Vanessa Gibson, Bronx Borough President, on City of Yes for Housing Opportunity zoning proposal
3:11:21
·
8 min
Vanessa Gibson, Bronx Borough President, offers her perspective on the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal. She supports most aspects of the plan with conditions, emphasizing the need for affordable housing and balanced development across all New York City neighborhoods.
- Gibson supports proposals for town center zoning, transit-oriented development, and the legalization of Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs), but calls for increased Department of Buildings inspectors to ensure safety.
- She opposes the removal of parking mandates, particularly in transit-poor areas of the Bronx, and does not support increasing small and shared housing units at the expense of family-sized apartments.
- Gibson stresses the importance of community engagement, preserving neighborhood character, and ensuring access to city services for all residents.
- Supports most of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal with conditions
- Emphasizes the need for affordable housing and homeownership opportunities
- Supports creating more housing in every neighborhood across all 59 community boards
- Advocates for maintaining neighborhood character and investing in existing communities
- Supports legalizing ADUs but calls for increased inspections and community engagement
- Supports infill development on NYCHA campuses with focus on housing for working-class families and seniors
- Opposes decreasing the dwelling unit factor and increasing small and shared housing
- Advocates for more 2 and 3 bedroom apartments for families
- Opposes removal of parking mandates, especially in transit-poor areas of the Bronx
- Commends efforts to streamline zoning regulations but emphasizes need for careful implementation
[EXPERIMENTAL]
Which elements of City of Yes for Housing Opportunity were discussed in this testimony?
- Town Center Zoning
- Parking Mandates
- ADU
- Transit-Oriented Development
- Campuses
- Small and Shared Housing
The following are AI-extracted quotes and reasoning about which elements of the proposal were discussed in this testimony.
This is a quick, close approximation. Occasionally, the connection between a testimony's transcript and specific elements of City Planning's proposal is tenuous.
Read about this AI-generated analysis here.
Town Center Zoning
"The town center is owning, transit orient, to development and district fixes, those proposals will add slightly more density while limiting any maximum height increases to moderate density areas."
This quote directly mentions 'town center zoning' as part of the proposals being discussed, indicating that the speaker is addressing this element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity proposal.
Parking Mandates
"In addition, I also do not support the removal of parking mandates. No surprise there. I'll tell you why. This proposal may work in many high density areas with significant access to transit, but simply put, it does not work in many neighborhoods in the Bronx."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to remove parking mandates, which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses her opposition to this element, particularly for areas in the Bronx with limited transit access.
"There's already significant parking competition in many of these same neighborhoods, and they believe that it would get much worse without mandates. We can highly suggest, but without a mandate, developers are not going to build parking because it's costly and because they don't always find that people utilize it."
This quote further elaborates on the speaker's concerns about removing parking mandates, highlighting the potential negative impacts on neighborhoods with existing parking issues and the likelihood that developers would not voluntarily include parking without mandates.
ADU
"I am absolutely in favor of the proposal to legalize the development of ADUs. However, I wanna note that there is a significant concern with this proposal that I raised to all of you today because allowing this new unit type in our city absolutely must come with an increase in the amount of inspectors at the Department of Buildings, DOB, to protect residents, safety, and their overall well-being."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to legalize Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs), which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses support for this element while also raising concerns about implementation and safety.
Transit-Oriented Development
"The town center is owning, transit orient, to development and district fixes, those proposals will add slightly more density while limiting any maximum height increases to moderate density areas. By focusing on areas within a half mile of transit, We can ensure that everyone can truly get around the Bronx and the Sea without adding more cars to our already congested streets."
This quote directly mentions 'transit orient[ed] development' as part of the proposals being discussed. The speaker also elaborates on the benefits of focusing development near transit, which is a key aspect of transit-oriented development.
Campuses
"When it comes to the infill development proposal, particularly on night shift campuses, the city must actively engage with residents and tenant association leadership. To ensure that their concerns are taken into account, infill development should have a focus on providing housing for working class families, older adults, and particularly those that already live in Nitro."
This quote discusses infill development on NYCHA campuses, which aligns with the Campuses element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity proposal. The speaker emphasizes the need for community engagement and prioritizing housing for existing residents and working-class families.
"We've seen through the prior administration in the Bronx. We have Millbrook Terrace. We have the development on the Morris 2 development project that's happening as well as Casa Salina that was open a few weeks ago on the Sultamayur campus. So we've already seen what we can do when we work with nonprofits, and we build senior housing on underutilized night shift land."
