New York City Council
City of Yes for Housing Opportunity, Day 1: DCP + HPD Hearing
Oct 21, 2024
·
10:30 AM
5 hr 59 min
Summary
Day 1 of the NYC Council's hearing on the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity zoning proposal.
This hearing features:
- Testimony from Department of City Planning (DCP)
- Testimony from Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD)
- Questioning by the council
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Introduction to the City of Yes hearing
Council Member Kevin C. Riley opens the New York City Council subcommittee hearing on zoning and franchises. He introduces the City of Yes initiative and its three major components, with …
0:00:52
·
4 min
Explanation of the hearing's structure and accessibility for the Zoning for Housing Opportunity (ZHO) proposal
Council Member Riley outlines the structure and accessibility of the hearing on Zoning for Housing Opportunity (ZHO). He explains the two-day format and the availability of translation services. - Today's …
0:05:07
·
165 sec
Overview of the current housing crisis in New York City
Council Member Riley addresses the severe housing crisis facing New York City and its communities. He highlights the difficulties residents face in finding affordable and suitable housing. - Many constituents …
0:07:52
·
49 sec
Root causes of the housing crisis in New York City
Council Member Riley outlines the two main causes of the housing crisis in New York City: insufficient housing production and income inequality. - New York City has not built enough …
0:08:42
·
117 sec
Concerns about the administration's approach to City of Yes for Housing Opportunity
Council Member Riley expresses concerns about the administration's approach to the Zoning for Housing Opportunity (ZHO) proposal. He criticizes the lack of community involvement in crafting the proposal. - The …
0:10:40
·
44 sec
Importance of community involvement and infrastructure improvements in housing development
Council Member Riley emphasizes the critical need for community involvement in the housing development process and the importance of addressing infrastructure needs alongside new housing construction. - Communities should be …
0:11:25
·
40 sec
Emphasis on affordable housing and home ownership opportunities
Council Member Riley stresses the need for more affordable housing and increased home ownership opportunities in New York City, particularly for Black and Brown families. - Zoning alone cannot create …
0:12:07
·
53 sec
Speaker Adams addresses the housing crisis and zoning reform proposal
Speaker Adrienne E. Adams addresses the New York City Council subcommittee on zoning and franchises, discussing the severe housing crisis in the city and the proposed City of Yes for …
0:13:00
·
4 min
Council Member Salamanca addresses housing crisis and zoning proposal concerns
Council Member Rafael Salamanca, Jr. acknowledges the housing crisis in New York City but emphasizes the need for responsive and diverse neighborhood-specific solutions. He highlights concerns about the proposed zoning …
0:17:07
·
142 sec
Introduction and setting the stage for the City of Yes proposal
Daniel Garodnick, Chair of the NYC City Planning Commission, introduces himself and thanks the council members for the opportunity to discuss the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal. He …
0:20:38
·
24 sec
Overview of New York City's severe housing crisis
Garodnick outlines the severe housing crisis gripping New York City, emphasizing its long-standing nature and widespread impact on residents. He argues that this crisis affects everyone and presents it as …
0:21:02
·
71 sec
Statistical evidence of NYC's housing shortage and its impacts
Garodnick presents compelling statistics to illustrate the severity of New York City's housing crisis, focusing on vacancy rates, rent burden, and homelessness. These figures provide a clear picture of the …
0:22:14
·
31 sec
Causes of NYC's housing shortage and uneven development
Garodnick explains the root causes of New York City's housing shortage, highlighting insufficient housing production, changing household demographics, and restrictive zoning rules. He also points out the uneven distribution of …
0:22:47
·
58 sec
Human consequences of the NYC housing crisis
Garodnick outlines the various human consequences of New York City's housing crisis, emphasizing its impact on residents' quality of life and financial stability. He highlights how the crisis affects different …
0:23:46
·
59 sec
Economic impacts of the housing crisis on businesses and job growth
Garodnick explains how the housing crisis negatively affects businesses and job growth in New York City. He emphasizes the ripple effects of high housing costs on the local economy and …
0:24:48
·
31 sec
Overview of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal
Garodnick introduces the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal, explaining its core principles and how it aims to address the housing crisis in New York City. He emphasizes the …
0:25:19
·
154 sec
Proposed changes for low-density neighborhoods
Garodnick outlines the proposed changes for low-density neighborhoods as part of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. He explains the current state of these areas and the rationale …
0:27:55
·
107 sec
Town center zoning and transit-oriented development in low-density areas
Garodnick explains two key proposals for increasing housing in low-density areas: town center zoning and transit-oriented development. These initiatives aim to create more housing opportunities in strategic locations within low-density …
0:29:41
·
3 min
Introducing Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) in low-density neighborhoods
Garodnick presents the proposal to allow Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) in low-density neighborhoods as part of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. He explains the benefits and details …
0:32:56
·
3 min
Issues with current zoning in low-density districts
Garodnick discusses the problems with current zoning regulations in low-density districts of New York City. He highlights how zoning complexity has made it practically impossible to build two-family homes in …
0:36:20
·
57 sec
Proposed changes to streamline zoning rules
Garodnick outlines the proposed changes to streamline zoning rules in low-density districts. The goal is to make it possible once again to build appropriate housing types in these areas. - …
0:37:20
·
26 sec
Addressing challenges of non-conforming buildings
Garodnick discusses issues faced by homeowners with buildings that are out of compliance with current zoning rules. He highlights the difficulties these homeowners face and proposes solutions. - Many older …
0:37:49
·
23 sec
Addressing concerns about neighborhood changes in low-density areas
Garodnick addresses concerns about potential drastic changes to low-density areas as a result of the proposed zoning changes. He argues that the changes would be modest and not disruptive to …
0:38:12
·
90 sec
Proposed changes for medium and high-density neighborhoods: Universal Affordability Preference
Garodnick introduces the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) as a key proposal for medium and high-density neighborhoods in the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. This proposal aims to increase …
0:39:43
·
3 min
Updates to Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH) options and other medium/high-density proposals
