Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

New York City Council

Committee on Environmental Protection, Resiliency and Waterfronts

Feb 28, 2025

·

10:00 AM

3 hr 45 min

PRO The fastest way to analyze public meetings in NYC & NY State. Learn more.

Summary

A hearing on air quality and last mile deliveries, focusing on two proposed bills:

  • Intro 107, which would require increased air quality monitoring along high-traffic corridors
  • Intro 1130, which would authorize the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) to create an indirect source rule to regulate emissions from large warehouses

Discussions centered on:

  • The environmental and health impacts of e-commerce growth
  • The proliferation of warehouses in low-income neighborhoods
  • Strategies to reduce truck emissions

Key issues included the appropriate threshold for regulated warehouses, enforcement of existing truck regulations, and the balance between environmental protection and economic concerns.

Features testimony from the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH), and the public.

Meeting chapters

Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.

REMARKS

Council Member Gennaro introduces the hearing on last mile deliveries and air quality

Council Member Jim Gennaro, Chair of the Committee on Environmental Protection, Resiliency and Water Fronts, opens the hearing on last mile deliveries and their effect on air quality. He introduces …

0:01:06

·

16 sec

REMARKS

Overview of Intro 107 and Intro 1130 proposed by Council Member Aviles

Council Member Gennaro provides an overview of two bills sponsored by Council Member Aviles: Intro 107 and Intro 1130. These bills aim to address air quality issues related to high-traffic …

0:01:23

·

59 sec

REMARKS

E-commerce growth and package delivery statistics in New York City

Council Member Gennaro presents statistics on the growth of e-commerce and package deliveries in New York City, highlighting the significant increase in direct-to-consumer deliveries. - E-commerce sales in the U.S. …

0:02:22

·

24 sec

REMARKS

Predicted increase in truck-transported freight and its environmental impact

Council Member Gennaro discusses the projected increase in truck-transported freight in New York City and its potential environmental consequences, particularly in communities where distribution centers are clustered. - The New …

0:02:47

·

65 sec

REMARKS

Air pollutants from vehicle exhaust and their health impacts

Council Member Gennaro outlines the main air pollutants found in vehicle exhaust and their potential health consequences, particularly for children. - Vehicle exhaust contains four of the six criteria air …

0:03:52

·

25 sec

REMARKS

Medium and heavy-duty trucks' outsized contribution to emissions

Council Member Gennaro highlights the disproportionate contribution of medium and heavy-duty trucks to air pollution, despite their relatively small numbers on the road. - Medium and heavy-duty trucks, often used …

0:04:18

·

50 sec

REMARKS

The need for alternative freight transport methods to reduce emissions

Council Member Gennaro discusses the potential benefits of shifting freight transport from roads to waterways and rail, emphasizing the environmental advantages and the need to balance different transportation modes. - …

0:05:07

·

104 sec

REMARKS

Acknowledgments and introductions of committee staff and council members

Council Member Gennaro concludes his opening remarks by acknowledging and introducing various staff members and fellow council members present at the hearing. - Thanks committee staff, including legislative counsels, policy …

0:06:51

·

94 sec

REMARKS

Council Member Alexa Avilés' remarks on indirect source rule and air quality monitoring

Council Member Alexa Avilés expresses support for the proposed indirect source rule and air quality monitoring legislation. She emphasizes the importance of these measures in addressing environmental justice issues in …

0:08:26

·

4 min

REMARKS

Council Member Jim Gennaro delivers remarks and reads statement from Councilmember Brooks Powers

Council Member Jim Gennaro expresses gratitude for the advocacy efforts and then reads a statement from Councilmember Brooks Powers regarding air quality and last mile deliveries. The statement emphasizes the …

0:12:38

·

3 min

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Introduction of speakers and organizations present

Commissioner Rohit Aggarwala introduces himself and his colleagues from the NYC Department of Environmental Protection and Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. He mentions that they will be presenting slides …

0:17:01

·

68 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Overview of air quality initiatives and New York City Community Air Survey

Commissioner Aggarwala introduces the legislation related to reducing polluting trucks in low-income neighborhoods and highlights the partnership between the administration and the council. He then discusses the New York City …

