Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.
New York City Council
Committee on Finance
Mar 05, 2025
·
10:30 AM
7 hr 15 min
PRO The fastest way to analyze public meetings in NYC & NY State. Learn more.
Summary
A hearing on the fiscal year 2026 preliminary budget for New York City.
Discussions focused on:
- Potential federal funding cuts
- Revenue forecasts
- Budget gaps
- Funding for essential services
- Strategies to address fiscal challenges while protecting vulnerable populations
Major concerns were raised about the city's preparedness for federal funding reductions, chronic underfunding in various areas, and the need for increased budget transparency.
Features testimony from the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), City Comptroller, Independent Budget Office (IBO), Department of Finance, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Councilmember Brannan opens the Finance Committee hearing on the FY 2026 preliminary budget
Councilmember Justin Brannan, Chair of the Committee on Finance, opens the hearing on the FY 2026 preliminary budget. He introduces the agenda, acknowledges his colleagues and the Finance Division staff, …
0:00:19
·
115 sec
Speaker Adams addresses the fiscal year 2026 preliminary budget hearing
Speaker Adrienne Adams opens the hearing on the fiscal year 2026 preliminary budget, providing an overview of the $114.5 billion budget and highlighting key financial figures, including new spending, gap …
0:02:14
·
173 sec
Brannan addresses threats to NYC budget from Trump administration
Council Member Justin Brannan expresses deep concern about the threat posed by the Trump administration to New York City's budget. He highlights the potential impact of federal funding cuts and …
0:05:16
·
91 sec
Brannan outlines concerns with preliminary budget and proposed cuts
Council Member Justin Brannan discusses the FY 2026 preliminary budget, acknowledging some positive investments while expressing concern over harmful cuts in various areas. He emphasizes that these cuts, if not …
0:06:48
·
62 sec
Brannan criticizes budget management and transparency issues
Council Member Justin Brannan criticizes the Adams administration's approach to budget management and transparency. He accuses the administration of framing fiscal choices as inevitabilities rather than policy decisions and creating …
0:07:50
·
137 sec
Brannan highlights NYC's economic resilience and strong revenue
Council Member Justin Brannan emphasizes New York City's economic resilience and strong revenue performance, contradicting the administration's more pessimistic outlook. He cites evidence of the city's economic recovery and growth. …
0:10:07
·
37 sec
Brannan calls for honest budget process and working partnership
Council Member Justin Brannan concludes by calling for an honest and transparent budget process. He reiterates the council's commitment to pushing back against unnecessary cuts and insists on a budget …
0:10:44
·
29 sec
Introduction and purpose of the FY 2026 preliminary budget testimony
Jacques Jiha, Director of NYC Mayor's Office of Management and Budget, introduces himself and his team to the City Council's Finance Committee. He outlines the purpose of his testimony, which …
0:11:46
·
76 sec
Budget balance and positive economic indicators for New York City
Jacques Jiha presents an overview of the FY 2026 preliminary budget, highlighting its balance and reduced future fiscal year gaps. He also emphasizes positive economic indicators for New York City. …
0:13:04
·
87 sec
Revenue revisions and citywide savings measures in the preliminary budget
Jacques Jiha outlines the revenue revisions and citywide savings measures included in the FY 2026 preliminary budget, highlighting significant increases in tax revenues and comprehensive savings across various areas. - …
0:14:33
·
62 sec
Asylum seeker crisis management and associated cost reductions
Jacques Jiha details the city's efforts to manage the asylum seeker crisis and the resulting cost reductions in the budget. He highlights the decline in the number of asylum seekers …
0:15:36
·
120 sec
Federal and state funding challenges impacting the city budget
Jacques Jiha outlines the significant funding challenges New York City faces from both state and federal sources, highlighting potential budget gaps and uncertainties in reimbursement. - The state budget does …
0:17:37
·
100 sec
Credit ratings and fiscal management approach validation
Jacques Jiha highlights the validation of New York City's fiscal management approach by top independent credit rating agencies, despite the various challenges faced by the city. - The four major …
0:19:18
·
36 sec
Investments in critical programs and services for New Yorkers
Jacques Jiha outlines the city's investments in critical programs and services, totaling $1.2 billion this fiscal year, to address various needs and mandates. - Over $500 million allocated to meet …
0:19:56
·
77 sec
Affordable housing initiatives and tax relief for working families
Jacques Jiha details the city's investments in affordable housing initiatives and tax relief programs aimed at supporting working-class New Yorkers and families. - Full funding for the 'City of Yes …
0:21:14
·
76 sec
Public safety and mental health investments
Jacques Jiha outlines the city's increased investments in public safety and mental health initiatives, totaling $650 million, to support vulnerable populations and improve public safety. - Addition of 900 Safe …
0:22:31
·
57 sec
Education and youth program investments
Jacques Jiha details the city's continued investments in education and youth programs, focusing on academic enrichment, career readiness, and safety initiatives. - Support for summer academic and enrichment programming, including …
0:23:29
·
75 sec
Parks and quality of life improvements across New York City
Jacques Jiha outlines the city's investments in parks and quality of life improvements, focusing on cleanliness, green spaces, and community amenities. - Expansion of second shift cleaning to 200 more …
0:24:45
·
72 sec
Ten-year capital investment plan for New York City infrastructure
Jacques Jiha presents an overview of New York City's largest ever ten-year capital investment plan, totaling $170 billion for various infrastructure and development projects across the five boroughs. - The …
0:25:51
·
35 sec
Economic risks and future outlook for New York City
Jacques Jiha outlines potential economic risks and future considerations that could impact New York City's financial outlook, while also noting some positive possibilities. - Potential risks include: - Tariff increases …
0:26:28
·
80 sec
Conclusion and next steps for the FY 2026 budget process
Jacques Jiha concludes his testimony by summarizing key achievements, outlining next steps in the budget process, and expressing commitment to working with the City Council. - Jiha highlights that the …
0:27:48
·
25 sec
