New York City Council
Committee on Cultural Affairs, Libraries and International Intergroup Relations
Dec 10, 2024
·
10:00 AM
2 hr 26 min
Summary
A hearing on supporting the arts, culture, and history of indigenous peoples in New York City.
Discussions focused on:
- Recognizing and amplifying indigenous voices, particularly those of the Lenape people
- Establishing permanent spaces for indigenous arts and culture
- Increasing funding for indigenous-led organizations and artists
- Improving educational resources and programming
- Addressing challenges such as housing affordability for artists
The hearing also explored partnerships between cultural institutions and indigenous groups, and the upcoming 400th anniversary of Dutch colonization as an opportunity to reframe historical narratives.
Features testimony from the Department of Cultural Affairs (DCLA), New York Public Library, Brooklyn Public Library, Queens Public Library, Museum of the City of New York, various cultural institutions, indigenous organizations, individual artists, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Carlina Rivera's opening remarks on supporting indigenous arts and culture
Council Member Carlina Rivera, chair of the Committee on Cultural Affairs, Libraries, and International Intergroup Relations, opens the oversight hearing on supporting the arts, culture, and history of indigenous peoples …
0:00:22
·
3 min
Introduction and opening remarks by DCLA Commissioner
Commissioner Laurie Cumbo of the NYC Department of Cultural Affairs opens her remarks at the hearing on arts, culture, and history of indigenous peoples in New York City. - Acknowledges …
0:04:06
·
41 sec
Importance of recognizing and celebrating Native American culture in NYC
Commissioner Cumbo emphasizes the growing momentum to recognize and celebrate Native American culture in New York City. She highlights the significant presence of Native Americans in the city and the …
0:04:47
·
96 sec
Recent Lenape Cultural Fair in Prospect Park
Commissioner Cumbo shares her experience at the recent Lenape Cultural Fair in Prospect Park, highlighting it as a vibrant celebration of indigenous culture. - The fair featured traditional crafts, artwork, …
0:06:24
·
50 sec
DCLA's support for cultural organizations featuring indigenous programming
Commissioner Cumbo outlines how the Department of Cultural Affairs supports cultural life in New York City, particularly in relation to indigenous programming. - DCLA primarily supports culture through funding to …
0:07:15
·
28 sec
Examples of indigenous programming at NYC cultural institutions
Commissioner Cumbo provides numerous examples of indigenous programming, exhibitions, and events from various cultural institutions supported by DCLA. - Historic Richmond Town's native encampment site and special programs - New …
0:07:44
·
4 min
DCLA's partnerships and funding for Native American cultural organizations
Commissioner Cumbo details DCLA's partnerships and funding initiatives supporting Native American cultural organizations in New York City. - DCLA works with the city council to invest in organizations through various …
0:12:03
·
171 sec
Public art commissions featuring Native American artists
Commissioner Cumbo highlights public art commissions featuring Native American artists through DCLA's Percent for Art program. - Jeffrey Gibson designed a mural for a community room in the NYPD's 40th …
0:14:55
·
22 sec
Upcoming 400th anniversary of Dutch colonization and related programming
Commissioner Cumbo discusses the upcoming 400th anniversary of Dutch colonization of Lenape land and related initiatives to mark this milestone. - The anniversary provides an opportunity to explore new, more …
0:15:18
·
52 sec
Current momentum in recognizing indigenous voices and closing remarks
Commissioner Cumbo concludes by highlighting the current momentum in recognizing and amplifying indigenous voices in New York City and beyond. - New opportunities are opening up for Native American artists …
0:16:10
·
85 sec
Council Member Rivera introduces the discussion on indigenous arts funding
Council Member Carlina Rivera opens the discussion by acknowledging other council members and addressing Commissioner Cumbo about the importance of supporting indigenous artists and organizations. She inquires about DCLA's plans …
0:17:36
·
73 sec
DCLA funding process and challenges for indigenous organizations
