New York City Council
Committee on Rules, Privileges and Elections
Aug 27, 2024
·
10:00 AM
11 hr 7 min
Summary
A hearing on the nomination of Randy Mastro for the position of Corporation Counsel.
Council members questioned Mastro extensively about his qualifications, experience, and past work, particularly his time as Deputy Mayor in the Giuliani administration.
Features testimony from the Randy Mastro, members of the legal community, advocacy groups, and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Keith Powers opens hearing on Randy Mastro's nomination for Corporation Counsel
Council Member Keith Powers opens the meeting of the Committee on Rules, Privileges, and Elections, introducing committee members and staff. He emphasizes the need for respect during the hearing and …
0:00:28
·
157 sec
Qualifications and responsibilities of the Corporation Counsel
Council Member Adams outlines the qualifications and responsibilities required for the position of Corporation Counsel, emphasizing that legal expertise alone is not sufficient. - The role requires a high standard …
0:03:21
·
86 sec
Council's role and responsibility in the Corporation Counsel nomination process
Council Member Adams explains the City Council's role and responsibility in evaluating the nomination for Corporation Counsel, emphasizing the importance of transparency and accountability. - The Council's duty is to …
0:04:48
·
172 sec
Importance of diversity and representation in city leadership
Council Member Adams emphasizes the importance of diversity and representation in city leadership, highlighting that top positions in government are not entitlements but privileges. - Adams notes that women and …
0:07:41
·
70 sec
Council Member Keith Powers introduces Randy Mastro and explains the role of Corporation Counsel
Council Member Keith Powers introduces Randy Mastro as the nominee for Corporation Counsel and provides an overview of the position's responsibilities and powers. He explains the role of the Corporation …
0:08:53
·
108 sec
Randy Mastro's opening remarks and expression of gratitude
Randy Mastro opens his testimony by expressing gratitude to the Speaker, Chair Powers, Rules Committee members, other council members, and the Public Advocate for the opportunity to present his qualifications …
0:11:02
·
14 sec
Mastro's qualifications and extensive career background
Randy Mastro presents his qualifications for the position of Corporation Counsel, highlighting his extensive career in both public service and private practice. He emphasizes his experience and dedication to using …
0:11:17
·
55 sec
Acknowledgment of Mastro's widespread support
Randy Mastro expresses gratitude for the widespread support he has received for his nomination, highlighting endorsements from various sectors of the legal and political community. - Thanks his family for …
0:12:12
·
114 sec
Clarification of Mastro's political affiliations and past work
Randy Mastro clarifies his political affiliations and provides context for his past work, addressing potential misconceptions about his background and values. - Identifies himself as a lifelong Democrat who has …
0:14:07
·
73 sec
Mastro's extensive pro bono work and advocacy
Randy Mastro highlights his extensive pro bono work and advocacy for various causes, demonstrating his commitment to social justice and public service beyond his paid legal work. - Represented peaceful …
0:15:21
·
58 sec
Mastro's vision for the Law Department
Randy Mastro outlines his vision for the Law Department, emphasizing a proactive approach to legal advocacy and a commitment to addressing a wide range of issues affecting New Yorkers. - …
0:16:21
·
68 sec
Mastro's personal background and core values
Randy Mastro shares his personal background and the values that have shaped his career and approach to public service, emphasizing his immigrant roots and family history. - Grandson of Italian …
0:17:29
·
80 sec
Mastro's stance on key social and political issues
Randy Mastro outlines his positions and track record on various social and political issues that are important to New Yorkers and council members: - Advocated for women's rights, including prosecuting …
0:18:50
·
3 min
Mastro addresses controversy surrounding his nomination
Randy Mastro directly addresses the controversy surrounding his nomination, emphasizing his qualifications and widespread support within the legal and political community. - Acknowledges that controversy stems from a few cases …
0:22:44
·
66 sec
Mastro asserts his independence and integrity
Randy Mastro strongly asserts his independence and integrity, addressing concerns that he might act solely as the mayor's lawyer if appointed as Corporation Counsel. - Emphasizes his reputation as 'his …
0:23:51
·
43 sec
Mastro's pledge to represent both council and administration
Randy Mastro pledges to represent both the city council and the administration impartially and professionally: - Acknowledges the reported tensions between the mayor and the council - Emphasizes that his …
0:24:36
·
86 sec
Mastro's request to respond to public comments
Randy Mastro concludes his testimony by requesting an opportunity to respond to public comments made during the hearing: - Expresses willingness to remain for the entire hearing - Requests the …
0:26:04
·
35 sec
Council Member Keith Powers explains hearing procedures for Corporation Counsel nomination
Council Member Keith Powers outlines the purpose and procedures for the hearing on the Corporation Counsel nominee. He emphasizes the importance of examining the nominee's record and determining their commitment …
0:27:07
·
170 sec
Mastro's commitment to accessibility for council members
Council Member Keith Powers questions Randy Mastro about his promise to be accessible to council members without requiring them to fill out forms. - Mastro promises to be on 'speed …
0:30:10
·
30 sec
Request for additional documentation on Mastro's cases against the city
Council Member Keith Powers inquires about additional documentation requested from Randy Mastro regarding his past cases against the city. Mastro commits to providing more information but notes potential limitations due …
0:30:41
·
147 sec
Mastro's past and current relationships with law firms
Council Member Keith Powers questions Randy Mastro about his relationships with Gibson Dunn & Crutcher and King & Spalding law firms, both past and present. Mastro clarifies his history with …
0:33:08
·
104 sec
Recusal plans and guidance from the Conflicts of Interest Board
Council Member Keith Powers inquires about Randy Mastro's recusal plans based on guidance from the Conflicts of Interest Board. Mastro confirms his agreement with the guidance and his commitment to …
0:34:52
·
123 sec
Mastro's recusal from cases involving current clients
Council Member Powers questions Randy Mastro about his recusal from cases involving current clients, specifically mentioning Local Law 97. Mastro confirms he would recuse himself from any current matter involving …
0:36:54
·
33 sec
Statute of limitations on recusals from past or present clients
Council Member Powers inquires about the duration of recusals for past or present clients. Mastro explains the policy on recusal timeframes and potential extensions. - Recusal typically lasts for the …
0:37:27
·
26 sec
Process for determining when recusal is necessary
Council Member Powers inquires about the process for determining when recusal is necessary, particularly in cases involving present clients with different attorneys. Mastro explains his approach to recusal decisions. - …
0:37:54
·
85 sec
Handling cases similar to past representations
Council Member Powers asks about Mastro's approach to handling cases similar to his past representations, using the example of Local Law 97. Mastro states he would recuse himself from any …
0:39:20
·
26 sec
Mastro's involvement in G-Max Management case challenging rent control laws
Council Member Powers questions Mastro about his involvement in the G-Max Management case challenging rent control laws and potential conflicts with his role as Corporation Counsel. Mastro explains the nature …
0:39:46
·
171 sec
Mastro's involvement in New Jersey's congestion pricing case
Council Member Powers inquires about other areas where Mastro might need to recuse himself, leading to a detailed discussion of the congestion pricing litigation. Mastro explains his involvement and stance …
0:42:37
·
170 sec
Impact of recusals on Corporation Counsel's ability to represent the city
Council Member Powers expresses concerns about how Mastro's recusals might affect his ability to work on important issues as Corporation Counsel. Mastro responds by explaining the value he believes he …
0:45:28
·
144 sec
Discussion on litigation as a strategy to delay or prevent policy implementation