Garodnick outlines proposed updates to the Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH) program and other changes for medium and high-density neighborhoods as part of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. …
0:42:59
·
5 min
Lifting parking mandates to increase housing production
Garodnick presents the proposal to lift parking mandates citywide as part of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. He explains the rationale behind this change and its potential …
0:48:47
·
4 min
Expanding opportunities for building conversions to housing
Garodnick outlines the proposal to expand opportunities for converting non-residential buildings into housing as part of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. He explains the current limitations and …
0:53:34
·
3 min
Relegalizing small apartments and shared housing
Garodnick presents the proposal to relegalize small apartments and shared housing as part of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. He explains the historical context and the potential …
0:56:57
·
3 min
Creating new zoning districts with higher Floor Area Ratios (FARs)
Garodnick introduces the proposal to create new zoning districts with higher Floor Area Ratios (FARs) as part of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. This proposal aims to …
1:00:18
·
73 sec
Simplifying processes for certain developments
Garodnick outlines several proposals to simplify and streamline processes for certain types of developments as part of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity initiative. These changes aim to remove …
1:01:34
·
5 min
Environmental impact assessment and infrastructure considerations
Garodnick discusses the environmental review process for the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal and addresses concerns about infrastructure impacts. He explains the methodology used and the findings of …
1:06:51
·
4 min
Racial equity report and fair housing goals
Garodnick explains how the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal addresses racial equity and fair housing goals. He discusses the proposal's alignment with the city's fair housing plan and …
1:11:10
·
83 sec
Timeline of the proposal development and public review process
Garodnick presents a detailed timeline of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal's development and public review process. He highlights key milestones and the extensive public engagement involved. - …
1:12:35
·
102 sec
Conclusion and expected outcomes of the City of Yes proposal
Garodnick concludes his presentation by summarizing the key aspects of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal and its expected outcomes. He emphasizes the proposal's comprehensive approach to addressing …
1:14:17
·
129 sec
Introduction and context of City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal
Council Member Riley initiates a discussion about the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity zoning proposal, seeking to understand how it was developed. He expresses concerns about the proposal being …
1:16:28
·
83 sec
Explanation of how the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity accounts for NYC's unique characteristics
Chair Garodnick explains how the zoning proposal accounts for New York City's unique characteristics while drawing on successful practices from other cities. He emphasizes that while some aspects are unique …
1:17:52
·
138 sec
Discussion on how zoning affects the housing market and affordability
Chair Garodnick explains the relationship between zoning, the housing market, and affordability in response to Council Member Riley's questions. He emphasizes that this proposal is the most pro-housing policy in …
1:20:10
·
145 sec
Provisions in the proposal directly impacting affordability
Chair Garodnick outlines specific provisions in the zoning proposal that directly impact affordability and the development of affordable housing. He emphasizes that creating more housing opportunities will lead to more …
1:22:36
·
79 sec
Additional non-zoning policy changes to address housing affordability
Chair Garodnick and Commissioner Carrión discuss additional non-zoning policy changes and investments that can help address housing affordability in New York City. They emphasize that while zoning is critical, it's …
1:23:56
·
4 min
Community engagement in developing the proposal
Chair Garodnick discusses the extensive community engagement process that went into developing the zoning proposal. He emphasizes the administration's efforts to involve community boards and other stakeholders in the process. …
1:28:44
·
3 min
Impact on special districts and neighborhood context
Chair Garodnick addresses concerns about the proposal's impact on special districts and neighborhood context. He explains how the proposal aims to balance citywide housing needs with respect for existing neighborhood …
1:31:53
·
121 sec
The role of neighborhood planning in NYC
Chair Garodnick emphasizes the continued importance of neighborhood planning in New York City, explaining how it complements the citywide zoning proposal. He contrasts the density potential of neighborhood plans with …
1:33:53
·
121 sec
Programs to help homeowners afford and navigate ADU development
Chair Garodnick and Commissioner Carrión discuss programs and strategies to help homeowners afford and navigate the process of developing Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs). They emphasize the potential benefits of ADUs …
1:35:54
·
5 min
Clarification on the Sliver Law in non-contextual districts
Council Member Riley seeks clarification on the application of the Sliver Law in non-contextual districts, and Chair Garodnick provides a brief confirmation. - Garodnick confirms that the Sliver Law will …
1:41:03
·
29 sec
Infrastructure concerns, particularly flooding issues in Council Member Riley's district
Council Member Riley raises concerns about infrastructure issues, particularly flooding, in his district and how the zoning proposal might impact these problems. Chair Garodnick responds to these concerns. - Riley …
1:41:32
·
3 min
Infrastructure concerns in Southeast Queens
Speaker Adams raises concerns about infrastructure, particularly flooding and sewer issues in Southeast Queens. Director Garodnick responds by explaining DEP's role in assessing and addressing these needs through its capital …
1:44:37
·
101 sec
Balancing rental housing and homeownership opportunities in new construction
Speaker Adams raises concerns about the imbalance between rental housing and homeownership opportunities in recent years, asking what the administration is doing beyond zoning to address this issue. - New …
1:46:17
·
76 sec
How the City of Yes proposal enables homeownership opportunities
Director Garodnick explains how the City of Yes proposal will create more opportunities for homeownership across the city. - The proposal reverses previous downzoning that decreased homeownership opportunities. - It …
1:47:33
·
106 sec
HPD's strategies for supporting existing homeowners and creating new homeownership opportunities
Commissioner Carrión outlines HPD's three-pronged strategy for supporting homeownership in New York City. - Focus on retaining and stabilizing existing homeowners to prevent the flight of moderate and middle-income families. …
1:49:19
·
152 sec
Alignment of City of Yes proposal with the Fair Housing Framework
Speaker Adams inquires about how the City of Yes zoning reform proposals fit into the Fair Housing Framework approach of planning for equitable housing growth. - The Fair Housing Framework, …
1:51:51
·
3 min
Preservation efforts needed to save existing affordable housing