This quote provides examples of existing campus developments in the Bronx, demonstrating that the speaker is familiar with and discussing the concept of utilizing campus spaces for housing development, which is part of the Campuses element of the proposal.
Small and Shared Housing
"I do not support the proposal to increase small and shared housing and to decrease the Duf. The dwelling unit factor, and let me explain why. The Bronx is already seeing an influx of smaller and smaller and smaller units and many of these new development projects."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to increase small and shared housing, which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses opposition to this element, citing concerns about the proliferation of smaller units in the Bronx.
"And throughout my tenure as borrower president, you all know, I've consistently advocated for building more units that have 2 and 3 bedroom apartments. We need larger units that work for families, not just single adults."
This quote further elaborates on the speaker's opposition to the small and shared housing proposal, emphasizing the need for larger family-sized units instead of smaller units targeted at single adults.
About this analysis:
This analysis is done by AI that reasons whether or not a quote from the testimony discusses a particular element of the proposal.
All the prompts and data are open and available on Github.
You can search for testimonies that mentioned a specific element in the table on the main meeting page.
When an element is explicitly stated in the testimony (e.g. "Universal Affordability Preference" or "UAP"), the analysis is accurate.
But the connection between a quote from the testimony and an element of the proposal is sometimes implicit.
In these cases, the AI might eagerly label a testimony as discussing a proposal when the connection is tenuous, or it might omit it entirely.
Follow-up discussion/remarks
Chair Garodnick inquires about Bronx residents' housing expansion preferences
3:19:59
·
169 sec
Chair Dan Garodnick asks Bronx Borough President Vanessa Gibson about housing options Bronx residents might want to see for expanding their homes or making changes to their properties. Gibson responds by discussing the potential benefits and challenges of Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) in the Bronx.
- Gibson supports ADUs as a way to regulate and improve safety for existing unofficial home additions
- She emphasizes the need for increased Department of Buildings staffing to ensure proper oversight and inspections
- Gibson highlights that ADUs can help accommodate growing families, returning college graduates, and elderly relatives
- Supports most of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal with conditions
- Emphasizes the need for affordable housing and homeownership opportunities
- Supports creating more housing in every neighborhood across all 59 community boards
- Advocates for maintaining neighborhood character and investing in existing communities
- Supports legalizing ADUs but calls for increased inspections and community engagement
- Supports infill development on NYCHA campuses with focus on housing for working-class families and seniors
- Opposes decreasing the dwelling unit factor and increasing small and shared housing
- Advocates for more 2 and 3 bedroom apartments for families
- Opposes removal of parking mandates, especially in transit-poor areas of the Bronx
- Commends efforts to streamline zoning regulations but emphasizes need for careful implementation
[EXPERIMENTAL]
Which elements of City of Yes for Housing Opportunity were discussed in this testimony?
- Town Center Zoning
- Parking Mandates
- ADU
- Transit-Oriented Development
- Campuses
- Small and Shared Housing
The following are AI-extracted quotes and reasoning about which elements of the proposal were discussed in this testimony.
This is a quick, close approximation. Occasionally, the connection between a testimony's transcript and specific elements of City Planning's proposal is tenuous.
Read about this AI-generated analysis here.
Town Center Zoning
"The town center is owning, transit orient, to development and district fixes, those proposals will add slightly more density while limiting any maximum height increases to moderate density areas."
This quote directly mentions 'town center zoning' as part of the proposals being discussed, indicating that the speaker is addressing this element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity proposal.
Parking Mandates
"In addition, I also do not support the removal of parking mandates. No surprise there. I'll tell you why. This proposal may work in many high density areas with significant access to transit, but simply put, it does not work in many neighborhoods in the Bronx."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to remove parking mandates, which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses her opposition to this element, particularly for areas in the Bronx with limited transit access.
"There's already significant parking competition in many of these same neighborhoods, and they believe that it would get much worse without mandates. We can highly suggest, but without a mandate, developers are not going to build parking because it's costly and because they don't always find that people utilize it."
This quote further elaborates on the speaker's concerns about removing parking mandates, highlighting the potential negative impacts on neighborhoods with existing parking issues and the likelihood that developers would not voluntarily include parking without mandates.
