Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.
New York City Council
Committee on Public Housing
Feb 26, 2025
·
10:00 AM
5 hr 40 min
PRO The fastest way to analyze public meetings in NYC & NY State. Learn more.
Summary
A hearing on transparency issues at the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA), particularly focusing on the RAD/PACT program for converting public housing to private management.
Discussions centered on:
- Resident engagement processes
- Concerns about evictions and displacement
- Poor living conditions
- Lack of repairs
- The need for greater accountability in NYCHA's operations
The council pressed for more transparency on conversion decisions, contracts, and impacts on residents. Many residents called for a moratorium on RAD/PACT conversions pending further study and more robust resident approval processes.
Features testimony from NYCHA officials, the NYC Comptroller's office, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council member Chris Banks opens the public housing committee hearing
Councilman Chris Banks calls the public housing committee hearing to order and introduces himself as the chair. He welcomes fellow council member Justin Brannan, members of the public, and representatives …
0:00:51
·
37 sec
Councilman Banks emphasizes the critical need for transparency in NYCHA operations
Councilman Banks stresses the importance of transparency for all city agencies, particularly for NYCHA due to its dual role as a public authority and landlord. He emphasizes that NYCHA is …
0:01:30
·
74 sec
Transparency issues in NYCHA housing conditions and maintenance practices
Councilman Banks highlights significant transparency problems in NYCHA's handling of housing conditions and maintenance. He points out that residents struggle to access clear and up-to-date information about repairs, violations, and …
0:02:44
·
49 sec
Councilman Banks addresses transparency concerns in the PACT program
Councilman Banks expresses major concerns about the lack of transparency in NYCHA's Permanent Affordability Commitment Together (PACT) program. He highlights that NYCHA has not provided clear answers about how developments …
0:03:34
·
102 sec
Council member calls for increased transparency and resident-informed decision-making
Councilman Banks strongly urges NYCHA to provide timely and accurate information to residents about decisions and operations affecting their homes. He emphasizes that this transparency is crucial to break harmful …
0:05:15
·
47 sec
Acknowledgments and outline of hearing structure
Councilman Banks concludes his opening remarks by thanking his staff and the public housing committee staff for their work in organizing the hearing. He then outlines the structure of the …
0:06:03
·
25 sec
Testimony by Celines Miranda, Representative of Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea Tenants Against Demolition
Celines Miranda, representing Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea Tenants Against Demolition, testifies against the proposed demolition of NYCHA buildings in Chelsea. She argues that the demolition proposal is based on false narratives …
0:08:06
·
4 min
Testimony by Marquis Jenkins, Member of the Public
Marquis Jenkins testifies about transparency issues in NYCHA's RAD/PACT program, emphasizing the need for resident involvement in decision-making and better evaluation of the program's impacts. He criticizes the lack of …
0:13:03
·
5 min
Testimony by Dr. Keisha Crawford, Resident Management Corporation Chair of Stuyvesant Gardens
Dr. Keisha Crawford, speaking as the Resident Management Corporation Chair of Stuyvesant Gardens, detailed years of neglect, poor living conditions, and recent intimidation tactics used to force residents into conversion. …
0:18:51
·
7 min
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams addresses NYCHA issues and RAD/PACT concerns
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams provides a comprehensive statement on NYCHA's challenges, including repair backlogs, funding needs, and concerns about the RAD/PACT program. He emphasizes the importance of transparency, resident input, …
0:26:55
·
4 min
Testimony by Eve, Member of the Public from Penn-Wortman Houses
Eve, a resident of Penn-Wortman Houses, provides passionate testimony criticizing NYCHA and the RAD/PACT program for lack of transparency, coercion, and poor management. She describes personal experiences of harassment, legal …
0:32:16
·
6 min
Testimony by Teresa Scott, Leader of Save Section 9
Teresa Scott, a leader of Save Section 9, passionately advocated for the protection of public housing and against RAD/PACT conversions. She emphasized the lack of transparency in the conversion process, …
0:39:17
·
5 min
NYCHA's commitment to transparency and accountability
Arvind Sohoni, Executive Vice President for Strategy Innovation at NYCHA, introduces the agency's commitment to transparency and accountability. He acknowledges past mistakes and outlines the reforms implemented over the last …
0:47:51
·
63 sec
NYCHA's public information resources and data transparency
Sohoni details the various public information resources and data transparency initiatives implemented by NYCHA. He emphasizes the accessibility of information through their website and other platforms. - Highlights the availability …
0:48:55
·
78 sec
Digital tools for NYCHA resident engagement