Speaker Adams raises concerns about the loss of affordable housing units and asks about preservation efforts needed to save existing affordable housing. - The city has lost approximately half a …
1:54:54
·
104 sec
HPD's historical and current efforts in housing preservation
Commissioner Carrión outlines HPD's historical and current efforts in housing preservation. - Preservation work has historically been the majority of HPD's work, averaging 60-70% of financing. - Recent years have …
1:56:39
·
142 sec
Public Advocate's concerns about gentrification risks and recommendations for the City of Yes proposal
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams expresses concerns about the City of Yes proposal and offers recommendations for improvement. - Williams acknowledges the proposal's good intentions but highlights potential challenges, including gentrification …
1:59:27
·
5 min
Fair distribution of affordable housing across NYC boroughs
Council Member Salamanca raises concerns about the uneven distribution of affordable housing in NYC, particularly the burden on the Bronx. Director Garodnick acknowledges this issue and explains how the City …
2:04:49
·
101 sec
Incorporating homeownership opportunities in the universal affordability program
Council Member Salamanca proposes incorporating homeownership opportunities into the universal affordability program, specifically suggesting that the 20% bonus in the program could be used for homeownership in communities doing their …
2:06:30
·
107 sec
Delays in HPD financing and closing of approved housing projects
Council Member Salamanca raises concerns about significant delays in HPD financing and closing of approved housing projects, some waiting 4-6 years after rezoning approval. Commissioner Carrión explains the complexities of …
2:08:17
·
3 min
Impact of AMI changes on rent prices for delayed projects
Council Member Salamanca highlights how delays in project closings lead to increases in rent prices due to annual AMI changes, potentially doubling initial rent estimates. Commissioner Carrión explains that projects …
2:11:41
·
84 sec
Concerns about changes to single-family zoning and introduction of ADUs
Council Member Salamanca raises concerns about changes to single-family zoning and the introduction of ADUs, noting that only 14% of NYC is currently zoned for single-family homes. Chair Garodnick explains …
2:13:05
·
162 sec
Clarification on the scale of multifamily developments allowed in low-density neighborhoods
Council Member Salamanca seeks clarification on the scale of multifamily developments that would be allowed in 1 to 2 family neighborhoods under the City of Yes proposal. Chair Garodnick provides …
2:15:48
·
150 sec
Proposal to eliminate parking requirements citywide and its potential impacts
Council Member Salamanca questions the proposal to eliminate parking requirements citywide, expressing concerns about its one-size-fits-all approach. Chair Garodnick explains the rationale behind the proposal and addresses concerns about areas …
2:18:17
·
129 sec
Council Member Hanks' initial remarks on the City of Yes proposal's impact on Staten Island
Council Member Kamillah Hanks opens by acknowledging the challenges of the City of Yes proposal for her district in Staten Island. She highlights the unique characteristics of her heavily residential …
2:21:38
·
103 sec
Discussion on transit-oriented development in Staten Island
Council Member Hanks questions how the City Planning Department has addressed transit-oriented development in heavily residential areas like Staten Island. Chair Garodnick explains the proposal's approach to transit-oriented development in …
2:23:21
·
137 sec
Concerns about the blanket approach to zoning changes in Staten Island
Council Member Hanks expresses concerns about the blanket approach to zoning changes, suggesting it may not work well for Staten Island's unique circumstances. She emphasizes the need for a more …
2:25:39
·
62 sec
Discussion on affordable housing creation in Staten Island
Chair Garodnick responds to Council Member Hanks' concerns about Staten Island's contribution to affordable housing creation. He explains the proposal's approach to enabling housing development in various parts of Staten …
2:26:41
·
69 sec
Council Member Brewer questions City Planning on housing proposal details
Council Member Gale A. Brewer engages in a rapid-fire Q&A session with Daniel Garodnick, Chair of the NYC City Planning Commission, about various aspects of the proposed housing plan. Brewer …
2:27:51
·
3 min
Council member raises concerns about community engagement in zoning proposal
Council Member Lynn C. Schulman expresses concerns about the lack of community engagement in developing the zoning proposal, particularly regarding direct communication with homeowners and residents in affected neighborhoods. She …
2:31:50
·
3 min
Discussion on zoning proposal's impact on emergency services
Council Member Schulman inquires about consultations with emergency services regarding the effects of the proposed zoning text amendment. Chair Garodnick confirms that partner agencies have been contacted and emphasizes that …
2:34:58
·
88 sec
Addressing warehoused rent-stabilized apartments and vacancy rates
Council Member Schulman raises the issue of warehoused rent-stabilized apartments and questions why they aren't being prioritized over new construction. Chair Garodnick responds by emphasizing the severity of the housing …
2:36:27
·
103 sec
Comparison of Universal Affordable Preference (UAP) with other development incentives
Council Member Schulman questions the attractiveness of the Universal Affordable Preference (UAP) for developers compared to other available incentives. Chair Garodnick explains the specifics of the UAP and its focus …
2:38:17
·
109 sec
Council Member Abreu inquires about UAP program's affordability permanence
Council Member Shaun Abreu introduces the discussion and asks about the permanence of affordable housing created under the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) proposal. Chair Daniel Garodnick confirms that the affordable …
2:40:08
·
27 sec
Comparison of UAP to existing inclusionary housing programs
Council Member Abreu asks about how the proposed Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) program compares to existing inclusionary housing programs. Chair Garodnick explains the key distinctions between UAP and current programs. …
2:40:36
·
55 sec
Potential impact of UAP on affordable housing creation
Council Member Abreu inquires about the potential impact of the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) program if it had been in place across high-density districts over the past decade. Chair Garodnick …
2:41:31
·
13 sec
Interaction between UAP and state tax incentive program 485x
Council Member Abreu inquires about how the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) program interacts with the state's newly enacted tax incentive program 485x. Chair Garodnick explains the alignment between the two …
2:41:45
·
105 sec
Affordability concerns and strategies to reduce housing costs
Council Member Abreu raises concerns about the proposed 60% AMI average in the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) program, citing community feedback. Chair Garodnick responds by explaining the administration's approach to …
2:43:30
·
95 sec
Council Member Carr questions impact of ADUs on homeownership affordability
Council Member David Carr expresses concerns about the inclusion of accessory dwelling units (ADUs) in one-family zoning districts, arguing it could increase property values and make homeownership less affordable. Chair …