Council Member Powers raises the concern that litigation is often used as a strategy to delay or prevent policy outcomes. Mastro responds to this concern and explains how his experience …
0:47:52
·
140 sec
Questioning Mastro's ability to represent all city officers impartially
Council Member Adams questions Randy Mastro about his ability to represent all city officers impartially, given his history with the Giuliani administration. Mastro defends his record, citing endorsements from Democratic …
0:50:12
·
3 min
Examining Mastro's record during the Giuliani administration
Council Member Adams presses Mastro on his record during the Giuliani administration, particularly regarding the administration's relationship with the City Council. Mastro defends his tenure, emphasizing his role in building …
0:53:47
·
147 sec
Addressing Mastro's past comments on the public advocate's office
Council Member Adams questions Mastro about his past comments regarding the public advocate's office, particularly his role in a charter revision commission. Mastro defends his actions, explaining his stance on …
0:56:14
·
120 sec
Responsibilities and expectations of the Corporation Counsel
Council Member Adams outlines the critical responsibilities of the Corporation Counsel, emphasizing the need to prioritize the city's long-term interests and provide transparent advice to elected officials. - The Corporation …
0:58:19
·
92 sec
Mastro's professional history and approach to public service
Randy Mastro discusses his professional history and approach to public service, highlighting his experience in both private practice and government roles. - Emphasizes his reputation for reaching across the aisle …
0:59:54
·
159 sec
Values and principles expected of the Corporation Counsel
Council Member Adams outlines the values and principles expected of the Corporation Counsel, emphasizing the need to serve all residents and consider the public interest. - The Corporation Counsel must …
1:02:33
·
158 sec
Mastro's record on civil rights and public safety
Randy Mastro emphasizes his long-standing commitment to civil rights, constitutional rights, and racial justice throughout his career. - Highlights his pro bono work, including standing up against federal authorities during …
1:05:13
·
3 min
Brooklyn Museum controversy and legal advice
Council Member Adams raises concerns about the Law Department's actions during the Giuliani administration, specifically regarding the Brooklyn Museum controversy in 1999. - Adams cites the incident where the Corporation …
1:09:04
·
3 min
Pro bono work and diversity in law firms
Council Member Adams inquires about Mastro's plans for pro bono services and the commitment to diversity in the legal community. - Mastro discusses his plans to develop a large-scale program …
1:12:23
·
149 sec
Collaboration with private firms and building the Law Department
Council Member Adams and Randy Mastro discuss the collaboration between the Law Department and private law firms, as well as strategies for building up the municipal workforce. - Adams raises …
1:14:52
·
4 min
Regarding Mayor Eric Adams administration's respect for democratic governance
Council Member Adams raises concerns about the Adams administration's respect for separation of powers and democratic governance. - Adams cites examples of the administration disregarding duly passed laws by the …
1:19:23
·
164 sec
State of emergency and solitary confinement law
Council Member Adams questions Mastro about the administration's use of a state of emergency to block a law banning solitary confinement. - Adams asks if Mastro would advise continuing the …
1:22:08
·
67 sec
Executive branch actions and independent government bodies
Council Member Adams questions Mastro about Mayor Adams' accusations against the Campaign Finance Board and the impact of the executive branch undermining independent government bodies. - Adams raises concerns about …
1:23:16
·
152 sec
Questions about Mastro's pro bono work for Mayor Adams' office
Council Member Diana Ayala questioned Randy Mastro about his pro bono legal work for Mayor Adams' office in 2023. Mastro revealed that the work was related to the migrant crisis, …
1:25:49
·
154 sec
Concerns about Mastro's impartiality given his relationship with the mayor
Council Member Ayala raised concerns about Mastro's impartiality as Corporation Counsel, given his undisclosed pro bono work for Mayor Adams' office. Mastro defended his actions, stating he viewed it as …
1:28:23
·
96 sec
Mastro's involvement in Rudy Giuliani's campaigns
Council Member Ayala questioned Mastro about his involvement in Rudy Giuliani's political campaigns. Mastro acknowledged his roles in Giuliani's 1993 mayoral campaign and 2007 presidential campaign, but clarified some details …
1:30:00
·
3 min
Mastro's representation of clients against vulnerable populations
Council Member Ayala criticized Mastro's record of representing clients who she claimed were against the interests of vulnerable populations in New York City. She expressed concern about Mastro's ability to …
1:33:12
·
3 min
Mastro's defense of his actions in the Lucerne Hotel shelter case
Randy Mastro defended his actions in the Lucerne Hotel shelter case, arguing that his involvement was mischaracterized. He claimed to have worked collaboratively with the De Blasio administration to find …
1:36:21
·
83 sec
Questioning Mastro's litigation tactics in the Lucerne Hotel case
Council Member Ayala questioned Mastro about his controversial litigation tactics in the Lucerne Hotel case, specifically the use of private investigators to photograph a homeless activist. Mastro attempted to defend …
1:37:44
·
3 min
Ethical concerns about Mastro's litigation tactics and moral character
Council Member Ayala raised serious concerns about Randy Mastro's ethical conduct and moral character, particularly regarding his litigation tactics in cases involving vulnerable populations. She questioned whether Mastro's past actions …
1:41:17
·
5 min
Mastro's defense of his actions regarding AIDS services and Housing Works contracts
Randy Mastro strongly defended his actions regarding AIDS services and Housing Works contracts during his time in the Giuliani administration. He disputed Ayala's characterization of events and emphasized his advocacy …
1:46:49
·
171 sec
Questions about Mastro's ability to act without retaliation as Corporation Counsel
Council Member Ayala questioned Randy Mastro's ability to act without retaliation as Corporation Counsel, citing past incidents where the Giuliani administration was found to have acted with retaliatory intent. Mastro …
1:49:40
·
53 sec
Discussion of Fran Reiter as a character witness for Mastro
Council Member Ayala questioned Randy Mastro's decision to invite former deputy mayor Fran Reiter as a character witness, given her alleged negative views towards Housing Works. Mastro defended Reiter and …
1:50:38
·
138 sec
Mastro's defense of his record on civil rights and advocacy for vulnerable populations
In response to Council Member Ayala's criticisms, Randy Mastro strongly defended his record on civil rights and advocacy for vulnerable populations. He emphasized his career-long commitment to these issues and …
1:52:59
·
86 sec
Introduction to affirmative action rollbacks discussion
Council Member Brooks-Powers introduces the topic of affirmative action rollbacks during the Giuliani administration and prepares to question Mastro about his involvement. Brooks-Powers ensures she has Mastro's attention before beginning …
1:54:33
·
21 sec
Criticism of Giuliani's actions on minority and women-owned business contracts
Council Member Brooks-Powers details criticisms of Mayor Giuliani's actions regarding programs for minority and women-owned businesses, characterizing them as rollbacks of progress made under the previous administration. - Brooks-Powers cites …
1:54:54
·
151 sec
Mastro's response to criticisms of minority business programs
Randy Mastro responds to criticisms about his role in the Giuliani administration's handling of minority and women-owned business programs, attempting to clarify his responsibilities and intentions. - Mastro states he …
1:57:28
·
128 sec
Questioning Mastro's support for Giuliani's policies
Council Member Brooks-Powers presses Randy Mastro on whether he agreed with Mayor Giuliani's direction regarding minority business programs, challenging his previous statements about limited involvement. - Brooks-Powers suggests that Mastro's …
1:59:37
·
158 sec
Mastro's defense of his tenure and role in Giuliani administration
Randy Mastro provides a detailed defense of his tenure in the Giuliani administration, emphasizing the limitations of his role and his lack of direct involvement in certain programs. - Mastro …
2:02:17
·
5 min
Questioning Mastro's praise for Giuliani and role in contract approvals