Sohoni outlines the digital tools NYCHA has implemented to enhance resident engagement and provide easy access to information and services. - Describes the My NYCHA app for creating work orders, …
0:50:14
·
23 sec
PACT program transparency and resident involvement
Sohoni explains how transparency and resident engagement are fundamental to the success of the PACT program, detailing the various ways residents are involved in the process. - Emphasizes resident involvement …
0:50:38
·
87 sec
Eviction protections and policies in the PACT program
Sohoni addresses concerns about evictions in PACT sites, detailing the protections and policies in place to prevent displacement and keep residents housed. - Explains that all authorized residents are offered …
0:52:06
·
81 sec
Conclusion on NYCHA's commitment to transparency and accountability
Sohoni concludes by reaffirming NYCHA's commitment to transparency and accountability, emphasizing their importance in serving residents and collaborating with partners. - Restates that transparency and accountability are core values driving …
0:53:26
·
17 sec
NYCHA's recertification process and options for residents
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about the recertification process for Section 8 participants. Brian Honan from NYCHA explains the various methods available for recertification, including online, kiosk, and …
0:53:45
·
112 sec
Quality of repair work by contractors and NYCHA's verification process
Council Member Banks questions NYCHA officials about residents' concerns regarding the quality of repair work done by contractors and NYCHA's process for verifying this work. - NYCHA acknowledges longstanding issues …
0:55:38
·
178 sec
Implementation of resident rating system for vendors
Council Member Banks presses NYCHA officials on their plans to implement a recommendation allowing residents to rate vendors and view other residents' reviews. - NYCHA admits there is no immediate …
0:58:36
·
118 sec
NYCHA's capital project management and quality control processes
Shaan Mavani, NYCHA's Chief Asset and Capital Management Officer, testifies about the agency's processes for managing and ensuring quality in capital projects. - Daily monitoring of work quality is conducted …
1:00:34
·
151 sec
Work order systems in PACT-converted developments
Council Member Banks questions NYCHA officials about the functionality of work order systems in developments converted to PACT (Permanent Affordability Commitment Together). - NYCHA officials assert that PACT partners have …
1:03:05
·
4 min
Document transfer and work order tracking during PACT conversions
Council Member Banks scrutinizes NYCHA's process for transferring documents and work orders during PACT conversions. - NYCHA officials claim that all relevant documents are transferred to the new property manager …
1:07:36
·
122 sec
Feedback on NYCHA's capital projects and needs tracker
Council Member Banks inquires about resident feedback on NYCHA's new capital projects and needs tracker launched in 2024. - NYCHA official Shaan Mavani explains that the current tracker is version …
1:09:38
·
104 sec
NYCHA complaint and service request systems
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about NYCHA's complaint and service request systems, including methods for filing complaints, wait times for the customer contact center, and performance tracking. - Residents can …
1:11:22
·
88 sec
Complaint procedures for PACT developments
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about complaint procedures for residents in PACT (Permanent Affordability Commitment Together) developments. - Residents of PACT developments should report repair issues to their management office …
1:12:51
·
90 sec
Use of 311 system for NYCHA complaints
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about the use of the 311 system for NYCHA complaints, as allowed by Local Law 01/1927 of 2021. - NYCHA officials are not directly aware …
1:14:23
·
48 sec
NYCHA customer contact center walk-in centers
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about NYCHA's customer contact center walk-in centers and their policies. - NYCHA currently operates two walk-in centers: one on Atlantic Avenue and one on Water …
1:15:12
·
82 sec
Transparency of code violations information
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about NYCHA's transparency regarding code violations information. - NYCHA is working with HPD to make code violations information publicly available on both agencies' websites. - …
1:16:34
·
175 sec
NYCHA's preparation for potential federal funding cuts
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about NYCHA's preparation for potential federal funding cuts and communication with residents. - NYCHA is closely monitoring the situation in Washington D.C. on a daily …
1:19:29
·
98 sec
State funding for rehabilitation of vacant NYCHA units
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about the governor's budget proposal for rehabilitating vacant NYCHA units. - The governor's 2026 executive budget proposal includes $25 million for rehabilitating vacant NYCHA units …
1:21:07
·
151 sec
NYCHA's selection process for PACT/RAD conversions
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about the selection process for PACT/RAD conversions. Brian Honan explains that developments are chosen based on tenant association opinions, property conditions, and the …
