikes. She speaks on behalf of Priscilla …
2:43:49
·
141 sec
Testimony by Peggy Ng, Educational Director of Chinatown Head Start
Peggy Ng, the Educational Director of Chinatown Head Start, provided emotional testimony about a tragic e-bike accident involving Priscilla, a colleague who was severely injured. The incident highlights the dangers …
2:46:15
·
125 sec
Testimony by Arthur Miller, Member of the Public
Arthur Miller, a regular cyclist, expresses strong concerns about the proliferation of e-bikes in New York City, particularly in Council District 30. He emphasizes the danger they pose to pedestrians …
2:48:53
·
97 sec
Testimony by Brian Van, Chair of Transportation Committee from Manhattan Community Board 6
Brian Van, Chair of the Transportation Committee for Manhattan Community Board 6, testified against Intro 606, arguing that it is harmful and ineffective in improving road safety. He criticized the …
2:50:37
·
142 sec
Testimony by Jackson Chabot, Director of Advocacy and Organizing at Open Plans
Jackson Chabot, representing Open Plans, testifies in opposition to Intro 606 and in support of Intro 1131. He argues that bike licensing disproportionately impacts marginalized communities, particularly people of color, …
2:54:36
·
129 sec
Testimony by Elizabeth Denys, Flatbush Resident
Elizabeth Denys, a Flatbush resident, testified in opposition to Intro 606 and any legislation that would restrict or ban e-bikes in New York City. She emphasized the importance of e-bikes …
2:56:47
·
121 sec
Testimony by Shannon Phipps on E-Bike Regulation and Safety
Shannon Phipps, a first-generation Iranian American, testifies in support of e-bike registration and licensing, sharing personal experiences with safety concerns. She criticizes the argument that such measures are racist and …
2:58:58
·
150 sec
Testimony by Jim Burke, Member of the Public, on E-bike Legislation
Jim Burke, a member of the public and safe street advocate, testified against Intro 606 and in favor of investing in bike infrastructure to improve safety. He shared his personal …
3:02:22
·
128 sec
Testimony by Marissa Redanti, Member of the Public, on E-bike Safety and Regulation
Marissa Redanti, a nearly 70-year-old member of the public, testifies in support of e-bike regulation, particularly the implementation of license plates. She emphasizes the safety concerns for pedestrians and the …
3:04:31
·
147 sec
Testimony by Cassandra Martinez on E-Bike Regulation
Cassandra Martinez testifies against Intro 606 and in support of Intro 1131, expressing concerns that the proposed e-bike regulation could lead to discriminatory practices akin to stop-and-frisk. She argues that …
3:07:14
·
130 sec
Testimony by Paul Mondeser on E-bike and Micromobility Regulation
Paul Mondeser, a Bronx native living in Brooklyn, provided testimony on the proposed legislation regarding e-bikes and micromobility devices. He shared his unique perspective as both an avid bike rider …
3:09:34
·
140 sec
Testimony by Daniel Solow from Central Queens Micro Mobility on E-bike Regulation
Daniel Solow, representing Central Queens Micro Mobility, testified against Intro 606 and in support of Intro 1131, emphasizing the benefits of micro mobility and opposing licensing and registration requirements for …
3:11:56
·
146 sec
Council Member Holden questions the effectiveness of wider bike lanes
Council Member Robert F. Holden engages in a Q&A session, questioning the effectiveness of wider bike lanes as a solution to e-bike safety issues. He directs his questions to Marissa, …
3:14:28
·
95 sec
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson, Member of the Public, on E-bike Regulation
Christopher Leon Johnson testifies in support of Intro 606, which proposes e-bike regulation. He strongly criticizes organizations opposing the bill, particularly Transportation Alternatives and Open Plans, accusing them of fearmongering …
3:18:23
·
128 sec
Testimony by Esther Blount on E-bike Regulation and Safety
Esther Blount testified in support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law), advocating for the regulation and licensing of e-bikes due to safety concerns. She emphasized the need for accountability and safety …
3:20:39
·
139 sec
Testimony by Eric McClure, Executive Director of StreetsPAC, on E-bike Regulation
Eric McClure, Executive Director of StreetsPAC, testified on the proposed e-bike regulations, particularly Intro 606. He acknowledged the need for policy solutions to address safety concerns but argued that Intro …
3:23:07
·
157 sec
Testimony by Ron Wisniewski, Resident of Hell's Kitchen
Ron Wisniewski, a long-time resident of Hell's Kitchen, testifies about the dangers posed by reckless bike riders in Manhattan, emphasizing the need for accountability and supporting the passage of Priscilla's …
3:25:46
·
120 sec
Council member responds to comments on attendance and compensation
Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers responds to the previous speaker's comments about council members' attendance and compensation during the hearing. She clarifies her role as chair and acknowledges the presence …