Council Member Brooks-Powers questions Randy Mastro about his past praise for Rudy Giuliani and his role in contract approvals during his time as deputy mayor for operations. - Brooks-Powers cites …
2:07:33
·
4 min
Discussion of Parks Department discrimination lawsuit
Council Member Brooks-Powers questions Randy Mastro about a discrimination lawsuit against the Parks Department during the Giuliani administration, challenging his ability to lead a diverse agency. - Brooks-Powers details findings …
2:12:29
·
5 min
Mastro's defense of his record on inclusion, diversity, and civil rights
Randy Mastro provides a defense of his record on inclusion, diversity, and civil rights, emphasizing his commitment to these issues throughout his career. - Mastro argues that his entire record …
2:17:48
·
5 min
Clarification of Mastro's roles and responsibilities in Giuliani administration
Council Member Powers asks Randy Mastro to clarify his roles and responsibilities as chief of staff and deputy mayor for operations in the Giuliani administration. - Mastro explains that as …
2:23:01
·
106 sec
Introduction and context about Mastro's supporters
Council Member Crystal Hudson opens the questioning by addressing Randy Mastro. She acknowledges his supporters but notes that some former council members speaking on his behalf are current lobbyists with …
2:24:48
·
40 sec
Mastro's record on policing and police accountability
Council Member Hudson questions Mastro about his record on policing and police accountability. She emphasizes the importance of the Corporation Counsel's role in assessing police misconduct cases and making ethical …
2:25:30
·
107 sec
1992 police riot and Giuliani's involvement
Council Member Hudson provides a detailed account of the 1992 police riot at City Hall, highlighting Rudy Giuliani's involvement. She then questions Mastro about his role and views on the …
2:27:17
·
159 sec
Mastro's involvement in Giuliani's 1993 campaign
Council Member Hudson questions Mastro about his involvement in Giuliani's 1993 mayoral campaign, particularly regarding the campaign's handling of the 1992 police riot incident. - Hudson cites an internal vulnerability …
2:29:57
·
152 sec
Mastro's decision to work for Giuliani's administration
Council Member Hudson questions Mastro about his decision to work for Giuliani's administration, given Giuliani's role in the 1992 police riot. Mastro defends his choice as answering a call to …
2:32:30
·
154 sec
Police brutality incidents during Giuliani's administration
Council Member Hudson lists several high-profile instances of police brutality against people of color during Giuliani's administration. She emphasizes the impact of aggressive policing policies on communities of color. - …
2:35:05
·
176 sec
Crime reduction during Giuliani's administration
Council Member Hudson and Randy Mastro discuss the crime reduction that occurred during Giuliani's administration. Hudson challenges the narrative that this reduction was solely due to Giuliani's policies. - Hudson …
2:38:03
·
59 sec
Mastro's plans for addressing police misconduct as Corporation Counsel
Randy Mastro outlines his plans for addressing police misconduct if he becomes Corporation Counsel. He proposes a more proactive approach to reviewing and addressing cases of police misconduct. - Mastro …
2:39:02
·
171 sec
Reconciling Mastro's pro bono work with his role in Giuliani administration
Council Member Hudson challenges Randy Mastro to reconcile his pro bono work in furtherance of racial justice with his role in the Giuliani administration, which she characterizes as using racist …
2:41:53
·
3 min
New York City's payouts for claims against the NYPD
Council Member Hudson questions Randy Mastro about the role of the Corporation Counsel in reducing the amount of taxpayer dollars spent on claims against the NYPD. Mastro outlines his plans …
2:45:06
·
95 sec
Abner Louima incident and task force on police-community relations
Council Member Hudson discusses the Abner Louima incident and the subsequent task force on police-community relations. She questions Mastro about his role in dismissing the task force's recommendations. - Hudson …
2:46:41
·
4 min
Other police killings during Giuliani's administration
Council Member Hudson discusses other instances of police killings during the Giuliani administration, including the cases of Amadou Diallo and Patrick Dorismond. She questions Mastro about his continued support for …
2:51:14
·
86 sec
Concerns about Mastro's ability to represent all New Yorkers as Corporation Counsel
Council Member Hudson concludes her questioning by expressing concerns about Randy Mastro's ability to represent all New Yorkers as Corporation Counsel. She emphasizes the importance of selecting someone who will …
2:52:42
·
65 sec
Council Member Restler questions Mastro on rent regulation and his involvement with the Rent Stabilization Association
Council Member Lincoln Restler begins his questioning of Randy Mastro by focusing on rent regulation and Mastro's involvement with the Rent Stabilization Association (RSA). Restler presents statistics on the loss …
2:53:48
·
3 min
Debate over Mastro's lawsuit challenging aspects of the 2019 rent stabilization law
Council Member Restler and Randy Mastro engage in a heated discussion about Mastro's lawsuit challenging aspects of the 2019 rent stabilization law. Restler expresses concern that the lawsuit could potentially …
2:57:10
·
5 min
Debate on the broader implications of Mastro's legal work against city policies
Council Member Restler and Randy Mastro engage in a debate about the potential broader implications of Mastro's various lawsuits against city policies, including Local Law 97 and congestion pricing. Restler …
3:02:48
·
5 min
Concerns about Mastro's litigation against city policies and potential impact on the law department
Council Member Restler raises concerns about Randy Mastro's litigation against city policies and questions how this might affect his potential role as head of the law department. Mastro defends his …
3:08:46
·
143 sec
Legal representation process for city employees accused of sexual harassment
Council Member Lincoln Restler questions Randy Mastro about the process for determining legal representation for city employees accused of sexual harassment. Mastro acknowledges his unfamiliarity with current procedures but commits …
3:11:09
·
147 sec
Timeline of Mastro's consideration for Corporation Counsel position
Council Member Lincoln Restler inquires about when Randy Mastro was first approached by the administration to consider the Corporation Counsel position. Mastro provides a brief timeline of events. - Mastro …
3:13:37
·
31 sec
Mastro's potential independence from the mayor in decision-making
Council Member Lincoln Restler questions Randy Mastro about his potential independence from the mayor in decision-making, particularly regarding legal representation for city officials. - Mastro denies having any conversations with …
3:14:09
·
55 sec
Discussion of Tim Pearson case and allegations of sexual misconduct
Council Member Lincoln Restler raises concerns about the Tim Pearson case, involving allegations of sexual misconduct and the city's handling of the situation. Mastro responds to these concerns. - Restler …
3:15:04
·
144 sec
Mastro's reflections on the Giuliani administration and its policies
Council Member Lincoln Restler asks Randy Mastro to reflect on aspects of the Giuliani administration that he's not proud of, seeking examples of his independence. - Mastro states that there …
3:17:30
·
121 sec
Debate over 'broken windows' policing and Giuliani-era policies
Council Member Lincoln Restler engages Randy Mastro in a debate about 'broken windows' policing and other controversial policies of the Giuliani administration. - Restler argues that problematic relationships with communities …
3:19:32
·
170 sec
Mastro's defense of his record and accomplishments in the Giuliani administration
Randy Mastro defends his record and accomplishments during his time in the Giuliani administration, responding to criticisms from Council Member Lincoln Restler. - Mastro emphasizes his role as a lawyer …
3:22:22
·
4 min
Concerns about Mastro potentially defending Mayor Adams too zealously
Council Member Lincoln Restler expresses concerns about Randy Mastro potentially defending Mayor Eric Adams too zealously as Corporation Counsel, rather than serving the interests of New York City. - Restler …
3:27:06
·
45 sec
Mastro's work history and compensation at Gibson Dunn
Council Member Farías questions Randy Mastro about his work history at Gibson Dunn, including his tenure as a partner and his compensation. Mastro clarifies his roles and timeline at the …
3:27:52
·
136 sec
Mastro's pursuit of managing partner position at Gibson Dunn