0:18:09

·

142 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Improvements in air quality and uneven distribution of benefits

Commissioner Aggarwala presents data on significant improvements in New York City's air quality over the past 20 years, including reductions in pollutants and health impacts. However, he notes that these …

0:20:31

·

106 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Impact of warehouses on local air pollution and freight movement statistics

Commissioner Aggarwala explains the relationship between warehouse density and air pollution levels in specific neighborhoods. He also provides statistics on freight movement in New York City and projections for future …

0:22:17

·

51 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Initiatives to shift freight and promote cleaner transportation

Commissioner Aggarwala outlines various initiatives aimed at shifting freight away from trucks and promoting cleaner transportation methods in New York City. - Clean Trucks program has funded more than 700 …

0:23:08

·

150 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Challenges in shifting freight to rail and current rail usage

Commissioner Aggarwala discusses the challenges faced in shifting freight back to rail and provides information on current rail usage in New York City. He also mentions recent investments in rail …

0:25:39

·

82 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Overview of warehouse landscape in New York City

Commissioner Aggarwala provides an overview of the warehouse landscape in New York City, including statistics on the number and size of warehouses, recent developments, and major operators. - New York …

0:27:04

·

72 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Concentration of large warehouses in specific neighborhoods

Commissioner Aggarwala details the concentration of large warehouses in specific New York City neighborhoods and the potential impact on truck traffic in these areas. - Largest concentrations in Red Hook, …

0:28:15

·

36 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Types of trucks and their impact on air pollution

Commissioner Aggarwala explains the different types of trucks operating in New York City and their impact on air pollution, focusing on the potential for electrification of medium-duty trucks. - Largest …

0:28:51

·

35 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Examples of electrification in warehouse operations and industry diversity

Commissioner Aggarwala provides examples of electrification in warehouse operations and discusses the diversity of the warehouse industry in New York City, highlighting the need for flexible policies. - Frito Lay …

0:29:26

·

54 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Explanation of indirect source rule concept

Commissioner Aggarwala explains the concept of an indirect source rule and its potential application to warehouses in New York City to address air pollution from freight movement. - Indirect source …

0:30:21

·

105 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Proposed structure for warehouse indirect source rule

Commissioner Aggarwala outlines the proposed structure for a warehouse indirect source rule in New York City, including compliance requirements and options for warehouse operators. - Large warehouses would need to …

0:32:06

·

133 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Discussion of Intro 1130 (indirect source rule legislation)

Commissioner Aggarwala discusses Intro 1130, which would direct the DEP to promulgate an indirect source rule for warehouses. He expresses support for the legislation and highlights areas for potential refinement. …

0:34:21

·

106 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Discussion of Intro 107 (air quality monitoring legislation)

Commissioner Aggarwala discusses Intro 107, which would require specific air monitoring on heavy-use thoroughfares. He expresses concerns about the bill and suggests alternative approaches to addressing air pollution. - Appreciation …

0:36:07

·

131 sec

AGENCY TESTIMONY

Conclusion and invitation for questions

Commissioner Aggarwala concludes his testimony by thanking the committee for their attention to the issue of air quality and last-mile deliveries. He expresses appreciation for the opportunity to testify and …

0:38:19

·

10 sec

Q&A

Discussion on CEQA review process for the Indirect Source Rule

Council Member Gennaro inquires about the SEQR analysis process for the Indirect Source Rule, questioning how it can proceed without finalized details of the rule. DEP officials explain that the …

0:39:23

·

176 sec

Q&A

Overview of freight transportation challenges in NYC

Council Member Gennaro discusses the increase in freight movement in NYC and distinguishes between last-mile delivery and through traffic. He expresses interest in increasing marine and rail transport to reduce …

0:42:19

·

5 min

REMARKS

Types of freight movement and potential for rail and marine transport in NYC

Commissioner Aggarwala explains the three types of freight movement in NYC: transit through the city, goods destined for NYC distribution centers, and last-mile delivery. He discusses the challenges and potential …

0:48:17

·

4 min

Q&A

Clarification on the number of warehouses covered by the proposed Indirect Source Rule

