The citymeetings.nyc logo showing a pigeon at a podium with a microphone.

citymeetings.nyc

Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.

PUBLIC TESTIMONY

Testimony by Janet Morgan on Randy Mastro's Support for Racial Justice

9:40:28

·

7 min

Janet Morgan testifies in support of Randy Mastro's nomination, sharing her personal experience of how Mastro represented her pro bono in a case involving her suspension as a teacher for assigning an essay on racism. She emphasizes Mastro's commitment to racial and social justice, and his crucial role in saving her career and financial stability.

  • Morgan describes Mastro as intervening like "divine providence" during her greatest crisis
  • She highlights that her case from the late 1980s was a precursor to current debates about teaching race in schools
  • Morgan urges the council to consider how Mastro has fought for people of color and social justice
Janet Morgan
9:40:28
Good evening, honorable speaker Adams, chairperson, the proceedings, the members of the city council who who are still here.
9:40:46
My name is Janet Morgan, and I'm here to testify to my support for Randy Mastro.
9:40:55
I have to say though, I feel kind of like Barack Obama, who didn't wanna come after, you know, speak after Michelle, And I'm speaking after a a host of people today, I have to say also that sadly Rudy Giuliani has loomed over these proceedings like a Shakespearean apparition, a specter, Van Close ghost to which I would say in the words of Lady Macbeth out damned spot.
9:41:37
We're here to talk about someone who is in 1 Iota like Rudy Giuliani.
9:41:48
Randy Mastro who was my attorney in the greatest crisis I ever faced in my life.
9:41:58
On the morning in the spring of 1990, my phone rang On the other end of the line was the voice of someone I did not know, Randy Mastro.
9:42:12
Having followed my case, my suspension, for now, 2 years from my social studies teaching position in the Malvern School District on Long Island suspended because of an essay I had assigned my students on racism.
9:42:34
Randy was calling to offer to represent me pro bono.
9:42:43
Randy Mastro's call came the morning after a brutal examination before trial regarding the civil rights lawsuit I had, by then, I was suspended in 1988.
9:42:59
I had filed against Malvern.
9:43:03
I was so nauseous.
9:43:06
I was praying.
9:43:07
I would not throw up Walmister Mastro was on the phone.
9:43:13
Divine providence intervened, I believe, and I do believe that.
9:43:20
Because of that, I was able to continue with the call.
9:43:24
The reason the school superintendent involved himself in the matter of an assignment that teacher makes, which is unusual, was that a parent, a white parent, had called the superintendent and complained about my essay assignment.
9:43:45
A week or so after the essays had been graded and returned to students, my share person informed me that the superintendent wanted me to resend the assignment.
9:43:58
Unable, of course, to resend an assignment might chair person returned with the order now, discount the students grades, the grades that they had made on the essay.
9:44:15
Apps served an order unthinkable to even consider such.
9:44:21
I refused.
9:44:24
On the Friday of the beginning of the Memorial Day weekend, the superintendent's Terry came to me at the end of the day with a letter informing me of my suspension.
9:44:35
My students' 5 classes would return to class on Monday, their teacher gone.
9:44:42
1992 years into the suspension, the state commission of education made his ruling that Malvern had made an impermissible intrusion into my classroom.
9:44:56
And ordered my reinstatement to my teaching position.
9:45:00
That would not be the end from Malvern, appeal the commissioner's ruling to the Supreme Court of the state of New York.
9:45:12
This was when Randy Massaro assumed all matters related to my cases with a passion for right and a consummate zeal with social justice and the skill of one of the nation's best.
9:45:31
Randy Mastro traveled to Albany to argue my case before the Supreme Court there.
9:45:43
Consider that three and a half decades before what is branded and besmirched now as DEI hiring of blacks, me, and CRT critical race teaching a time when across this nation, my essay, may likewise be banned.
9:46:08
It is deja vu.
9:46:11
My case, a precursor, three and a half decades ago, before.
9:46:20
There's no doubting certainly in my mind that Randy Mastro had he not come into my life I would have had no more career.
9:46:35
I was financially destitute when I mortgaged my my home.
9:46:42
I'm I was single at that point.
9:46:46
I had a mortgage.
9:46:47
I mortgaged my home again.
9:46:51
Had he not come into my life and taken my cases over, I would not have had a career at age forty eight, still a few years at that point before retirement, I would have remained financially destitute.
9:47:14
In addition to the fact that he the fight for me, he won the case before the Supreme Court.
9:47:25
And He also represented me on my civil rights case and managed a won a settlement for me that restored me to, you know, financial health.
9:47:53
I I hope in spite of some of the things that have been said here today, you will seriously consider people like me, you know, people of color.
9:48:04
I mean, this is a man who fights for people of color.
9:48:08
I believe you can entrust into into him the position.
9:48:14
I believe he will fight for all people, certainly fighting for people for of color, racial justice, social justice, and thank you very much for your consideration.
Citymeetings.nyc pigeon logo

Is citymeetings.nyc useful to you?

I'm thrilled!

Please help me out by answering just one question.

What do you do?

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date? Sign up for the newsletter.