Your guide to NYC's public proceedings.
New York City Council
Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection
May 06, 2025
·
10:00 AM
6 hr 42 min
PRO The fastest way to analyze public meetings in NYC & NY State. Learn more.
Summary
A hearing on street vending enforcement and licensing, focusing on proposed legislation to reform street vending regulations.
Discussions centered on:
- Increasing the number of available vending licenses
- Creating new support services for vendors
- Improving enforcement practices
- Balancing the needs of vendors, brick-and-mortar businesses, and communities
Features testimony from the Department of Sanitation (DSNY), Department of Small Business Services (SBS), Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP), Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH), and the public, including street vendors, business improvement districts, and small business representatives.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Julie Menin opens the hearing on street vending
Council Member Julie Menin opens the hearing on street vending enforcement and licensing. She welcomes attendees and recognizes fellow council members and the public advocate who are present. - Introduces …
0:05:08
•
35 sec
Historical context and importance of street vending in New York City
Council Member Menin provides historical context on the importance of street vending in New York City. She highlights its role in the city's culture and as an economic opportunity for …
0:05:45
•
24 sec
Challenges and concerns surrounding street vending in New York City
Council Member Menin outlines the challenges and concerns associated with street vending in New York City. She highlights issues raised by various stakeholders and the complexity of vending regulations. - …
0:06:09
•
37 sec
Overview of Local Law 18 of 2021 on street vending
Council Member Menin provides an overview of Local Law 18 of 2021, a landmark legislation aimed at improving street vending opportunities and enforcement in New York City. - Passed in …
0:06:46
•
33 sec
Establishment of the Office of Street Vendor Enforcement
Council Member Menin explains the establishment of the Office of Street Vendor Enforcement as part of Local Law 18 of 2021 and its subsequent relocation. - Created a specialized unit …
0:07:20
•
36 sec
Persistent issues in street vending enforcement and licensing
Council Member Menin outlines the ongoing challenges in street vending enforcement and licensing despite recent legislative efforts. - Both vendors and brick-and-mortar businesses report inconsistent and arbitrary enforcement - Lack …
0:07:57
•
50 sec
Introduction of bills to be discussed in the hearing
Council Member Menin introduces the bills that will be discussed during the hearing, focusing on various aspects of street vending regulation and support. - Introduction 408: Create a division within …
0:08:48
•
113 sec
Recognition of additional attending council members
Council Member Menin concludes her opening remarks by recognizing additional council members in attendance and preparing to hand over to the Public Advocate. - Recognizes council members Nurs and Abreu …
0:10:41
•
20 sec
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams advocates for street vendor reform legislation
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams delivers remarks supporting a package of street vending reform bills, emphasizing the need to end criminalization of vendors and provide more licenses, services, and training. He …
0:11:03
•
3 min
Council Member Pierina Sanchez discusses street vending reform and Intro 431
Council Member Pierina Sanchez presents her views on the current state of street vending in New York City and discusses the proposed legislation, particularly Intro 431. She highlights the challenges …
0:14:28
•
4 min
Council Member Amanda Farías advocates for street vendor legislation
Council Member Amanda Farías expresses strong support for a package of bills aimed at reforming street vending regulations in New York City. She highlights the importance of street vendors to …
0:18:59
•
144 sec
Department of Sanitation's role in street vending enforcement
Joshua Goodman, Deputy Commissioner of Public Affairs and Customer Experience at the New York City Department of Sanitation, testifies about DSNY's role as the lead agency for coordinating enforcement of …
0:22:09
•
3 min
Department of Small Business Services testimony on street vendor support and Intro 408
Haris Khan, Chief of Staff at the Department of Small Business Services (SBS), provides testimony on SBS's support for street vendors and the department's perspective on Intro 408. He outlines …
0:25:41
•
3 min
Department of Consumer and Worker Protection testimony on street vending legislation
Carlos Ortiz, Deputy Commissioner of External Affairs at the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, provided testimony on street vending issues and proposed legislation. He outlined the current state of …
0:28:52
•
88 sec
Department of Health and Mental Hygiene testimony on street food vending enforcement and proposed legislation
Corinne Schiff, Deputy Commissioner for Environmental Health at the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, testifies on the department's role in street food vending enforcement and discusses proposed legislation. …
0:30:29
•
4 min
Update on supervisory licenses and permits for street vendors
Council Member Julie Menin requests an update on the number of approved supervisory licenses and permits for street vendors. Deputy Commissioner Corinne Schiff provides a breakdown of the 823 supervisory …
0:34:48
•
51 sec
Discrepancy between supervisory licenses issued and permits obtained
Council Member Menin inquires about the discrepancy between the 823 supervisory licenses issued and only 382 permits obtained. Deputy Commissioner Schiff explains: - There is no actual discrepancy, but rather …
