New York City Council
Committee on Immigration
Jan 16, 2025
·
10:00 AM
6 hr 27 min
Summary
A hearing on New York City's protections and resources for immigrant communities in light of potential changes to federal immigration policies under the incoming Trump administration.
Discussions focused on:
- Strengthening sanctuary city policies
- Expanding legal services
- Improving agency compliance with existing laws
- Addressing concerns about increased ICE enforcement and family separations
The council introduced resolutions calling for state-level protections and a bill to create accountability for violations of city sanctuary laws.
Features testimony from the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs (MOIA), Office of Asylum Seeker Operations (OASO), and the public.
Meeting chapters
Read summaries and watch videos for short segments that matter to you.
Council Member Aviles opens the immigration committee hearing
Council Member Alexa Aviles calls the immigration committee hearing to order and introduces the attendees, including other council members and available interpretation services. - Hearing focuses on examining New York …
0:06:44
·
60 sec
Council Member Aviles emphasizes the need to protect immigrant communities
Council Member Aviles stresses the importance of protecting immigrant communities in light of the incoming presidential administration's promised policies on immigration. - New York City is described as a long-standing …
0:07:46
·
88 sec
New York City's history and commitment as a sanctuary city
Council Member Aviles discusses New York City's past efforts and commitment to being a sanctuary city, highlighting the importance of protecting immigrant communities. - Mentions the 2017 efforts to codify …
0:09:15
·
79 sec
Examination of New York City's current protections and resources for immigrants
Council Member Aviles examines the current protections and resources New York City offers to immigrant communities, emphasizing the importance of upholding and strengthening these measures. - Discusses the benefits of …
0:10:35
·
3 min
Introduction of legislation supporting immigrant protections
Council Member Aviles introduces two resolutions aimed at strengthening protections for immigrants at the state level. - Presents a resolution calling for the passage of the New York for All …
0:13:43
·
77 sec
Council Member Aviles concludes with acknowledgments and introduces the next speaker
Council Member Aviles concludes her opening remarks by acknowledging and thanking the staff involved in organizing the hearing. - Thanks committee staff, including legislative counsel, policy analyst, and financial analysts …
0:15:00
·
38 sec
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams addresses immigrant protections in New York City
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams delivers remarks on the importance of protecting immigrant communities in New York City, especially in light of potential changes in federal immigration policies. He emphasizes the …
0:15:40
·
4 min
Council Member Shahana K. Hanif speaks on Resolution 2970 and immigrant protections
Council Member Shahana K. Hanif delivers remarks on Resolution 2970, urging the state legislature to pass the New York for All Act, which would prohibit state and local resources from …
0:20:25
·
169 sec
Council Member Crystal Hudson advocates for immigrant rights and legal representation
Council Member Crystal Hudson discusses her efforts to expand legal representation for immigrants and urges support for state legislation to protect immigrant rights. She emphasizes the importance of providing free …
0:23:23
·
89 sec
Introduction and personal background of MOIA Commissioner Manuel Castro
Manuel Castro, Commissioner of the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs (MOIA), introduces himself and shares his personal immigration story. He expresses his deep personal connection to the work and his …
0:25:37
·
125 sec
Transition planning for potential changes in federal administration
Commissioner Castro outlines the city government's efforts in transition planning in response to potential changes in the federal administration. The planning process has been ongoing since the summer of the …
0:27:44
·
60 sec
Reinforcement of sanctuary laws and guidance to city agencies
Commissioner Castro details MOIA's efforts to reinforce sanctuary laws and provide guidance to city agencies. The focus is on ensuring that immigrant New Yorkers can access city services without fear, …
0:28:44
·
93 sec
Interagency collaboration and communication on immigrant issues
Commissioner Castro highlights the increased collaboration and communication across city agencies to address issues impacting immigrant New Yorkers. This effort aims to ensure a coordinated response to immigrant concerns. - …
0:30:18
·
32 sec
Launch of MOIA Immigrant Rights Collaborative for community outreach
Commissioner Castro announces the launch of the MOIA Immigrant Rights Collaborative, an initiative aimed at delivering immigrant rights presentations and information to various community spaces. This program expands upon MOIA's …
0:30:51
·
100 sec
Communications campaign and multilingual materials on immigrant rights
Commissioner Castro outlines MOIA's launch of a communications campaign to inform immigrant communities about their legal rights. This initiative aims to counteract misinformation and empower immigrants with accurate information. - …