Council Member Farías questions Randy Mastro about his pursuit of the managing partner position at Gibson Dunn in 2021. Mastro clarifies that he did not actively pursue the position, but …
3:30:08
·
93 sec
Inquiry into Mastro's departure from Gibson Dunn
Council Member Farías questions Randy Mastro about his departure from Gibson Dunn and the current status of their relationship dissolution. Mastro provides limited information due to confidentiality constraints. - Mastro …
3:31:41
·
36 sec
Concerns about Mastro's leadership abilities and criticisms from law department attorneys
Council Member Farías presents criticisms of Randy Mastro's leadership abilities from current and former law department attorneys. Mastro defends his record and disputes the characterizations. - Farías reads anonymous statements …
3:32:19
·
4 min
Mastro's views on using city resources to defend officials against sexual assault allegations
Council Member Farías questions Randy Mastro about his views on using city resources to defend officials against sexual assault allegations, referencing the departure of Judge Hinds-Radix. Mastro claims no knowledge …
3:37:15
·
4 min
Mastro's role in Giuliani's task force on bilingual education
Council Member Farías questions Randy Mastro about his role as co-chair of Mayor Giuliani's task force on bilingual education in the 1990s. Mastro defends the task force's recommendations and his …
3:41:17
·
7 min
Questions about Mastro's support for Ninfa Segarra and her controversial positions
Council Member Farías questions Randy Mastro about his support for Ninfa Segarra, who held controversial positions on education and LGBTQ+ issues during her time on the Board of Education and …
3:48:18
·
168 sec
Mastro's work on the Bridgegate scandal for Chris Christie
Council Member Farías questions Randy Mastro about his work investigating the Bridgegate scandal for then-Governor Chris Christie of New Jersey. Mastro defends his investigation and report against accusations of bias …
3:51:06
·
5 min
Criticism of sexist content in Mastro's Bridgegate report
Council Member Farías criticizes Randy Mastro for including sexist content in his Bridgegate investigation report, particularly regarding Bridget Anne Kelly. Mastro attempts to defend the report's content and relevance. - …
3:56:58
·
3 min
Questions about Mastro's knowledge of alleged voter suppression tactics in Giuliani's 1993 campaign
Council Member Farías questions Randy Mastro about his knowledge of alleged voter suppression tactics during Rudy Giuliani's 1993 mayoral campaign, for which Mastro served as outside counsel. Mastro denies any …
4:00:29
·
171 sec
Concluding remarks on Mastro's suitability for the Corporation Counsel role
Council Member Farías provides concluding remarks on Randy Mastro's testimony and his suitability for the role of Corporation Counsel. She expresses concerns about his past associations and actions. - Farías …
4:03:21
·
110 sec
Mastro's opinion on Rudy Giuliani in 2024
Council Member Justin Brannan asks Randy Mastro about his opinion of Rudy Giuliani in 2024. Mastro responds that he hasn't spoken to Giuliani in years and finds the situation heartbreaking. …
4:05:18
·
46 sec
Mastro's view on City Council as an equal branch of government
Council Member Justin Brannan asks Randy Mastro if he believes the City Council is an equal branch of city government. Mastro unequivocally agrees and promises unprecedented responsiveness from the Corporation …
4:06:07
·
22 sec
Transparency in Giuliani's administration and removal of public records
Council Member Brannan questions Mastro about his previous statements regarding transparency in Giuliani's administration, contrasting them with reports of secrecy and the removal of public records. Mastro defends his past …
4:06:30
·
152 sec
Mastro's personal lawsuit against NYC over a $375 fine
Council Member Brannan questions Mastro about a personal lawsuit he filed against NYC and the FDNY over a $375 fine for unwarranted fire alarms. Mastro defends his actions, framing the …
4:09:03
·
4 min
Mastro's involvement in fighting against minimum wage increases for fast food workers
Council Member Brannan questions Mastro about his role in opposing minimum wage increases for fast food workers. Mastro defends his position, arguing that he was advocating for fair application of …
4:13:26
·
4 min
Clarification on Mastro's position regarding minimum wage for fast food workers
Council Member Powers seeks clarification on Mastro's earlier statements about his position on minimum wage increases for fast food workers. Mastro reiterates and elaborates on his argument that the $15 …
4:18:17
·
167 sec
Discussion on 9/11 aftermath and FOIL requests for related documents
Council Member Gale A. Brewer questions Randy Mastro about the aftermath of 9/11, including health issues for workers and residents, and a FOIL request for documents related to the city's …
4:21:05
·
5 min
Discussion on reducing costs for private school tuition (Carter cases)
Council Member Brewer asks Randy Mastro about strategies to reduce the amount of money spent on private school tuition, specifically referring to Carter cases. Mastro acknowledges the long-standing nature of …
4:27:02
·
65 sec
Balancing liability and just governance in police misconduct cases
Council Member Brewer questions Randy Mastro about the city's approach to civil cases against police officers and how to balance minimizing liability with just governance. Mastro proposes a proactive approach …
4:28:07
·
98 sec
Mayor's representation by law department in a sex assault case
Council Member Brewer asks Randy Mastro whether the mayor should be represented by the law department in a sex assault case. Mastro provides a nuanced response, citing the need for …
4:29:47
·
39 sec
Discussion on the Lucerne Hotel homeless shelter situation
Council Member Brewer and Randy Mastro discuss the controversial situation at the Lucerne Hotel, which was used as a homeless shelter. They have differing views on the conditions and handling …
4:30:25
·
117 sec
1998 budget disagreement between mayor and city council
Council Member Brewer questions Randy Mastro about the 1998 budget disagreement when the council passed its own budget. Mastro provides context for the situation and expresses disappointment over the breakdown. …
4:32:23
·
123 sec
Mastro's motivations for wanting the Corporation Counsel position
Council Member Brewer asks Randy Mastro why he wants the Corporation Counsel job so badly. Mastro provides a passionate response about his motivations and aspirations for the role. - Mastro …
4:34:26
·
82 sec
Discussion on administrative practice of signing papers before meetings
Council Member Brewer raises concerns about the practice of commissioners requiring signed papers before meetings. Mastro responds with his stance on the issue. - Brewer expresses frustration with the requirement …
4:35:48
·
107 sec
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams expresses initial concerns about Mastro's nomination
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams opens the hearing by expressing his concerns about Randy Mastro's nomination for Corporation Counsel. He highlights Mastro's career choices and past representations that he believes are …
4:37:36
·
25 sec
Debate over Mastro's past work and its implications for the Corporation Counsel role
Jumaane Williams questions Randy Mastro about his past work and its implications for the role of Corporation Counsel. The discussion focuses on Mastro's choice of clients and the potential conflicts …
4:38:02
·
7 min
Discussion of Mastro's past interactions with the City Council
Jumaane Williams questions Randy Mastro about his behavior during a 2014 City Council hearing, where Mastro represented a private client. The exchange highlights concerns about Mastro's approach to Council interactions. …
4:45:15
·
3 min
Debate over Mastro's work with Giuliani and controversial policing policies
Jumaane Williams questions Randy Mastro about his work with former Mayor Rudy Giuliani and his stance on controversial policing policies like 'broken windows' policing. The exchange reveals tensions between past …
4:48:52
·
4 min
Questions about NYPD practices and sanctuary city laws
Jumaane Williams questions Randy Mastro about his stance on NYPD stop and frisk practices and sanctuary city laws. The discussion reveals the complexities of these issues and Mastro's approach to …
4:53:31
·
3 min
Debate over hypothetical scenarios where Mastro might side against the mayor
Jumaane Williams presents Randy Mastro with hypothetical scenarios where he might need to side against the mayor. The exchange highlights the complexities of the Corporation Counsel's role and the potential …
4:57:23
·
6 min
Discussion of the definition of 'the city' in the context of Corporation Counsel's responsibilities