1:23:39
·
105 sec
Debate over resident engagement and voting rights in PACT/RAD conversions
Council Member Chris Banks presses NYCHA officials on the extent of resident engagement and voting rights in PACT/RAD conversions. NYCHA officials describe their engagement process but acknowledge there's no formal …
1:25:24
·
5 min
Addressing misinformation about the PACT program
NYCHA officials discuss common misconceptions about the PACT program, while Council Member Chris Banks challenges their characterization of resident concerns as 'misinformation.' - NYCHA claims residents often mistakenly believe they …
1:30:58
·
85 sec
Concerns over income recertification processes in converted properties
Council Member Chris Banks raises concerns about residents in converted properties having to complete multiple income recertifications. NYCHA officials acknowledge issues in some developments but assert they are limited. - …
1:32:23
·
156 sec
NYCHA's authority to initiate PACT conversions without resident votes
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA's authority to initiate PACT conversions without resident votes. NYCHA officials emphasize their engagement process but maintain final decision-making authority. - NYCHA acknowledges early PACT …
1:35:00
·
4 min
Developer selection process for PACT conversions
NYCHA officials explain the process for selecting developers for PACT conversions, emphasizing resident involvement in the selection process. - NYCHA conducts an annual request for qualifications to pre-qualify contractors, developers, …
1:39:08
·
48 sec
Composition and role of resident review committees in PACT conversions
NYCHA officials detail the composition and role of resident review committees in the PACT conversion process, responding to questions from Council Member Chris Banks. - Committees typically consist of the …
1:39:56
·
117 sec
Transparency and public access to PACT selection process documentation
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about the transparency of the PACT selection process and public access to related documentation. - NYCHA maintains documentation of scorecards but does not …
1:41:53
·
92 sec
Discussion on resident agreement process for RAD/PACT conversions
Council Member Darlene Mealy questions NYCHA officials about the process of resident agreement for RAD/PACT conversions. Simon Kawitzky from NYCHA explains that they seek support from resident leaders at the …
1:43:28
·
48 sec
Inquiry into developments not participating in RAD/PACT and Fairstead case
Council Member Mealy presses NYCHA officials for specific numbers on developments not participating in RAD/PACT, particularly focusing on 14 Fairstead developments in her district. NYCHA's Simon Kawitzky struggles to provide …
1:44:16
·
71 sec
Addressing allegations of harassment and forced document signing
Council Member Mealy confronts NYCHA officials about allegations of harassment and forced signing of documents in RAD/PACT conversions. NYCHA's Simon Kawitzky states they want to know about specific instances of …
1:45:27
·
3 min
Discussion of maintenance issues in RAD/PACT properties
Council Member Mealy raises concerns about ongoing maintenance issues in RAD/PACT converted properties, particularly focusing on heating problems at Park Rock and Reed. NYCHA officials struggle to provide specific responses …
1:49:03
·
3 min
NYCHA's approach to handling controversies and resident opposition
Council members press NYCHA officials on their plan to address controversies and resident opposition to RAD/PACT conversions. NYCHA representatives struggle to provide clear answers, leading to increased frustration from council …
1:52:33
·
98 sec
Addressing allegations at Stuyvesant Gardens One
NYCHA officials attempt to address specific allegations of harassment and opposition at Stuyvesant Gardens One. Council members express frustration with NYCHA's responses and perceived lack of action. - Discussion of …
1:54:11
·
117 sec
Timing of resident engagement and handling of petitions in RAD/PACT process
Council members question NYCHA officials about the timing of resident engagement in the RAD/PACT process and the handling of resident petitions opposing conversions. NYCHA representatives face criticism for perceived lack …
1:56:08
·
150 sec
NYCHA's plan for addressing harassment and data on resident support
Council members demand NYCHA's plan for addressing alleged harassment by management companies and request data on resident support/opposition to RAD/PACT. NYCHA officials struggle to provide satisfactory answers, leading to increased …
1:58:38
·
116 sec
NYCHA's approach to resident consensus for PACT conversions
Council Member Banks questions NYCHA representatives about the level of resident consensus required before proceeding with PACT conversions. NYCHA's Jonathan Gouveia states there is no specific target, but they work …
2:00:51
·
63 sec
Debate over implementing formal voting processes for RAD/PACT conversions
Council Member Banks presses NYCHA representatives about implementing formal voting processes for RAD/PACT conversions across developments. NYCHA's responses indicate reluctance to commit to universal voting. - Discussion of voting process …
2:01:54
·
5 min
Debate over NYCHA's resident engagement practices and obligations
