The citymeetings.nyc logo showing a pigeon at a podium with a microphone.

citymeetings.nyc

Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

Q&A

Rationale for R7-1 zoning choice and comparison with R7A

2:48:50

ยท

131 sec

The project team explains the reasoning behind choosing R7-1 zoning over R7A, emphasizing the design flexibility it offers. They clarify the differences between the two zoning options in terms of building envelope controls and setbacks.

  • R7-1 was chosen for its design flexibility compared to R7A
  • R7-1 allows for more varied building massing and setbacks
  • The team explains how R7-1 permits a 4-story street wall, which wouldn't be possible with R7A
Shahana K. Hanif
2:48:50
It's imperative that we recognize that we need, units that are 40%, 30%, 20%, 10% AMI, particularly the political climate we're entering and the already existing affordability crisis.
2:49:12
Why was the R71?
2:49:13
And I know, Chair Riley asked a version of this question.
2:49:17
Could you just again summarize why r 71 was chosen, and have you considered other, options?
2:49:27
And I know r 7a was considered, but Summer can you provide just a quick summary?
Nora Martins
2:49:34
Sure.
2:49:34
Sure.
2:49:35
So yes, like, as I mentioned, r7a was considered.
2:49:39
And again, we decided to proceed with the r7.1 really due to the design flexibility that it offered to the project.
Shahana K. Hanif
2:49:48
And can you just, for the average person, what is design Sure.
Nora Martins
2:49:54
Yeah.
2:49:54
No.
2:49:55
Sure.
Shahana K. Hanif
2:49:55
I'll Tell us.
Nora Martins
2:49:55
Point and maybe In Elliot can can jump in as our expert here.
2:49:59
But basically, there are overall height limitations in zoning, but there are also other building envelope controls, particularly in contextual districts, which are the districts that end in a letter, like r seven a instead of r seven one, that provide for certain minimum street wall, minimummaximum street wall heights, setbacks, and other ways the building is actually masked other than the total overall height.
2:50:26
So the R71, as a non contextual district, front facade of both buildings to 4 stories, which would not be possible in the r seven a district.
Shahana K. Hanif
2:50:40
The difference between the r seven one, r seven a, is basically the the setbacks that would be possible with r71, whereas with r7a, no setbacks, and it would be a bulkier
Nora Martins
2:50:57
building.
2:50:57
Right.
2:50:58
There would still be some setbacks, but it would be less flexibility.
2:51:01
Less flexibility
Shahana K. Hanif
2:51:01
with the R7A.
Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.