Jumaane Williams and Randy Mastro discuss the definition of 'the city' in the context of the Corporation Counsel's responsibilities. - Mastro defines 'the city' as including the administration, city council, …
5:04:03
·
53 sec
Questions about supporting the Public Advocate's right to information and potential litigation
Jumaane Williams questions Randy Mastro about supporting the Public Advocate's right to information and how he would handle potential litigation between city entities. - Mastro affirms his support for the …
5:04:56
·
4 min
Mastro's response to concerns about his independence and ability to side against the mayor
Randy Mastro provides a final response to concerns about his independence and ability to side against the mayor if necessary. He emphasizes his track record of standing up to powerful …
5:09:20
·
4 min
Remarks from Randy Mastro before the hearing break
The hearing concludes with closing remarks from Randy Mastro and a discussion about scheduling for the remainder of the session. The exchange highlights the length and intensity of the questioning. …
5:14:01
·
160 sec
Randy Mastro provides example of opposing mayoral wishes as Corporation Counsel
Randy Mastro, the Corporation Counsel nominee, responds to a request for an example of when he would represent the City Council over the mayor. He provides two examples: refusing to …
5:38:07
·
3 min
Introduction to questioning session with Randy Mastro
Council Member Shekar Krishnan begins the questioning session with Randy Mastro, setting the context for the upcoming discussion. He acknowledges Mastro's credentials as a leading litigator but emphasizes that the …
5:41:21
·
16 sec
Basic principles of public accountability and transparency
Council Member Krishnan questions Mastro on fundamental principles of public accountability and transparency in government. Mastro agrees with these basic tenets. - Mastro confirms that the mayor and city agencies …
5:41:37
·
32 sec
Mastro's role in Giuliani administration and state controller audit controversy
Council Member Krishnan questions Mastro about his role as deputy mayor under Giuliani in 1997 and his handling of a state controller's audit. Mastro acknowledges there was a dispute over …
5:42:10
·
5 min
Collegial relationships and controversial mailer during Giuliani administration
Council Member Krishnan questions Mastro about his role in maintaining collegial relationships between City Hall and the City Council during the Giuliani administration. The discussion focuses on a controversial publicly …
5:47:33
·
3 min
Bridgegate investigation: Document preservation and investigation practices
Council Member Krishnan questions Mastro about his role in the Bridgegate investigation, focusing on document preservation practices and the controversy surrounding the lack of notes from witness interviews. - Mastro …
5:50:47
·
5 min
Bridgegate investigation: Public perception and judicial criticism
Council Member Krishnan questions Mastro about the public perception and judicial criticism of the Bridgegate investigation, focusing on the cost to taxpayers and the judge's harsh words about the investigation's …
5:56:37
·
4 min
Mastro's relationship with Giuliani and views on recent controversies
Council Member Krishnan questions Mastro about his long-standing relationship with Rudy Giuliani and his views on Giuliani's recent controversial actions, including efforts to overturn the 2020 election. - Mastro's professional …
6:00:55
·
3 min
Council Member Gennaro questions Mastro's environmental record
Council Member James Gennaro introduces his concerns about Randy Mastro's environmental record, focusing on Mastro's involvement in the Chevron case related to oil drilling in Ecuador. Gennaro provides extensive background …
6:04:13
·
7 min
Mastro defends his role in the Chevron/Ecuador case
Randy Mastro responds to Council Member Gennaro's allegations about his involvement in the Chevron/Ecuador case. Mastro argues that he was defending the integrity of the justice system against fraud committed …
6:11:21
·
121 sec
Debate over Chevron's accountability for environmental damage in Ecuador
Council Member Gennaro and Randy Mastro engage in a heated debate over Chevron's accountability for environmental damage in Ecuador. Gennaro insists on the need for accountability, while Mastro maintains his …
6:13:21
·
6 min
Discussion of Mastro's opposition to NYC's styrofoam ban
Council Member Gennaro questions Randy Mastro about his past opposition to NYC's styrofoam ban, particularly focusing on Mastro's public comments ridiculing the ban. - Gennaro quotes Mastro calling the styrofoam …
6:20:20
·
168 sec
Questioning about financing of Mastro's challenge to Local Law 97
Council Member Gennaro presses Randy Mastro to disclose who is financing his legal challenge to Local Law 97. Mastro cites client confidentiality, leading to a tense exchange and intervention by …
6:23:08
·
5 min
Introduction to Charter Revision Commission discussion
Council Member Pierina Ana Sanchez introduces her line of questioning, focusing on Randy Mastro's role in several Charter Revision Commissions. She indicates that she will start with questions about these …
6:28:29
·
35 sec
1999 Charter Revision Commission controversy
Council Member Sanchez discusses the controversial context of the 1999 Charter Revision Commission, which was seen as a political move by Mayor Giuliani against Public Advocate Mark Green. - Sanchez …
6:29:04
·
69 sec
Mastro's defense of his actions in past Charter Revision Commissions
Randy Mastro defends his actions during the 1999 and 2001 Charter Revision Commissions, emphasizing his independence and the positive outcomes of the 2001 commission. - Mastro claims he stood up …
6:30:15
·
177 sec
Examination of proposals affecting Council powers
Council Member Sanchez details specific proposals from the 1999 Charter Revision Commission that would have affected Council powers, and questions Mastro about his stance on these proposals. - Proposals included …
6:33:12
·
6 min
Discussion of fiscal impact statement recommendations
Council Member Sanchez presents information about fiscal impact statement recommendations from the 1999 Charter Revision Commission and draws parallels to recent proposals from Mayor Adams' commission. - The 1999 recommendations …
6:39:35
·
83 sec
Questions about current Adams administration charter commission
Council Member Sanchez questions Mastro about any potential involvement or discussions with the Adams administration regarding charter revisions. - Sanchez asks if Mastro has advised or discussed his past charter …
6:41:00
·
149 sec
Critique of Mastro's legal career and representation of controversial clients
Council Member Sanchez presents a critique of Randy Mastro's legal career, focusing on his representation of clients in cases that challenged public interest policies. - Sanchez argues that Mastro has …
6:43:29
·
159 sec
Questions about Mastro's commitment to rent regulation and tenant protections
Council Member Sanchez questions Randy Mastro's commitment to rent regulation and tenant protections, citing his past legal work and statements. - Sanchez asks if Mastro believes rent regulation is essential …
6:46:08
·
131 sec
Council Member Adams questions Mastro on Charter Revision Commission and pro bono work
Council Member Adrienne E. Adams questions Randy Mastro about his knowledge of the recent Charter Revision Commission's proposals, his past involvement in Charter Revision Commissions, and his recent pro bono …
6:48:19
·
3 min
Mastro's 2014 testimony for Cablevision questioned
Council Member Carmen De La Rosa questions Randy Mastro about his 2014 testimony on behalf of Cablevision regarding a franchise agreement and labor disputes. Mastro defends his past statements, explaining …
6:51:52
·
154 sec
Debate over NLRB complaints and labor violations at Cablevision
Council Member De La Rosa presses Randy Mastro on his knowledge and beliefs about labor violations at Cablevision during the 2014 hearing. Mastro maintains that he was not directly involved …
6:54:25
·
135 sec
Council's role in franchise agreement oversight debated
Council Member De La Rosa questions Randy Mastro about his past assertions regarding the City Council's role in overseeing franchise agreements. Mastro explains his perspective on the unusual nature of …
6:56:42
·
61 sec
Mastro's stance on labor issues as potential Corporation Counsel
Council Member De La Rosa questions Randy Mastro about his potential stance on labor issues if appointed as Corporation Counsel. Mastro defends his pro-union record and explains the difference between …
6:57:44
·
169 sec
Use of drones for emergency communications questioned
Council Member De La Rosa raises concerns about the city's use of drones for emergency communications, particularly in flood-prone areas. Mastro expresses unfamiliarity with the specific issue but commits to …