Commissioner Aggarwala clarifies the discrepancy between the number of warehouses covered by the proposed bill and DEP's vision for the Indirect Source Rule. - The bill, as interpreted by DEP, …

0:52:23

·

147 sec

Q&A

Discussion of ozone pollution in NYC and the region

Council Member Gennaro and Commissioner Aggarwala discuss the current state of ozone pollution in the New York, New Jersey, and Long Island region, its causes, and efforts to address it. …

0:54:51

·

4 min

Q&A

Status update on new air quality monitoring program development

Council Member Gennaro inquires about the status of the new air quality monitoring program mentioned in the 2023 Plan NYC report. Commissioner Aggarwala provides a brief update on the program's …

0:59:39

·

3 min

REMARKS

Council Member Holden raises concerns about 53-foot trailers and underutilized waterways in Maspeth

Council Member Robert F. Holden expresses frustration over the long-standing issues with illegal 53-foot trailers in Maspeth and the underutilization of waterways for freight transport. He highlights the problems these …

1:02:39

·

3 min

Q&A

Discussion on enforcement challenges for truck regulations in NYC

Commissioner Rohit Aggarwala and Council Member Robert F. Holden discuss the challenges of enforcing regulations on 53-foot trailers in New York City. The commissioner acknowledges the difficulty in enforcing violations …

1:06:16

·

93 sec

REMARKS

Commissioner Aggarwala outlines marine transport initiatives and future plans

Commissioner Rohit Aggarwala discusses the administration's efforts to promote marine transport in New York City and the potential impact of the Indirect Source Rule on transportation approaches. He also mentions …

1:07:50

·

114 sec

Q&A

Council members debate agency responsibility for 53-foot trailer enforcement

Council Members Jim Gennaro and Robert F. Holden discuss which agency should be responsible for enforcing regulations on 53-foot trailers in New York City. They explore the potential roles of …

1:09:50

·

152 sec

Q&A

Council members express frustration over lack of enforcement of truck regulations

Council Members Jim Gennaro and Robert F. Holden voice their frustrations with the lack of enforcement of existing laws regarding 53-foot trailers in New York City. They discuss the challenges …

1:12:22

·

89 sec

Q&A

Differences between last mile facilities and traditional warehouses

Council Member Avilés inquires about the differences between last mile facilities and traditional warehouses. Dawn Miller from DEP explains that last mile facilities focus on the final step of bringing …

1:13:51

·

126 sec

Q&A

Size and characteristics of last mile warehouses

Dawn Miller from DEP describes the size and characteristics of last mile warehouses in New York City. She explains that many of these facilities are among the largest warehouses, with …

1:15:58

·

121 sec

Q&A

Hours of operation for last mile facilities

Dawn Miller from DEP discusses the hours of operation for last mile facilities compared to traditional warehouses. While noting that they haven't specifically studied this aspect, she shares anecdotal information …

1:17:59

·

72 sec

Q&A

Estimated truck trips for large warehouses

Commissioner Aggarwala and Dawn Miller discuss the estimated number of truck trips generated by large warehouses in New York City. They also mention an ongoing study in Red Hook to …

1:19:13

·

160 sec

Q&A

Expanding the definition of warehouses for regulation

Dawn Miller from DEP discusses the potential for expanding the definition of warehouses in the proposed regulation to include a broader range of facilities that generate truck traffic and air …

1:21:54

·

126 sec

Q&A

Comparison of NYC's plan to the state's Clean Deliveries Act

Dawn Miller from DEP compares NYC's proposed plan to the state's potential Clean Deliveries Act. She highlights the benefits of developing a local program tailored to New York City's specific …

1:24:00

·

89 sec

Q&A

Differences between NYC's proposed rule and California's indirect source rule

Dawn Miller from DEP outlines key differences between NYC's proposed indirect source rule and the one implemented in Southern California. These distinctions reflect New York City's unique urban environment and …

1:25:29

·

91 sec

Q&A

Enforcement mechanisms for the indirect source rule

Dawn Miller from DEP explains the enforcement mechanisms for the proposed indirect source rule, emphasizing that it is a regulatory policy with compliance requirements and penalties for non-compliance. - The …