Federal funding threats and OMB's response to potential budget cuts
Speaker Adams inquires about OMB's analysis of federal funding streams at risk due to potential federal government actions. Director Jiha explains that while they aim to protect revenue streams, they …
0:28:52
·
155 sec
Education funding cliff and concerns over program continuity
Speaker Adams raises concerns about the education funding cliff, particularly for programs previously funded by federal COVID relief funds. She asks why OMB didn't baseline these funds in the preliminary …
0:31:27
·
164 sec
Commitment to protecting immigrant communities amid federal threats
Speaker Adams inquires about the city's commitment to allocating more funds to protect immigrant families from federal overreach. Director Jiha responds that OMB continues to evaluate programs and will work …
0:34:12
·
63 sec
Funding for Rikers Island alternatives and jail population reduction programs
Speaker Adams inquires about the $1.5 billion reportedly budgeted for initiatives to reduce the jail population and provide alternatives to incarceration. Director Jiha confirms several funded programs but cannot vouch …
0:35:15
·
108 sec
NYPD and uniformed agency overtime spending control measures
Speaker Adams expresses concern about excessive overtime spending, particularly for NYPD. Director Jiha explains the administration's efforts to control and reduce overtime costs through a new mayoral directive and monthly …
0:37:05
·
7 min
City staffing levels and impact of the two-for-one hiring freeze
Speaker Adams questions the rationale for maintaining the two-for-one hiring freeze, given its negative impact on agency services. Director Jiha explains that the freeze is necessary due to budgetary savings …
0:44:52
·
3 min
Addressing delays in contract payments to nonprofits
Speaker Adams raises concerns about delayed payments and contract registration for nonprofits, suggesting that inadequate staffing is at the heart of the problem. Director Jiha outlines the administration's efforts to …
0:48:21
·
158 sec
Allocation of City of Yes housing investment funds
Speaker Adams inquires about the plans for allocating and spending the $5 billion investment negotiated as part of the City of Yes City for All legislation, including $1 billion from …
0:50:59
·
140 sec
Speaker Adams calls for an end to the annual budget dance
Speaker Adams expresses frustration with the annual budget process, which she describes as a 'dance' or 'tango' where the Council must fight to restore critical funding for necessary agency services. …
0:53:21
·
3 min
Council questions OMB on potential federal funding cuts
Council Member Justin Brannan questions OMB Director Jacques Jiha about the potential impact of federal funding cuts proposed by the Trump administration. Jiha explains that OMB has not conducted a …
0:57:12
·
141 sec
Discussion on city's response to FEMA funding clawback
Council Member Brannan questions OMB Director Jiha about the city's response to the $80 million FEMA funding clawback. Jiha defends the administration's actions, explaining the process of filing a lawsuit. …
0:59:34
·
143 sec
Debate over OMB's revenue forecasting approach
Council Member Brannan challenges OMB Director Jiha on the agency's conservative approach to revenue forecasting, particularly regarding business and personal income tax collections. Jiha defends OMB's methodology and explains the …
1:01:59
·
5 min
OMB director defends migrant crisis spending and budget management
OMB Director Jacques Jiha strongly defends the administration's handling of the migrant crisis and its impact on the city budget. He emphasizes the unexpected nature of the $7 billion spent …
1:07:38
·
126 sec
Explanation of labor reserve reductions and future funding
Council Member Brannan questions OMB officials about the $400 million reduction in the city's labor reserve for FY25 and the implications for future labor settlements. First Deputy Budget Director Kenneth …
1:09:46
·
119 sec
Discussion on CUNY funding and budget priorities
Council Member Brannan questions OMB Director Jiha about CUNY funding in light of the city's overall financial picture. Jiha defends the administration's approach to CUNY funding and explains the difference …
1:11:48
·
103 sec
Debate over one-time funding vs. permanent funding for city programs
Council Member Brannan questions OMB Director Jiha about the administration's practice of using one-time funding for critical positions instead of making them permanent. Jiha explains the reasoning behind this approach …
1:13:31
·
174 sec
Inquiry into emergency contracting and asylum seeker services
Council Member Brannan questions OMB Director Jiha about the city's use of emergency contracts, particularly for asylum seeker services. Jiha provides limited information and agrees to follow up with more …
1:16:26
·
104 sec
Discussion on arts and cultural budget, including DCLA funding
Council Member Brannan inquires about the arts and cultural budget, specifically addressing the funding for the Department of Cultural Affairs (DCLA). OMB Director Jiha provides a brief response about current …
1:18:15
·
78 sec
Addressing delays in payments to nonprofits
Council Member Brannan raises concerns about timely payments to nonprofits, referencing the administration's previous success in clearing backlog payments. OMB Director Jiha acknowledges the challenge and outlines efforts to address …
1:19:35
·
110 sec
Asylum seeker response savings and factors contributing to budget reductions
Council Member Diana Ayala inquires about the savings achieved in the city's asylum seeker response, including $1.09 billion in FY25 and $1.34 billion in FY26. OMB Director Jacques Jiha explains …
1:21:42
·
91 sec
Impact of changing shelter population dynamics on the city budget
Council Member Ayala asks about the budget impact of declining asylum seeker numbers and increasing New Yorkers in shelters. Director Jiha explains the challenges faced by the administration due to …
1:23:12
·
84 sec
Per diem costs for asylum seekers and challenges with empty bed payments
Council Member Ayala inquires about the current per diem cost for asylum seekers. Director Jiha, with input from other officials, provides information on costs and explains the challenges with empty …
1:24:36
·
100 sec
State funding for asylum seeker response and potential budget shortfalls
Council Member Ayala questions the inclusion of $2.7 billion in state funding for asylum seeker response in the preliminary plan, given that the governor did not include this in her …
1:26:16
·
94 sec
Rental assistance programs budget and baseline adjustments
Council Member Ayala inquires about the budget for rental assistance programs, noting that actual spending has been higher than the baseline budget. She asks when OMB will increase the baseline …
1:27:51
·
83 sec
Fair Fares program expansion and budget allocation challenges