A tense exchange occurs between Council Member Banks and NYCHA representatives about the agency's obligations for resident engagement in the PACT conversion process. The debate highlights fundamental disagreements about the …
2:07:11
·
5 min
Statistics on PACT conversions and affected residents
Council Member Banks asks for specific data on PACT conversions and the number of affected residents. NYCHA's Jonathan Gouveia provides the following statistics: - 24,584 apartments have been converted to …
2:12:48
·
76 sec
Comparison of resident rights under PACT and conventional public housing
Council Member Banks questions NYCHA representatives about whether residents maintain the same rights under PACT as they had under conventional public housing. NYCHA affirms that rights are maintained. - NYCHA …
2:14:06
·
38 sec
Council member inquires about negative impacts of RAD/PACT conversions
Council Member Chris Banks asks NYCHA about any negative impacts residents have experienced before, during, or after their developments have been converted to PACT. Jonathan Gouveia from NYCHA acknowledges that …
2:14:44
·
37 sec
NYCHA's process for monitoring renovation quality in converted developments
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA about their monitoring process for developments undergoing rehab, especially in light of resident complaints about poor quality materials. Jonathan Gouveia explains NYCHA's oversight process, …
2:15:21
·
98 sec
Resident involvement in selecting materials for PACT renovations
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about the process of selecting materials for renovations and whether tenants are involved. Jonathan Gouveia explains that in recent projects, NYCHA has improved resident involvement …
2:16:59
·
50 sec
Debate over use of flat paint in PACT renovations
Council Members Chris Banks and Darlene Mealy question NYCHA representatives about the use of flat paint in renovated apartments, expressing concern about its durability and appropriateness. - Council members argue …
2:17:49
·
64 sec
Inquiry into minority contracting in RAD/PACT renovations
Council Member Darlene Mealy questions NYCHA representatives about the extent of minority contracting in RAD/PACT renovations. The discussion reveals a lack of immediate, specific information from NYCHA on this topic. …
2:18:55
·
24 sec
Debate over quality of renovations: Bathtub replacements vs. refitting
Council Member Darlene Mealy confronts NYCHA representatives about the quality of renovations, particularly focusing on the practice of refitting bathtubs instead of replacing them with new ones in some developments. …
2:19:19
·
3 min
Concerns raised about Stuyvesant Town's future without RAD/PACT conversion
Council Member Darlene Mealy questions NYCHA representatives about a previous statement suggesting that Stuyvesant Town might not have a future if it doesn't undergo RAD/PACT conversion. - A statement was …
2:22:35
·
149 sec
Discussion on potential foreclosure in RAD/PACT properties and NYCHA's role
Council Member Darlene Mealy inquires about the possibility of foreclosure in RAD/PACT properties and NYCHA's role in such scenarios. The discussion reveals the complexities of the RAD/PACT conversion process and …
2:25:04
·
100 sec
Detailed explanation of the vetting process for RAD/PACT conversion projects
Jonathan Gouveia provides a comprehensive explanation of the process for vetting and approving RAD/PACT conversion projects, emphasizing the multiple layers of review and approval involved. - The process involves a …
2:26:45
·
92 sec
Discussion on resident opposition to RAD/PACT conversions and ability to opt out
Council Member Darlene Mealy questions NYCHA representatives about scenarios where residents or developments oppose RAD/PACT conversions or reject specific developers. The discussion reveals the complexities of the conversion process and …
2:28:18
·
86 sec
RAD/PACT management oversight and resident feedback process
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about the process for addressing resident dissatisfaction with management companies in RAD/PACT developments. Jonathan Gouveia explains NYCHA's oversight mechanisms and cites examples of …
2:29:44
·
159 sec
Eviction rates in RAD/PACT developments compared to traditional public housing
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about eviction rates in RAD/PACT developments compared to conventional public housing. NYCHA officials respond to concerns and discuss resident rights related to eviction prevention. - …
2:32:23
·
101 sec
Anti-displacement measures in the RAD/PACT program
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about anti-displacement language in the RAD/PACT program. NYCHA officials briefly explain the existence of housing stability and retention guidelines. - NYCHA confirms the existence of …
2:34:04
·
19 sec
NYCHA's response to NYC Comptroller's audit on RAD/PACT eviction rates
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about the findings of a December 2024 NYC Comptroller's audit on eviction rates in RAD/PACT developments. NYCHA officials disagree with some of the …
2:34:24
·
105 sec
NYCHA's role in RAD/PACT eviction processes
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about NYCHA's role in eviction processes within RAD/PACT developments. NYCHA officials explain the division of responsibilities between property managers and NYCHA. - Property managers are …
2:36:13
·
125 sec