0:32:34
·
70 sec
Launch of MOIA's immigration legal support centers initiative
Commissioner Castro announces the upcoming launch of MOIA's immigration legal support centers initiative. This program aims to provide comprehensive legal and support services to immigrant communities. - The initiative represents …
0:33:45
·
60 sec
Commissioner's personal commitment and concluding remarks
Commissioner Castro concludes his testimony by reaffirming his personal commitment to supporting immigrant communities and expressing readiness to face future challenges. He draws on his personal experiences to emphasize the …
0:34:45
·
60 sec
Council Member Aviles introduces questioning session and requests concise answers
Council Member Alexa Aviles opens the questioning session by thanking the commissioner for summarizing their testimony. She emphasizes the need for concise answers due to time constraints and sets the …
0:35:48
·
27 sec
MOIA's advisory role on sanctuary and detainer laws
Council Member Aviles inquires about MOIA's role in advising on the city's sanctuary and detainer laws. Commissioner Castro explains MOIA's important advisory role to deputy mayors and the mayor on …
0:36:15
·
135 sec
Staffing at MOIA dedicated to sanctuary law work
Council Member Aviles inquires about the specific staffing at MOIA dedicated to sanctuary and detainer law work. Rebecca Engel, Director of Policy and Legislative Affairs at MOIA, explains her role …
0:38:31
·
112 sec
MOIA's interactions with NYPD, DOC, and DOP on detainer requests
Council Member Aviles questions MOIA representatives about their interactions with NYPD, Department of Corrections, and Department of Probation regarding detainer requests. Rebecca Engel explains MOIA's engagement with these agencies. - …
0:40:23
·
71 sec
Accountability measures in agency policies related to sanctuary laws
Council Member Aviles inquires about accountability elements within the policies MOIA helps develop for city agencies regarding sanctuary laws. Rebecca Engel explains the reporting requirements and MOIA's role in ensuring …
0:41:35
·
88 sec
MOIA's point of contact for immigration attorneys and public defenders
Council Member Aviles inquires about MOIA's point of contact for immigration attorneys and public defenders seeking to prevent the transfer of their clients into federal immigration custody. MOIA representatives provide …
0:43:03
·
51 sec
MOIA's process for handling requests for legal assistance
Council Member Aviles questions MOIA representatives about their process for handling requests for legal assistance. Commissioner Castro and other MOIA staff explain their referral system and the scope of their …
0:43:55
·
3 min
Inter-agency task force meetings under Local Law 186 of 2017
Council Member Aviles inquires about the frequency and nature of inter-agency task force meetings mandated by Local Law 186 of 2017. MOIA representatives provide details on recent meetings and participation. …
0:47:16
·
136 sec
Level of agency representation and outcomes of inter-agency task force meetings
Council Member Aviles inquires about the seniority of agency representatives attending the task force meetings and the outcomes of these meetings. MOIA representatives provide information on attendee levels and specific …
0:49:33
·
144 sec
Expansion of Know Your Rights workshops and immigrant rights training
Council Member Jumaane Williams inquires about the expansion of immigrant rights workshops and training for other city agencies. Commissioner Manuel Castro and Chief Policy Advisor Lorena Lucero respond, detailing the …
0:52:39
·
116 sec
MOIA's role in briefing the mayor on sanctuary city laws
Council Member Jumaane Williams questions Commissioner Manuel Castro about MOIA's role in briefing the mayor on sanctuary city laws, expressing concern about the mayor's apparent lack of understanding. - MOIA …
0:54:50
·
33 sec
Constitutional rights of asylum seekers and coordination with ICE
Council Member Jumaane Williams questions Commissioner Manuel Castro about the constitutional rights of asylum seekers and undocumented immigrants, as well as the city's coordination with ICE on certain crimes. - …
0:55:23
·
89 sec
Concerns over divisive statements and misinformation about immigrant costs
Council Member Jumaane Williams raises concerns about divisive statements and misinformation regarding the $6 billion cost associated with migrants, questioning Commissioner Manuel Castro about efforts to address this issue with …
0:56:52
·
77 sec
Call for unity and protection of all New Yorkers amid immigration challenges
Council Member Jumaane Williams concludes with remarks on the need for a balanced approach to immigration challenges, emphasizing unity and protection for all New Yorkers. - Williams acknowledges failures at …
0:58:09
·
75 sec
Council member inquires about upholding sanctuary protections under new administration
Council Member Sandy Nurse questions MOIA officials about the city's commitment to upholding sanctuary protections during the incoming Trump administration. The discussion covers the removal of ICE from Rikers jails, …
0:59:34
·
179 sec
Clarification on NYPD's role in civil immigration enforcement
Council Member Sandy Nurse seeks clarification on whether the NYPD can make arrests solely for civil immigration enforcement purposes without a judicial warrant. The discussion reveals some initial confusion in …