0:35:39
•
44 sec
Communication and deadlines for street vendor license applications
Council Member Menin inquires about the communication process and deadlines for street vendor license applications. Deputy Commissioner Schiff explains: - Extensive outreach and education efforts are made to inform eligible …
0:36:24
•
146 sec
DSNY's enforcement strategy for street vending
Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman explains DSNY's enforcement strategy for street vending: - Focus on ensuring clean streets and clear sidewalks - Addressing vending that doesn't follow city rules - Taking …
0:38:51
•
78 sec
Determination of enforcement locations and complaint-driven approach
Deputy Commissioner Goodman explains how DSNY determines enforcement locations for street vending: - Enforcement is largely complaint-driven - Complaints come through formal channels like 311 - Informal complaints come from …
0:40:08
•
27 sec
Analysis of vending violation cases at OATH hearings
Council Member Menin inquires about the decrease in vending-related cases at OATH hearings from 2014 to 2024. Deputy Commissioner Goodman explains: - The legal regime for licensing and enforcement has …
0:40:36
•
61 sec
Number and types of complaints about street vendors
Deputy Commissioner Goodman provides information on complaints about street vendors: - In fiscal year 2025 (through April), there were over 22,000 311 complaints about street vending - Complaints are categorized …
0:41:38
•
81 sec
DSNY's approach to correcting noncompliant activity and education efforts
Deputy Commissioner Goodman explains DSNY's approach to correcting noncompliant activity and education efforts: - DSNY shares outreach and education materials prepared by other agencies - Written warning notices are created …
0:43:01
•
59 sec
Outreach efforts by the Department of Small Business Services for street vendors
Haris Khan from the Department of Small Business Services (SBS) explains their outreach efforts for street vendors: - SBS partners with city agencies to promote licensing opportunities - For supervisory …
0:44:00
•
56 sec
DSNY's policy on civil vs. criminal penalties for vending violations
Council Member Menin confirms DSNY's policy on penalties for vending violations: - DSNY exclusively issues civil penalties for violations of vending laws - The agency has not changed its enforcement …
0:44:57
•
22 sec
DOHMH's approach to engaging vendors and correcting non-compliant activity
Deputy Commissioner Schiff explains DOHMH's approach to engaging vendors and correcting non-compliant activity: - DOHMH uses a risk-based inspection program - Every inspection is treated as a teachable moment to …
0:45:20
•
52 sec
Discussion on the potential role of an interagency portal for street vending enforcement
Council Member Menin inquires about the potential role of an interagency portal in improving street vending enforcement. Deputy Commissioner Goodman responds: - DSNY doesn't believe an interagency portal would improve …
0:46:13
•
39 sec
Council Member De La Rosa inquires about agency training for new vending laws
Council Member Carmen N. De La Rosa raises questions about the implementation of proposed vending bills, focusing on how agencies will be trained on enforcement and regulations. She expresses concern …
0:47:16
•
3 min
Council Member Sandy Nurse questions DSNY on street vending enforcement protocol
Council Member Sandy Nurse inquires about the protocol for street vending enforcement, particularly focusing on the relationship between the Department of Sanitation (DSNY) and the NYPD. Joshua Goodman from DSNY …
0:50:25
•
166 sec
Discussion on supervisory license applications and potential impact of Intro 1251
Council Member Amanda Farías inquires about the potential impact of Intro 1251 on addressing the gap between license applications released and licenses issued for supervisory roles in street vending. Corinne …
0:53:17
•
100 sec
Inquiry into rules regulating competition for street vendors
Council Member Amanda Farías inquires about any existing rules regulating competition between street vendors and brick-and-mortar businesses. Representatives from different agencies provide responses regarding current regulations. - DCWP representative is …
0:55:00
•
76 sec
DSNY's approach to outreach and education in street vending enforcement
Council Member Amanda Farías inquires about the Department of Sanitation's incorporation of education and outreach components in their enforcement efforts. Joshua Goodman, Deputy Commissioner of Public Affairs and Customer Experience …
0:56:26
•
117 sec
Coordination between DSNY and NYPD in responding to street vending complaints
Council Member Amanda Farías inquires about the coordination between the Department of Sanitation (DSNY) and the NYPD in responding to street vending complaints. Joshua Goodman from DSNY provides insights into …
0:58:24
•
169 sec
Council Member Menin questions SBS on support for street vendors
Council Member Julie Menin interrogates the Department of Small Business Services (SBS) about their support for street vendors since the implementation of Local Law 18. SBS Chief of Staff Haris …
1:01:17
•
133 sec
DCWP explains general vending license process and waitlist
Carlos Ortiz from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) explains the process and conditions for issuing general vendor licenses in response to questions from Council Member Julie Menin. …
1:03:31
•
134 sec
DCWP provides data on general vending license issuance
Carlos Ortiz from DCWP provides data on general vending license issuance in response to Council Member Julie Menin's questions. The discussion covers recent license issuance numbers, the current waitlist, and …
1:05:46
•
89 sec