Council Member Ayala discusses the recent expansion of the Fair Fares program and inquires about its budget allocation, particularly the lack of baseline funding for the expansion in future years. …
1:29:14
·
3 min
Community Food Connections program funding and food insecurity concerns
Council Member Ayala raises concerns about the funding for the Community Food Connections (CFC) program, particularly the lack of baseline funding in out years. She emphasizes the critical nature of …
1:33:09
·
62 sec
Street homelessness programs and subway safety plan funding and effectiveness
Council Member Ayala inquires about the funding and effectiveness of street homelessness programs and the subway safety plan. She notes persistent concerns despite additional funding and asks about changes in …
1:34:11
·
3 min
Majority Leader Amanda Farias questions OMB on economic development initiatives and World Cup funding
Majority Leader Amanda Farias questioned OMB officials about various economic development initiatives, including tax breaks for the office sector, funding for the 2026 World Cup, and their economic impacts on …
1:37:58
·
3 min
Discussion on Rockaway Trauma Center funding and services
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about the funding and services for the planned Rockaway Trauma Center. Director Jiha explains that $50 million has been allocated in the capital commitment plan, with …
1:40:59
·
128 sec
Inquiry on Vision Zero funding and street safety measures
Council Member Brooks-Powers questions the restoration of Vision Zero funding and addresses street safety concerns. Director Jiha outlines current efforts to improve street safety. - 193 people died in traffic …
1:43:08
·
91 sec
Discussion on MTA funding shifts and payroll mobility tax impact
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about the city's increased funding obligations for MTA operations and the impact of the payroll mobility tax. Director Jiha is asked to address the budgetary implications …
1:44:43
·
130 sec
Clarification on paratransit funding and state budget impact
Director Jiha explains the city's current and potential future obligations for paratransit funding, highlighting the impact of the governor's proposed budget. Council Member Brooks-Powers seeks clarification on the preliminary budget's …
1:46:53
·
120 sec
Explanation of city's $3 billion contribution to MTA capital plan
Director Jiha provides information on the city's mandated $3 billion contribution to the MTA capital plan. This requirement impacts the city's ability to fund other priorities. - The state requires …
1:48:53
·
34 sec
Inquiry on NYC Streets Plan implementation and funding
Council Member Brooks-Powers questions the implementation progress of the NYC Streets Plan and its funding in the preliminary budget. Director Jiha provides information on current efforts and funding allocations. - …
1:49:28
·
132 sec
Discussion on Parks Department budget and staffing concerns
Council Member Krishnan expresses concern over the declining Parks Department budget and ongoing hiring freeze. He questions Director Jiha about the adequacy of current staffing levels, particularly for forestry workers. …
1:51:49
·
4 min
Debate over urban park ranger positions and funding
Council Member Krishnan raises concerns about the inadequate number of urban park rangers and the precarious nature of temporary positions. He urges for permanent funding to ensure job security for …
1:56:44
·
85 sec
Questioning the adequacy of PEP officer staffing in city parks
Council Member Krishnan questions the adequacy of Parks Enforcement Patrol (PEP) officer staffing levels, arguing that the current number is insufficient for ensuring safety in New York City's parks. - …
1:58:08
·
85 sec
Council Member Lee questions OMB Director on maternal health funding and opioid settlement allocations
Council Member Linda Lee questions OMB Director Jacques Jiha about reductions in maternal health program funding and the allocation of opioid settlement funds. Jiha is unable to provide detailed answers …
1:59:40
·
4 min
Discussion on federally funded city employees and potential funding loss
Council Member Lynn Schulman inquires about the number of city employees funded by federal money and the plan if federal funding is lost. Director Jacques Jiha explains that some employees, …
2:04:41
·
83 sec
Grant-funded staff exemption from two-for-one approval process
Council Member Lynn Schulman asks if grant-funded staff are exempt from the two-for-one approval process. Director Jacques Jiha confirms that about 200 grant-funded positions are being removed from this process. …
2:06:05
·
17 sec
City's plan to recruit experts leaving federal agencies
Council Member Lynn Schulman inquires about the city's plan to recruit experts leaving federal agencies, noting that the governor has announced a similar plan for New York State. Director Jacques …
2:06:23
·
50 sec
OMB hiring approval process and planned improvements
Council Member Lynn Schulman asks about the timeframe for OMB to approve hiring actions. First Deputy Budget Director Kenneth Godiner explains that the process has been expedited, typically taking one …
2:07:13
·
143 sec
City's approach to attracting laid-off federal employees
Chair Justin Brannan inquires about OMB's plans to attract federal employees who are being laid off. Director Jacques Jiha explains that while there isn't a specific plan, the city is …
2:09:38
·
57 sec
Council Member Carr discusses NYPD recruitment and migrant shelter costs with OMB officials
Council Member David Carr engages in a Q&A session with OMB Director Jacques Jiha and First Deputy Budget Director Kenneth Godiner, focusing on two main topics: NYPD recruitment challenges and …
2:10:40
·
4 min
Council member inquires about CORE funding and staffing
Council Member Nantasha Williams questions Director Jacques Jiha about the funding allocation for additional staff positions at the Commission on Racial Equity (CORE). Jiha explains the current budget allocations and …
2:15:51
·
149 sec
Comparison of staffing levels between CORE and Mayor's Office of Equity and Racial Justice
Council Member Williams raises a question about the disparity in staffing levels between CORE and the Mayor's Office of Equity and Racial Justice. - The Mayor's Office of Equity and …
2:18:21
·
7 sec
Discussion on racial equity plans and their budget implications
Council Member Williams inquires about the delayed release of racial equity plans and their impact on budget decisions. Director Jiha explains OMB's role and the administration's approach to equity in …
2:18:29
·
145 sec
Council Member Louis questions OMB on housing vouchers, community board funding, and maternal health initiatives
Council Member Farah N. Louis engages in a Q&A session with OMB Director Jacques Jiha, addressing concerns about housing voucher delays, community board funding, and maternal health initiatives. Jiha provides …