3:27:47
·
25 sec
Testimony by Liz OuYang, Civil Rights Attorney and Member of E-Vehicle Safety Alliance, on E-Bike Safety and Intro 606
Liz OuYang, a civil rights attorney and member of the E-Vehicle Safety Alliance, testified in support of Intro 606, emphasizing the importance of safety and accountability in e-bike regulation. She …
3:29:45
·
154 sec
Testimony by Peter Beadle, Co-chair of Transportation Committee at Queens Community Board 6
Peter Beadle testifies in opposition to Intro 606 and in favor of Intro 1131, arguing that Intro 606 will not improve street safety and may lead to discriminatory enforcement. He …
3:32:29
·
140 sec
Testimony by Peter Brown on E-Bike Safety Concerns
Peter Brown shares his personal experience of being severely injured by an e-bike rider on the sidewalk, highlighting the need for stricter regulations and enforcement of e-bike laws in New …
3:34:52
·
153 sec
Testimony by Jeffrey Thomas on E-bike Regulation
Jeffrey Thomas, a Brooklyn resident, testified against Intro 606, which would require licensing for e-bikes. He argued that the proposed legislation would be difficult to enforce and unnecessary for many …
3:37:29
·
135 sec
Testimony by Renee, 76-year-old E-bike Accident Victim
Renee, a 76-year-old woman, provided emotional testimony about her experience as a victim of an e-bike accident. She described the severe injuries she sustained, multiple surgeries, and the ongoing impact …
3:39:48
·
104 sec
Council member addresses decorum and acknowledges testimonies
Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers calls for decorum in the room and acknowledges the emotional testimonies heard, particularly from those impacted by e-bike accidents. - Warns that disruptive individuals may …
3:41:33
·
22 sec
Council member explains legislative approach to e-bike safety
Council Member Brooks-Powers outlines the council's approach to addressing e-bike safety concerns through legislation. She explains the rationale behind the current bills and the process of regulating new modes of …
3:41:56
·
91 sec
Council Member Holden advocates for e-bike registration and accountability
Council Member Robert F. Holden emphasizes the need for accountability in e-bike usage and argues for his proposed bill to require registration. He highlights the current inability to identify hit-and-run …
3:43:28
·
98 sec
Testimony by Seth Jacobson, 40-year Resident of New York City, on E-bike Safety and Regulation
Seth Jacobson, a long-time New York City resident and cyclist, testifies about the safety concerns surrounding e-bikes and the need for stricter regulation. He emphasizes the difficulty pedestrians face in …
3:47:23
·
136 sec
Testimony by Kathleen Brady, Member of E-Vehicle Safety Alliance on E-bike Safety and Intro 606
Kathleen Brady, an unpaid member of the E-Vehicle Safety Alliance, testified in support of Intro 606, highlighting the negative impact of unlicensed e-bikes on New York City's tourism and safety. …
3:49:48
·
105 sec
Testimony by Carl Tate, Resident of Midtown Manhattan, on E-Bike Regulation
Carl Tate, a long-time resident of midtown Manhattan, testified in support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's law) which would require license plates on e-vehicles. He argued that e-bikes, while theoretically a …
3:51:44
·
121 sec
Testimony by Raul Rivera, TLC Driver and Advocate
Raul Rivera, a TLC driver and advocate, strongly supports Intro 606 and urges the City Council to pass the bill quickly. He shares a personal experience of an e-bike accident …
3:53:49
·
117 sec
Testimony by Alia Soomro, Deputy Director for New York City Policy at New York League of Conservation Voters
Alia Soomro, representing the New York League of Conservation Voters, expressed support for e-mobility devices to reduce fossil fuel-based transportation while acknowledging safety concerns. She opposed Intro 606, which would …
3:55:50
·
129 sec
Testimony by Angela DeWood, Deputy Executive Director of Carnegie East House on E-Vehicle Safety and Intro 606
Angela DeWood, Deputy Executive Director of Carnegie East House, testified in support of Intro 606, emphasizing the dangers posed by unregulated e-vehicles to elderly residents of her assisted living community. …
3:58:04
·
123 sec
Testimony by Unknown Member of the Public on E-bike Regulation
A long-time New York City resident testifies in support of Intro 606, citing personal experiences of feeling threatened by e-bikes and other e-vehicles. The speaker emphasizes the need for e-bike …
4:01:23
·
124 sec
Testimony by Karen Chagru, District 7 Voter
Karen Chagru, a long-time New York resident and District 7 voter, testifies about the dangers of unregulated e-bikes and other motorized devices in the city. She shares her personal experience …
4:03:36
·
133 sec
Testimony by Anne McDermott, Member of the Public, on E-bike and Micromobility Safety Concerns
Anne McDermott, a lifelong cyclist and licensed NYC tour guide, testifies about safety concerns related to e-bikes and other motorized vehicles in New York City. She describes personal experiences of …