1:27:00

·

120 sec

Q&A

Preventing operators from gaming the system with smaller warehouses

Commissioner Aggarwala discusses strategies to prevent operators from gaming the system by using smaller warehouses to avoid regulation. He suggests a flexible approach to adjusting the size threshold if necessary. …

1:29:01

·

66 sec

Q&A

Potential inclusion of other indirect sources in the rule

Commissioner Aggarwala discusses the potential for including other categories of indirect sources in the rule beyond warehouses. He emphasizes the importance of starting with warehouses and the flexibility to expand …

1:30:08

·

106 sec

Q&A

Discussion of Intro 107 on air quality monitoring

Commissioner Aggarwala discusses Intro 107, which would require the installation of street-level air monitors at major intersections. He expresses concerns about the scale and cost of the proposed monitoring expansion. …

1:31:55

·

3 min

Q&A

Integration of local air quality monitoring with NICAS predictive model

Cari Olson from the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene discusses how NICAS (New York City Community Air Survey) integrates with local air quality monitoring efforts and its predictive …

1:35:30

·

4 min

REMARKS

Balancing data collection with active mitigation efforts

Council Member Gennaro emphasizes the importance of balancing data collection through monitoring with active efforts to mitigate air pollution problems. He stresses the need for affirmative action to reduce air …

1:39:56

·

126 sec

REMARKS

Using data to inform industry practices and consider design solutions

Council Member Avilés emphasizes the importance of using collected data to inform and push industry practices towards more responsible behavior, as well as to consider design solutions for environmental issues. …

1:42:03

·

173 sec

REMARKS

Council Member Gennaro's opening remarks and acknowledgments

Council Member Jim Gennaro opens the session with acknowledgments and procedural remarks. He expresses appreciation for the work of Rit (likely referring to Commissioner Rohit Aggarwala) and his team, as …

1:44:57

·

71 sec

Q&A

Discussion on potential shift of warehouse activity outside NYC due to Intro 1130

Council Member Gennaro asks about criticism of Intro 1130, suggesting it might shift warehouse activity outside New York City's jurisdiction, potentially increasing truck travel distances. Commissioner Aggarwala acknowledges this risk …

1:45:50

·

43 sec

REMARKS

Council Member Gennaro's personal anecdote about rapid last-mile delivery

Council Member Gennaro shares a personal anecdote about needing specialized eye drops and how quickly they were delivered, illustrating the efficiency of last-mile delivery services in NYC. - Gennaro ordered …

1:46:33

·

57 sec

REMARKS

Handling of additional questions for the administration

Council Member Gennaro decides to provide the administration with additional questions in writing, to be answered later, rather than extending the Q&A session. - Gennaro chooses to give the administration's …

1:47:31

·

84 sec

REMARKS

Final thanks and dismissal of administration representatives

Council Member Gennaro concludes the administration's portion of the hearing with final thanks and remarks, looking forward to future collaboration on air quality initiatives. - Gennaro expresses appreciation for the …

1:48:56

·

70 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Lacey Tauber, Representative from Brooklyn Borough President's Office

Lacey Tauber, representing Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso, expressed support for Intros 107 and 1130, addressing air quality issues in low-income communities of color exacerbated by last-mile delivery facilities. She …

1:55:01

·

3 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Chantal Lee, Community Engagement Coordinator at Newtown Creek Alliance

Chantal Lee from Newtown Creek Alliance testified in support of Intro 1130, emphasizing the need for strong regulations to address the environmental and health impacts of warehouses and delivery trucks …

1:59:34

·

131 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Jessica Enzmann, Senior Campaign Organizer, Clean Transportation for All at Sierra Club

Jessica Enzmann from Sierra Club testified in support of an indirect source rule to regulate emissions from warehouses in New York City. She emphasized the need for such regulation due …

2:01:51

·

102 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Andrew Saavedra, Associate Attorney at Earthjustice on Intro 1130

Andrew Saavedra from Earthjustice testified in support of Intro 1130, which would create an indirect source rule to regulate air pollution from heavy-duty vehicles associated with last-mile warehouses. He emphasized …