2:21:03
·
3 min
Council Member Hudson questions DFTA budget decrease for FY 2026
Council Member Crystal Hudson highlights the significant decrease in the Department for the Aging (DFTA) budget for fiscal year 2026, noting a $124.5 million reduction compared to the current fiscal …
2:25:05
·
52 sec
OMB Director Jiha discusses commitment to finding resources for DFTA
OMB Director Jacques Jiha responds to Council Member Hudson's concerns about the DFTA budget decrease, expressing a commitment to work on finding resources while acknowledging the challenges faced. - Jiha …
2:26:00
·
97 sec
Discussion on potential impact of DFTA funding cuts
Council Member Hudson inquires about the potential impact of funding cuts on DFTA programs and services, while Director Jiha emphasizes the administration's goal to find solutions and preserve programs. - …
2:27:36
·
43 sec
Council Member Hudson addresses growing older adult population and DFTA budget alignment
Council Member Hudson highlights the growing older adult population in New York City and questions whether DFTA's budget aligns with the increasing demand for services. Director Jiha briefly responds, acknowledging …
2:28:19
·
97 sec
Discussion on OMB's use of metrics for DFTA budget decisions
Council Member Hudson questions OMB Director Jiha about how metrics and population projections are used in making budget decisions for DFTA. The exchange reveals differences in perspective on the budget …
2:29:57
·
135 sec
Council Member Narcisse's opening remarks and acknowledgments
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse opens with acknowledgments and personal comments. She thanks the chair and team, mentions the passing of May Hazel Duke, and expresses concern for Haitian people facing …
2:32:19
·
18 sec
Discussion on potential federal budget cuts and Medicaid impacts on NYC Health + Hospitals
Council Member Narcisse inquires about the potential impact of federal budget cuts on NYC Health + Hospitals (H+H), particularly concerning Medicaid funding. Director Jacques Jiha expresses significant concern about possible …
2:32:37
·
107 sec
Update on Indigent Care Pool payments and Directed Payment Template request
Council Member Narcisse inquires about the discontinuation of the state's Indigent Care Pool (ICP) payments and the status of the Directed Payment Template (DPT) request. Director Jiha provides an update …
2:34:25
·
120 sec
Discussion on $150 million state intercept for distressed hospital fund
Council Member Narcisse raises concerns about the state intercepting $150 million of city tax revenue for a distressed hospital fund. Director Jiha explains OMB's efforts to advocate against this intercept …
2:36:26
·
91 sec
Council Member Narcisse's remarks on need for swimming pools in New York City
Council Member Narcisse briefly comments on the need for swimming pools for children in New York City, referencing it as part of the city's plan. - Emphasizes the importance of …
2:37:57
·
13 sec
Council Member Riley questions OMB on 311 staffing, Big Apple Connect, and Department of City Planning vacancies
Council Member Kevin Riley questions OMB representatives about 311 staffing, the Big Apple Connect program, and Department of City Planning vacancies. The OMB team provides responses on hiring plans, future …
2:54:05
·
3 min
Council member questions OMB director about Department of Investigation funding
Council Member Gale Brewer inquires about funding for the Department of Investigation (DOI), particularly the use of asset forfeiture funding for operating costs. OMB Director Jacques Jiha responds by detailing …
2:57:32
·
116 sec
Council member inquires about NYPD Office of Inspector General budget allocation
Council Member Gale Brewer questions OMB Director Jacques Jiha about the NYPD Office of Inspector General (OIG) budget, specifically regarding the allocation of funds for rentals. - Brewer points out …
2:59:27
·
35 sec
Discussion on potential risks to federal asset forfeiture funds
Council Member Gale Brewer raises concerns about the potential clawback of federal asset forfeiture funds, similar to recent federal funding issues. OMB Director Jacques Jiha responds with the city's approach …
3:00:03
·
57 sec
Debate over capital eligibility of water fountains and bottle filling stations in schools
Council Member Gale Brewer engages in a discussion with OMB Director Jacques Jiha about the capital eligibility of water fountains and water bottle filling stations in schools. Brewer argues for …
3:00:59
·
141 sec
Council Member Sandy Nurse questions OMB on borough-based jails and HPD programs
Council Member Sandy Nurse engages in a Q&A session with OMB officials, focusing on the budget for borough-based jails and updates on HPD programs. She inquires about the increased cost …
3:03:27
·
4 min
Council member inquires about MTA funding and congestion pricing impact
Council Member Lincoln Restler questions OMB Director Jacques Jiha about the potential impact of reduced congestion pricing revenue on the city's contributions to MTA funding. Jiha explains that the state …
3:08:05
·
86 sec
Discussion on early childhood education funding cuts
Council Member Restler expresses concern about potential cuts to early childhood education, particularly 3-K and pre-K programs. OMB Director Jiha maintains that there are no cuts, explaining that the program …
3:09:31
·
105 sec
Concerns raised over childcare voucher reductions
Council Member Restler expresses concern about potential cuts to childcare vouchers, citing information from ACS that 11,000 children may lose access to vouchers due to lack of state funding. OMB …
3:11:16
·
108 sec
Inquiry into Hydro Quebec pipeline and potential tariffs
Council Member Restler inquires about the potential impact of new tariffs on the Hydro Quebec pipeline, which is meant to provide renewable energy to New York City government. OMB Director …
3:13:04
·
73 sec
Council Member Rivera advocates for arts in education
Council Member Carlina Rivera emphasizes the importance of arts in the education system, highlighting its role in social-emotional learning and students' mental health. She expresses hope for collaboration to ensure …
3:14:36
·
19 sec
Discussion on baselining DCLA funding for cultural institutions
Council Member Rivera inquires about baselining the $45 million one-time funding for DCLA secured in the previous year's budget. Director Jiha explains the challenges of baselining without a long-term funding …
3:14:56
·
100 sec
Support for struggling cultural institutions and their workers
Council Member Rivera inquires about the city's plan to support cultural institutions facing financial difficulties, particularly in light of the pandemic's impact. OMB officials discuss current support and their approach …
3:16:36
·
66 sec
Addressing Cultural Development Fund (CDF) funding delays