4:05:53
·
135 sec
Testimony by Ernest Augustus, Member of Brooklyn Community Board 2, on E-bike Safety and Intro 606
Ernest Augustus, a member of Brooklyn Community Board 2, testifies in strong support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's law), which would require license plates for all e-bikes and e-mobility vehicles. He …
4:08:10
·
150 sec
Testimony by Judy Paulson, Member of the Public
Judy Paulson, a long-time New York resident, testified in support of Intro 606, urging for the licensing and registration of e-vehicles to increase accountability for reckless riders. She shared personal …
4:10:52
·
114 sec
Testimony by Michael Giurbino, Member of the Public, on E-bike Safety Concerns
Michael Giurbino, a lifelong New Yorker, testified about his concerns regarding the proliferation of e-bikes in the city, emphasizing the safety risks they pose to pedestrians. He expressed strong support …
4:12:52
·
134 sec
Council Member Holden discusses commissioner's testimony with Karen Chagru
Council Member Robert F. Holden engages in a discussion with Karen Chagru about her reaction to the commissioner's testimony regarding e-bike safety. Holden shares his personal experience of being hit …
4:15:10
·
94 sec
Testimony by Scott Poole, Member of the Public, on E-Scooter Safety and Priscilla's Law
Scott Poole testifies in support of Priscilla's Law, sharing his personal experience of being hit by an e-scooter which resulted in severe injuries including traumatic brain injury. He emphasizes the …
4:18:32
·
63 sec
Testimony by Mary Ivanchoe, Member of the Public
Mary Ivanchoe, a long-time New York City resident, testifies in support of Priscilla's law, emphasizing the need for e-bike regulation and accountability to improve pedestrian safety. She argues that the …
4:19:41
·
111 sec
Testimony by Sonya Poe, Member of the Public, on E-Scooter Safety
Sonya Poe shares her personal experience of being hit by an e-scooter, resulting in severe injuries to her and her husband. She advocates for stricter rules and consequences for e-vehicle …
4:21:42
·
102 sec
Testimony by Carol Wilson, Member of the Public
Carol Wilson, a member of the public, shares her personal experiences of being hit by bicycles twice while crossing the street, resulting in serious injuries including a skull fracture. She …
4:23:35
·
125 sec
Testimony by Karen Phillips, Member of the Public
Karen Phillips, an octogenarian, expresses her support for the proposed legislation requiring visible licenses for bicycles. She describes her fear of being hit by cyclists who disregard traffic rules and …
4:25:47
·
97 sec
Testimony by Mary Vakras, Member of the Public, on E-Vehicle Safety and Intro 606
Mary Vakras, a lifelong New Yorker, testifies in support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law), advocating for the registration and licensing of e-vehicles to improve pedestrian safety and quality of life …
4:27:29
·
130 sec
Council Member Brooks-Powers clarifies the purpose of her task force bill in relation to Intro 606
Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers clarifies that her proposed task force bill aims to implement regulations similar to Priscilla's Law (Intro 606), but with a more comprehensive approach. She addresses …
4:29:39
·
61 sec
Council Member Holden discusses legality of proposed legislation and questions panelists about e-vehicle incidents
Council Member Robert F. Holden addresses the legality of the proposed legislation, asserting that the city's legislative team confirmed its legality. He then questions panelists who were struck by e-vehicles …
4:30:43
·
143 sec
Council Member Brooks-Powers provides closing remarks on accountability and next steps
Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers concludes the discussion by addressing the legality of the proposed bill and emphasizing the need for comprehensive solutions that go beyond identification to ensure accountability …
4:33:06
·
178 sec
Testimony by Michael Phillips, Member of the Public, on E-bike Licensing and Compliance
Michael Phillips testifies in favor of licensing requirements for e-bikes, arguing that it is necessary for ensuring compliance and accountability. He emphasizes that licensing would enable law enforcement to identify …
4:36:11
·
82 sec
Testimony by Member of the Public on E-Vehicle Registration and Licensing
A member of the public speaks in favor of Intro 606, also known as Priscilla's law, which proposes registration and licensing for e-vehicles. The speaker emphasizes the differences between e-bikes …
4:37:40
·
126 sec
Testimony by Member of the Public on E-Bike Safety and Regulation
A 71-year-old resident of Brooklyn recounts their recent experience of being hit by a bicycle while crossing the street in Manhattan, emphasizing the need for e-bike regulation and accountability. The …
4:39:53
·
141 sec
Testimony by Sandy Rayburn, Member of the Public, on E-bike Safety and Regulation
Sandy Rayburn, an 80-year-old lifelong New York City resident, testifies in support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's law) to address e-bike safety concerns and accountability. She emphasizes the need for protection …