2:45:10
·
117 sec
Council Member Carr questions if proposal is a text amendment or mapping action
Council Member David Carr questions whether the zoning proposal is truly a text amendment or if it constitutes a mapping action due to changes in lot sizes and creation of …
2:47:27
·
102 sec
Council Member Carr raises concerns about infrastructure impacts of increased density
Council Member David Carr expresses strong concerns about the potential infrastructure impacts of increasing density, particularly on water and sewer systems. He questions the environmental review's conclusion of little to …
2:49:09
·
134 sec
Council Member Sanchez's introduction and appreciation
Council Member Pierina Ana Sanchez opens her remarks by expressing gratitude to Chair Riley, Chair Salamanca, Speaker Adams, and the Council Land Use team for their work on the City …
2:51:23
·
24 sec
Discussion on the scale of the zoning proposal and potential modifications
Council Member Sanchez raises concerns about the distribution of affordable housing across NYC boroughs and questions the scale of the proposed zoning changes. She asks if there are any modifications …
2:51:48
·
132 sec
Questions and answers about the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP)
Council Member Sanchez asks several questions about the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP), including how it balances different community concerns and projections for its impact. Chair Garodnick provides answers addressing these …
2:54:00
·
49 sec
Discussion on non-zoning policy changes for affordable housing
Council Member Sanchez inquires about effective non-zoning policy changes and investments that can quickly deliver real affordability in communities. Commissioner Carrión provides a detailed response outlining various strategies and initiatives. …
2:54:50
·
149 sec
Follow-up question about HPD staffing and budget
Council Member Sanchez asks a follow-up question about whether HPD needs more staffing and capital in their budget. Commissioner Carrión responds, addressing the agency's ongoing efforts to build capacity and …
2:57:22
·
40 sec
Council Member Brooks-Powers introduces Southeast Queens' housing challenges
Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers begins her remarks by acknowledging the housing crisis in New York City and emphasizing the need for comprehensive and equitable solutions. She introduces the unique …
2:58:12
·
16 sec
Importance of homeownership for generational wealth in Southeast Queens
Council Member Brooks-Powers emphasizes the critical role of homeownership in Southeast Queens as a pathway to generational wealth and stability for families. She expresses appreciation for the City of Yes …
2:58:28
·
21 sec
Infrastructure concerns in Southeast Queens, including flooding and parking
Council Member Brooks-Powers outlines the unique infrastructure challenges faced by Southeast Queens, particularly in relation to climate change and transportation. She emphasizes the need for smart growth that doesn't compromise …
2:58:50
·
44 sec
Questions about City Planning Commission's role in advancing homeownership opportunities
Council Member Brooks-Powers poses questions about the City Planning Commission's responsibility in advancing homeownership opportunities, particularly in areas like Southeast Queens where it's crucial for economic stability. - Emphasizes the …
2:59:34
·
34 sec
Concerns about increased density and infrastructure investments in Southeast Queens
Council Member Brooks-Powers raises concerns about the increased density proposed by the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity and its impact on infrastructure in Southeast Queens and Rockaway. She poses …
3:00:09
·
47 sec
Discussion on removal of parking mandates citywide and its impact on transit-poor areas
Council Member Brooks-Powers addresses the proposal to remove parking mandates citywide and expresses concerns about its impact on transit-poor areas like Southeast Queens. She emphasizes the need for a nuanced …
3:00:56
·
74 sec
Concerns about legalizing ADUs in flood-prone areas of Southeast Queens
Council Member Brooks-Powers raises concerns about the legalization of Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) in flood-prone areas of Southeast Queens. She questions the city's plans to address potential infrastructure strain and …
3:02:11
·
89 sec
City Planning Commission's response on homeownership opportunities in the proposal
Daniel Garodnick, Chair of the NYC City Planning Commission, responds to Council Member Brooks-Powers' questions about homeownership opportunities in the City of Yes proposal. He outlines how the text amendment …
3:03:50
·
93 sec
Debate on flood risk mapping and its accuracy for Southeast Queens
Council Member Brooks-Powers challenges the accuracy of flood risk mapping in the City of Yes proposal, particularly as it relates to her district in Southeast Queens. She points out discrepancies …
3:05:23
·
29 sec
Discussion on infrastructure investments related to the proposal
Daniel Garodnick addresses Council Member Brooks-Powers' concerns about infrastructure investments related to the City of Yes proposal. He explains the administration's stance on infrastructure needs and the impact of the …
3:05:52
·
87 sec
Debate on parking mandate removal and concerns about negotiating power with developers
Council Member Brooks-Powers and Daniel Garodnick engage in a debate about the removal of parking mandates and its potential impact on transit-poor areas. The council member expresses concerns about losing …
3:07:20
·
104 sec
Council Member Rivera's introduction and appreciation for City Planning Commission
Council Member Carlina Rivera begins by thanking the chairs and expressing gratitude to Commissioner Garodnick and other public servants for their work. She acknowledges the difficulty of their jobs and …
3:09:16
·
43 sec
Discussion on community engagement and fair share concerns
Council Member Rivera addresses the importance of community engagement and fair share in city planning. She compares the number of meetings held for this project to those for the Eastside …
3:10:00
·
46 sec
Q&A on Universal Affordability Preference incentives and housing diversity
Council Member Rivera inquires about incentives for Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) participation and how the City of Yes plan addresses housing diversity for families. Chair Garodnick explains the zoning and …
3:10:46
·
152 sec
Addressing concerns about conversion of multi-bedroom units to micro-units
Council Member Rivera expresses concern about the potential unintended consequence of incentivizing the conversion of existing multi-bedroom units to micro-units or shared apartments. Chair Garodnick responds by clarifying the intent …
3:13:18
·
63 sec
Commissioner Carrión on market needs and private sector involvement
Commissioner Adolfo Carrión Jr. addresses the importance of meeting market needs and highlights the role of the private sector in housing production. He emphasizes that the proposed changes respond to …
3:14:22
·
45 sec
Debate on the importance of eliminating parking minimums
Council Member Rivera emphasizes the critical role of eliminating parking minimums in the City of Yes plan, referencing the impact of similar actions in other cities. Chair Garodnick responds by …
3:15:12
·
76 sec
Council member expresses infrastructure concerns and community impact
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse raises significant concerns about the impact of the proposed zoning changes on infrastructure in her district, particularly in areas prone to flooding and sewer backups. She …