Council Member Rivera raises concerns about the six-month delay in Cultural Development Fund (CDF) funding and inquires about the administration's plan to ensure timely disbursement. Director Jiha responds with assurances …
3:17:42
·
60 sec
Discussion on library funding and expanded services
Council Member Rivera addresses the crucial role of libraries in the community and their unmet financial needs. She inquires about additional resources for libraries and funding for increased seven-day service. …
3:18:43
·
67 sec
Council Member Rivera's closing remarks on federal budget cuts and city priorities
Council Member Rivera concludes by emphasizing the importance of protecting New Yorkers from potential federal budget cuts. She calls for collaboration between the administration and the council to address basic …
3:19:51
·
44 sec
Council Member Stevens questions OMB on homeless youth funding and program contracts
Council Member Althea Stevens engages in a Q&A session with OMB Director Jacques Jiha and Senior Deputy Director Latonia McKinney regarding funding for homeless and runaway youth programs. Stevens expresses …
3:20:41
·
3 min
Council Member Menin questions OMB on healthcare cost savings initiatives
Council Member Julie Menin raises concerns about two healthcare-related initiatives aimed at reducing costs for the city. She questions the understaffing of the health care accountability office and the delay …
3:24:17
·
4 min
Discussion on foundation aid and potential $347 million loss for NYC schools
Council Member Rita Joseph inquires about the potential $347 million loss in foundation aid for New York City schools due to a new formula. OMB Director Jacques Jiha explains their …
3:28:36
·
111 sec
Discussion on state funding for education and NYC's role
Council Member Rita Joseph raises concerns about decreasing state funding for education and New York City's increasing role in filling the gap. OMB Director Jacques Jiha addresses these concerns. - …
3:30:27
·
36 sec
Impact of potential foundation aid reduction on NYC public schools
Council Member Rita Joseph inquires about the potential impact of a $347 million reduction in foundation aid on New York City public schools. OMB Director Jacques Jiha explains the administration's …
3:31:04
·
36 sec
Discussion on Carter cases funding and differentiation from Conner cases
Council Member Rita Joseph questions OMB about Carter cases funding and the differentiation between Carter and Conner cases. OMB representatives struggle to provide clear answers. - OMB acknowledges Carter cases …
3:31:39
·
76 sec
Class size mandate and teacher hiring discussion
Council Member Rita Joseph inquires about the progress on meeting class size mandates and the hiring of teachers. OMB representatives provide updates on compliance efforts and hiring processes. - OMB …
3:32:55
·
81 sec
Council member raises concerns about Fire Department budget and staffing
Council Member Joann Ariola expresses concerns about the Fire Department's budget being flatlined for the past three years. She highlights staffing issues, particularly the need for a fifth firefighter in …
3:34:20
·
50 sec
Council member highlights Fire Department equipment and facility needs
Council Member Ariola outlines various equipment and facility issues facing the Fire Department, emphasizing the need for upgrades and improvements. - Mentions antiquated equipment, including rigs over 25 years old …
3:35:11
·
30 sec
OMB Director outlines current Fire Department budget allocations
OMB Director Jacques Jiha responds to Council Member Ariola's funding concerns by detailing current budget allocations for the Fire Department. - Explains the ten-year capital plan includes $1.8 billion for …
3:35:41
·
93 sec
Debate over the necessity of a fifth firefighter and current response strategies
OMB officials and Council Member Ariola debate the necessity of a fifth firefighter and discuss current fire response strategies. - OMB states that 90% of engine companies work safely with …
3:37:16
·
117 sec
Council member pushes for increased Fire Department funding
Council Member Ariola challenges the OMB Director's budget figures and insists on the need for additional funding for the Fire Department. - Ariola argues that the presented budget figures are …
3:39:13
·
102 sec
Council Member Brannan inquires about 911 operator staffing and EMS pay parity negotiations
Council Member Justin Brannan concludes the session with Director Jacques Jiha by asking about staffing issues for 911 operators and updates on EMS pay parity negotiations. Jiha is unaware of …
3:40:56
·
46 sec
Introduction and overview of New York City's budget challenges
Comptroller Brad Lander opens his testimony by addressing the New York City Council Committee on Finance regarding the FY 2026 preliminary budget. He emphasizes the critical nature of the current …
3:54:36
·
41 sec
Criticism of Mayor Adams' budget practices and transparency
Comptroller Lander strongly criticizes Mayor Adams' budget practices, characterizing them as short-sighted and lacking transparency. He accuses the administration of misrepresenting budget needs and threatening core services. - Lander describes …
3:55:18
·
86 sec
Economic outlook and revenue forecasts for New York City
Comptroller Lander presents an overview of New York City's economic outlook and revenue forecasts, highlighting areas of growth and potential challenges. He emphasizes the need to adjust economic assumptions in …
3:56:44
·
64 sec
Overestimation of asylum seeker costs in the city budget
Comptroller Lander criticizes the Adams administration for overstating expenses related to services for asylum seekers in the city budget. He presents his office's estimates of potential savings based on current …
3:57:50
·
71 sec
Under-budgeting concerns in various city services
Comptroller Lander highlights significant under-budgeting issues in various areas of the city's financial plan, arguing that these shortfalls will lead to substantial budget gaps in the coming years. - The …
3:59:02
·
78 sec
Federal funding threats and city's response
Comptroller Lander discusses recent and potential future federal funding threats to New York City, criticizing the mayor's lack of preparedness and detailing his office's efforts to address these challenges. - …
4:00:21
·
57 sec
Proposal for increased city reserve funds
Comptroller Lander proposes significant increases to the city's reserve funds to protect against potential federal funding cuts and economic downturns. He outlines specific recommendations for both the general reserve and …
4:01:19
·
71 sec
Projected budget gaps and need for strategic planning
Comptroller Lander presents his office's projections for budget gaps, which are higher than those estimated by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB). He emphasizes the need for strategic planning …
4:02:30
·
55 sec
Recommendations for priority investments in city services