Transfer policies and processes in RAD/PACT developments
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about transfer policies and processes in RAD/PACT developments. The discussion covers various aspects of transfers, including resident concerns, communication, and current limitations. - …
2:38:19
·
6 min
Discussion on Housing Choice Vouchers for NYCHA residents
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about the effectiveness of Housing Choice Vouchers as an alternative for residents who can't remain in NYCHA housing. The discussion highlights concerns about …
2:45:06
·
88 sec
NYCHA's policy on publishing PACT partner transaction documents
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about their policy of not publishing documents governing transactions with PACT partners. The discussion reveals that NYCHA continues to keep specific deal documents …
2:46:33
·
66 sec
NYCHA's rationale for withholding PACT transaction documents
Council Member Chris Banks presses NYCHA officials on their reasons for not making PACT transaction documents public. NYCHA maintains that withholding these documents is necessary to preserve their negotiating power …
2:47:39
·
91 sec
Debate on transparency and resident access to PACT transaction documents
Council Member Chris Banks engages in a heated debate with NYCHA officials over the lack of transparency in PACT transactions and the impact on residents. Banks argues that residents should …
2:49:10
·
145 sec
Enforcement of PACT contracts and protection of residents' rights
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about how they enforce PACT contracts to ensure residents' rights are protected. The discussion reveals the complexity of the contractual arrangements and the …
2:51:36
·
150 sec
Resident engagement in the PACT negotiation process
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about resident engagement in the PACT negotiation process. The discussion reveals the iterative nature of the process and the various ways NYCHA claims …
2:54:06
·
4 min
NYCHA's involvement in replacing property managers at Hope Gardens
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about NYCHA's involvement in the replacement of the property manager at Hope Gardens by a PACT developer in late 2023. Jonathan Gouveia from NYCHA confirms …
2:58:22
·
54 sec
Authority to replace PACT property managers by NYCHA, developers, or residents
Council Member Banks questions the authority to replace PACT property managers, exploring whether NYCHA, developers, or residents can initiate such changes. Jonathan Gouveia from NYCHA provides insights into the process …
2:59:16
·
99 sec
Resident engagement and information about replacing PACT developers
Council Member Banks inquires about the information provided to residents during engagement processes regarding the possibility of replacing PACT developers. NYCHA officials confirm that this information is shared with residents. …
3:00:56
·
39 sec
Process of signing leases with PACT partners and HUD approval
Council Member Banks raises concerns about tenants being asked to sign leases with PACT partners prior to HUD approval. Jonathan Gouveia from NYCHA explains the lease signing process and HUD's …
3:01:36
·
163 sec
Consequences for residents refusing to sign Section 8 leases during conversion
Council Member Banks questions the consequences for residents who refuse to sign Section 8 leases during the PACT conversion process. NYCHA officials explain the necessity of having an active lease …
3:04:19
·
3 min
Apartment rehabilitation for residents who don't sign PACT leases
Council Member Banks inquires about the rehabilitation of apartments for tenants who refuse to sign PACT leases. NYCHA officials provide information on their approach to these situations. - NYCHA confirms …
3:07:20
·
54 sec
Evictions and homelessness concerns for residents refusing Section 8 leases
Council Member Banks raises concerns about evictions and homelessness resulting from residents refusing to sign Section 8 leases. NYCHA officials respond to these inquiries. - NYCHA officials state they don't …
3:08:14
·
86 sec
NYCHA's tracking and reporting of evictions in RAD/PACT portfolio
Council Member Banks presses NYCHA officials on their tracking and reporting of evictions in the RAD/PACT portfolio, particularly those related to lease refusals. - NYCHA confirms they know the total …
3:09:40
·
35 sec
Non-disclosure agreements for resident leaders in PACT conversion process
Council Member Banks questions NYCHA officials about non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) for resident leaders participating in the PACT conversion process. NYCHA officials explain the purpose and scope of these agreements. - …
3:10:20
·
144 sec
Approval status for RAD/PACT conversion of Fulton/Elliott-Chelsea campuses
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about the approval status for bringing the Fulton/Elliott-Chelsea (FEC) campuses under the RAD program. Jonathan Gouveia from NYCHA confirms that while HUD is …
3:12:44
·
57 sec
HUD approval status for demolition/disposition of FEC campuses
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about HUD's approval of a Section 18 application for the demolition or disposition of the Fulton/Elliott-Chelsea (FEC) campuses. NYCHA officials confirm that HUD has not …
3:13:42
·
45 sec
Section 8 recertification issues for FEC residents