ADU
"I am absolutely in favor of the proposal to legalize the development of ADUs. However, I wanna note that there is a significant concern with this proposal that I raised to all of you today because allowing this new unit type in our city absolutely must come with an increase in the amount of inspectors at the Department of Buildings, DOB, to protect residents, safety, and their overall well-being."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to legalize Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs), which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses support for this element while also raising concerns about implementation and safety.
Transit-Oriented Development
"The town center is owning, transit orient, to development and district fixes, those proposals will add slightly more density while limiting any maximum height increases to moderate density areas. By focusing on areas within a half mile of transit, We can ensure that everyone can truly get around the Bronx and the Sea without adding more cars to our already congested streets."
This quote directly mentions 'transit orient[ed] development' as part of the proposals being discussed. The speaker also elaborates on the benefits of focusing development near transit, which is a key aspect of transit-oriented development.
Campuses
"When it comes to the infill development proposal, particularly on night shift campuses, the city must actively engage with residents and tenant association leadership. To ensure that their concerns are taken into account, infill development should have a focus on providing housing for working class families, older adults, and particularly those that already live in Nitro."
This quote discusses infill development on NYCHA campuses, which aligns with the Campuses element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity proposal. The speaker emphasizes the need for community engagement and prioritizing housing for existing residents and working-class families.
"We've seen through the prior administration in the Bronx. We have Millbrook Terrace. We have the development on the Morris 2 development project that's happening as well as Casa Salina that was open a few weeks ago on the Sultamayur campus. So we've already seen what we can do when we work with nonprofits, and we build senior housing on underutilized night shift land."
This quote provides examples of existing campus developments in the Bronx, demonstrating that the speaker is familiar with and discussing the concept of utilizing campus spaces for housing development, which is part of the Campuses element of the proposal.
Small and Shared Housing
"I do not support the proposal to increase small and shared housing and to decrease the Duf. The dwelling unit factor, and let me explain why. The Bronx is already seeing an influx of smaller and smaller and smaller units and many of these new development projects."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to increase small and shared housing, which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses opposition to this element, citing concerns about the proliferation of smaller units in the Bronx.
"And throughout my tenure as borrower president, you all know, I've consistently advocated for building more units that have 2 and 3 bedroom apartments. We need larger units that work for families, not just single adults."
This quote further elaborates on the speaker's opposition to the small and shared housing proposal, emphasizing the need for larger family-sized units instead of smaller units targeted at single adults.
About this analysis:
This analysis is done by AI that reasons whether or not a quote from the testimony discusses a particular element of the proposal.
All the prompts and data are open and available on Github.
You can search for testimonies that mentioned a specific element in the table on the main meeting page.
When an element is explicitly stated in the testimony (e.g. "Universal Affordability Preference" or "UAP"), the analysis is accurate.
But the connection between a quote from the testimony and an element of the proposal is sometimes implicit.
In these cases, the AI might eagerly label a testimony as discussing a proposal when the connection is tenuous, or it might omit it entirely.
Commissioner Benjamin inquires about transit-oriented development in the Bronx
3:22:56
·
131 sec
Commissioner Gail Benjamin asks Bronx Borough President Vanessa Gibson about the possibility of implementing a more tailored transit-oriented development (TOD) approach in areas of the Bronx with limited public transportation options. Gibson responds by discussing the potential impact of upcoming Metro North stations and the need to balance development with parking concerns in transit-poor neighborhoods.
- Gibson supports a modified TOD approach that considers areas within half a mile of Metro North stations or subway lines
- She highlights the importance of maintaining parking mandates in areas defined as 'transit deserts,' more than half a mile from local subways
- The Borough President emphasizes the need to balance future transit improvements with the current reliance on cars in certain Bronx neighborhoods
- Supports most of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal with conditions
- Emphasizes the need for affordable housing and homeownership opportunities
- Supports creating more housing in every neighborhood across all 59 community boards
- Advocates for maintaining neighborhood character and investing in existing communities
- Supports legalizing ADUs but calls for increased inspections and community engagement
- Supports infill development on NYCHA campuses with focus on housing for working-class families and seniors
- Opposes decreasing the dwelling unit factor and increasing small and shared housing
- Advocates for more 2 and 3 bedroom apartments for families
- Opposes removal of parking mandates, especially in transit-poor areas of the Bronx
- Commends efforts to streamline zoning regulations but emphasizes need for careful implementation
[EXPERIMENTAL]
Which elements of City of Yes for Housing Opportunity were discussed in this testimony?