Council Member Menin criticizes SBS's data collection and outreach efforts
Council Member Julie Menin expresses frustration with SBS's lack of specific data on their support for street vendors and questions their outreach efforts. SBS Chief of Staff Haris Khan defends …
1:07:17
•
3 min
Council Member Sanchez's opening remarks and appreciation for agency coordination
Council Member Pierina Sanchez opens the session by thanking the administration for their coordination in attending the hearing. She expresses appreciation for the administration's position on reducing regulatory barriers for …
1:10:23
•
32 sec
Discussion on supervisory license system and the role of commissaries in food vending
Council Member Sanchez inquires about the transition to the supervisory license system for food vendors and the importance of commissaries in ensuring food safety for street vending operations. - Deputy …
1:10:55
•
145 sec
Clarification of Department of Health's focus on food safety in vending
Council Member Sanchez seeks clarification on the Department of Health's position regarding the number of vending licenses issued, emphasizing their focus on food safety rather than license quantities. - The …
1:13:21
•
29 sec
Department of Sanitation's enforcement capacity and complaint handling
Council Member Sanchez inquires about the Department of Sanitation's enforcement capacity, focusing on the number of agents, complaints received, and violations issued. - Sanitation has 35 dedicated enforcement agents - …
1:13:50
•
51 sec
Impact of licensing all eligible street vendors on enforcement
Council Member Sanchez explores how licensing all currently eligible street vendors would affect the Department of Sanitation's enforcement work. - Licensed vendors are reported to have more productive interactions with …
1:14:41
•
65 sec
Potential need for increased enforcement personnel with license expansion
Council Member Sanchez inquires about the need for additional enforcement personnel if the number of vending licenses were to increase over time. - The Department of Sanitation confirms that current …
1:15:47
•
58 sec
DCWP's perspective on lifting the cap on vending licenses
Council Member Sanchez asks DCWP about their view on lifting the current cap on available vending licenses and its potential impact on street congestion. - DCWP expresses uncertainty about whether …
1:16:45
•
51 sec
Determining the appropriate number of vending licenses
Council Member Sanchez inquires about how the appropriate number of vending licenses should be determined, seeking input from DCWP and the Department of Health. - DCWP emphasizes the importance of …
1:17:38
•
68 sec
Agency staffing needs and costs associated with increasing vending licenses
Council Member Sanchez asks each agency to detail how their staffing needs would change if the cap on vending licenses were raised, including associated costs and potential revenue. - Department …
1:18:47
•
162 sec
SBS programs for vendor education and outreach
Council Member Sanchez inquires about existing SBS programs that could be adapted to educate and support street vendors, particularly those who may not speak English. - SBS mentions their New …
1:21:30
•
91 sec
Conclusion and reflection on benefits of licensed vendor interactions
Council Member Sanchez concludes the session with final remarks, thanking the administration representatives and reflecting on the key points discussed. - Expresses gratitude to the Department of Sanitation for sharing …
1:23:01
•
19 sec
Council Member Farías questions agencies on street vendor data and enforcement
Council Member Amanda Farías interrogates city agency representatives about data collection on street vendors and the potential benefits of regulating unpermitted vending. She focuses on how the Department of Small …
1:23:22
•
4 min
Council Member Julie Menin questions Department of Sanitation on street vending confiscations and property retrieval
Council Member Julie Menin inquires about the confiscation processes related to street vending enforcement since the Office of Street Vending Enforcement moved to the Department of Sanitation. Joshua Goodman from …
1:28:04
•
4 min
Council Member Sanchez questions regulations on vendor distances and effectiveness of confiscations
Council Member Pierina Sanchez engages in a Q&A session with Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman, focusing on clarifying vending regulations and the effectiveness of enforcement measures. They discuss the required distance …
1:32:18
•
71 sec
NYC Independent Budget Office Testimony on Fiscal Impact of Lifting Street Vending Permit Caps
Alaina Turnquist from the NYC Independent Budget Office presents findings on the potential fiscal impact of lifting caps on street vending permits and licenses. The analysis indicates a net positive …
1:34:44
•
5 min
Council Member Sanchez questions IBO on economic impacts of lifting street vendor license caps
Council Member Pierina Sanchez inquires about the potential economic impacts of lifting the cap on street vendor licenses, specifically addressing concerns about a possible influx of new vendors. Representatives from …
1:40:01
•
84 sec
Testimony by Matthew Shapiro, Legal Director of the Street Vendor Project at the Urban Justice Center
Matthew Shapiro, representing the Street Vendor Project, advocates for economic justice for street vendors in New York City. He supports Intro 431, which would gradually increase the number of vending …
1:45:07
•
170 sec
Testimony by Carina Kaufman-Gutierrez, Deputy Director of Street Vendor Project on Street Vending Enforcement and Licensing
Carina Kaufman-Gutierrez, Deputy Director of the Street Vendor Project, testified in support of Intros 431, 408, and 1251, addressing the challenges faced by street vendors due to excessive enforcement and …
1:48:01
•
153 sec