Council Member Chris Banks raises concerns about tenants seeing Section 8 recertification notifications in their self-service portals, despite the project not having received HUD approval. NYCHA officials provide a possible …
3:14:27
·
37 sec
Reports required for Section 18 applications (Obsolescence Report)
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about the Obsolescence Report required for Section 18 applications. NYCHA officials confirm that this report has not yet been completed. - The Obsolescence Report for …
3:15:08
·
26 sec
Independent audits and physical needs assessments for RAD applications
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about independent audits and physical needs assessments required for RAD applications. NYCHA officials explain the different types of assessments conducted and their availability. - A …
3:15:35
·
46 sec
Cost estimates for renovation vs. demolition/redevelopment of FEC campuses
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about cost estimates for both renovation and demolition/redevelopment of the Fulton/Elliott-Chelsea (FEC) campuses. NYCHA officials provide details on how cost estimates have changed over time …
3:16:21
·
3 min
Community engagement and surveys regarding FEC demolition plans
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about the community engagement process and surveys conducted to justify the demolition plans for Fulton/Elliott-Chelsea (FEC) campuses. NYCHA officials describe the engagement process and survey …
3:19:25
·
81 sec
Relocation plans for FEC residents during redevelopment
Council Member Chris Banks questions NYCHA officials about relocation plans for Fulton/Elliott-Chelsea (FEC) residents during the redevelopment process. NYCHA provides details on available vacant units and the relocation strategy. - …
3:20:46
·
4 min
Compliance with Local Law 65 reporting requirements on PACT conversions
Council Member Chris Banks inquires about NYCHA's compliance with Local Law 65, which requires annual reporting on the impacts of PACT conversions on residents. The discussion reveals some confusion about …
3:25:13
·
115 sec
Availability and content of required PACT impact reports
Council Member Chris Banks scrutinizes the content of NYCHA's PACT impact report required under Local Law 65, pointing out several areas where the report appears to be incomplete or non-compliant. …
3:27:07
·
6 min
Comptroller's new approach to NYCHA audits
Deputy Comptroller Maura Hayes-Chaffe introduces the NYC Comptroller's Office's new approach to auditing NYCHA, prioritizing resident input. This innovative method, implemented since January 2022, involved surveys, town halls, and the …
3:34:50
·
78 sec
Findings from NYCHA contractor oversight audit
The audit on NYCHA's oversight of repair contractors revealed significant issues with transparency and resident engagement. Key findings highlight a lack of feedback mechanisms and poor contractor performance. - NYCHA …
3:36:08
·
109 sec
Recommendations for improving contractor accountability
The Comptroller's Office proposes creating a feedback system to improve contractor accountability and transparency in NYCHA repairs. - Recommendation to create a 'Yelp-like' tool for residents to review contractors - …
3:37:58
·
48 sec
Findings from PACT eviction rates audit
The audit examining eviction rates in PACT properties compared to traditional Section 9 NYCHA developments revealed concerning trends in eviction practices. - Eviction rates at PACT developments are higher than …
3:38:46
·
57 sec
Issues with PACT property manager compliance and reporting
The audit uncovered significant issues with PACT property managers' compliance with reporting requirements and tenant protection procedures. - NYCHA failed to ensure PACT property managers reported all eviction and pre-eviction …
3:39:44
·
39 sec
Importance of transparency for residents facing conversion decisions
As NYCHA developments face growing capital needs, residents are confronted with difficult choices about the future of their homes. Transparency in this process is crucial. - Many residents will need …
3:40:23
·
42 sec
Conclusion and commitment to ongoing oversight
The Comptroller's Office reaffirms its commitment to prioritizing resident input and ensuring transparency in NYCHA operations. - The office will continue to respond to suggestions from residents on public housing …
3:41:06
·
9 sec
Audit findings on NYCHA's transparency issues
Council Member Chris Banks questions Deputy Comptroller Maura Hayes-Chaffe about transparency concerns at NYCHA revealed by recent audits. Hayes-Chaffe highlights inaccurate and incomplete reporting on PACT evictions as a major …
3:41:21
·
85 sec
Suggestions for improving NYCHA's transparency
Council Member Banks asks Deputy Comptroller Hayes-Chaffe about the most impactful change to increase transparency at NYCHA. Hayes-Chaffe suggests improving the validation of information from property managers. - NYCHA needs …
3:42:46
·
39 sec
Challenges in accessing information from NYCHA
Council Member Banks inquires about challenges faced by the Comptroller's office in accessing information from NYCHA. Deputy Comptroller Hayes-Chaffe describes a lengthy process with repeated requests but ultimately receiving the …
3:43:25
·
69 sec
Implementation of audit recommendations by NYCHA