3:25:20
·
3 min
Discussion on Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) and community support
Council Member Narcisse and Daniel Garodnick discuss the potential benefits and challenges of implementing Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) in the community. They explore how ADUs could help homeowners financially while …
3:28:57
·
114 sec
Addressing gentrification and housing affordability concerns
Council Member Narcisse raises concerns about gentrification and housing affordability, while Daniel Garodnick responds by explaining how the proposed changes aim to address these issues. They discuss the balance between …
3:30:52
·
94 sec
Council member raises parking concerns for transportation deserts
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse briefly addresses the issue of parking in areas with limited public transportation options. - Emphasizes the need for parking in transportation deserts - Suggests that residents …
3:32:26
·
10 sec
Commissioner outlines ADU financing programs and future plans
Commissioner Adolfo Carrión Jr. provides information about existing and planned financing programs for Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) to address affordability concerns. - Mentions the Plus One ADU program launched last …
3:32:36
·
29 sec
Council Member Hanif expresses appreciation for City of Yes housing initiative
Council Member Shahana Hanif opens by expressing gratitude to the Department of City Planning team for their commitment to addressing the housing crisis through the City of Yes for Housing …
3:33:13
·
55 sec
Discussion on affordability requirements in low-density proposals
Council Member Hanif inquires about the absence of affordability requirements in low-density proposals, and Chair Garodnick explains the reasoning behind this decision. The discussion centers on the potential impacts of …
3:34:11
·
109 sec
Inquiry into Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) and affordability levels
Council Member Hanif inquires about the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) program, focusing on affordability levels and potential requirements. Chair Garodnick provides insights into the program's design and expected outcomes. - …
3:36:00
·
58 sec
Potential impact of UAP on affordable housing in specific neighborhoods
Council Member Hanif inquires about the potential impact of the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) on specific neighborhoods, particularly in her district. Chair Garodnick provides a positive outlook on the program's …
3:36:58
·
46 sec
Discussion on ADUs and basement apartment legalization
Council Member Hanif inquires about the relationship between proposed Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) allowances and the goal of legalizing existing unsafe basement apartments. Chair Garodnick provides a comprehensive response on …
3:37:45
·
77 sec
Council Member Holden raises concerns about infrastructure and flooding in his district
Council Member Robert F. Holden expresses serious concerns about infrastructure issues in his district, particularly focusing on flooding and sewer problems. He references the tragedy of Hurricane Ida, which resulted …
3:39:10
·
77 sec
Council Member Holden highlights parking problems in his district
Council Member Robert F. Holden raises concerns about severe parking issues in his district. He emphasizes that the current situation is already problematic and argues that the proposed changes will …
3:40:27
·
28 sec
Council Member Holden discusses electrical grid issues and zoning concerns
Council Member Robert F. Holden raises concerns about the electrical grid in his district and discusses past efforts to protect zoning. He argues that the proposed changes will undo previous …
3:40:56
·
83 sec
Council Member Holden questions City Planning Commission about addressing illegal apartments
Council Member Robert F. Holden questions the City Planning Commission about concrete plans to address illegal apartments and other issues in his district. Daniel Garodnick, Chair of the NYC City …
3:42:20
·
61 sec
Council Member Holden and City Planning Commission debate infrastructure and housing concerns
Council Member Robert F. Holden and Daniel Garodnick, Chair of the NYC City Planning Commission, engage in a debate about the proposed zoning changes and their potential impact on Holden's …
3:43:20
·
107 sec
Council Member Marte introduces development context in his district
Council Member Christopher Marte begins by acknowledging the chair and commissioner, then provides context about the extensive development that has occurred in his district over the years. He mentions specific …
3:45:19
·
19 sec
Marte expresses concerns about affordable housing and displacement
Council Member Marte articulates his concerns about the ongoing housing crisis in his district, highlighting issues of displacement, eviction, and speculation despite increased development. He emphasizes the urgent need for …
3:45:38
·
61 sec
Discussion on vacancy rates and off-market housing units
Council Member Marte inquires about the city's housing and vacancy survey, particularly focusing on units kept off the market. He questions the accuracy of the reported 1.4% vacancy rate and …
3:46:40
·
56 sec
Discussion on strengthening Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH)
Chair Garodnick addresses Council Member Marte's concerns about strengthening Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH). He explains the current approach to MIH and outlines proposed improvements in the new housing plan. - …
3:47:38
·
92 sec
Commitment to future review of Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH)
Council Member Marte presses for a commitment from the Department of City Planning to further review and potentially strengthen Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH) in the future. Chair Garodnick responds to …
3:49:09
·
56 sec
Discussion on eliminating the dwelling unit factor
Council Member Marte raises concerns about the proposal to eliminate the dwelling unit factor, particularly its potential impact on unit sizes in his district. Chair Garodnick responds to these concerns. …
3:50:07
·
74 sec
Commissioner Carrión explains housing emergency and vacancy rates
HPD Commissioner Adolfo Carrión Jr. provides a detailed explanation of the housing vacancy survey and the current housing emergency in New York City. He emphasizes the severity of the affordable …
3:51:22
·
107 sec
Follow-up on vacancy data availability
Council Member Marte asks a quick follow-up question about the availability of vacancy data, receiving a brief affirmative response. - Marte requests confirmation that the vacancy data is available - …
3:53:10
·
16 sec
Council Member Cabán's introduction and constituent feedback on the housing plan
Council Member Tiffany Cabán opens by expressing gratitude for the support provided in navigating the housing plan. She acknowledges that Queens is diverse in its opinions, with some constituents seeing …
3:53:30
·
28 sec
Council Member Cabán outlines affordability crisis and deep affordability concerns
Council Member Cabán focuses on the issue of deep affordability in housing, presenting data and research to highlight the severity of the affordability crisis in New York City. - She …
3:53:57
·
67 sec
Discussion on Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) impact on low-income families