Commissioner Laurie Cumbo explains the DCLA funding process and challenges faced in supporting indigenous arts organizations. She outlines the current funding structure and suggests ways to increase support for indigenous …
0:18:51
·
143 sec
Suggestions for creating dedicated funding for indigenous arts
Commissioner Cumbo explains that DCLA cannot give priority to specific organizations due to the panel review process. She suggests alternative ways to create dedicated funding for indigenous arts and cultural …
0:21:15
·
65 sec
Affordability crisis and support for indigenous artists in NYC
Council Member Rivera addresses the affordability crisis in New York City and its impact on artists, particularly indigenous artists. She inquires about DCLA's efforts to ensure indigenous artists can continue …
0:22:22
·
44 sec
DCLA's efforts to fund and support indigenous artists
Commissioner Cumbo outlines DCLA's various efforts to fund and support indigenous artists in New York City. She describes multiple programs and initiatives aimed at providing opportunities and resources for the …
0:23:08
·
110 sec
Housing issues for artists in NYC
Council Member Rivera briefly addresses the critical issue of housing for artists in New York City. Commissioner Cumbo agrees on the importance of the topic and suggests future collaboration. - …
0:24:59
·
17 sec
Educational component and awareness of indigenous arts and culture
Council Member Rivera inquires about the educational role of arts organizations and whether New Yorkers are sufficiently aware of the importance of indigenous arts and culture. Commissioner Cumbo responds by …
0:25:16
·
170 sec
Legacy of colonialism and the need for support for indigenous communities
Council Member Rivera emphasizes the importance of addressing the legacy of colonialism, exclusion, and erasure of indigenous communities. She stresses the need for tangible support, including funding and representation, led …
0:28:08
·
67 sec
Closing remarks and commitment to remain for the hearing
Commissioner Cumbo and Council Member Rivera exchange closing remarks, with Cumbo committing to stay for the remainder of the hearing and Rivera thanking her for her testimony. - Cumbo expresses …
0:29:15
·
9 sec
Joe Baker introduces himself and his Lenape heritage
Joe Baker, an enrolled member of the Delaware Tribe of Indians, introduces himself and provides context about his Lenape heritage. He mentions his tribal affiliation and his family's history of …
0:30:21
·
20 sec
Historical context of Lenape people and their contributions to New York
Joe Baker provides historical context about the Lenape people's significant role in early American history and their contributions to New York. He references a painting of George Washington to illustrate …
0:30:44
·
54 sec
The Lenape Center and its challenges in New York City
Joe Baker discusses the Lenape Center, which he co-founded and directs, and the challenges it faces in maintaining Lenape cultural presence in New York City. He expresses disappointment at the …
0:31:40
·
57 sec
Missed opportunity: Nora Thompson Dean's visit to Mayor Koch
Joe Baker recounts a story from 40 years ago about tribal elder Nora Thompson Dean's attempt to meet with then-Mayor Ed Koch at City Hall. This anecdote illustrates the historical …
0:32:39
·
75 sec
Recent progress: Chief Brad Kills Crow's meeting with Mayor Adams
Joe Baker highlights a recent positive development in Lenape relations with New York City leadership, contrasting it with the missed opportunity from 40 years ago. - On November 1, 2024, …
0:33:56
·
33 sec
The importance of recognizing Lenape as distinct
Joe Baker emphasizes the importance of recognizing the Lenape people as distinct from other groups, rather than lumping them under a general 'people of color' or 'native communities' umbrella. He …
0:34:30
·
57 sec
Consultation with federally recognized Lenape nations
Joe Baker stresses the importance of consulting with federally recognized Lenape nations when developing programs for art and culture. He emphasizes the sovereign status of these nations and their historical …
0:35:29
·
68 sec
Call for respect and celebration of Lenape sovereignty and culture
Joe Baker concludes his testimony with a direct appeal to the city and the committee, calling for respect of Lenape sovereignty and culture, and for celebration of the unique story …
0:36:39
·
21 sec
Introduction and overview of BPL Presents program
Joel Whitney, the BPL Presents literary curator at Brooklyn Public Library, introduces himself and provides an overview of the library's year-round arts and culture events program. He highlights the diverse …