Council Member Banks asks about NYCHA's response to audit recommendations and their implementation. Deputy Comptroller Hayes-Chaffe discusses NYCHA's varying levels of agreement with different audit findings. - NYCHA disagreed with …
3:44:34
·
98 sec
Comparison of communication in Section 9 vs PACT developments
Council Member Banks asks about differences in communication and outreach between Section 9 and PACT developments. Deputy Comptroller Hayes-Chaffe provides insights based on eviction rates and outreach efforts. - The …
3:46:14
·
74 sec
Testimony by Layla Law-Gisiko, President of City Club of New York, on NYCHA Transparency Issues
Layla Law-Gisiko, President of the City Club of New York and Democratic district leader for Chelsea, testified about transparency issues with NYCHA, particularly regarding the proposed demolition of Fulton and …
3:50:39
·
125 sec
Testimony by Veronica Gonzalez on NYCHA and RAD/PACT Issues
Veronica Gonzalez, a long-time resident of the Lower East Side, testified about her concerns regarding NYCHA's negligence and the RAD/PACT program. She emphasized the negative impact on tenants and accused …
3:52:52
·
111 sec
Testimony by Jason Morello, Advocate and Resident from Jacob Riis Houses
Jason Morello, a NYCHA resident and advocate from Jacob Riis Houses, testifies about the deteriorating conditions in public housing and criticizes the RAD/PACT program. He expresses frustration with local leaders …
3:54:50
·
122 sec
Testimony by Zulai Velasquez, Resident of Jacob Riis Houses, on NYCHA RAD/PACT Conversion and Tenant Association Issues
Zulai Velasquez, a resident of Jacob Riis Houses, testified about concerns regarding the RAD/PACT conversion process and issues with the tenant association. She presented a petition signed by over 600 …
3:56:59
·
3 min
Testimony by Alexa Cruz, NYCHA Resident
Alexa Cruz, a long-time NYCHA resident since 1969, expressed strong concerns about NYCHA's treatment of residents and potential changes to public housing. She criticized the lack of attention from NYCHA …
4:03:01
·
109 sec
Testimony by Carla Hollingsworth on NYCHA Housing Conditions and PACT Program
Carla Hollingsworth, a long-time resident of Stuyvesant Gardens, testified about the poor living conditions in NYCHA housing and her concerns about the PACT program. She described decades of enduring deplorable …
4:05:11
·
134 sec
Testimony by Renee Keith, Member of the Public, on NYCHA Demolition Plans and Lack of Transparency
Renee Keith testifies about concerns regarding NYCHA's plans for demolition at Fulton and Elliott Chelsea Houses, highlighting issues with resident surveys, lack of transparency, and the potential for displacement. She …
4:07:28
·
157 sec
Testimony by Christina Chaise, Advocacy Coordinator at TakeRoot Justice and NYCHA Resident
Christina Chaise, a long-term NYCHA resident and Advocacy Coordinator at TakeRoot Justice, testifies about the lack of transparency in the RAD/PACT program and its negative impacts on public housing residents. …
4:10:17
·
157 sec
Testimony by Manny Martinez, Resident Council President of South Jamaica Houses, on NYCHA Transparency and Resident Representation
Manny Martinez, Resident Council President of South Jamaica Houses, testifies about the lack of genuine resident participation in NYCHA operations and the problematic role of the Citywide Council of Presidents …
4:14:17
·
3 min
Testimony by Amelia Walden from Pitwork with Houses on NYCHA and PACT Issues
Amelia Walden, a resident from Pitwork with Houses, testified about various issues with NYCHA and the PACT program. She expressed concerns about the conversion process, management problems, and maintenance issues …
4:18:00
·
4 min
Testimony by Ted Burrows, Founder of A Vision for Change, on NYCHA Forced Conversions and Resident Rights
Ted Burrows, founder of A Vision for Change, testified about forced conversions in NYCHA developments and the need for more resident rights and options. He highlighted issues of gentrification, aggressive …
4:23:40
·
179 sec
Testimony by Metin N Sarci, Public Housing Expert, on NYCHA Transparency Issues
Metin N Sarci, a public housing expert, testified about transparency issues within the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA). He highlighted discrepancies between NYCHA's policies on paper and actual practices, …
4:26:48
·
147 sec
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson on NYCHA Privatization
Christopher Leon Johnson testifies in support of keeping NYCHA public and calls for greater transparency. He warns against the privatization of NYCHA through RAD/PACT conversions and expresses concerns about displacement …
4:35:00
·
125 sec
Testimony by Ken Bravo, Member of the Public
Ken Bravo, a resident of Jacob Riis housing, shares his concerns about the RAD/PACT program and NYCHA's resident engagement practices. He highlights issues with accessibility, transparency, and decision-making processes in …
4:37:16
·
132 sec
Testimony by Galiano Francois, Resident of Tilden Houses, on NYCHA Annual Recertification Issues
Galiano Francois, a resident of Tilden Houses, testified about ongoing issues with NYCHA's annual recertification process. He described how his family and other residents are repeatedly asked to redo their …
4:39:42
·
75 sec
Testimony by Sharon Brown, Member of the Public
Sharon Brown testifies about ongoing issues in NYCHA housing, emphasizing long-standing problems with repairs, heat, and hot water. She expresses sympathy for NYCHA residents and questions why they should trust …
