The citymeetings.nyc logo showing a pigeon at a podium with a microphone.

citymeetings.nyc

Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

Q&A

Council Member Holden discusses legality of proposed legislation and questions panelists about e-vehicle incidents

4:30:43

·

143 sec

Council Member Robert F. Holden addresses the legality of the proposed legislation, asserting that the city's legislative team confirmed its legality. He then questions panelists who were struck by e-vehicles about their experiences with reporting incidents and seeking accountability.

  • Holden emphasizes that the proposed bill (Intro 606) is legal and can be implemented
  • He questions victims about police reports and outcomes of their incidents
  • The discussion reveals a lack of accountability and follow-up in e-vehicle accident cases
Robert F. Holden
4:30:43
Just on that subject, our legislative team said it is legal.
4:30:48
They're the ones who came up with the idea.
4:30:50
So I just proposed what can we do about it.
4:30:53
Our legislative team said, sure, you can do this.
4:30:55
Because we do this in other other areas, in the city.
4:30:59
And DOT does it.
4:31:00
So this could be done.
4:31:02
It's, it's perfectly legal.
4:31:03
However, I just want to ask the panel, especially the the panelists that were struck, by e vehicles.
4:31:13
Were was a police report issued?
4:31:15
Did you get any, responsible party?
4:31:19
Did did you know who hit who hit you?
4:31:23
And did you get any satisfaction at all other than your injuries that and suffering that you experienced?
Carol Wilson
4:31:33
Since I was hit twice, they found neither one of the riders.
Robert F. Holden
4:31:37
So nobody they didn't find anybody?
4:31:39
No.
4:31:39
I'd like Eudonis Rodriguez, the commissioner, to hear that because he has no solutions.
4:31:44
Anybody else?
4:31:45
Did did you get any, yes?
Sonya Poe
4:31:49
They know who the guy is because he badly crashed too.
Robert F. Holden
4:31:53
Okay.
Sonya Poe
4:31:53
But the helmet saved him.
4:31:55
And I spent whole night in the emergency room watching at him.
4:32:01
Whole night.
4:32:01
They didn't separate
Robert F. Holden
4:32:03
us.
4:32:04
Unbelievable.
4:32:06
Anybody else?
Scott Poole
4:32:07
Just to just to build on that, he was identified and there was a police report.
4:32:13
Nothing has happened since
Robert F. Holden
4:32:14
No penalties.
Scott Poole
4:32:15
Well, not nothing that we've
Robert F. Holden
4:32:17
heard.
4:32:18
But you would think that the police would have told you this person was charged with a crime.
Scott Poole
4:32:22
They they actually we complained more formally about 2 weeks ago, and they just informed us or they just called us to ask how we feel.
4:32:33
That was that was
Sonya Poe
4:32:34
that was yesterday after I talked in one of the community boards and they called the inspector.
4:32:41
Yeah.
4:32:41
So after 6 months, he called me to tell me that he's going to close the case.
Robert F. Holden
4:32:45
Yeah.
4:32:46
So this is
Sonya Poe
4:32:46
And that he's not that he he he's not a vehicle.
4:32:49
He's a a scooter.
Robert F. Holden
4:32:52
Right.
4:32:52
And so this is what my bill will do.
4:32:55
It'll add accountability.
4:32:57
And again, the victims would have some recourse.
4:32:59
Right now, the victims have no recourse, and that's the heartbreaking issue here.
4:33:05
Thank you.
4:33:06
Thank you, chair.
Selvena N. Brooks-Powers
4:33:06
Thank you.
Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.