Comptroller Lander outlines several areas where he recommends the city council increase resources to protect vulnerable New Yorkers and maintain essential services. These recommendations span various sectors and programs. - …
4:03:25
·
175 sec
Addressing delays in payments to nonprofit service providers
Comptroller Lander addresses the critical issue of delayed payments to nonprofit human service providers and outlines steps his office has taken to improve the situation. He also recommends further action …
4:06:22
·
32 sec
Call for strong fiscal leadership and transparency
Comptroller Lander concludes his testimony by reiterating the need for strong fiscal leadership and greater transparency in budgeting. He emphasizes the importance of preparing the city for potential federal funding …
4:06:55
·
42 sec
Questions on emergency contracts for asylum seekers
Councilmember Brannan inquires about the oversight of emergency contracts issued for the asylum seeker crisis. The Comptroller's office explains their review process and recommendations for competitive procurement. - The Comptroller's …
4:07:38
·
147 sec
Discussion on business tax collections and forecasting
Councilmember Brannan and the Comptroller's office discuss the strong performance of business tax collections and the challenges in forecasting future revenues. - Business tax collections have outpaced other revenue sources …
4:10:06
·
158 sec
Property tax forecasting for FY 2025
Councilmember Brannan inquires about the Comptroller's office forecast for FY 2025 property tax collections, which is below OMB's forecast. - The Comptroller's forecast for FY 2025 property taxes differs from …
4:12:46
·
45 sec
Challenges in implementing property tax reform
Councilmember Brannan questions why the mayor is hesitant to address property tax reform, and Comptroller Lander provides insights on the political challenges involved. - Property tax reform has potential winners …
4:13:32
·
72 sec
Update on city pension system returns
Councilmember Brannan requests an update on the year-to-date returns for the city's five pension systems. - Francesco Brindisi reports that the preliminary return as of February is 6.1%
4:14:46
·
12 sec
Strategies for addressing federal funding uncertainty
Councilmember Brannan and Comptroller Lander discuss how to prepare for potential federal funding cuts and the administration's response to this uncertainty. - Comptroller's office proposes increasing the general reserve by …
4:15:01
·
129 sec
Discovery and response to $80 million unauthorized account withdrawal
Councilmember Brannan inquires about the discovery of an $80 million unauthorized withdrawal from a city account and the administration's response. - The withdrawal was noticed due to a $79 million …
4:17:11
·
172 sec
Analysis of proposal to refinance pension system's unfunded liability
Councilmember Brannan asks for the Comptroller's opinion on the mayor's proposal to refinance the unfunded accrual liability for three of the city's pension systems. Comptroller Lander provides a detailed analysis …
4:20:03
·
3 min
Council Member Brewer and Comptroller Lander discuss nonprofit payment structure and contract transparency
Council Member Gale Brewer inquires about suggestions for improving the payment structure for nonprofits. Comptroller Brad Lander responds by discussing the need for greater transparency in contract processing times and …
4:23:25
·
117 sec
Introduction and overview of IBO's budget analysis
Louisa Chafee, Director of the Independent Budget Office (IBO), introduces herself and her colleagues to the NYC Council Committee on Finance. She provides a brief overview of IBO's recent analysis …
4:28:37
·
42 sec
Shrinking surpluses and rising risks in NYC budget
The IBO highlights the decreasing budget surpluses and increasing financial risks facing New York City. Despite relatively close estimates with the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), the city's financial …
4:29:20
·
71 sec
Impact of federal policy changes and funding cuts on NYC budget
The IBO expresses serious concerns about the impact of federal policy changes and potential funding cuts on New York City's budget and services. These changes pose significant risks to various …
4:30:32
·
3 min
Chronic underfunding practices in NYC budget
The IBO identifies several chronically underfunded areas in the New York City budget, which exacerbate the city's financial challenges amid external budget threats. - City FHEPS (housing voucher program) is …
4:33:42
·
104 sec
Procurement choices and fiscal risks in NYC
The IBO highlights significant issues with New York City's procurement practices, particularly concerning late payments to nonprofit providers. These practices pose fiscal risks and create instability for service providers. - …
4:35:27
·
113 sec
Budget transparency and unit of appropriation (UA) issues
The IBO emphasizes the importance of budget transparency and highlights issues with the current unit of appropriation (UA) structure in New York City's budget. The lack of granularity in UAs …
4:37:20
·
71 sec
Recommendations for fiscal responsibility and transparency
In conclusion, the IBO emphasizes the critical need for fiscal responsibility and transparency in New York City's budget process, especially given the current challenges and uncertainties. - IBO urges the …
4:38:32
·
29 sec
Council Member Brannan questions IBO on revenue forecasts and foundation aid
Council Member Justin Brannan, Chair of the Committee on Finance, engages in a Q&A session with representatives from the Independent Budget Office (IBO) regarding revenue forecasts and foundation aid. The …
4:39:02
·
3 min
Introduction and overview of the Department of Finance's budget
Preston Niblack, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Finance, introduces himself and provides an overview of the department's role and budget for fiscal year 2026. - The Department …
5:02:34
·
63 sec
Staffing initiatives and hiring progress at the Department of Finance
Commissioner Niblack discusses the Department of Finance's efforts to fill vacancies and improve staffing levels. - A new class of 87 deputy sheriffs started training on February 24. - The …
5:03:39
·
53 sec
Implementation of Local Law 82 and tax lien sale reforms
Commissioner Niblack discusses the passage and implementation of Local Law 82, which reforms the tax lien sale process. - The law aims to ensure property owners who can pay do …
5:04:34
·
78 sec
Technology and customer service improvements at the Department of Finance
Commissioner Niblack outlines recent technological improvements and customer service enhancements implemented by the Department of Finance. - A new coop and condo abatement system has been implemented to streamline the …
5:05:54
·
57 sec
Sheriff's office enforcement of unlicensed cannabis sales
Commissioner Niblack highlights the recent enforcement activities of the sheriff's office regarding unlicensed cannabis sales. - Since May of the previous year, the sheriff's office has conducted 5,700 inspections. - …