0:37:04
·
62 sec
Initial collaboration with the Lenape Center
Joel Whitney describes the beginning of Brooklyn Public Library's collaboration with the Lenape Center, emphasizing the importance of the Lenape as the original inhabitants of New York City. - BPL …
0:38:06
·
33 sec
Lenapehoking exhibition at Greenpoint Library
Joel Whitney details the Lenapehoking exhibition, a groundbreaking showcase of Lenape cultural arts curated by Joe Baker at the Greenpoint Library and Environmental Education Center. - The exhibition used contemporary …
0:38:40
·
113 sec
Lenapehoking anthology and curriculum development
Joel Whitney explains the creation and impact of the Lenapehoking anthology, a collaborative project between BPL and the Lenape Center to address the lack of published materials on Lenape culture. …
0:40:34
·
73 sec
Indigenous materials acquisition and services committee
Joel Whitney describes BPL's efforts to improve its collection and services related to indigenous materials and stories. - BPL staff worked with the Lenape Center to identify books that should …
0:41:47
·
38 sec
Heritage Ambassador program supporting indigenous artists
Joel Whitney introduces BPL's Heritage Ambassador program, which supports folk and traditional artists in Brooklyn, including indigenous artists. - The program connects library patrons to cultural heritage practices through art-making, …
0:42:26
·
36 sec
Conclusion: BPL's living land acknowledgment in action
Joel Whitney concludes his testimony by framing BPL's initiatives as part of a living land acknowledgment, emphasizing the library's commitment to supporting indigenous cultures through action. - BPL considers all …
0:43:03
·
22 sec
Introduction and overview of Queens Public Library's mission
Sharon Myrie, Vice President of Programs and Services at Queens Public Library, introduces herself and provides an overview of the library's mission. She emphasizes QPL's commitment to welcoming all individuals …
0:43:29
·
65 sec
Queens Public Library's collections on indigenous peoples
Queens Public Library offers a comprehensive collection of materials focused on indigenous peoples, including books, ebooks, periodicals, and multimedia resources. - The collection covers various aspects of indigenous life, including …
0:44:35
·
44 sec
Programming for Indigenous Peoples' Day and Native American Heritage Month
Queens Public Library offers special programming during Indigenous Peoples' Day and Native American Heritage Month to highlight indigenous cultures and histories. - Programs include a Native American-focused QPL Baby and …
0:45:19
·
37 sec
Queens Memory Project and collaborations on indigenous history
The Queens Memory Project, a collaboration between QPL and CUNY Queens College, focuses on collecting and preserving local histories, including those of indigenous peoples. - A notable project is the …
0:45:57
·
122 sec
Queens Public Library's archives on indigenous peoples
Queens Public Library maintains extensive archives documenting the lives and histories of indigenous peoples in the region. - The archives include an interview with Chief Little Fox, discussing Native American …
0:48:00
·
67 sec
Research databases and resources on indigenous peoples
Queens Public Library offers access to various research databases and resources focused on indigenous peoples and their histories. - Britannica Academic provides comprehensive information on the Lenape and other native …
0:49:07
·
82 sec
Conclusion and future plans for indigenous resources at QPL
Queens Public Library reaffirms its commitment to serving as a free and trusted repository of information, with a focus on expanding resources related to indigenous peoples. - QPL acknowledges that …
0:50:29
·
36 sec
Introduction to NYPL's support for indigenous arts, culture, and history
Jason Baumann, Director for Collection Development and Global Studies at the New York Public Library, introduces the library's efforts to support indigenous arts, culture, and history in New York City. …
0:51:09
·
38 sec
NYPL's extensive research collections on indigenous peoples
The New York Public Library houses a vast collection of over 100,000 volumes documenting indigenous peoples of the Americas. These research collections span centuries and continents, offering a comprehensive resource …
0:51:48
·
86 sec
Recent acquisitions and collaborations in indigenous collections