7:00:33
·
114 sec
Mastro's representation of MSG in facial recognition case discussed
Council Member De La Rosa questions Randy Mastro about his representation of Madison Square Garden in a lawsuit involving facial recognition technology. Mastro clarifies the focus of the case and …
7:02:27
·
126 sec
Questions on facial recognition use in law enforcement and schools
Council Member De La Rosa raises concerns about the use of facial recognition technology in law enforcement and school facilities. Mastro acknowledges his limited familiarity with the current use of …
7:04:34
·
51 sec
Closing statements and concerns about Mastro's nomination
Council Member De La Rosa expresses concerns about Randy Mastro's nomination, questioning his ability to defend the Council and his moral values. Mastro responds by defending his moral values and …
7:05:25
·
94 sec
Feliz criticizes Mastro's history of representing large corporations
Council Member Oswald Feliz opens his questioning by criticizing Randy Mastro's history of representing large corporations with questionable business practices. He sets the stage for a critical examination of Mastro's …
7:07:00
·
28 sec
Feliz questions Mastro about his representation of Portfolio Recovery Associates
Council Member Feliz interrogates Mastro about his representation of Portfolio Recovery Associates (PRA), a debt collection agency accused of fraudulent practices. Feliz outlines PRA's violations and questions Mastro's decision to …
7:07:28
·
5 min
Feliz inquires about Mastro's client selection criteria
Council Member Feliz questions Mastro about the factors he considers when deciding which clients to represent. Mastro explains his obligations as a law firm partner and his ethical considerations in …
7:12:51
·
3 min
Debate over Mastro's career choices and public service commitment
Council Member Feliz challenges Mastro's commitment to public service, questioning why he didn't pursue a career as a civil rights lawyer. Mastro defends his career choices and the two engage …
7:16:41
·
7 min
Questioning about an incident during the Giuliani administration
Council Member Feliz questions Mastro about an incident during the Giuliani administration where a city official allegedly threatened to end a legal apprenticeship at NYU Law School in retaliation for …
7:23:48
·
66 sec
Feliz's closing statement on qualifications for Corporation Counsel
Council Member Feliz delivers a closing statement, reflecting on the qualities needed for the position of Corporation Counsel. He acknowledges Mastro's legal talent but raises concerns about his values and …
7:24:57
·
66 sec
Questioning Mastro's educational background and experience
Council Member Rita Joseph inquires about Randy Mastro's experience in education, particularly his role as an educator. Mastro explains his experience teaching law school and overseeing education-related matters as deputy …
7:26:08
·
101 sec
Discussion of Mastro's work on bilingual education task force
Council Member Rita Joseph questions Randy Mastro about his involvement in the bilingual education task force and its impact on current education policies. Mastro defends his work, while Joseph challenges …
7:27:50
·
31 sec
Debate over the implementation of parental choice in bilingual education
Council Member Rita Joseph and Randy Mastro engage in a heated debate about the implementation of parental choice in bilingual education. They disagree on the novelty and effectiveness of Mastro's …
7:28:21
·
158 sec
Impact of Mastro's work on current education policy perspectives
Council Member Rita Joseph questions Randy Mastro about the long-term impact of his work on education policy and how principles of fairness and equity should apply in current education policies, …
7:30:59
·
3 min
Discussion on language acquisition for English language learners
Council Member Rita Joseph questions Randy Mastro about his understanding of language acquisition for English language learners and how he would address legal challenges related to supporting these students in …
7:34:49
·
3 min
Discussion of Carter cases and their financial impact on education system
Council Member Rita Joseph questions Randy Mastro about addressing Carter cases and their significant financial impact on the education system. Mastro acknowledges the need for improvement in handling these cases. …
7:37:55
·
87 sec
Council Member Ariola thanks Mastro for his patience
Council Member Joann Ariola expresses gratitude to Randy Mastro for his patience in answering questions during the lengthy hearing process. She acknowledges the long duration of the questioning and commends …
7:39:24
·
11 sec
Council Member Ariola praises Mastro's background and accomplishments
Council Member Joann Ariola commends Randy Mastro for his professional background and accomplishments. She highlights his reputation as a tenacious litigator, fearless advocate for the city, and staunch supporter of …
7:39:35
·
27 sec
Council Member Ariola discusses COVID-19 vaccine mandate and its impact on city workers
Council Member Joann Ariola provides a detailed account of the COVID-19 vaccine mandate for New York City municipal workers and its consequences. She discusses the legal challenges faced by the …
7:40:02
·
3 min
Mastro responds to question about handling pending legal matters related to vaccine mandates
Randy Mastro provides a measured response to Council Member Ariola's question about handling pending legal matters related to the COVID-19 vaccine mandate. He emphasizes the need to study the cases …
7:44:03
·
114 sec
Discussion of Mastro's motivation for seeking the Corporation Counsel position
Council Member Joann Ariola inquires about Randy Mastro's motivation for seeking the Corporation Counsel position, given the financial sacrifice and intense scrutiny he has faced. Mastro provides a passionate response, …
7:45:59
·
5 min
Council Member Ariola's closing remarks on challenges facing the Law Department
Council Member Joann Ariola delivers her closing remarks, addressing the challenges facing the Law Department and expressing her support for Randy Mastro. She emphasizes the need for fair and consistent …
7:51:00
·
104 sec
Council member Paladino defends Rudy Giuliani and criticizes current city conditions
Council member Vickie Paladino opens her remarks by defending Rudy Giuliani's tenure as mayor and criticizing those who attack his legacy. She highlights the differences between New York City in …
7:53:19
·
131 sec
Council member Paladino criticizes the hearing process and praises Mastro's opening statement
Council member Vickie Paladino criticizes the nature of the hearing, characterizing it as an inquisition rather than a fair process. She expresses her admiration for Randy Mastro's opening statement and …
7:55:30
·
125 sec
Discussion of Local Law 97 and its impact on property owners
Council member Paladino raises concerns about Local Law 97's impact on her constituents, particularly elderly and working-class property owners. Randy Mastro responds by explaining the legal issues surrounding the law …
7:57:36
·
6 min
Mastro outlines legal strategies for addressing public safety issues
Randy Mastro responds to Council member Paladino's question by outlining various legal strategies to address public safety concerns in New York City. He emphasizes the need for creativity and collaboration …
8:03:59
·
3 min
Council member Paladino endorses Mastro and concludes her remarks
Council member Vickie Paladino concludes her time by strongly endorsing Randy Mastro for the position of Corporation Counsel. She expresses her belief that Mastro would bring balance and sensibility to …
8:07:21
·
94 sec
Council Member Avilés questions Mastro on bilingual education advocacy
Council Member Alexa Avilés questions Randy Mastro, the Corporation Counsel nominee, about his past work on bilingual education. Mastro clarifies his position on advocating for improvements to bilingual education and …
8:09:03
·
156 sec
Council Member Avilés provides context on NYC's sanctuary policies
Council Member Alexa Avilés, chair of the immigration committee, provides background on New York City's sanctuary policies. She emphasizes their importance for public safety, community trust, and the city's economy. …
8:11:39
·
4 min
Mastro recalls Giuliani administration's stance on sanctuary policies
Randy Mastro discusses his recollection of the Giuliani administration's support for sanctuary policies and the subsequent enshrinement of these policies in the city charter. - Confirms that the Giuliani administration …
8:15:53
·
121 sec
Discussion of current laws on cooperation with ICE and public safety exceptions