4:42:28
·
125 sec
Testimony by Member of the Public on E-Bike Regulation
A member of the public strongly criticizes the DOT Commissioner's stance on e-bikes and expresses support for Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law). The speaker describes feeling unsafe due to e-bike traffic …
4:44:42
·
144 sec
Council member's stance on Intro 606 and Intro 1131
Council Member Brooks-Powers expresses support for the spirit of Intro 606 but has concerns about its implementation. She introduces Intro 1131 as an alternative approach to address the issue more …
4:47:08
·
62 sec
Personal experiences and commitment to addressing safety concerns
Council Member Brooks-Powers shares personal experiences with e-bike safety issues and emphasizes the council's commitment to addressing these concerns. - She recounts a personal incident of almost being run over …
4:48:11
·
29 sec
Testimony by Ricardo Pacheco, Resident of Jackson Heights, Queens
Ricardo Pacheco, a resident of Jackson Heights, Queens, testified in full support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law) and expressed concerns about e-vehicle violence in his neighborhood, particularly on 34th Avenue. …
4:48:44
·
90 sec
Testimony by David Tobias, Criminal Defense Attorney at Legal Aid Society
David Tobias, a criminal defense attorney at the Legal Aid Society, urged the council to vote against Intro 606. He argued that the bill would disproportionately affect people of color …
4:51:30
·
134 sec
Testimony by Lynn Glassner, Upper West Side Resident, on E-bike Regulation
Lynn Glassner, an Upper West Side resident, testified against the arguments made by bike lobby groups opposing Intro 606. She criticized their claims about motorized wheelchairs and their use of …
4:53:54
·
145 sec
Testimony by Gail Benjamin, Member of the Public, on E-bike Safety and Intro 606
Gail Benjamin testifies in support of Intro 606, sharing personal experiences and community concerns regarding e-bike safety. She emphasizes the need for accountability and behavior change among e-bike riders to …
4:56:32
·
138 sec
Testimony by Virginia Ryan, 12-year-old bicyclist, on e-bike safety concerns
Virginia Ryan, a 12-year-old bicyclist, testifies about the dangers of e-bikes for children and pedestrians in New York City. She shares personal experiences of near-accidents and advocates for stricter e-bike …
4:58:54
·
127 sec
Testimony by Ally Ryan, Virginia's Mom and Advocate
Ally Ryan, a mother and advocate, testified in support of legislation to register and insure e-bikes. She shared her experiences as a cyclist and expressed concerns about the lack of …
5:01:06
·
129 sec
Testimony by Cathy Conry, Member of the Public, on E-bike Safety Concerns
Cathy Conry, a 77-year-old long-time New York City resident, testifies about her fears and experiences regarding e-bike safety in the city. She recounts a recent near-miss incident with a delivery …
5:03:17
·
88 sec
Testimony by Unnamed 80-Year-Old Retired Actor on E-Bike Safety Concerns
An 80-year-old retired actor testified in support of Priscilla's law, expressing fears about the dangers posed by unlicensed and unidentifiable vehicles in New York City. The speaker emphasized the need …
5:06:14
·
104 sec
Testimony by Martin Hannon on E-bike Safety Concerns
Martin Hannon shares his personal experience of being injured by an e-bike while cycling on the FDR Drive bicycle path. He describes the challenges he faced in reporting the incident …
5:08:06
·
135 sec
Testimony by Marilyn Levin, Member of Public, on E-bike Accident Experience
Marilyn Levin's testimony, read by proxy Elizabeth Bailin, recounts a severe e-bike accident in Central Park that left Levin with significant injuries and ongoing medical issues. The testimony highlights the …
5:10:29
·
132 sec
Testimony by Jacqueline Savage on E-Vehicle Safety and Regulation
Jacqueline Savage, a 75-year-old member of the public, testifies in support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law) to regulate electric vehicles due to safety concerns for pedestrians. She expresses fear and …
5:12:43
·
88 sec
Testimony by Don Reid, Member of a Neighborhood Association Safety Committee, on E-bike Safety and Identification
Don Reid, a resident of Midtown East and member of a neighborhood association safety committee, testified in support of e-bike regulation, emphasizing the need for identification measures such as license …
5:14:18
·
137 sec
Testimony by Member of the Public on E-Bike Safety and Regulation
The speaker addresses the issue of e-bike safety and regulation, arguing against a knee-jerk response to implement licensing. They emphasize the need for a more thoughtful approach based on historical …
5:16:52
·
126 sec
Testimony by Michael Sutherland, Policy Analyst at Open Plans
Michael Sutherland, a policy analyst at Open Plans, testified against Intro 606 and in favor of Intro 1131 regarding e-bike regulation in NYC. He argued that Intro 606 would be …
5:23:11
·
124 sec