2:03:38

·

107 sec

REMARKS

Council Member Holden advocates for mandatory waterway usage by waterfront facilities

Council Member Robert F. Holden strongly advocates for requiring facilities located on waterways, particularly along Newtown Creek, to utilize water transportation. He argues this would be more environmentally friendly and …

2:05:28

·

149 sec

REMARKS

Council Member Holden's closing remarks and panel interaction on waterfront usage

Council Member Holden concludes by reiterating the importance of waterfront usage and engaging with panel members on the topic. He thanks the Newtown Creek Alliance for their work and suggests …

2:08:00

·

96 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Damian Contreras, Business Agent of Teamsters Local 804, on Air Quality and Last Mile Deliveries

Damian Contreras, representing Teamsters Local 804, supports the proposed bill to improve air quality and safety in relation to last mile deliveries. He emphasizes the need for stronger enforcement mechanisms …

2:10:22

·

4 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Nicholas Kammer, Amazon Driver and Union Organizer

Nicholas Kammer, an Amazon driver and union organizer, testified about the environmental and labor issues faced by Amazon workers and their communities. He emphasized the need for action from the …

2:14:47

·

86 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Renzo Ramirez, Amazon Driver and Union Organizer

Renzo Ramirez, an Amazon driver and union organizer, testified about the working conditions and challenges faced by Amazon drivers in New York City. He highlighted the need for better regulation …

2:16:17

·

87 sec

Q&A

Council member Avilés inquires about exhaust and working conditions in facilities

Council Member Alexa Avilés asks about the exhaust conditions within the facilities and requests more information on work speed-ups and injuries. Damian Contreras from Teamsters Local 804 responds, describing the …

2:17:46

·

80 sec

REMARKS

Council member Avilés remarks on the massive scale of warehouse facilities

Council Member Alexa Avilés expresses astonishment at the scale of these warehouse facilities, highlighting the impact of having thousands of trucks idling inside. Damian Contreras from Teamsters Local 804 corroborates …

2:19:12

·

43 sec

Q&A

Council member inquires about Amazon facility operations and truck traffic

Council Member Robert F. Holden questions witnesses about the operations of an Amazon facility, focusing on its proximity to a school and the logistics of truck deliveries. The discussion covers …

2:19:57

·

121 sec

REMARKS

Council member addresses illegal use of 53-foot trailers in NYC

Council Member Robert F. Holden raises concerns about the illegal use of 53-foot trailers on New York City streets. He questions the witnesses about driver certification, company practices, and the …

2:22:29

·

43 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Bryce Nack, Member of New York City Clean Air Collective on Air Quality and Last Mile Deliveries

Bryce Nack, representing the New York City Clean Air Collective, testified in strong support of Intro 107 for improved air quality monitoring, particularly in environmental justice zones. He expressed concerns …

2:24:11

·

138 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Zach Miller, Vice President of Government Affairs at Trucking Association of New York

Zach Miller from the Trucking Association of New York testified on the proposed Indirect Source Rule (ISR) for warehouses, emphasizing the need for a flexible, menu-based approach to incentivize cleaner …

2:26:35

·

80 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Osagie Afe, Senior Business Assistance Manager of Long Island City Partnership

Osagie Afe from the Long Island City Partnership testified on the potential impacts of the proposed indirect source rule on industrial businesses in New York City. He emphasized the importance …

2:28:02

·

149 sec

REMARKS

Council member explains relationship between city and state ISR regulations

Council Member Alexa Avilés discusses the relationship between city and state Indirect Source Rule (ISR) regulations. She explains that if the state passes an ISR, it will preempt the city's …

2:30:38

·

57 sec

REMARKS

Council member discusses balancing regulation of mega facilities and smaller industrial businesses

Council Member Alexa Avilés discusses the challenge of balancing regulation of large e-commerce facilities with the protection of smaller industrial businesses. She emphasizes the need to focus on mega facilities …

2:31:49

·

75 sec

Q&A

Council member highlights efforts to protect industrial zones and working waterfronts

Council Member Alexa Avilés responds to Mr. Afe's request for industrial advocates to be part of the discussion and highlights the council's efforts to protect industrial zones and working waterfronts. …