Council Member Cabán questions the effectiveness of the Universal Affordability Preference (UAP) in addressing housing needs for the city's lowest-income families. Chair Garodnick responds, explaining the potential impact of UAP …
3:55:04
·
67 sec
Discussion on city's lawsuit against housing voucher expansion
Council Member Cabán questions the administration's stance on housing affordability in light of a lawsuit blocking the expansion of housing vouchers. Commissioner Carrión responds, highlighting current efforts in affordable housing …
3:56:12
·
146 sec
Racial analysis of zoning changes and City of Yes plan impact
Council Member Cabán requests a racial analysis of previous zoning decisions, particularly those from the Bloomberg era, and how the City of Yes plan addresses resulting disparities. Chair Garodnick responds, …
3:58:38
·
132 sec
Discussion on underdeveloped areas and current zoning capacity
Council Member Eric Dinowitz questions Chair Daniel Garodnick about underdeveloped areas in the city and the current zoning capacity. Garodnick acknowledges that while there are underdeveloped areas, the mere existence …
4:00:57
·
51 sec
Developer decision-making and concerns about non-residential development
Council Member Dinowitz raises concerns about developers choosing to build non-residential structures like charter schools and shelters in residential zones, questioning the effectiveness of current zoning in promoting housing development. …
4:01:48
·
133 sec
Lack of guarantees for housing development in zoning changes
Council Member Dinowitz questions the assurances that expanded zoning will result in housing rather than other types of development. Chair Garodnick explains that while there are no guarantees in zoning, …
4:04:02
·
85 sec
Concerns about stormwater management and infrastructure
Council Member Dinowitz raises concerns about stormwater management and flooding in his district, questioning the administration's commitment to infrastructure projects. He specifically mentions cuts to the Tibbett Brook daylighting project. …
4:05:27
·
51 sec
Affordability concerns in Mitchell-Lama housing
Council Member Dinowitz briefly raises concerns about affordability issues in Mitchell-Lama housing, particularly focusing on rent increases and maintenance fees. Chair Garodnick responds by connecting these issues to the overall …
4:06:18
·
108 sec
Council Member Ariola introduces her district's environmental challenges
Council Member Joann Ariola introduces her district, emphasizing its environmental vulnerability. She describes the western half of the Rockaway peninsula as fragile, with areas less than 5 feet above sea …
4:08:11
·
110 sec
Ariola questions development in environmentally sensitive areas
Council Member Ariola challenges the City Planning Commission's proposal to promote higher density development in her environmentally sensitive district. She questions the wisdom of encouraging development in areas prone to …
4:10:01
·
21 sec
Ariola questions changes to lot size and zoning regulations
Council Member Ariola challenges proposed changes to lot size regulations and zoning in her district. She expresses concern about the impact of these changes on neighborhood character and infrastructure. - …
4:10:23
·
50 sec
Ariola questions the relinquishing of council power over land use decisions
Council Member Ariola directly challenges Daniel Garodnick about the proposal's impact on council power over land use decisions. She asks if he would have supported such a change during his …
4:11:14
·
22 sec
Garodnick responds to concerns about relinquishing council power
Daniel Garodnick, Chair of the NYC City Planning Commission, responds to Council Member Ariola's concerns about the potential relinquishing of council power over land use decisions. He argues that the …
4:11:37
·
106 sec
Garodnick addresses concerns about overdevelopment and neighborhood character
Daniel Garodnick responds to Council Member Ariola's concerns about overdevelopment and changes to neighborhood character in her district. He argues that the proposal is more targeted and limited than Ariola …
4:13:24
·
68 sec
Ariola rebuts Garodnick's points on existing multifamily housing
Council Member Ariola responds to Garodnick's points about existing multifamily housing in her district, clarifying her concerns about the potential impact of the proposed changes on neighborhood character. - Acknowledges …
4:14:34
·
44 sec
Garodnick reiterates the limited scope of the proposal
Daniel Garodnick provides a final response to Council Member Ariola's concerns, reiterating that the proposal does not allow for unrestricted development and emphasizing its targeted nature. - Firmly states that …
4:15:18
·
41 sec
Council Member Avilés inquires about housing unit construction and preservation
Council Member Alexa Avilés asks for clarification on the breakdown of constructed versus preserved housing units mentioned in the presentation. Commissioner Adolfo Carrión Jr. provides details on the numbers and …
4:16:00
·
56 sec
Clarification on housing in industrial zones and transition zones
Council Member Avilés seeks clarification on the proposal's impact on industrial and manufacturing zones, as well as transition zones. Chair Daniel Garodnick provides answers regarding housing development in these areas. …
4:16:57
·
47 sec
Discussion on affordability mechanisms in low-density neighborhoods
Council Member Avilés inquires about affordability mechanisms in low-density neighborhood proposals. Chair Daniel Garodnick explains the reasoning behind not mandating affordability in these areas. - No mandated affordability in low-density …
4:17:43
·
100 sec
Council Member Avilés expresses concerns about luxury housing in her district
Council Member Alexa Avilés shares her observations and concerns about the housing development occurring in her district, particularly regarding affordability issues. - The 'missing middle' housing being built in her …
4:19:24
·
35 sec
Inquiry about trash management in new housing developments
Council Member Avilés raises concerns about trash management in new housing developments and asks if the proposal addresses this issue. Chair Daniel Garodnick explains the changes being made to address …
4:19:59
·
79 sec
Council Member Avilés emphasizes deep affordability needs in her district
Council Member Alexa Avilés underscores the critical need for deep affordability in her district and highlights issues of displacement and overcrowding. - Emphasizes that 40% AMI (deep affordability) is where …
4:21:18
·
30 sec
Clarification on building conversion rules
Council Member Kevin C. Riley seeks clarification on the rules for converting buildings to residential use. Chair Daniel Garodnick provides details on the current and proposed regulations. - Currently, only …
4:21:50
·
43 sec
Council Member Linda Lee introduces herself and expresses appreciation
Council Member Linda Lee begins by thanking everyone for their patience during the long hearing. She expresses gratitude to Chair Garodnick and his team for their efforts in addressing concerns …
4:22:34
·
72 sec
Discussion on ADUs and flooding concerns in Southeast Queens
Council Member Lee raises concerns about Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) and flooding issues in Southeast Queens. She emphasizes the unique challenges faced by her district, including water table issues and …
4:23:46
·
139 sec
Inquiry about infrastructure funding for proposed changes
Council Member Lee inquires about specific infrastructure funding to support the proposed zoning changes. She expresses concern about the cumulative impact of small changes across the city. - Asks if …
4:26:05
·
25 sec