NYPL has recently expanded its indigenous collections through new acquisitions and collaborative efforts. The library has focused on acquiring visual works by contemporary indigenous artists and forming partnerships to enhance …
0:53:15
·
149 sec
Exhibitions and programs highlighting indigenous voices
NYPL hosts a variety of exhibitions and programs that showcase indigenous arts, culture, and history. These events range from author talks to major exhibitions featuring indigenous works and perspectives. - …
0:55:46
·
134 sec
Branch library initiatives supporting indigenous culture
NYPL's branch libraries conduct various initiatives to support and promote indigenous arts, culture, and history. These efforts aim to engage local communities and highlight indigenous voices through diverse programming. - …
0:58:01
·
81 sec
World Literature Festival and indigenous languages
NYPL's annual World Literature Festival provides a platform for celebrating indigenous languages and literature. The festival features events and discussions that highlight the diversity of indigenous voices and languages. - …
0:59:23
·
44 sec
Conclusion: NYPL's commitment to indigenous representation
Jason Baumann concludes his testimony by reaffirming the New York Public Library's dedication to representing and featuring the works and stories of indigenous peoples across all aspects of its operations. …
1:00:08
·
17 sec
Council Member Rivera acknowledges challenges and importance of indigenous arts and culture
Council Member Carlina Rivera opens the discussion by acknowledging the struggles faced by indigenous communities and the importance of arts and culture. She emphasizes the need to balance recognition of …
1:00:26
·
95 sec
Joe Baker discusses the need for a permanent Lenape Center in New York City
Joe Baker, Executive Director of the Lenape Center, responds to Council Member Rivera's question about the center's vision for the future. He emphasizes the critical need for a permanent physical …
1:02:03
·
90 sec
Ensuring authentic representation and curation of Lenape culture
Council Member Rivera and Joe Baker discuss the importance of authentic curation and representation of Lenape culture. Baker emphasizes the need for proper consultation with federally recognized tribal nations. - …
1:03:36
·
77 sec
Exploring partnerships and support for the Lenape Center
Council Member Rivera and Joe Baker discuss potential partnerships and support to help grow the Lenape Center's capacity and presence in New York City. They explore ways to leverage agency …
1:04:55
·
101 sec
Library systems' approaches to indigenous programming and public awareness
Council Member Rivera inquires about the processes used by different library systems for selecting indigenous pieces for exhibitions and ensuring public awareness of programming related to indigenous artists and talent. …
1:06:38
·
159 sec
Content creation and partnerships for authentic Lenape storytelling
Representatives from Brooklyn Public Library discuss their efforts in content creation and partnerships to tell authentic Lenape stories, addressing the lack of accurate materials available. - Brooklyn Public Library has …
1:09:19
·
81 sec
Planning for the Americas 250th exhibition and Lenape artist commissions
Jason Baumann from the New York Public Library briefly discusses the planning for the Americas 250th exhibition, which will include Lenape representation. - The curatorial team for the Americas 250th …
1:10:41
·
18 sec
Council Member Rivera emphasizes the importance of arts and culture in New York City's identity
Council Member Carlina Rivera concludes the session by emphasizing the crucial role of arts and culture in New York City's identity and well-being, and expresses appreciation for the work being …
1:11:00
·
96 sec
Testimony by Maeve Montalvo, Director of Education at Museum of the City of New York
Maeve Montalvo, Director of Education at the Museum of the City of New York, testified about the museum's efforts to support and showcase indigenous arts, culture, and history, particularly focusing …
1:14:57
·
4 min
Testimony by Ty Defoe, Transgender Indigiqueer Artist from Oneida Nation and Anishinaabe Tribe
Ty Defoe, a transgender indigiqueer artist from the Oneida Nation and Anishinaabe tribe, shared his experiences as an indigenous artist in New York City. He emphasized the importance of community, …
1:19:55
·
7 min
Testimony by Ika Santamaria, Representative from Coopdanza