Testimony by Austin Ferd, Director of Safety and Zero Emission Fleet at a New York City logistics company
Austin Ferd, representing a New York City logistics company, testified against Intro 606, arguing that it is redundant, costly, and ineffective in addressing safety concerns related to e-bikes and other …
5:25:23
·
127 sec
Testimony by Patty Myers, Former Teacher and Volunteer, on E-bike Safety and Intro 606
Patty Myers, a former teacher and current volunteer, testified in support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law) to regulate e-bikes. She shared her personal experience of being hit by an e-biker, …
5:27:41
·
130 sec
Testimony by Leslie Clark from Greenwich Village on E-bike and Bicycle Safety Concerns
Leslie Clark, a resident of Greenwich Village, expresses skepticism about the effectiveness of bike infrastructure and education in improving cyclist behavior and safety. She shares personal experiences of cyclists disregarding …
5:29:54
·
126 sec
Testimony by Dr. Eric Rudesky, Cyclist and Accident Victim, on E-Bike Safety and Intro 606
Dr. Eric Rudesky, a lifelong New Yorker and avid cyclist, testified in support of Intro 606 based on his personal experience as a victim of a violent crash involving a …
5:32:03
·
127 sec
Testimony by Eleanor Wano on E-Bike Safety and Support for Intro 606
Eleanor Wano, a resident of Little Italy and Chinatown, testifies in support of Intro 606, sharing personal experiences with e-bike accidents and expressing concerns about e-bike safety in her neighborhood. …
5:34:20
·
124 sec
Testimony by Roxanne Delgado, Founder of Friends of Pelham Parkway
Roxanne Delgado, founder of Friends of Pelham Parkway, testified about the dangers of e-scooters being ridden on sidewalks in her community, emphasizing the need for safety measures and urging the …
5:39:11
·
126 sec
Testimony by Ronald Colangelo on E-Bike Safety and Regulation
Ronald Colangelo shares his concerns about e-bike safety in New York City, criticizing the lack of enforcement and regulation. He emphasizes the need for safety measures across all boroughs and …
5:41:24
·
125 sec
Testimony by Elizabeth Williams on E-Bike Legislation and Safety Studies
Elizabeth Williams provided testimony on e-bike legislation and safety studies, emphasizing the underreporting of pedestrian and bicycle injuries and discussing recent legislation in other states. She referenced studies by UC …
5:43:33
·
142 sec
Testimony by Maxine Deseder, Retired NYC Public School Teacher, on E-bike Regulation
Maxine Deseder, an 85-year-old retired NYC public school teacher, artist, and activist, expressed strong support for e-bike regulation, particularly licensing and registration requirements. She criticized the lack of accountability for …
5:46:02
·
126 sec
Testimony by Jason Fromwitz, Chair of the Transportation Committee at Manhattan Community Board 6
Jason Fromwitz, speaking as an individual, strongly opposes the proposed bill requiring e-bike registration, arguing it would disproportionately burden immigrant workers and deepen existing inequalities. He emphasizes the importance of …
5:48:16
·
118 sec
Testimony by Santis Cardillo, Community Activist
Santis Cardillo, a long-time cyclist and community activist, testified in support of Priscilla Lowe and advocated for the licensing, registration, and insurance of motorized bikes. He shared his personal experience …
5:50:18
·
145 sec
Council Member Holden questions Jason Fromwitz on e-bike solutions
Council Member Robert F. Holden engages in a heated exchange with Jason Fromwitz, Chair of the Transportation Committee for Manhattan Community Board 6, demanding concrete solutions to the e-bike safety …
5:52:44
·
98 sec
Debate over racism allegations in e-bike legislation
Council Member Holden and Jason Fromwitz engage in a heated exchange over allegations of racism in the proposed e-bike legislation. Holden strongly disagrees with Fromwitz's suggestion that the language used …
5:54:23
·
42 sec
Testimony by Patricia Hannam, Member of the Public, on E-Bike Safety and Accident Reporting
Patricia Hannam, an 80-year-old Brooklyn resident, shared her harrowing experience of being hit by two e-bike riders while crossing an intersection. She detailed her severe injuries, ongoing medical issues, and …
5:59:06
·
127 sec
Testimony by Meryl LaBorde, Member of the Public
Meryl LaBorde, a resident of Greenpoint, Brooklyn, testifies in opposition to Intro 606 and in support of Intro 1131. She argues that e-bikes are essential for her transportation needs and …
6:01:20
·
125 sec
Testimony by Stephen Baumann, Retired Research and Development Scientist, on E-bike Safety Data Analysis
Stephen Baumann, an 82-year-old retired research and development scientist, presented an analysis of 12 years of publicly available data from MV 104 reports, breaking down traffic injuries and fatalities by …
6:03:27
·
123 sec
Testimony by Alex Duncan on E-bike Safety and Transportation
Alex Duncan argues against the proposed e-bike regulations, emphasizing that e-bikes are a safer alternative to cars and an important transportation tool. He criticizes the opposition to e-bikes as a …
6:05:33