City Planning's response to infrastructure concerns
Chair Garodnick explains the city's approach to addressing infrastructure concerns related to the proposed zoning changes. He emphasizes the diffuse nature of the changes and how this allows for gradual …
4:26:31
·
81 sec
Council Member Joseph expresses concerns about community engagement in rezoning process
Council Member Rita Joseph opens by thanking the commissioner and chair, then expresses concerns about constituents feeling excluded from the rezoning process in her district. She highlights the 2009 Flatbush …
4:28:10
·
40 sec
Discussion on zoning changes, community impact, and housing needs in Flatbush
Chair Garodnick responds to Council Member Joseph's concerns about community engagement in the rezoning process, explaining the city's changing needs and the importance of enabling multifamily housing near transit. He …
4:28:51
·
83 sec
Council Member Joseph raises concerns about flooding and environmental impact studies
Council Member Joseph expresses concerns about the environmental impact of proposed zoning changes, particularly focusing on flooding issues in parts of her district. She questions the lack of district-level environmental …
4:30:15
·
164 sec
Chair Garodnick addresses balancing flooding concerns with housing needs
Chair Garodnick acknowledges the significance of flooding and environmental concerns raised by multiple council members while emphasizing the urgent need to address the city's housing crisis. He stresses the importance …
4:32:58
·
83 sec
Special districts and rezoning in City Island and Metro North areas
Council Member Marmorato inquires about the status of special districts, particularly City Island, and the impact of the proposal on existing rezonings like Metro North. Daniel Garodnick assures that special …
4:34:46
·
54 sec
Debate over parking requirements in council member's district
Council Member Marmorato expresses strong opposition to eliminating parking requirements in her district, viewing it as a non-starter. Daniel Garodnick argues that parking will still be provided where needed, citing …
4:35:40
·
100 sec
Discussion on infrastructure funding sources for DEP projects
Council Member Marmorato questions the source of $20 billion funding for DEP infrastructure projects. Daniel Garodnick explains that the funding comes from a combination of the city's capital budget and …
4:37:21
·
67 sec
Concerns over housing affordability in the Bronx and Housing Connect program
Council Member Marmorato raises concerns about the affordability of housing in the Bronx, particularly through the Housing Connect program. Commissioner Carrión responds by emphasizing HPD's focus on financing housing for …
4:38:31
·
92 sec
Council Member Riley questions flood plain maps and inland flooding data
Council Member Kevin C. Riley questions Daniel Garodnick of the City Planning Commission about the maps used to determine 100-year flood plains and inland flooding. Garodnick promises to follow up …
4:40:11
·
54 sec
Council Member Restler's introduction and appreciation for City Planning Commission
Council Member Lincoln Restler opens with appreciation for Chair Riley's leadership and endurance. He expresses rare agreement with Mayor Eric Adams on the need for zoning text changes to address …
4:41:06
·
49 sec
Discussion on housing production equity across NYC council districts
Council Member Restler highlights the inequity in housing production across NYC council districts, noting that his district (33rd) has generated more housing starts than any other in recent years. He …
4:41:55
·
45 sec
Discussion on parking minimums and their impact on housing production
Council Member Restler and Chair Garodnick discuss the importance of eliminating parking minimums for housing production in NYC. They explore the potential impact on the City of Yes plan and …
4:42:40
·
4 min
Discussion on incorporating affordability and tenant protections in the City of Yes package
Council Member Restler emphasizes the importance of including affordability measures and tenant protections in the City of Yes package. Chair Garodnick acknowledges the need for a comprehensive approach to housing …
4:46:43
·
55 sec
Discussion on the 1% of ULURPs removed from council jurisdiction
Council Member Brooks-Powers inquires about the 1% of ULURPs that would be removed from the council's jurisdiction under the City of Yes proposal. Chair Garodnick clarifies that it's less than …
4:47:48
·
64 sec
Expansion of building types eligible for residential conversion
The discussion focuses on the expansion of building types eligible for conversion to residential use under the City of Yes proposal. Chair Garodnick explains that the plan now includes other …
4:48:52
·
146 sec
Explanation of district fixes and zoning changes
Chair Garodnick explains the rationale behind district fixes and zoning changes proposed in the City of Yes plan. He highlights how current zoning rules often result in buildings smaller than …
4:51:23
·
39 sec
Transit-oriented development in transit-poor communities
Council Member Brooks-Powers raises concerns about the applicability of transit-oriented development in transit-poor areas like Southeast Queens, where many residents still depend on cars due to long commute times. - …
4:52:12
·
80 sec
Preserving landmark buildings through air rights flexibility
Chair Garodnick explains how the City of Yes proposal aims to preserve landmark buildings by providing more flexibility in transferring air rights. - The proposal will make it easier for …
4:53:32
·
57 sec
Council member's concerns about policy impact on transit-poor communities
Council Member Brooks-Powers concludes with remarks emphasizing the need for nuanced policy-making that considers the unique challenges of transit-poor and historically underresourced communities. - She provides real-life examples of development …
4:55:26
·
79 sec
Council Member Narcisse expresses concerns about coastal flooding and infrastructure issues
Council Member Mercedes Narcisse raises serious concerns about coastal flooding and infrastructure problems in her district, particularly in areas like Bergen Beach and Kenosi. She emphasizes the severity of the …
4:56:50
·
123 sec
Director Garodnick addresses concerns about flooding and zoning text amendments
Director Daniel Garodnick responds to Council Member Narcisse's concerns about flooding and infrastructure issues, acknowledging the severity of the problem while explaining the limitations of addressing it through zoning text …
4:58:53
·
91 sec
Discussion on the impact of ADUs on property values and taxes
Council Member Narcisse inquires about the impact of Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) on property values and taxes, with Director Garodnick providing insights on potential effects and considerations for homeowners. - …
5:00:25
·
70 sec
Discussion on plans for protecting and creating homeownership opportunities
Council Member Narcisse inquires about the administration's plans for protecting existing homeownership and creating new homeownership opportunities within the proposed zoning changes. Director Garodnick outlines several ways the plan supports …
5:01:36
·
79 sec
Changes in housing production proportionality across community boards
Council Member Eric Dinowitz inquires about how the City of Yes proposal would affect the proportionality of housing production across different community boards and council districts. Chair Daniel Garodnick explains …
5:10:37
·
137 sec
Parking requirements and transportation challenges in the Bronx