2:33:04

·

39 sec

REMARKS

Council member concludes with remarks on legislation details and introduces next panel

Council Member Alexa Avilés concludes her response with remarks on the legislative process and the challenges ahead. - Emphasis that the current legislation is a framework and details will be …

2:33:43

·

60 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Julia Corrado, Researcher and Policy Analyst at The Alliance for Greater New York (ALIGN)

Julia Corrado from ALIGN strongly supports Intro 1130, which aims to regulate emissions from large warehouses and protect environmental justice communities. She suggests aligning the bill with similar state legislation …

2:35:29

·

107 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Gloria Boyce-Charles, Springfield Gardens Brookville Community Resident

Gloria Boyce-Charles, a long-time resident of Springfield Gardens Brookville, testifies about the environmental challenges faced by her community due to air pollution from JFK Airport, trucking traffic, and warehouses. She …

2:37:20

·

6 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Member of Public on Air Quality and Last Mile Deliveries

A resident of Brookville, Queens testifies in support of Intro 1130, the Indirect Source Rule (ISR), sharing personal experiences with truck traffic and warehouse impacts in their neighborhood. They advocate …

2:44:03

·

105 sec

REMARKS

Council Member Holden shares personal experience with 53-foot trucks

Council Member Robert F. Holden relates his personal experience with 53-foot trucks in his neighborhood, drawing parallels to Gloria Boyce-Charles's testimony. He describes the damage and danger these trucks cause, …

2:45:51

·

82 sec

Q&A

Discussion on enforcement and technology for truck regulations

Council Member Holden engages in a discussion about the challenges of enforcing truck regulations and the potential for technological solutions. He criticizes the lack of political will to implement available …

2:47:13

·

77 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Dan Hockman, Employee at QuantAQ, Inc. on Air Quality Monitoring Legislation

Dan Hockman, a resident of Sunnyside, Queens and employee at QuantAQ, Inc., voiced support for both pieces of legislation, particularly emphasizing the need to expand air quality monitoring capabilities. He …

2:49:20

·

112 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Ryan Lokey, Amazon Driver on Air Quality and Last Mile Deliveries

Ryan Lokey, an Amazon delivery driver, provided testimony on Intro 1130 and Intro 107, offering insights from his unique perspective as both a driver and an active participant in citizen …

2:51:19

·

5 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Clifton Smith

Clifton Smith, who works at Burlington Coat Factory in Yonkers, provides a somewhat disjointed testimony about his work experiences and support for Amazon workers. He describes his job in receiving …

2:56:37

·

143 sec

Q&A

Council member inquires about Mr. Lokey's sleep habits

Council Member Alexa Avilés asks Mr. Ryan Lokey, an Amazon driver, about his sleep habits. Mr. Lokey reveals he only slept for two hours to attend the council meeting.

2:59:04

·

8 sec

REMARKS

Council member expresses appreciation for Mr. Lokey's testimony

Council Member Alexa Avilés expresses gratitude for Mr. Lokey's insightful testimony and acknowledges the value of his recommendations and cautionary advice. She indicates that they will have further discussions on …

2:59:12

·

28 sec

Q&A

Council Member Holden discusses Amazon operations and local issues with driver Ryan Lokey

Council Member Robert F. Holden engages in a discussion with Amazon driver Ryan Lokey about various issues related to Amazon's operations and their impact on the local community. They cover …

2:59:41

·

138 sec

REMARKS

Council Member Holden comments on technology issues and plans for future discussions

Council Member Robert F. Holden expresses frustration with the slow adoption of modern technology by the Department of Transportation (DOT) and outlines his intentions for future discussions on these issues. …

3:02:00

·

39 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Amy Turner, Director of Cities Climate Law Initiative at Sabin Center for Climate Change Law, Columbia Law School on Intro 1130

Amy Turner testifies in strong support of Intro 1130, which aims to regulate indirect sources of air pollution. She provides legal context for the viability of Indirect Source Rules (ISRs) …

3:03:16

·

3 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Kevin Garcia, Senior Transportation Planner from New York City Environmental Justice Alliance