·
126 sec
Testimony by Unknown Park Slope Resident on Intro 606
A Park Slope resident testified against Intro 606, arguing that e-bike registration is ineffective, expensive, and potentially discriminatory. The speaker emphasized that other cities have repealed similar laws due to …
6:07:46
·
123 sec
Testimony by Florence Friedman, Member of the Public, on E-Bike Safety and Regulation
Florence Friedman recounts her personal experience of being hit by an e-bike on the sidewalk, resulting in a broken wrist. She advocates for stronger accountability measures for e-bike riders, comparing …
6:13:13
·
124 sec
Testimony by Bonnie Gerard, Member of the Public, on E-bike Safety and Regulation
Bonnie Gerard provides a personal account of being hit by an e-bike, resulting in significant injuries and medical expenses. She advocates for e-bike licensing, insurance, and adherence to traffic rules …
6:15:22
·
132 sec
Testimony by Carrie Michaels, Steering Committee Member of NYC EFSA
Carrie Michaels, a steering committee member of NYC EFSA, testified in support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law). She shared her personal experiences of being hit by e-bikes and expressed concerns …
6:17:54
·
129 sec
Testimony by Maria Danzilo, Executive Director of One City Rising
Maria Danzilo, Executive Director of One City Rising, testified in support of Intro 606, focusing on the financial interests behind e-bike delivery services and the need for regulation. She highlighted …
6:20:11
·
112 sec
Testimony by Peggy Yannis on E-bike Safety Concerns
Peggy Yannis, a lifelong New Yorker, expressed strong concerns about e-bike safety and criticized the arguments put forth by TransAlta and similar organizations. She shared personal experiences of near-misses with …
6:22:12
·
128 sec
Testimony by Bernadette Ferrara, President of Van Nest Neighborhood Alliance and Member of Bronx Community Board 11, on E-bike and Scooter Regulations
Bernadette Ferrara, representing multiple community organizations in the Bronx, expressed strong support for Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law). She criticized the implementation of the e-bike and scooter pilot program in her …
6:24:31
·
125 sec
Testimony by Joan Marie Zimmerman, Opera Singer and Voice Teacher, on E-bike Safety
Joan Marie Zimmerman, an opera singer and voice teacher, shared her personal experience of being hit by an e-bike while cycling, resulting in severe injuries. She expressed support for stricter …
6:28:17
·
115 sec
Testimony by Member of Public on E-bike Safety and Priscilla's Law
A member of the public testified in support of Priscilla's Law and Intro 606, expressing concerns about the safety hazards posed by e-bikes to pedestrians. The speaker emphasized the need …
6:30:12
·
123 sec
Testimony by Member of the Public on E-bike Safety and Personal Experience
A member of the public shared their experience as a cyclist and advocate for human-powered transportation, followed by a personal account of being hit by an e-bike. The speaker suffered …
6:32:25
·
126 sec
Testimony by Kathy Park Price, Brooklyn Organizer at Transportation Alternatives
Kathy Park Price, speaking in her personal capacity, strongly opposes Intro 606 and supports Intro 1131. She argues that the city should focus on reducing crashes caused by cars and …
6:34:32
·
124 sec
Testimony by Michelle Campo on E-bike Safety and Intro 606
Michelle Campo, a 3rd generation New Yorker, testified in support of Intro 606 (Priscilla's Law) and shared a personal story about her husband, a professional cyclist, who was hit by …
6:36:43
·
124 sec
Testimony by Brian Howald, Member of the Transportation Committee of Brooklyn Community Board 2
Brian Howald, a member of Brooklyn Community Board 2's transportation committee, testifies in opposition to Intro 606, which would require licensing and registration of e-bikes. He argues that the bill …
6:38:55
·
124 sec
Testimony by Laura Shepherd, Queens Organizer at Transportation Alternatives and Chair of Environment, Parks, and Recreation Committee at Queens Community Board 2
Laura Shepherd, representing Transportation Alternatives and Queens Community Board 2, testified in opposition to Intro 606 and in support of Intro 1131. She emphasized the need for better infrastructure to …
6:42:11
·
127 sec
Testimony by Solomon Blecher, Member of Manhattan Community Board 3, on E-bike Regulation
Solomon Blecher, a teenage member of Manhattan Community Board 3, testifies in opposition to Intro 606, which would require e-bike licensing. He argues that while streets need to be safer, …
6:44:28
·
108 sec
Testimony by Kevin Siegel, Civil Rights Attorney, on Intro 606
Kevin Siegel, a civil rights attorney and e-bike rider, testifies in opposition to Intro 606, arguing that it would decrease e-bike usage and push people towards using cars. He expresses …
6:46:18
·
120 sec
Testimony by Adrian Morcecho on E-bike Safety and Regulation
Adrian Morcecho, a member of the public, presents testimony on e-bike safety and regulation, opposing Intro 606 while suggesting alternative solutions. Morcecho shares personal experience with bike accidents and proposes …