Testimony by Clotilde Juarez, Street Vendor from Queens
Clotilde Juarez, a street vendor from Queens, testifies in support of the street vendor reform package. She emphasizes the importance of vending for single mothers, grandmothers, and survivors of domestic …
1:51:25
•
170 sec
Testimony by Deacon Calvin Baker, Street Vendor Advocate
Deacon Calvin Baker, a street vendor advocate, testified in support of Intro 431 and Intro 408, part of the street vendor reform package. He spoke about his experiences as a …
1:54:26
•
133 sec
Testimony by Mohamed Attia, Managing Director of Street Vendor Project, on Street Vending Legislation
Mohamed Attia, Managing Director of the Street Vendor Project, testified in support of Intro 431, which would increase the number of vending licenses available. He emphasized the rich history of …
1:56:52
•
144 sec
Discussion on current vending system and potential impact of Intro 431
Council Member Sanchez inquires about the current vending system's issues and how Intro 431 might address them. Mohamed Attia from the Street Vendor Project explains the challenges vendors face in …
1:59:21
•
161 sec
Concerns about immigration enforcement impact on street vendors
Council Member Sanchez inquires about concerns related to federal immigration enforcement affecting street vendors. Carina Kaufman-Gutierrez from the Street Vendor Project explains the heightened risks and fear vendors face due …
2:02:03
•
123 sec
Spatial concerns and impact on brick-and-mortar businesses
Council Member Julie Menin questions the Street Vendor Project representatives about the spatial implications of increasing vending licenses and the potential impact on brick-and-mortar businesses. The vendors argue that there …
2:04:20
•
4 min
Engagement with BIDs and addressing their concerns
Council Member Julie Menin inquires about the Street Vendor Project's engagement with Business Improvement Districts (BIDs) and how they've addressed concerns raised by small businesses. The SVP representatives discuss their …
2:08:28
•
163 sec
SBS involvement and support for street vendors
Council Member Julie Menin expresses concern about the Small Business Services (SBS) department's inability to provide data on assistance to street vendors. The Street Vendor Project representatives criticize SBS's approach …
2:11:11
•
3 min
Testimony by Evan Sweet, Director of Neighborhood Operations at Meatpacking Business Improvement District
Evan Sweet, representing the Meatpacking Business Improvement District, expresses concerns about the proposed expansion of street vending permits. He argues that increased vending creates challenges for pedestrian access, storefront visibility, …
2:15:38
•
118 sec
Testimony by Barbara Blair, President of Garment District Alliance, on Street Vending Legislation
Barbara Blair, President of the Garment District Alliance, testifies against Intro 431, arguing for better regulation of street vending in New York City. She emphasizes the need for enforceable rules …
2:17:45
•
120 sec
Testimony by Nelson Eusebio, Representative of National Supermarket Association
Nelson Eusebio, representing the National Supermarket Association (NSA), testified about the challenges faced by supermarkets due to the current street vending system in New York City. He emphasized the need …
2:19:53
•
145 sec
Testimony by Erin Piscopink, Executive Director of SoHo Broadway Initiative and Co-Chair of NYC BID Association
Erin Piscopink, representing the NYC BID Association, testified on the proposed street vending legislation. She emphasized the need for balanced policies that support both vendors and storefront businesses while addressing …
2:22:23
•
129 sec
Council Member Menin asks about structural reforms for street vending
Council Member Julie Menin asks representatives from the Meatpacking District and the National Supermarket Association about their recommended structural reforms for street vending. The representatives discuss enforcement challenges and propose …
2:24:32
•
94 sec
Council Member Menin asks for questions from colleagues
Council Member Julie Menin concludes her questioning and asks if there are any questions from her colleagues. The transcript ends with a brief acknowledgment from another participant. - Menin transitions …
2:26:07
•
3 sec
Council member inquires about supermarkets affected by street vending
Council Member Amanda Farías questions Nelson Eusebio about the number of supermarkets in their association affected by street vending. Eusebio provides information on the percentage of affected supermarkets and the …
2:26:11
•
21 sec
Council member discusses amendments and seeks input on enforcement measures
Council Member Pierina Sanchez discusses proposed amendments to street vending legislation, focusing on increasing enforcement capacity and creating clear standards for license suspension. She seeks specific input from stakeholders on …
2:26:38
•
6 min
Council member uses personal analogy and appeals for continued stakeholder engagement
Council Member Pierina Sanchez uses a personal analogy about parenting to emphasize the need for both 'carrots and sticks' in policy-making. She appeals to stakeholders for continued engagement and collaboration …
2:33:17
•
90 sec
Council Member Brewer's Q&A on street vending issues
Council Member Gale A. Brewer engages in a Q&A session with the panel, focusing on specific issues related to street vending. She inquires about the challenges faced by supermarkets with …
2:35:51
•
162 sec
Council Member Menin gives brief procedural instruction
Council Member Julie Menin makes a quick procedural remark to the next panel. - Menin instructs the next panel to begin their testimony
2:39:39
•
2 sec
Testimony by Scott Foletta, Managing Attorney of Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem on Street Vendor Reform for Immigrant New Yorkers