Council Member Eric Dinowitz raises concerns about eliminating parking minimums across the board, highlighting the unique transportation challenges faced by residents in the Bronx. He emphasizes the need for cars …
5:12:54
·
3 min
Developer authority in parking decisions and community input concerns
Council Member Eric Dinowitz expresses concerns about giving developers more authority to decide on parking provisions without community input. He argues that the proposal shifts decision-making power away from community …
5:16:09
·
104 sec
Inquiry on municipal lots and street parking cleanup efforts
Council Member Eric Dinowitz follows up on his earlier questions about efforts to address parking issues in the Bronx, specifically asking about investments in municipal lots and cleanup of existing …
5:17:53
·
22 sec
Request for data on changes in housing production proportionality
Council Member Eric Dinowitz requests data on the analysis of how the proportionality of housing production would change under the proposed plan. Chair Garodnick agrees to provide what information they …
5:18:15
·
39 sec
Council Member Marte discusses landmark air rights, district zoning, and parking mandates
Council Member Christopher Marte engages in a Q&A session with Daniel Garodnick about various aspects of the proposed zoning changes. They discuss the expansion of air rights transfers for landmarks, …
5:19:07
·
4 min
Council member requests transparency on DCP communications with outside groups
Council Member Holden requests transparency from Chair Garodnick regarding the Department of City Planning's communications with outside special interest groups about the City of Yes proposal. Garodnick expresses willingness to …
5:23:15
·
84 sec
Debate on New York City's housing construction progress
Council Member Holden challenges the administration's portrayal of New York City's housing construction progress, citing recent data showing significant new apartment completions. Chair Garodnick responds by explaining the incremental nature …
5:24:39
·
139 sec
Council member challenges necessity of City of Yes proposal and raises concerns about neighborhood impacts
Council Member Holden argues that New York City is already building significant amounts of housing without the City of Yes proposal. He expresses concerns about the proposal's potential negative impacts …
5:26:59
·
86 sec
Chair defends City of Yes proposal as necessary for addressing housing shortage
Chair Garodnick responds to Council Member Holden's criticisms by acknowledging current housing production but arguing it's insufficient to meet demand. He defends the City of Yes proposal as necessary to …
5:28:27
·
67 sec
Council Member Ariola criticizes City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal
Council Member Joann Ariola strongly criticizes the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal, arguing that it would lead to overdevelopment, worsen parking problems, and decrease quality of life across …
5:29:35
·
124 sec
Disagreement over characterization of City of Yes for Housing Opportunity
Daniel Garodnick, Chair of the NYC City Planning Commission, and Council Member Joann Ariola engage in a heated exchange over City of Yes for Housing Opportunity. Garodnick defends the proposal's …
5:31:41
·
85 sec
Council Member Lee raises concerns about parking restrictions in transit deserts
Council Member Linda Lee expresses concerns about the proposal to remove parking restrictions, particularly in transit-poor areas like her district. She highlights the reliance on cars in these areas due …
5:33:11
·
51 sec
Impact of zoning changes on parking in new developments
Council Member Lee presents a hypothetical scenario to illustrate concerns about the impact of zoning changes on parking in new developments, particularly in areas prone to flooding. - Lee describes …
5:34:02
·
26 sec
Concerns about accountability for developers and administration
Council Member Lee expresses concerns about accountability for developers and the administration if parking mandates are completely removed. She emphasizes the need for council oversight and the challenges of enforcing …
5:34:28
·
47 sec
Proposal for maintaining parking waivers with adjustments
Council Member Lee proposes maintaining the existing parking waiver process with adjustments, as an alternative to completely removing parking mandates. She seeks to balance development needs with community concerns. - …
5:35:16
·
3 min
Discussion on landmark air rights transfers and community input
Council Member Lee and Daniel Garodnick engage in a discussion about landmark air rights transfers, focusing on the process, its impact on communities, and the balance between landmark flexibility and …
5:38:20
·
156 sec
Council Member Rita Joseph questions zoning proposal language and affordability measures
Council Member Rita Joseph engages in a Q&A session with Chair Daniel Garodnick about the City of Yes zoning proposal. She inquires about potentially misleading language in the proposal, the …
5:41:03
·
3 min
Impact of zoning proposal on Special Natural Area District (SNAD)
Council Member David Carr expresses concern about the zoning proposal's impact on special districts, particularly the Special Natural Area District (SNAD). He questions why SNAD areas were not exempted from …
5:44:32
·
63 sec
Reduction of minimum lot sizes in R1 and R2 districts
Chair Daniel Garodnick explains the rationale behind reducing minimum lot sizes in R1 and R2 districts, including areas within the Special Natural Area District (SNAD). The proposal aims to create …
5:45:36
·
60 sec
Balancing neighborhood preservation with housing opportunities
Council Member David Carr and Chair Daniel Garodnick discuss the tension between preserving past zoning achievements and creating new housing opportunities. The conversation highlights differing perspectives on neighborhood character and …
5:46:37
·
84 sec
Concerns about permeability and stormwater management
Council Member David Carr raises concerns about the impact of the zoning proposal on permeability and stormwater management, particularly in the Special Natural Area District (SNAD) and MS4 stormwater areas. …
5:48:01
·
168 sec
Potential increase in property taxes due to new development rights
Council Member David Carr expresses concern about the potential increase in property taxes due to new development rights created by the zoning proposal, even for homeowners who do not take …
5:50:49
·
94 sec
Discussion on housing unit projections and goals
Council Member Bottcher inquires about the City of Yes plan's projected 100,000 new housing units over 15 years and how it compares to the Regional Plan Association's estimate of 473,000 …
5:52:34
·
60 sec
Addressing concerns about market-rate housing and building density
Council Member Bottcher raises concerns from constituents about new housing being predominantly market-rate and the potential for tall buildings with few apartments. Chair Garodnick responds by explaining the Universal Affordability …
5:53:34
·
3 min
Implications of the proposal on building types and affordability
Council Member Bottcher inquires about the implications of the proposal on tall buildings with few apartments and the distinction between rental and condo construction. Chair Garodnick clarifies the affordability requirements …
5:56:41
·
63 sec
Closing remarks and information about upcoming public hearing
Council Member Riley provides closing remarks for the hearing, thanks the participants, and shares important information about the upcoming public hearing for the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity proposal. …
5:57:47
·
116 sec