6:57:07
·
123 sec
Testimony by Alita Camp, Member of Manhattan Community Board 8, on E-bike Registration and Safety
Alita Camp, speaking individually as a member of Manhattan Community Board 8, strongly advocates for the registration of e-bikes to improve safety and accountability for pedestrians and e-bike riders. She …
6:59:20
·
105 sec
Testimony by Alex Morano, Resident of Brooklyn, on Intro 606
Alex Morano, a lifelong New Yorker and Brooklyn resident, testifies against Intro 606, arguing that while street safety is important, the proposed bill won't effectively address the issue. He emphasizes …
7:01:49
·
118 sec
Testimony by Brian Holbrook, Public Defender, on Intro 606
Brian Holbrook testifies in opposition to Intro 606, arguing that upgrading traffic infrastructure and creating more space for pedestrians and cyclists is more important for safety than the proposed legislation. …
7:04:06
·
108 sec
Testimony by Karl Wojciechowski on E-bike Regulations
Karl Wojciechowski, a resident of Riverdale in the Northwest Bronx, testified against Intro 606 and in favor of Intro 1131 regarding e-bike regulations. He emphasized the importance of e-bikes for …
7:06:08
·
82 sec
Testimony by Chris Ryan, Cyclist and Commercial Driver, on E-bike Regulations
Chris Ryan, a cyclist, dad, vehicle owner, and commercial driver, testified in support of Intro 606, emphasizing the need for accountability in e-bike usage. He argued that license plates for …
7:08:18
·
126 sec
Testimony by Ellen Sandals on E-Vehicle Regulation
Ellen Sandals, a long-time New York City resident, testifies in support of Intro 606 and stricter regulation of e-vehicles. She expresses concern about the deterioration of quality of life due …
7:10:55
·
113 sec
Testimony by Emily Jacobi, Manhattan organizer at Transportation Alternatives, on Intro 606
Emily Jacobi, speaking as a New Yorker and Brooklyn resident, strongly opposes Intro 606, arguing that it fails to address the root causes of street safety issues. She emphasizes the …
7:13:01
·
125 sec
Testimony by Janine Pantchakberry on Support for Intro 606 and E-Vehicle Registration
Janine Pantchakberry testified in support of Intro 606, Priscilla's Law, and e-vehicle registration and licensing. She shared her personal experience of being hit by an e-scooter while biking, resulting in …
7:15:14
·
122 sec
Testimony by John Noble on E-bike Legislation
John Noble, a Manhattan resident, testified in support of Intro 1131 and against Intro 606 regarding e-bike legislation in New York City. He emphasized the need for safer street design …
7:18:02
·
112 sec
Testimony by Ken Coughlin, Member of Manhattan Community Board 7
Ken Coughlin, a member of Manhattan Community Board 7, testifies in strong opposition to Intro 606, arguing that it's an overly simplistic solution to the complex issue of street safety. …
7:20:08
·
99 sec
Testimony by Kenneth Lay, Brooklyn Resident
Kenneth Lay, a Brooklyn resident and daily cyclist, testified about the benefits of biking in New York City and shared his views on improving street safety. He emphasized the need …
7:21:56
·
118 sec
Testimony by Elaine Karas, Executive Director of Purple Circle Early Childhood Program on E-bike Safety and Support for Intro 606
Elaine Karas, representing Purple Circle Early Childhood Program, testified in support of Intro 606 and expressed concerns about the safety issues posed by e-bikes and fast bicycles in New York …
7:24:24
·
142 sec
Testimony by Mai Schultz on Intro 606 and Street Safety
Mai Schultz strongly opposes Intro 606, arguing that it is not an effective solution to improve street safety. She emphasizes that the $19 million cost of the bill could be …
7:28:01
·
128 sec
Testimony by Matt Moore, Policy Counsel for People For Bikes
Matt Moore, Policy Counsel for People For Bikes, testified on behalf of the national advocacy group for cyclists and the US bicycle industry. He expressed support for Introduction 1131 and …
7:30:18
·
125 sec
Testimony by Matt Dennis from Flatbush on Intro 606 and Street Safety
Matt Dennis, a resident of Flatbush, strongly opposes Intro 606, arguing that it fails to improve safety and creates new problems, particularly regarding selective enforcement. He urges the City Council …
7:32:33
·
125 sec
Testimony by McLean Cozine on Intro 606 and Street Safety
McLean Cozine testifies against Intro 606, arguing that it will not effectively address street safety concerns and instead create bureaucratic hurdles. He supports Intro 1131 and emphasizes the need for …
7:34:46
·
126 sec
Testimony by Miriam Fischer, Transportation and Disability Rights Activist, on Intro 606
Miriam Fischer, a transportation and disability rights activist, testified in support of Intro 606, which would require licensing and registration of e-bikes. She emphasized the need for accountability in bike-related …
7:38:05
·
127 sec
Testimony by Nathaniel Bachelis on Opposition to Intro 606
Nathaniel Bachelis, a resident of Brooklyn, testifies against Intro 606, expressing concern over the proposed e-bike regulations. He shares his personal experience as an e-bike user and argues that e-bikes …