Scott Foletta, Managing Attorney for the immigration defense team at the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem, emphasizes the critical importance of street vendor reform for immigrant New Yorkers. He highlights …
2:39:42
•
114 sec
Testimony by Adrian Cepeda, Owner of World's Borough Bookshop
Adrian Cepeda, owner of World's Borough Bookshop in Queens, testifies in support of street vendors. He argues that competition is beneficial for businesses and innovation, and that street vendors play …
2:41:41
•
127 sec
Testimony by James Gonzalez, Co-owner of La Fonda on Street Vendor Reform
James Gonzalez, co-owner of La Fonda, testifies in support of the street vendor reform package, particularly Intros 431 and 408. He argues that street vendors are entrepreneurs who contribute to …
2:43:53
•
106 sec
Testimony by Juan Nuñez, Community Organizer from Northwest Bronx Community and Clergy Coalition
Juan Nuñez, a community organizer with the Northwest Bronx Community and Clergy Coalition, testified in support of Intros 431 and 408 regarding street vending reform. He emphasized the importance of …
2:45:44
•
137 sec
Testimony by Shamier Settle, Senior Policy Analyst at Immigration Research Initiative, on Street Vendor Research
Shamier Settle, a senior policy analyst at the Immigration Research Initiative, presented findings from a comprehensive report on street vendors in New York City. The report, based on a survey …
2:48:06
•
122 sec
Testimony by Daniel Scorse, Representative of Hudson Yards/Hells Kitchen Alliance on Street Vending Regulations
Daniel Scorse, representing the Hudson Yards/Hells Kitchen Alliance, argues against Intro 431, which proposes lifting the cap on street vendor licenses. He warns that unlimited vending would lead to overcrowded …
2:51:28
•
85 sec
Testimony by Noah Sheroff, Representative of Bayside Village Business Improvement District
Noah Sheroff, representing the Bayside Village Business Improvement District in Northeast Queens, testifies against the proposed expansion of street vending licenses. He argues that the increase in street vendors would …
2:52:59
•
114 sec
Testimony by Brian McGinn, Representative of 34th Street Partnership and Bryant Park Corporation
Brian McGinn, representing the 34th Street Partnership and Bryant Park Corporation, testifies against Intros 431 and 1251, citing concerns about vendor behavior in Midtown Manhattan. He highlights issues with both …
2:54:58
•
61 sec
Testimony by Brian McGinn, Representative of 34th Street Partnership/Bryant Park Corporation
Brian McGinn, representing the 34th Street Partnership and Bryant Park Corporation, expressed strong concerns about expanding vending licenses in New York City. He cited safety issues and potential negative impacts …
2:55:59
•
22 sec
Enforcement response to illegal vending in the 34th Street area
Council Member Gale A. Brewer inquires about the response to 311/911 calls regarding illegal vending in the 34th Street area. Brian McGinn from the 34th Street Partnership explains the challenges …
2:56:33
•
78 sec
Presence of legal and illegal vendors in the 34th Street area
Council Member Gale A. Brewer asks about the presence of legal vendors in the area. Brian McGinn acknowledges some legal vendors but emphasizes ongoing issues with licensed vendors operating in …
2:57:51
•
32 sec
Discussion on potential concession areas for street vendors
Council Member Amanda Farías proposes the idea of creating legal concession areas for street vendors, particularly in busy areas like 34th Street. She discusses this potential solution with Brian McGinn …
2:58:25
•
86 sec
Council Member Farías on tailored vending solutions for NYC
Council Member Amanda Farías emphasizes the need for diverse approaches to street vending regulations across different areas of New York City. She acknowledges that a one-size-fits-all solution is not appropriate …
3:00:27
•
62 sec
Council Member Sanchez discusses vending licenses and enforcement
Council Member Pierina Sanchez addresses the panel about street vending licenses and enforcement. She mentions her willingness to have unlimited licenses in her district if vendors behave properly and asks …
3:01:35
•
61 sec
Panel members respond to questions about vending enforcement
Panel members respond to Council Member Sanchez's questions about vending enforcement and additional measures that could be taken to address issues with street vendors. - Brian McGinn suggests worsening consequences …
3:02:36
•
132 sec
Testimony by Jose Sanchez, Street Vendor from The Bronx
Jose Sanchez, a street vendor from The Bronx, provided testimony about his experience and the importance of street vending to his family and community. He emphasized the need to support …
3:07:55
•
67 sec
Testimony by Luzuru Chima, Street Vendor from Brooklyn
Luzuru Chima, a street vendor from Brooklyn, testifies about the challenges faced by street vendors and the discrimination they experience. She highlights the importance of customer perspective and the unfair …
3:09:02
•
3 min
Testimony by Eliana, Street Vendor and Member of Street Vendor Project
Eliana, a street vendor for 39 years and member of the Street Vendor Project, testified about the challenges faced by street vendors in New York City. She emphasized the need …
3:13:08
•
4 min
Testimony by Angel, Street Vendor and Member of York
Angel, a street vendor from The Bronx, testifies in support of the street vendor reform package (Intros 431, 408, 407, and 204). He describes the challenges and fears faced by …
3:19:15
•
3 min
Testimony by Pedro Goico, Treasurer of National Supermarket Association on Street Vending Legislation
Pedro Goico, Treasurer of the National Supermarket Association and a supermarket owner, shared his perspective on street vending legislation. He emphasized the need for responsible licensing and fair enforcement for …