Ika Santamaria, representing Coopdanza, testified about the organization's work in promoting indigenous cultures in New York City through interdisciplinary art, media, and educational programs. She highlighted Coopdanza's mission to foster …
1:27:15
·
147 sec
Testimony by Brent Stonefish, Member of Eenda-Lunaapeewahkiing Collective
Brent Stonefish, representing the Eenda-Lunaapeewahkiing Collective, provided testimony on Lenape presence and initiatives in New York City. He discussed the collective's partnerships, language preservation efforts, and challenges faced by indigenous …
1:30:13
·
5 min
Council member emphasizes importance of hearing and supporting marginalized communities
Council Member Carlina Rivera expresses gratitude for the testimonies and emphasizes the importance of the hearing in bringing people together and sharing information. She highlights her commitment to supporting marginalized …
1:36:06
·
105 sec
Testimony by Laura Phipps, Associate Curator and Co-chair of Indigenous Artists and Audiences Working Group at Whitney Museum of American Art
Laura Phipps presented testimony on behalf of the Whitney Museum of American Art, focusing on their efforts to incorporate indigenous art and engage with indigenous artists and communities. She highlighted …
1:39:34
·
3 min
Testimony by Murielle Borst Tarrant, Artistic Director of Safe Harbors NYC
Murielle Borst Tarrant, Artistic Director of Safe Harbors NYC, testified about the need for greater support and recognition of Native American theater and performing arts in New York City. She …
1:43:01
·
5 min
Testimony by Natalia Mesa, Community Engagement Director of Ballet Hispanico
Natalia Mesa, representing Ballet Hispanico, advocated for continued support of cultural organizations, especially those led by indigenous, black, and people of color. She highlighted Ballet Hispanico's approach to incorporating indigenous …
1:48:45
·
124 sec
Testimony by Janice Monger, President and CEO of Staten Island Museum
Janice Monger, President and CEO of Staten Island Museum, provided testimony on the museum's efforts to preserve, display, and educate about Lenape cultural heritage. She highlighted the museum's collections, educational …
1:50:54
·
151 sec
Testimony by Katie Hill, Assistant to the Executive Director of Perelman Performing Arts Center at the World Trade Center (PAC NYC)
Katie Hill presented testimony on behalf of PAC NYC, highlighting their commitment to working with indigenous artists and communities. She detailed various initiatives, partnerships, and programming that showcase indigenous voices …
1:57:19
·
3 min
Testimony by Dylan Yeats, Director of Museum Programs and Operations at Prospect Park Alliance
Dylan Yeats, representing Prospect Park Alliance, discussed their efforts to honor indigenous cultures and histories at Lefferts Historic House Museum. He highlighted recent initiatives, partnerships, and funding sources that support …
2:00:42
·
3 min
Testimony by Luke Boyd, Director of Education and Public Programs at Historic Richmond Town
Luke Boyd from Historic Richmond Town advocates for financial support for cultural organizations and indigenous artists, scholars, and presenters. He discusses the creation of a native encampment exhibit at Historic …
2:04:11
·
3 min
Testimony by George Stonefish, Founder of Eenda-Lunaapeewahkiing Collective
George Stonefish, founder of the Eenda-Lunaapeewahkiing Collective, provided testimony on Lenape history, culture, and initiatives in New York City. He discussed the formation of the Lenapehokam Circle, recent cultural events, …
2:08:05
·
11 min
Council member expresses gratitude and acknowledges funding needs
Council Member Carlina Rivera responds to the previous speaker with heartfelt appreciation and acknowledges the need for financial support in the indigenous arts and culture sector. She emphasizes the importance …
2:19:18
·
44 sec
Testimony by Lucy Sexton, Executive Director of New Yorkers for Culture & Arts
Lucy Sexton, Executive Director of New Yorkers for Culture & Arts, testified on the importance of supporting indigenous arts and culture in New York City. She highlighted the economic challenges …
2:20:35
·
147 sec
Testimony by Bortriramkamanis Qucano Nur, Member of the Public and Tradition Bearer of the Maranao People
Bortriramkamanis Qucano Nur, a Filipino nurse and tradition bearer of the Maranao people from Southern Philippines, testifies about the importance of preserving indigenous traditions and visibility in New York City. …
2:23:27
·
147 sec