7:40:23
·
124 sec
Testimony by Nora McCauley on E-Bike Safety and Regulation
Nora McCauley, a resident of Brooklyn and employee at an electric bike store, testified about the varied uses of e-bikes and concerns about proposed regulations. She emphasized that while safety …
7:43:22
·
134 sec
Testimony by Nabil Ahmed Katri, Small Business Owner of E-Bike Rental Business
Nabil Ahmed Katri, a small business owner of an e-bike rental business, testified against Intro 606 and the proposed licensing requirements for e-bikes. He emphasized the distinction between e-bikes and …
7:45:55
·
92 sec
Testimony by Patrick DiRoma on Proposed E-bike Legislation
Patrick DiRoma testified in opposition to Intro 606 and in support of Intro 1131, highlighting perceived inconsistencies and hypocrisies in arguments made by supporters of Intro 606 during the hearing. …
7:48:18
·
109 sec
Testimony by Richard Robbins, Member of the Public, on Intro 606
Richard Robbins testifies against Intro 606, arguing that license plates for e-bikes are not an effective solution to address safety concerns. He outlines several flaws in the proposed legislation, including …
7:50:21
·
127 sec
Testimony by Ryan Barthel on E-bike and Micromobility Regulation
Ryan Barthel testifies against Intro 606, arguing that the proposed e-bike and micromobility device registration would be costly, unnecessary, and potentially harmful to vulnerable New Yorkers. He highlights concerns about …
7:53:24
·
121 sec
Testimony by Robert Price, Parent and E-bike User, on Intro 606
Robert Price, a parent and e-bike user, testifies in opposition to Intro 606, arguing that e-bikes are an excellent mode of transportation in New York City despite challenges posed by …
7:55:42
·
73 sec
Testimony by Samir Lavingia, Member of the Public
Samir Lavingia, a resident of Midtown Manhattan, expresses opposition to Intro 606, arguing that requiring licenses for e-bikes would lead to unintended consequences and not improve safety. He advocates for …
7:57:08
·
128 sec
Testimony by Eureka Anderson on Intro 606 and Intro 1131
Eureka Anderson testified in opposition to Intro 606 and in support of Intro 1131. She argued that Intro 606 would unfairly penalize sustainable transportation choices and distract from real safety …
7:59:55
·
113 sec
Testimony by Valerie Mason, Chair of Manhattan Community Board 8, on E-bike Regulation
Valerie Mason, Chair of Manhattan Community Board 8, expressed support for Intro 606 and emphasized the urgent need for e-bike regulation in New York City. She highlighted the community's concerns …
8:02:11
·
125 sec
Clarification on the timeline of Intro 1131
Council Member Brooks-Powers clarifies that Intro 1131 was not created in just a few days, contrary to what was previously stated. She explains that she had been waiting for the …
8:04:16
·
16 sec
Testimony by Vishnu Reddy from Sunnyside, Queens on E-bike Legislation
Vishnu Reddy, a resident of Sunnyside, Queens, testified against Intro 606, expressing strong disapproval of the proposed e-bike registration legislation. He argued that the bill is poorly thought out, impossible …
8:04:39
·
114 sec
Testimony by Andre Braga on Opposition to Intro 606
Andre Braga testifies in opposition to Intro 606, expressing concerns about its impact on e-bike users, particularly delivery workers and those who rely on e-bikes for transportation. He argues that …
8:06:42
·
44 sec
Testimony by Hayden Brockett, Upper West Side Resident, on E-bike Legislation
Hayden Brockett, an Upper West Side resident, testified in opposition to Intro 606, arguing that it would be a step backward for public safety. He emphasized that motor vehicles pose …
8:08:00
·
127 sec
Testimony by Kevin Lechera, Green Point Resident, on Intro 606
Kevin Lechera, a Green Point resident, strongly opposes Intro 606, arguing that it will not address the root causes of street safety issues in New York City. He acknowledges the …
8:10:18
·
75 sec
Testimony by Scott Weinstein on Intro 606 and E-bike Safety
Scott Weinstein, a resident of Crown Heights, testified against Intro 606, arguing that while he understands the motivation for the bill as a vulnerable road user, he believes it will …
8:11:43
·
128 sec
Testimony by Michele Birnbaum, Community Organizer
Michele Birnbaum, a lifelong New Yorker and community organizer, expresses strong support for Intro 606, emphasizing the importance of accountability, responsibility, and liability in the legal system. She argues that …
8:14:43
·
126 sec
Testimony by Andrew Stern on E-bike Regulations
Andrew Stern testifies in opposition to Intro 606, expressing concerns about potential scrutiny of cyclists by the NYPD and the impact on e-bike users. He advocates for addressing issues with …
8:17:00
·
92 sec
Testimony by Ryan Chrisman, Crown Heights resident, on Intro 606
Ryan Chrisman, a Crown Heights resident, testifies in opposition to Intro 606, arguing that it would hamper the ability of parents to use e-bikes for transporting their children to school …
8:18:43
·
99 sec