3:25:55
•
165 sec
Testimony by Betsy Mak, Vice Chair of Community Board 7 in Queens, on Street Vending Legislation
Betsy Mak, Vice Chair of Community Board 7 in Queens, strongly opposes the new proposal to increase street vending licenses. She cites numerous complaints about illegal vending in Downtown Flushing, …
3:28:54
•
152 sec
Testimony by Lisa Sorin, President of the Bronx Chamber of Commerce, on Street Vending Legislation
Lisa Sorin, representing the Bronx Chamber of Commerce, opposes Intro 431 which seeks to expand street vendor licenses. She argues that the bill fails to address the issue of illegal …
3:31:29
•
140 sec
Testimony by Jessica Walker, President and CEO of Manhattan Chamber of Commerce
Jessica Walker, representing the Manhattan Chamber of Commerce, presented testimony on street vending regulations. She emphasized the need for a balanced approach that supports both street vendors and brick-and-mortar businesses. …
3:33:51
•
108 sec
Testimony by Nick Aquino, Staff Attorney at Microenterprise Project at Volunteers of Legal Service
Nick Aquino, a staff attorney with the Microenterprise Project at Volunteers of Legal Service, testifies in support of Intro 431 and Intro 408 to reform the street vending system in …
3:36:36
•
118 sec
Testimony by Balanda Joachim, Campaign Organizer at Association for Neighborhood and Housing Development
Balanda Joachim, representing the Association for Neighborhood and Housing Development and the United for Small Businesses of New York City coalition, testified in support of Intro 408 and Intro 431. …
3:38:42
•
130 sec
Testimony by Dylan DelliSanti, Economist at Institute for Justice, on Street Vending Economic Impact
Dylan DelliSanti, an economist from the Institute for Justice, presents research findings on the economic impact of street vending. He argues that increasing the number of mobile food vendors does …
3:40:54
•
117 sec
Testimony by Nishat Tabassum, Representative from Make the Road New York
Nishat Tabassum, representing Make the Road New York, testifies in support of proposed legislation to reform street vending regulations in New York City. She emphasizes the need for a predictable, …
3:42:55
•
175 sec
Testimony by Street Vendor from Brooklyn
A street vendor from Brooklyn testified about the challenges and fears faced by immigrant street vendors in New York City. She highlighted the difficulties of working without a license due …
3:48:01
•
3 min
Testimony by Street Vendor from Brooklyn Sunset Park
A street vendor from Brooklyn Sunset Park testifies in support of the reform packet for street vendors. She urges the council to approve several bills, including Intro 431 and Intro …
3:51:53
•
96 sec
Testimony by Salvador Quituna, Street Vendor from Brooklyn
Salvador Quituna, a street vendor from Brooklyn, testifies in support of the reform packages for street vendors. He emphasizes the importance of these reforms for vendors to work legally and …
3:53:28
•
87 sec
Testimony by Street Vendor supporting intros 431, 408, 407, and 24
A street vendor expresses support for several laws related to street vending, emphasizing the need for permits and licenses for street vendors. She specifically mentions support for Intros 431, 408, …
3:54:56
•
29 sec
Testimony by Jimmy Hernandez on Street Vending Reform
Jimmy Hernandez, a 26-year-old unemployed individual, testifies in support of street vendor package reform, specifically mentioning Intro 431. He expresses his desire to work for himself by selling household and …
3:55:38
•
120 sec
Testimony by Elsa Zamaniego, Street Vendor from Brooklyn
Elsa Zamaniego, a street vendor from Sunset Park, Brooklyn, testified about her 18-year experience as a vendor and alternative therapist. She sells accessories and quartz used in therapy to help …
3:58:07
•
142 sec
Testimony by Maryam Shuaib, Representative of Council on American Islamic Relations of New York
Maryam Shuaib, representing the Council on American Islamic Relations of New York, testified in support of Intros 408 and 431 to address the issues faced by street vendors in New …
4:02:15
•
135 sec
Testimony by High School Student from Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School
A high school student and child of street vendors testified in support of Intro 431 and Intro 408. She shared her parents' struggles as street vendors and emphasized how these …
4:04:35
•
116 sec
Testimony by Brenda Irizarry, Member of Northwest Bronx Community and Clergy Coalition
Brenda Irizarry, a member of the Northwest Bronx Community and Clergy Coalition, testified in support of Intro 431 and Intro 408, part of the street vendors reform package. She emphasized …
4:06:39
•
135 sec
Testimony by Josh Bloom, Liaison from JFREJ and Street Vendor Project
Josh Bloom, representing JFREJ and the Street Vendor Project, testified in support of Intros 431 and 408, emphasizing the historical and cultural significance of street vending in New York City, …
4:08:59
•
133 sec
Testimony by Calvin Harrison, Organizer at Street Vendor Project and JFREJ Member
Calvin Harrison, an organizer at the Street Vendor Project and JFREJ member, testifies in support of street vendors and urges the committee to pass legislation to improve their working conditions. …
4:11:17
•
128 sec
Testimony by Gillabuhilong Karayane, Street Vendor and Community Gardener
Gillabuhilong Karayane, a street vendor and community gardener, testifies in support of street vendors, emphasizing their contributions to the city and their desire to comply with laws. She refutes negative …
4:14:49
•
150 sec
Testimony by street vendor in Times Square
A street vendor in Times Square testified in support of Intro 431 and Intro 408. He shared his personal struggles as a vendor without a permit, including financial difficulties and …
4:18:37
•
55 sec
Testimony by Walid Salama, Street Vendor