4:41:08
·
151 sec
Testimony by Monica Royal Horn, Retired NYPD Officer and Elderly Advocate, on NYCHA Housing Conditions and Safety Concerns
Monica Royal Horn, a retired NYPD officer and advocate for the elderly, testifies about her experiences living in Linden Houses and the declining quality of life in NYCHA housing. She …
4:44:28
·
3 min
Testimony by April Summers, Treasurer of Tenant Association at LaGuardia Houses
April Summers, treasurer of the LaGuardia Houses tenant association, testifies about urgent crises affecting residents, including poor living conditions and misuse of federal funds. She demands action from NYCHA and …
4:48:41
·
3 min
Testimony by Karen Blondel, Housing Advocate
Karen Blondel, a housing advocate, testified about the RAD/PACT program, her involvement in creating the NYC Preservation Trust, and her concerns about the Citywide Council of Presidents (CCOP). She called …
4:52:07
·
3 min
Testimony by Simone Hall, Resident of Boston Secor Houses, on NYCHA Privatization and RAD/PACT Program
Simone Hall, a resident of Boston Secor Houses in the Bronx, testified about her experiences and concerns with the RAD/PACT program and privatization of NYCHA housing. She highlighted issues such …
4:56:10
·
3 min
Testimony by Christine Burke, Resident of Howard Houses, on RAD/PACT Program Concerns
Christine Burke, a resident of Howard Houses in Brooklyn, testifies about concerns with the RAD/PACT program implementation at her development. She criticizes the lack of transparency and resident participation in …
4:59:39
·
148 sec
Testimony by Cynthia Tibbs, Tenant Association President of West Side Urban Renewal Brownstones on NYCHA Transparency Issues
Cynthia Tibbs, Tenant Association President of West Side Urban Renewal Brownstones, delivers a scathing critique of NYCHA and the Citywide Council of Presidents (CCOP), accusing them of corruption, bullying, and …
5:02:21
·
154 sec
Testimony by Ramona Ferreyra, Founder of Save Section 9, on NYCHA Solutions and RAD/PACT Program
Ramona Ferreyra, founder of Save Section 9, presented solutions to improve NYCHA and called for a moratorium on RAD/PACT conversions. She emphasized the need for restructuring NYCHA, holding it accountable, …
5:05:09
·
152 sec
Testimony by Jeannie Lopez, Resident of Boston Secor House, on RAD/PACT Program Impacts
Jeannie Lopez, a resident of Boston Secor House for 19 years, testified about the negative impacts of the RAD/PACT program on her living situation and well-being. She expressed concerns about …
5:07:53
·
145 sec
Testimony by Rosemary Williams, Public Health Leader and NYCHA Resident
Rosemary Williams, a NYCHA resident, provided testimony about her experiences living in public housing, highlighting issues of safety, health, and unresolved complaints. She shared personal stories of dangerous living conditions …
5:10:57
·
171 sec
Testimony by Danette Chavis, Tenant Association President of LaGuardia Houses
Danette Chavis, the Tenant Association president of LaGuardia Houses, testifies about concerns regarding NYCHA's RAD/PACT program and issues affecting tenant associations. She criticizes the lack of time for residents to …
5:14:19
·
143 sec
Testimony by Carmen Quinones, Tenant Association President of Frederick Douglass Houses on NYCHA Transparency and Resident Representation
Carmen Quinones, Tenant Association President of Frederick Douglass Houses, testifies about the need to dissolve NYCHA's public council, specifically the Citywide Council of Presidents (CCOP). She criticizes the current system …
5:17:01
·
162 sec
Testimony by Dana Elden, President of Saint Mary's Park Houses
Dana Elden, President of Saint Mary's Park Houses, testified about the lack of transparency and respect from NYCHA towards residents, particularly in relation to conversion projects and resident engagement. She …
5:20:16
·
3 min
Testimony by Beverly MacFarlane, Resident Council President of Taft Houses
Beverly MacFarlane, Resident Council President of Taft Houses, testified about concerns regarding Section 18 and the NYCHA trust, urging the council to abolish the trust and address issues with RAD/PACT …
5:24:16
·
119 sec
Testimony by Louis Bartot, Former Resident of Elliot Chelsea Houses
Louis Bartot, a 79-year-old former resident of Elliot Chelsea Houses, testifies about his experiences with NYCHA and subsequent homelessness. He criticizes NYCHA's handling of vacant apartments and their failure to …
5:26:32
·
179 sec
Testimony by Sadie, Resident of Jacob Riis Houses
Sadie, a resident of Jacob Riis Houses, testified about concerns with NYCHA's transparency, violations of resident rights, and issues with the PACT program. She expressed strong opposition to PACT conversions …
5:31:46
·
3 min
Testimony by Sabrina Dingle on NYCHA Housing Conditions and Health Concerns
Sabrina Dingle testifies about serious health and safety issues in her NYCHA housing, including asbestos and mold. She links these conditions to severe health problems experienced by her two sons …
5:35:39
·
56 sec
Testimony by Lisa Hall, Resident of Boston Secor Houses, on RAD/PACT Program Issues
Lisa Hall, a resident of Boston Secor Houses in the Bronx, testifies about serious issues with the RAD/PACT program implementation at her development. She highlights discrepancies between the program's marketing …
5:36:53
·
175 sec