Council Member Avilés and Mastro discuss the current laws regarding cooperation with ICE and public safety exceptions in New York City's sanctuary policies. - Avilés clarifies that current laws do …
8:17:55
·
85 sec
Mastro outlines approach to handling conflicts between council and administration
Randy Mastro explains his approach to handling potential conflicts between the city council and administration regarding sanctuary policies and immigration enforcement. - Emphasizes the importance of studying the issue thoroughly …
8:19:20
·
5 min
Avilés presses Mastro on commitment to due process and sanctuary policies
Council Member Avilés questions Mastro about his commitment to due process and upholding sanctuary policies, leading to a tense exchange. - Mastro affirms his belief in due process but hesitates …
8:25:13
·
142 sec
Discussion on emergency authority for shelter siting
Council member Avilés questions Mastro about the city's use of emergency authority to site shelters in the face of neighborhood opposition. Mastro affirms his commitment to defending the city's policies …
8:27:39
·
115 sec
Mastro's stance on fair share policy for shelter siting
Council member Avilés questions Mastro about his personal beliefs on the fair share proposal for shelter siting. Mastro affirms his support for the policy and commits to enforcing it if …
8:29:35
·
26 sec
Council member Avilés' closing remarks on Mastro's nomination
Council member Avilés delivers her closing remarks, expressing concerns about Mastro's past affiliations with the Giuliani administration and the potential impact on marginalized communities if he becomes Corporation Counsel. - …
8:30:02
·
109 sec
Mastro's final appeal to the City Council
Randy Mastro makes a final appeal to the City Council, urging them to consider his entire record and the potential for positive change if he is appointed as Corporation Counsel. …
8:32:03
·
81 sec
Testimony by Bertha Lewis, President of the Black Institute, the Black Leadership Action Coalition, and Black Institute Group
Bertha Lewis strongly opposes the appointment of Randy Mastro as Corporation Counsel, citing his controversial history with the Giuliani administration and his involvement in policies that she believes were detrimental …
8:36:01
·
4 min
Testimony by Gabrielle Semel, Retired Union Side Labor Lawyer and Former District Counsel for Communication Workers of America, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Gabrielle Semel, a retired union-side labor lawyer, testifies in opposition to Randy Mastro's appointment as Corporation Counsel. She criticizes Mastro's behavior during a 2014 City Council hearing, accusing him of …
8:40:29
·
3 min
Council member inquires about Randy Mastro's misrepresentation of labor dispute facts
Council Member Amanda Farías asks for elaboration on Randy Mastro's alleged misrepresentation of facts regarding Cablevision's unfair labor practices and NLRB procedures. Two witnesses, Gabrielle Semel and Bertha Lewis, provide …
8:43:51
·
3 min
Testimony by David I. Weprin, Assemblyman from New York State Assembly, on Randy Mastro's Confirmation
Assemblyman David I. Weprin testifies in support of Randy Mastro's confirmation as the next corporation counsel of New York City. He highlights Mastro's qualities as a bridge builder, his ability …
8:47:44
·
3 min
Testimony by David Paterson, Former Governor of State of New York, on Randy Mastro's Appointment as Corporation Counsel
David Paterson, former Governor of New York, testifies in support of Randy Mastro's appointment as Corporation Counsel. He emphasizes Mastro's ability to represent not just the mayor, but the entire …
8:51:18
·
5 min
Testimony by Bridget Anne Kelly, Former Deputy Chief of Staff to Governor Chris Christie, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Bridget Anne Kelly, former Deputy Chief of Staff to New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, testifies against Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel for New York City. She criticizes Mastro's role …
8:57:01
·
4 min
Bridget Anne Kelly details the impact of Bridgegate and Randy Mastro's actions on her life and career
Bridget Anne Kelly provides a detailed and emotional account of how Bridgegate and Randy Mastro's actions have severely impacted her life and career. She describes the psychological trauma, legal battles, …
9:01:49
·
7 min
Impact of the Me Too movement on Bridget Anne Kelly's experience
Council Member Amanda Farías asks Bridget Anne Kelly if her experience with Randy Mastro and the Bridgegate scandal would have been viewed differently if it had occurred after the Me …
9:09:15
·
160 sec
Kelly's response to Mastro's claims about his report and the Supreme Court decision
Council Member Farías asks Bridget Anne Kelly to respond to Randy Mastro's claim that no wrongdoing was found and that his report and the Supreme Court's decision came to the …
9:11:57
·
86 sec
Testimony by Rudy Washington, Former Deputy Mayor of New York City under Mayor Rudy Giuliani
Rudy Washington, former Deputy Mayor under Rudy Giuliani, provided testimony in support of Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. He shared personal experiences working with Mastro, highlighting their collaboration on …
9:13:59
·
6 min
Testimony by Veronica Moyé, Partner at King & Spalding
Veronica Moyé, a partner at King & Spalding and former colleague of Randy Mastro, testifies in support of Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. She emphasizes Mastro's commitment to diversity and …
9:20:27
·
3 min
Testimony by Darius Khalil Gordon, Executive Director of Met Council on Housing
Darius Khalil Gordon, Executive Director of Met Council on Housing, strongly opposes Randy Mastro's appointment as corporation counsel due to Mastro's history of opposing tenant rights and supporting landlord interests. …
9:25:05
·
162 sec
Testimony by Natalie Druce, Staff Attorney at Safety Net Project of the Urban Justice Center, on Randy Mastro's Nomination for Corporation Counsel
Natalie Druce, representing the Safety Net Project at the Urban Justice Center, testifies against Randy Mastro's nomination for Corporation Counsel due to his history of anti-homeless and anti-tenant activities. She …
9:27:48
·
3 min
Testimony by Donovan Taveras, Community Safety Coordinator of Justice Committee, on Randy Mastro's Nomination for Corporation Counsel
Donovan Taveras, representing the Justice Committee, strongly opposes Randy Mastro's appointment as Corporation Counsel due to Mastro's history with the Giuliani administration and concerns about police accountability under Mayor Adams. …
9:30:54
·
154 sec
Testimony by Iris Baez, Member of the Public, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Iris Baez, a member of the public who lived through the Giuliani era, strongly opposes Randy Mastro's appointment as Corporation Counsel. She cites Mastro's history of defending controversial policies and …
9:36:01
·
136 sec
Speaker Adams asks about main concern regarding Mastro nomination
Speaker Adrienne E. Adams asks Iris Baez about her main concern regarding Randy Mastro potentially becoming the city's top lawyer. Baez expresses worry that Mastro would simply follow the mayor's …
9:38:28
·
71 sec
Testimony by Janet Morgan on Randy Mastro's Support for Racial Justice
Janet Morgan testifies in support of Randy Mastro's nomination, sharing her personal experience of how Mastro represented her pro bono in a case involving her suspension as a teacher for …
9:40:28
·
7 min
Testimony by Devorah Halberstam on Randy Mastro's Nomination for Corporation Counsel
Devorah Halberstam provides emotional testimony in support of Randy Mastro's nomination for Corporation Counsel. She shares her personal tragedy of losing her son Ari in a terrorist attack and emphasizes …
9:48:51
·
4 min
Testimony by Lawrence 'Muzzy' Rosenblatt, Leader of Bowery Residents' Committee (BRC)
Lawrence 'Muzzy' Rosenblatt, leader of the Bowery Residents' Committee (BRC), testifies in support of Randy Mastro's nomination as NYC's corporation counsel. Rosenblatt praises Mastro's legal expertise, dedication to justice, and …
9:53:28
·
3 min
Testimony by Matthew W. Daus, Longest-Serving Former Commissioner of Taxi Limousine Commission, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Matthew W. Daus, the longest-serving former Commissioner of the Taxi Limousine Commission, testifies in support of Randy Mastro's nomination for Corporation Counsel. Daus highlights his extensive experience in New York …
9:57:41
·
122 sec
Council member and speaker discuss time management for testimony
Council Member Keith Powers and Matthew W. Daus engage in a back-and-forth about time management for Daus's testimony. Daus expresses frustration with the process and requests more time to speak. …
9:59:43
·
35 sec
Matthew Daus provides brief remarks in support of Randy Mastro