Walid Salama, a street vendor for 25 years, testifies in support of bills Intro 431 and Intro 408. He describes the financial challenges of working without a permit, including high …
4:21:34
•
87 sec
Testimony by Ning Jin Fang, Street Vendor from Flushing
Ning Jin Fang, a street vendor from Flushing, testifies about the challenges faced by vendors, including frequent police actions and difficulties in obtaining permits. He emphasizes the economic contribution of …
4:24:45
•
146 sec
Testimony by Helen Fang from Flushing on Street Vending Regulations
Helen Fang from Flushing testifies about the need for better regulation and enforcement of street vending licenses. She proposes a system similar to driver's licenses, where violations result in fines …
4:27:36
•
4 min
Testimony by Al Long, Street Vendor from Flushing
Al Long, a street vendor from Flushing, shares his experiences with confiscations and violations, advocating for fair competition and the ability for small vendors to obtain licenses. He argues that …
4:32:18
•
4 min
Testimony by street vendor from Flushing on Street Vending Legislation
A street vendor from Flushing, speaking through a Mandarin interpreter, expresses support for new legislation that would legalize and protect small vendors. The vendor emphasizes the historical nature of street …
4:37:09
•
3 min
Testimony by MD Rahman, Street Vendor from Street Vendor Project
MD Rahman, a street vendor since 2010, testifies about his experiences and challenges as a food vendor in New York City. He discusses the difficulties faced by vendors, including weather …
4:42:10
•
3 min
Testimony by Julie Torres Moskovitz, Architect and Urban Designer, on Street Vending Reform
Julie Torres Moskovitz, an architect and urban designer from Brooklyn, testifies in support of street vending reform. She emphasizes the importance of vendors to the city's fabric and calls for …
4:46:20
•
155 sec
Testimony by Nick Gulotta on Street Vending Reform
Nick Gulotta, a resident of Jackson Heights, testifies in support of Intros 408 and 431, advocating for street vendor reform in New York City. He argues that the current system …
4:49:00
•
138 sec
Testimony by Abram Morris
Abram Morris, a constituent from Council Member Menin's district, testifies in support of street vendors and the proposed street vendor reform package. He emphasizes the importance of street vendors to …
4:51:22
•
125 sec
Testimony by Evelina Coyotzi, Street Vendor from Corona, Queens
Evelina Coyotzi, a street vendor for 25 years from Corona, Queens, testified in support of the street vendor reform package, emphasizing the importance of these reforms for vendors who contribute …
4:55:15
•
115 sec
Testimony by Guadalupe Sosa, Street Vendor
Guadalupe Sosa, a second-generation street vendor, testified in support of passing legislation to increase vending licenses and permits. She emphasized the need for regulation and organization of street vendors to …
4:57:17
•
129 sec
Testimony by Yomara Reyes, Street Vendor and Leader of Brunswick Vendors
Yomara Reyes, a street vendor selling t-shirts and artisanal goods, testifies about the challenges faced by vendors in New York City due to outdated laws and unjust persecution. She urges …
5:01:01
•
113 sec
Testimony by Vicente Ventimilla, Leader of the Bronx Street Vendors Group
Vicente Ventimilla, a leader of the Bronx Street Vendors Group, testifies in support of reforming informal retail legislation. He highlights the long-standing freeze on general merchandise licenses and the insufficient …
5:04:31
•
81 sec
Council member asks about reasons for vendor tickets
Council Member Pierina Sanchez inquires about the reasons vendors receive tickets. The vendors, through an interpreter, explain that they believe there's no justification for the tickets and the high amounts …
5:06:23
•
139 sec
Testimony by Yu Chao Han, Street Vendor from Flushing
Yu Chao Han, a street vendor from Flushing with a disability, testified about his reliance on street vending to support his family. He mentioned his father's lung cancer and that …
5:14:08
•
63 sec
Testimony by Flushing Vendor of Electronic Parts on Street Vending Legislation
A vendor of electronic parts from Flushing expresses support for proposed street vending laws, emphasizing the importance of vending licenses for immigrants and those with disabilities to make a living. …
5:15:31
•
5 min
Testimony by Street Vendor from Flushing on Vending Challenges
A street vendor from Flushing describes their experience becoming a vendor after losing their job, highlighting the satisfaction of customers but also the challenges faced with law enforcement and licensing …
5:20:46
•
3 min
Testimony by Street Vendor from Flushing on Street Vending Permits
An elderly vendor from Flushing testifies about their desire to obtain a legal vending permit. The vendor, who is 70 years old, sells clothing items in Flushing and expresses that …
5:24:56
•
50 sec
Testimony by Rosie Alvarez, Street Vendor from The Bronx
Rosie Alvarez, a street vendor from The Bronx, testifies about her experience as a vendor for over 20 years and the challenges she faces due to the lack of available …
5:28:13
•
154 sec
Testimony by Margarita, Street Vendor from the Bronx
Margarita, a street vendor from the Bronx with over 25 years of experience, testifies about the challenges faced by vendors due to enforcement actions and the difficulty of obtaining permits. …
5:31:39
•
4 min
Testimony by Teresa Carpio, Street Vendor from Corona, Queens
Teresa Carpio, an Ecuadorian street vendor from Corona, Queens, testifies in support of the street vendor reform package, emphasizing the importance of vending for her livelihood and family. She highlights …
5:35:52
•
3 min
Testimony by Macrina Navarrete, Leader of Bronx Street Vendors