- Town Center Zoning
- Parking Mandates
- ADU
- Transit-Oriented Development
- Campuses
- Small and Shared Housing
The following are AI-extracted quotes and reasoning about which elements of the proposal were discussed in this testimony.
This is a quick, close approximation. Occasionally, the connection between a testimony's transcript and specific elements of City Planning's proposal is tenuous.
Read about this AI-generated analysis here.
Town Center Zoning
"The town center is owning, transit orient, to development and district fixes, those proposals will add slightly more density while limiting any maximum height increases to moderate density areas."
This quote directly mentions 'town center zoning' as part of the proposals being discussed, indicating that the speaker is addressing this element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity proposal.
Parking Mandates
"In addition, I also do not support the removal of parking mandates. No surprise there. I'll tell you why. This proposal may work in many high density areas with significant access to transit, but simply put, it does not work in many neighborhoods in the Bronx."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to remove parking mandates, which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses her opposition to this element, particularly for areas in the Bronx with limited transit access.
"There's already significant parking competition in many of these same neighborhoods, and they believe that it would get much worse without mandates. We can highly suggest, but without a mandate, developers are not going to build parking because it's costly and because they don't always find that people utilize it."
This quote further elaborates on the speaker's concerns about removing parking mandates, highlighting the potential negative impacts on neighborhoods with existing parking issues and the likelihood that developers would not voluntarily include parking without mandates.
ADU
"I am absolutely in favor of the proposal to legalize the development of ADUs. However, I wanna note that there is a significant concern with this proposal that I raised to all of you today because allowing this new unit type in our city absolutely must come with an increase in the amount of inspectors at the Department of Buildings, DOB, to protect residents, safety, and their overall well-being."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to legalize Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs), which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses support for this element while also raising concerns about implementation and safety.
Transit-Oriented Development
"The town center is owning, transit orient, to development and district fixes, those proposals will add slightly more density while limiting any maximum height increases to moderate density areas. By focusing on areas within a half mile of transit, We can ensure that everyone can truly get around the Bronx and the Sea without adding more cars to our already congested streets."
This quote directly mentions 'transit orient[ed] development' as part of the proposals being discussed. The speaker also elaborates on the benefits of focusing development near transit, which is a key aspect of transit-oriented development.
Campuses
"When it comes to the infill development proposal, particularly on night shift campuses, the city must actively engage with residents and tenant association leadership. To ensure that their concerns are taken into account, infill development should have a focus on providing housing for working class families, older adults, and particularly those that already live in Nitro."
This quote discusses infill development on NYCHA campuses, which aligns with the Campuses element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity proposal. The speaker emphasizes the need for community engagement and prioritizing housing for existing residents and working-class families.
"We've seen through the prior administration in the Bronx. We have Millbrook Terrace. We have the development on the Morris 2 development project that's happening as well as Casa Salina that was open a few weeks ago on the Sultamayur campus. So we've already seen what we can do when we work with nonprofits, and we build senior housing on underutilized night shift land."
This quote provides examples of existing campus developments in the Bronx, demonstrating that the speaker is familiar with and discussing the concept of utilizing campus spaces for housing development, which is part of the Campuses element of the proposal.
Small and Shared Housing
"I do not support the proposal to increase small and shared housing and to decrease the Duf. The dwelling unit factor, and let me explain why. The Bronx is already seeing an influx of smaller and smaller and smaller units and many of these new development projects."
This quote directly addresses the proposal to increase small and shared housing, which is a key element of the City of Yes For Housing Opportunity plan. The speaker expresses opposition to this element, citing concerns about the proliferation of smaller units in the Bronx.
"And throughout my tenure as borrower president, you all know, I've consistently advocated for building more units that have 2 and 3 bedroom apartments. We need larger units that work for families, not just single adults."
This quote further elaborates on the speaker's opposition to the small and shared housing proposal, emphasizing the need for larger family-sized units instead of smaller units targeted at single adults.
About this analysis:
This analysis is done by AI that reasons whether or not a quote from the testimony discusses a particular element of the proposal.
All the prompts and data are open and available on Github.
You can search for testimonies that mentioned a specific element in the table on the main meeting page.
When an element is explicitly stated in the testimony (e.g. "Universal Affordability Preference" or "UAP"), the analysis is accurate.
But the connection between a quote from the testimony and an element of the proposal is sometimes implicit.
In these cases, the AI might eagerly label a testimony as discussing a proposal when the connection is tenuous, or it might omit it entirely.