Matthew W. Daus provides a brief summary of his support for Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel, emphasizing Mastro's character and potential for independence. - Daus asserts that Mastro will …
10:00:18
·
73 sec
Testimony by Kelly Grace Price, Founder of Close Rosies, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Kelly Grace Price, founder of Close Rosies, testified against the appointment of Randy Mastro as Corporation Counsel. She argued that approving Mastro would be an act of deliberate indifference and …
10:01:52
·
129 sec
Testimony by James Inniss, Public Safety Organizer from New York Communities for Change
James Inniss, representing New York Communities for Change, strongly opposes Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel, citing Mastro's controversial legal career and its potential impact on low-income communities. - Inniss …
10:04:07
·
128 sec
Testimony by Mark E. Bini, Partner at Reed Smith LLP, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Mark E. Bini, a partner at Reed Smith LLP, testifies in support of Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. He shares personal experiences of how Mastro inspired him to pursue …
10:07:25
·
132 sec
Testimony by Georgia Winston, Partner at Walden Macht & Haran LLP on Randy Mastro's Nomination for Corporation Counsel
Georgia Winston, a former colleague of Randy Mastro, provides testimony in support of his nomination as Corporation Counsel. She highlights Mastro's qualities as an extraordinary lawyer, his dedication to pro …
10:09:49
·
3 min
Testimony by Jim Walden, Partner at Walden Macht Haran & Williams LLP
Jim Walden, a partner at Walden Macht Haran & Williams LLP, testifies in support of Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. Despite being an opponent of Mayor Adams, Walden credits …
10:13:02
·
161 sec
Testimony by Louis J. Coletti, Senior Adviser at Davidoff Hutcher & Citron LLP, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Louis J. Coletti testifies in support of Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel for New York City, emphasizing Mastro's character, legal expertise, and ability to find common ground. Coletti urges …
10:16:14
·
165 sec
Council Member Adams clarifies statement about lobbyists supporting Mastro
Council Member Adrienne E. Adams corrects a misunderstanding about a previous statement regarding lobbyists supporting Randy Mastro. She clarifies that it was not said that everyone speaking on behalf of …
10:19:03
·
38 sec
Brief exchange following clarification and wrap-up
A short exchange occurs between Louis J. Coletti and Council Member Adams following the clarification about lobbyists. The hearing then concludes with brief comments from other council members and procedural …
10:19:41
·
70 sec
Testimony by Ross Sandler, Law Professor and Former Commissioner, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Ross Sandler, a law professor and former commissioner, strongly endorses Randy Mastro for the position of Corporation Counsel. He argues that Mastro's experience and knowledge make him the most qualified …
10:20:55
·
175 sec
Testimony by Steve Gradman, President of Pride Democrats of New York City
Steve Gradman, President of Pride Democrats of New York City, testified in support of Randy Mastro's nomination, highlighting Mastro's contributions to LGBTQ+ rights. Gradman emphasized Mastro's role in creating the …
10:23:56
·
62 sec
Testimony by Mark Kirsch, Partner at King & Spalding on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Mark Kirsch, a partner at King & Spalding, provides a strong endorsement of Randy Mastro for the position of Corporation Counsel. He highlights Mastro's legal skills, integrity, and commitment to …
10:25:03
·
140 sec
Testimony by Adam Offenhartz, Senior Counsel at Baughman Kroup Bosse (BKB) on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Adam Offenhartz provides a strong endorsement of Randy Mastro for the position of Corporation Counsel, based on his 25-year professional relationship with Mastro. He highlights Mastro's leadership qualities, mentorship skills, …
10:27:34
·
157 sec
Testimony by Anne Champion, Partner at Gibson Dunn, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Anne Champion, a partner at Gibson Dunn and former colleague of Randy Mastro, provides strong support for his nomination as Corporation Counsel. She emphasizes Mastro's ethical standards, legal expertise, and …
10:31:34
·
122 sec
Testimony by Christopher Porrino, 60th Attorney General of New Jersey, on Randy Mastro's Bridgegate Investigation
Christopher Porrino, former Attorney General of New Jersey, testifies in support of Randy Mastro, focusing on Mastro's handling of the Bridgegate investigation. Porrino emphasizes the accuracy and impartiality of Mastro's …
10:33:47
·
149 sec
Testimony by Neil Getnick, Managing Partner of Getnick Law, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Neil Getnick, Managing Partner of Getnick Law, provides testimony in support of Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. He emphasizes his own background in social and economic justice to establish …
10:36:24
·
134 sec
Testimony by Jessica Benvenisty, Partner at King & Spalding, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Jessica Benvenisty, a partner at King & Spalding, provides testimony in support of Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. She emphasizes Mastro's qualities as a mentor, leader, and colleague, drawing …
10:38:42
·
3 min
Testimony by Robert Avaltroni, Former City Official
Robert Avaltroni, a former city official who served in multiple administrations, provides emotional testimony strongly supporting Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. He emphasizes Mastro's character, integrity, and dedication to …
10:42:39
·
135 sec
Testimony by Peter Carnival, Board Member of New Era Democrats, on Randy Mastro's Nomination as Corporation Counsel
Peter Carnival, representing New Era Democrats (NED), testifies in support of Randy Mastro's appointment as Corporation Counsel for New York City. He emphasizes Mastro's character, experience, and commitment to public …
10:45:08
·
132 sec
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson on Randy Mastro's Appointment
Christopher Leon Johnson supports Randy Mastro's appointment as Corporation Counsel, arguing that opposition is driven by political motivations rather than Mastro's qualifications. He criticizes the City Council and Speaker Adrienne …
10:48:14
·
121 sec
Testimony by Towaki Komatsu, Member of the Public
Towaki Komatsu, a frequent testifier at city council hearings, presented a brief but intense testimony criticizing the council's handling of public safety issues and the hearing process itself. He mentioned …
10:50:20
·
48 sec
Testimony by Representative from Stonewall Rebellion Veterans Association on Randy Mastro
The representative from the Stonewall Rebellion Veterans Association spoke in support of Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. They highlighted their organization's history and Mastro's long-standing support for the LGBTQ+ …
10:51:21
·
165 sec
Testimony by Norman Eisen, Former White House Ethics Czar and Ambassador, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Norman Eisen, a former White House Ethics Czar and Ambassador, provides strong support for Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel. He emphasizes Mastro's qualifications, progressive values, and potential to defend …
10:55:10
·
128 sec
Testimony by Marc Rosenbaum, Managing Director of Berkeley Research Group, on Randy Mastro's Appointment as Corporation Counsel
Marc Rosenbaum, Managing Director of Berkeley Research Group, strongly endorses Randy Mastro for the position of Corporation Counsel for New York City. He emphasizes Mastro's qualifications, dedication, and personal character, …
10:57:55
·
145 sec
Testimony by Mark Dore on Randy Mastro's Nomination for Corporation Counsel
Mark Dore provides a personal testimony in support of Randy Mastro's nomination for Corporation Counsel. He speaks about Mastro's mentorship, professionalism, and ability to inspire loyalty and enthusiasm in others. …
11:00:23
·
99 sec
Testimony by Smitha Milich on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Smitha Milich testifies against Randy Mastro's nomination as Corporation Counsel, citing concerns about his past actions and associations. She criticizes Mastro's involvement in Giuliani's task force on bilingual education and …
11:02:23
·
113 sec
Testimony by Darren Mack, Co-founder of Freedom Agenda, on Randy Mastro's Nomination
Darren Mack, co-founder of Freedom Agenda, urges the city council to reject Randy Mastro's appointment as Corporation Counsel. He expresses concerns about Mastro's involvement in the Giuliani administration and the …
11:04:24
·
129 sec