Kevin Garcia, representing the New York City Environmental Justice Alliance, testified in support of Intro 107 and Intro 1130, emphasizing their importance in addressing the impacts of e-commerce warehouses and …

3:07:24

·

124 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Christopher Gawarecki, Compliance Manager at HUB Truck Rental, on Air Quality and Last Mile Deliveries

Christopher Gawarecki, Compliance Manager at HUB Truck Rental, testifies on the proposed air quality and last mile delivery bills, expressing both agreement and concerns. He emphasizes the challenges of implementing …

3:10:32

·

124 sec

Q&A

Council Member Avilés clarifies which bill Christopher Gawarecki's testimony addressed

Council Member Alexa Avilés asks Christopher Gawarecki to specify which bill his testimony was referring to. Gawarecki confirms he was commenting on Intro 1130, the indirect source rule. - Avilés …

3:12:38

·

19 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Michelle Meyer, Researcher at International Council on Clean Transportation

Michelle Meyer, a researcher from the International Council on Clean Transportation, testified on the importance of addressing air quality and public health impacts of truck emissions through policies like indirect …

3:13:08

·

112 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Hayden Brockett, Founding Member of New York Clean Air Collective

Hayden Brockett, a founding member of the New York Clean Air Collective, testified in support of Intro 107 for improved air quality monitoring while expressing concerns about Intro 1130. He …

3:15:20

·

3 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Jim Wright, Representative of American Institute of Architects New York on Intro 1130

Jim Wright, representing the American Institute of Architects New York, expressed strong support for Intro 1130, which aims to reduce emissions from freight delivery vehicles through an Indirect Source Rule …

3:19:13

·

3 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Katie Walsh, Transportation Chair of Brooklyn Community Board 7, on Air Quality and Last Mile Deliveries

Katie Walsh, Transportation Chair of Brooklyn Community Board 7, testified in support of Intro 1130 (Indirect Source Rule) and Intro 107 (air quality monitoring expansion). She shared her personal experience …

3:23:13

·

3 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Eric Eisenberg on Air Quality and DEP Authority

Eric Eisenberg provides testimony on the proposed bills related to air quality monitoring and indirect source rules for warehouses. He expresses support for additional air quality monitoring but raises concerns …

3:27:09

·

3 min

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Nathan Taft, Senior Campaigner of SAFE Cities at Stand.earth, on Warehouse Pollution and Indirect Source Rules

Nathan Taft from Stand.earth's SAFE Cities campaign strongly supports New York City's efforts to reduce pollution from mega warehouses through measures like an indirect source rule. He emphasizes the significant …

3:30:29

·

118 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Jaqi Cohen, Director of Climate and Equity Policy at Tri-State Transportation Campaign

Jaqi Cohen, representing Tri-State Transportation Campaign and the Electrify New York Coalition, testified in support of Intro 1130, which aims to reduce emissions from mega warehouses in New York City. …

3:32:34

·

141 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Dylan Jaff, Policy Analyst at Consumer Reports on Intro 1130

Dylan Jaff, a policy analyst at Consumer Reports, testifies in support of Intro 1130, which aims to reduce emissions from warehouse facilities. He emphasizes the negative impacts of e-commerce distribution …

3:35:08

·

125 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Robyn Marquis, Senior Director of Innovative Mobility at CALSTART, on Indirect Source Rule for Air Pollution

Robyn Marquis from CALSTART provided testimony in support of the proposed legislation to regulate indirect sources of air pollution in New York City. She emphasized the need for interventions to …

3:37:37

·

128 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Evi Boyd, Vice President of Rosedale Civic Association on Air Quality and Last Mile Deliveries

Evi Boyd, representing the Rosedale Civic Association, expressed concerns about the negative impacts of large trucks, tractor trailers, industrial warehouses, and industrial pollution on their community in Southeast Queens. She …

3:39:57

·

122 sec

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Michael Streeter, Member of the New York Clean Air Collective, on Air Quality and Last Mile Deliveries

Michael Streeter, a member of the New York Clean Air Collective, testified in support of Intro 107 for increased air quality monitoring, particularly around last-mile delivery facilities. He expressed concerns …

3:42:14

·

133 sec

Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.