Macrina Navarrete, a leader of Bronx Street Vendors and seller of Amway Vitamins in the Bronx, testifies in support of the street vending reform package. She highlights the challenges faced …
5:41:55
•
89 sec
Testimony by Andrew Gustafson, Vice President of Turnstile Tours & Studio, on Street Vending Reform
Andrew Gustafson, Vice President of Turnstile Tours & Studio, testified in support of Intros 431 and 408, emphasizing the challenges faced by street vendors in New York City. He highlighted …
5:45:19
•
137 sec
Testimony by Street Vendor on Vending Permit Reform
A street vendor, speaking through a Spanish interpreter, appeals for vending permit reform. She shares her personal experience of working in street vending for 15 years and the challenges of …
5:49:21
•
3 min
Testimony by Lola, Street Vendor from Ecuador
Lola, a street vendor from Ecuador, testifies about her experiences and challenges as a vendor in New York City. She expresses fear and anxiety due to repeated confiscations of her …
5:53:19
•
73 sec
Testimony by Marlene Ensaldo, Leader of the Bronx Street Vendors
Marlene Ensaldo, leader of the Bronx Street Vendors, testifies about the aspirations of street vendors' children and the importance of street vending for their families' survival and future. She urges …
5:57:11
•
3 min
Testimony by Anna, Leader of Bronx Street Vendors
Anna, a leader of Bronx Street Vendors, testified in support of the proposed package of laws for street vending, emphasizing the need for real changes and inclusive legislation. She criticized …
6:00:24
•
57 sec
Testimony by Tiffany Hervas, President of National Association of Puerto Rican Hispanic Social Workers and Co-founder of Algundia
Tiffany Hervas testified in support of Intros 408 and 431, focusing on the challenges faced by immigrant families and children engaged in street vending. She emphasized the need for regulatory …
6:01:29
•
3 min
Testimony by Florca Madero, Street Vendor from Corona Plaza
Florca Madero, a street vendor from Corona Plaza, testified to request permits for street vendors to work freely. She emphasized that vendors work to support their families and do not …
6:04:53
•
54 sec
Testimony by Mohammed Awad, Street Vendor
Mohammed Awad, a street vendor, testified in support of the street vendor project budget and addressed misconceptions about vendors. He refuted claims that vendors don't pay tickets and criticized organizations …
6:07:42
•
127 sec
Testimony by Jennifer Salgado, Daughter of Former Street Vendor and Bronx Resident
Jennifer Salgado, a daughter of a former street vendor and Bronx resident, testifies in support of the street vendor reform package, particularly bills Intro 431 and Intro 408. She highlights …
6:09:53
•
121 sec
Testimony by Leeanne G-Bowley, Director of Public Programs and Partnerships from Elmhurst, Queens
Leeanne G-Bowley, a homeowner and community board member from Elmhurst, Queens, testified in support of Intros 431 and 408 regarding street vending. She emphasized the positive impact of street vendors …
6:12:33
•
157 sec
Testimony by Mahmoud Zayed, Street Vendor
Mahmoud Zayed, a street vendor since 2008, testified about the challenges faced by food vendors in New York City. He emphasized the high costs of fines and the unfair permit …
6:15:16
•
145 sec
Testimony by Street Vendor on Permit Issues and Reform
A street vendor shares their frustrating experience with obtaining proper permits and facing enforcement actions. They express support for permit reforms to allow vendors to work legally without fear of …
6:18:35
•
135 sec
Testimony by Jackson Chabot, Director of Advocacy and Organizing at Open Plans
Jackson Chabot, representing Open Plans, expresses strong support for Intro 431 and Intro 408, which propose reforms to New York City's street vending laws. He emphasizes the cultural and economic …
6:20:55
•
131 sec
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson, Member of the Public
Christopher Leon Johnson testified in support of street vendor reform bills, advocating for lifting all caps on street vending licenses and allowing vendors to sell without harassment. He criticized Council …
6:24:16
•
139 sec
Testimony by Walid Salama, Street Vendor
Walid Salama, a street vendor and member of the Street Vendor Project, provided testimony on the challenges faced by street vendors in New York City. He emphasized the importance of …
6:29:40
•
68 sec
Testimony by Bill Bruno, Member of the Public from Jackson Heights
Bill Bruno, a resident of Jackson Heights, testifies in support of Intros 408 and 431 regarding street vending reform. He argues that the current enforcement-heavy approach is ineffective and that …
6:31:19
•
125 sec
Testimony by Sandra Jaquez, President of New York State Latino Restaurant Bar & Lounge Association
Sandra Jaquez, representing the New York State Latino Restaurant Bar & Lounge Association, expressed concerns about the current state of street vending in New York City. She emphasized the need …
6:33:34
•
124 sec
Testimony by Justin Pollack from an investment firm on the importance of street vendors for office workers
Justin Pollack, an employee at a Manhattan investment firm, testifies about the positive impact of street vendors on office workers' willingness to return to work in person. He argues that …
6:35:45
•
115 sec
Testimony by Ariel Mintz on Street Vending for Independent Clothing Label
Ariel Mintz, an aspiring independent clothing label owner, expressed support for the proposed street vending resolutions. He highlighted the potential benefits of street vending for connecting with customers and building …
6:38:09
•
45 sec
Testimony by Rob Martinez, Filmmaker and Content Creator
Rob Martinez, a filmmaker and content creator, testifies in support of Intros 431 and 408, highlighting the cultural significance of New York City street vendors and the challenges they face. …
6:39:08
•
130 sec