5:06:51
·
23 sec
Achievement of MWBE procurement goals
Commissioner Niblack reports on the Department of Finance's success in meeting Minority and Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) procurement goals. - The department received an A+ grade from the mayor's office …
5:07:15
·
29 sec
Upcoming property tax reform initiative
Commissioner Niblack announces plans to introduce a property tax reform bill in the state legislature. - The goal is to make the property tax burden fairer. - The department is …
5:07:45
·
25 sec
Upgrade of the parking violations tracking system
Commissioner Niblack outlines plans to replace the outdated STARS system for tracking parking violations. - The current system is 30 years old and based on mainframe technology. - The new …
5:08:10
·
15 sec
Ongoing exemption application season and outreach efforts
Commissioner Niblack discusses the current exemption application season and efforts to increase enrollment in homeowner exemption programs. - The department is building on last year's success in increasing enrollment in …
5:08:27
·
26 sec
Ongoing customer service enhancements and future plans
Commissioner Niblack outlines various customer service improvements and future plans for the Department of Finance. - The department has simplified access for business and parking customers by combining platforms for …
5:08:55
·
70 sec
Federal government clawback of $80 million FEMA grant
Council Member Justin Brannan questions Commissioner Preston Niblack about the recent federal clawback of an $80 million FEMA grant. They discuss the process of how the clawback occurred, the lack …
5:10:06
·
4 min
Sheriff's Office handling of cannabis raids after court ruling
Council Member Justin Brannan inquires about how the Sheriff's Office is handling cannabis raids following a New York State Supreme Court ruling that enjoined warrantless searches and unlawful seizures. Commissioner …
5:14:32
·
52 sec
Sheriff's Office overtime expenditures and budgeting
Council Member Justin Brannan questions Commissioner Preston Niblack about the Sheriff's Office overtime expenditures, which are significantly higher than budgeted. They discuss the reasons for the increased overtime and how …
5:15:27
·
175 sec
Staffing levels and vacancies in the Sheriff's Office
CFO Jacqueline James provides information on the current staffing levels and vacancies in the Sheriff's Office in response to Council Member Justin Brannan's inquiry. - The authorized headcount for the …
5:18:24
·
26 sec
Department of Finance auditor vacancies and impact on audit completion times
Council Member Justin Brannan inquires about the Department of Finance auditor vacancies and their impact on audit completion times. Commissioner Preston Niblack and CFO Jacqueline James provide details on the …
5:18:51
·
4 min
Tax lien sales and HDFC co-ops on the warning list
Council Member Justin Brannan raises concerns about HDFC co-ops appearing on the 90-day tax lien sale warning list, despite not being authorized for lien sales. First Deputy Commissioner Jeffrey Shear …
5:23:25
·
154 sec
Con Edison's proposed rate increases attributed to property taxes
Council Member Justin Brannan inquires about Con Edison's filed rate increases, which the company attributes to property taxes. Commissioner Preston Niblack provides a cautious response about the situation. - Con …
5:25:59
·
80 sec
Discussion on property tax inequities and reform plans
Councilmember Selvena Brooks-Powers inquires about steps the Department of Finance is taking to address inequities in the property tax system, particularly its impact on lower-income neighborhoods. Commissioner Preston Niblack responds …
5:27:35
·
158 sec
Assessment methodology for co-ops and condos
Councilmember Brooks-Powers raises concerns about the disconnect between the assessment methodology for co-ops and condos and their actual sale prices. Commissioner Niblack explains the limitations imposed by state law on …
5:30:13
·
78 sec
Impact of tax burdens on commercial properties and affordable housing
Councilmember Brooks-Powers inquires about balancing the city's revenue needs with creating a fairer tax environment for commercial property owners and apartment building landlords. Commissioner Niblack explains the department's approach to …
5:31:32
·
146 sec
Council Member Hudson questions Department of Finance on rent freeze programs and eligibility
Council Member Crystal Hudson questions Commissioner Preston Niblack and other representatives from the Department of Finance about rent freeze programs, specifically Screedry and Shahi. The discussion covers eligibility data, outreach …
5:34:01
·
138 sec
Testimony by George Sweeting, Senior Fellow at the Center for New York City Affairs at The New School
George Sweeting from the Center for New York City Affairs at The New School testified on two tax credits in the mayor's budget: the "axe the tax" credit and the …
5:46:51
·
6 min
Testimony by Gabriela Sandoval Requena, Director of Policy and Communications at New Destiny Housing
Gabriela Sandoval Requena from New Destiny Housing testified about the importance of housing solutions for domestic violence survivors and the potential impact of federal budget cuts on their programs. She …
5:53:49
·
156 sec
Testimony by Candice Ficalora, President of Local 1757 of DC 37, on Staffing Needs for NYC Assessors
Candice Ficalora, President of Local 1757 of DC 37, testified about the understaffing of assessors in the New York City Department of Finance and Tax Commission. She emphasized the need …
5:56:29
·
3 min
Testimony by Keriann Pauls, Interim Executive Director of Take Root Justice
Keriann Pauls, Interim Executive Director of Take Root Justice, testified before the finance committee to request increased funding and resources for organizations providing legal support to immigrant communities. She highlighted …
6:00:16
·
151 sec
Testimony by Sarita Daftary-Steel, Co-Director of Freedom Agenda
Sarita Daftary-Steel, Co-Director of Freedom Agenda, testified on the need to reallocate funds from Rikers Island to community-based programs and services. She urged the city council to prioritize spending on …
6:03:50
·
144 sec
Testimony by Hailey Nolasco, Senior Director of Government Relations at the Center for Justice Innovation
Hailey Nolasco from the Center for Justice Innovation testified on the importance of sustained investment in community-driven solutions and fair interventions to address public safety concerns in New York City. …
6:06:17
·
118 sec
Testimony by Jane Fox, Chapter Chair of the Legal Aid Society Attorneys Chapter at Association of Legal Advocates and Attorneys, UAW Local 2325
Jane Fox, representing UAW Local 2325, testifies about the challenges faced by legal services workers in New York City, including underfunding, attrition, and a workload crisis. She requests full funding …
6:08:25
·
3 min
Testimony by Alice Mo, Public Affairs and Advocacy Associate at Homecrest Community Services, on Funding for Older Adult Services and AAPI Community Support
Alice Mo from Homecrest Community Services testified about the importance of funding for older adult services and AAPI community support in New York City. She highlighted the potential impact of …
6:11:58
·
174 sec
Testimony by Agnes Kim, Program Officer of Policy & Communications at Enterprise Community Partners, on Family Homelessness
Agnes Kim, representing the Family Homelessness Coalition, testifies on the urgent need to address the growing crisis of family homelessness in New York City. She highlights the dramatic increase in …
6:15:45
·
116 sec
Testimony by Nikita Boyce, Budget Policy Coordinator at Coalition for Asian American Children and Families (CACF)
Nikita Boyce, representing the Coalition for Asian American Children and Families (CACF), advocated for increased funding for Asian American and Pacific Islander (AAPI) communities in New York City. She highlighted …
6:17:46
·
3 min
Testimony by Thomas Gogan, Representative of Move the Money-NYC
Thomas Gogan, representing the Move the Money New York City Coalition, testified about the need to challenge federal budget priorities, particularly the high percentage of discretionary spending on military and …
6:20:56
·
164 sec
Testimony by Kimberly Olson, Executive Director of New York City Arts and Education Roundtable on Arts Education Funding
Kimberly Olson, Executive Director of the New York City Arts and Education Roundtable, testifies on behalf of the "It Starts With The Arts" coalition and the coalition for equitable education …
6:23:43
·
137 sec
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson, Member of the Public
Christopher Leon Johnson testifies to advocate for protections for delivery workers, specifically supporting Intro 992 and requesting funding for nonprofits to support this initiative. He urges Council Member Brannan to …
6:26:36
·
142 sec
Testimony by Sharon Brown on Funding Priorities for New York City
Sharon Brown testified on various funding priorities for New York City, focusing on Jewish community safety, anti-Semitism prevention, homelessness, and police funding. She emphasized the importance of recognizing Israel's connection …
6:29:02
·
151 sec
Testimony by Miss Lopez Martinez, Director of Pa'lante Green Cleans
Miss Lopez Martinez, director of Pa'lante Green Cleans, testified about the importance of worker cooperatives in New York City's economy and advocated for support to fight unemployment and promote economic …
6:35:20
·
6 min
Testimony by Elizabeth Polanco, Leader of the Council for Advocacy of Corporations in New York and Worker at RADI Consulting NYC
Elizabeth Polanco testified about the importance of worker cooperatives in New York City, highlighting their role in providing various services and contributing to economic growth. She emphasized the need for …
6:42:26
·
6 min
Testimony by Juan Cuautle, Director of the Cooperative Development Program at Center for Family Life in Sunset Park
Juan Cuautle, representing the Center for Family Life in Sunset Park, requests continued support for the Worker Cooperative Business Development Initiative (WCBDI) with an allocation of $5,110,000 for fiscal year …
6:49:46
·
130 sec
Testimony by Melat Seyoum, Director of Political Affairs and Strategic Partnerships at New York City Network of Worker Cooperatives (NYC NOWC)
Melat Seyoum from NYC NOWC testified before the NYC Council Committee on Finance, requesting continued support for the expansion of worker ownership in the next year's budget. She highlighted the …
6:52:05
·
138 sec
Testimony by Scott Trumbull, Co-Executive Director of The Working World
Scott Trumbull, Co-Executive Director of The Working World, testified to encourage continued support for worker ownership in New York City by enhancing funding for the Worker Cooperative Business Development Initiative …
6:54:34
·
130 sec
Testimony by Carlyn Cowen, Chief Policy and Public Affairs Officer of Chinese American Planning Council (CPC)
Carlyn Cowen from the Chinese American Planning Council (CPC) testified about the impact of current policies on immigrant communities and stressed the need for proactive investment in human services and …
6:56:54
·
137 sec
Testimony by Sierra Kraft, Executive Director of Immigrant Children Advocates' Relief Effort (ICARE)
Sierra Kraft, Executive Director of ICARE, testifies to request increased funding for legal services for unaccompanied immigrant children in New York City. She emphasizes the critical need for legal representation …
6:59:19
·
129 sec
Testimony by Kevin Lee, Parent Advocate from Forest Hills, Queens
Kevin Lee, a parent advocate from Forest Hills, Queens, testified to the NYC Council Committee on Finance, urging for increased funding and improvements in early childhood education and after-school programs. …
7:01:35
·
124 sec
Testimony by Sienna Fontaine, Legal Director / General Counsel of Make The Road New York
Sienna Fontaine, representing Make The Road New York, testified about the critical services their organization provides to immigrant and working-class communities in NYC. She urged the city council to reverse …
7:03:47
·
132 sec
Testimony by Matthew Weber, Advocate for NYC Retirees
Matthew Weber, an advocate for NYC Retirees, testified about preserving promised retirement health care benefits for city employees and retirees. He criticized the mayor's efforts to appeal court rulings and …
7:06:23
·
79 sec
Testimony by Akiana Smith, Director of Community + Court Peer Navigation at Women's Community Justice Association (WCJA)
Akiana Smith, representing the Women's Community Justice Association (WCJA), testified about the importance of court peer navigation for justice-impacted women and gender-expansive individuals. She emphasized the need for community-based alternatives …
7:07:51
·
98 sec
Testimony by Marianne Pizzitola, President of New York City Organization of Public Service Retirees, on Retiree Health Care Benefits
Marianne Pizzitola, representing 250,000 municipal retirees, argues against attempts to change retiree health care benefits that have been protected by law since 1967. She criticizes union leaders for trying to …
7:09:38
·
102 sec
Testimony by Audacia Ray, Interim Executive Director of New York City Anti-Violence Project
Audacia Ray, Interim Executive Director of the New York City Anti-Violence Project, testified about their organization's services for LGBTQ survivors of violence and their funding priorities for the next fiscal …
7:11:31
·
127 sec
Testimony by Tierra Labrada, Director of Policy and Advocacy at Supportive Housing Network of New York
Tierra Labrada from the Supportive Housing Network of New York testified about their plan for 1515 reallocation and requested continued support from the council to codify the plan in the …
7:13:45
·
104 sec