1:02:34
·
25 sec
MOIA's considerations for street vendors under new immigration policies
Council Member Sandy Nurse inquires about MOIA's considerations for street vendors who might be impacted by changes in federal administration. MOIA officials discuss their ongoing efforts to address concerns for …
1:02:59
·
109 sec
DOC's interpretation of detainer laws and MOIA's involvement
Council Member Aviles inquires about the Department of Corrections' (DOC) interpretation of detainer laws and MOIA's involvement in ensuring compliance. MOIA representatives explain their monitoring process and assert that DOC …
1:04:52
·
69 sec
MOIA's guidance and training for city agencies on sanctuary laws
MOIA representatives discuss the guidance and training they provide to city agencies regarding sanctuary laws. They outline the broad issues covered in their training sessions and emphasize the importance of …
1:06:18
·
45 sec
Allegations of DOC violating detainer laws and colluding with ICE
Council Member Aviles presents allegations of the Department of Corrections (DOC) violating city detainer laws and colluding with ICE, based on results from a FOIL request. MOIA Commissioner Manuel Castro …
1:07:05
·
154 sec
MOIA's response to allegations and accountability measures
Council Member Aviles presses MOIA representatives on their response to allegations of DOC violations and their approach to ensuring accountability. MOIA representatives struggle to provide specific answers about their engagement …
1:09:39
·
112 sec
MOIA's advisory role to the mayor on accountability for sanctuary law violations
Council Member Aviles questions MOIA Commissioner Manuel Castro about the office's advisory role to the mayor regarding accountability for sanctuary law violations. The exchange is tense, with the Council Member …
1:11:32
·
46 sec
Agency policies and protocols for implementing sanctuary laws
Council Member Shahana K. Hanif questions MOIA representatives about agency policies and protocols for implementing sanctuary laws. MOIA officials confirm that they now require all city agencies to have written …
1:12:22
·
43 sec
Training of city employees on immigration enforcement policies
Council Member Shahana K. Hanif inquires about the training of city employees regarding their obligations not to use resources for immigration enforcement. MOIA representatives explain the ongoing training efforts and …
1:13:05
·
4 min
Recent agency guidance on sanctuary laws
Council Member Shahana K. Hanif inquires about the most recent agency guidance issued regarding sanctuary laws. MOIA representatives provide information on recent communications and documents distributed to city agencies. - …
1:17:35
·
67 sec
ACS incident violating Local Law 228
Council Member Shahana K. Hanif raises concerns about a 2024 incident where an ACS staff person communicated with ICE in violation of Local Law 228, resulting in the detention of …
1:18:43
·
62 sec
MOIA's reporting of sanctuary law violations
Council Member Shahana K. Hanif questions MOIA about the omission of the ACS incident from their 2023-2024 compliance reports. MOIA representatives explain the situation and how it was addressed. - …
1:19:45
·
35 sec
Council member inquires about feedback and implementation of sanctuary law trainings
Council Member Aviles questions MOIA representatives about agency feedback on sanctuary law trainings and the expectations for implementing these trainings across city agencies. The discussion reveals that while specific feedback …
1:20:21
·
95 sec
City's preparations for potential ICE enforcement at sensitive locations
Council Member Aviles questions MOIA representatives about the city's preparations for potential ICE enforcement at sensitive locations like hospitals, schools, and religious institutions. The discussion reveals that the city is …
1:21:57
·
3 min
City's preparation for potential changes to Temporary Protected Status
Council Member Aviles inquires about the city's preparations for potential changes to Temporary Protected Status (TPS) that could leave thousands without protection from deportation and work authorization. MOIA Commissioner Castro …
1:25:37
·
86 sec
Exploration of expanded legal services and funding commitments for immigrants
Council Member Aviles presses MOIA representatives on plans to expand legal services for immigrants and secure additional funding commitments. The discussion reveals that while MOIA is exploring options, there are …
1:27:03
·
3 min
City's preparation for possible termination of DACA program
Council Member Aviles inquires about the city's preparation for a possible federal attempt to terminate the DACA program. MOIA Commissioner Castro responds, highlighting the agency's concerns and limitations. - MOIA …
1:30:04
·
74 sec
Distribution of updated materials on immigrant rights
Council Member Aviles questions MOIA about the distribution of updated materials on immigrant rights in various languages. The discussion reveals some gaps in the current distribution strategy. - MOIA is …
1:31:19
·
89 sec
MOIA's communications campaign to inform immigrant communities
Council Member Aviles asks for details about MOIA's planned communications campaign to inform immigrant communities. Commissioner Castro outlines the goals and strategies of the campaign. - The campaign aims to …
1:32:48
·
88 sec
City's advocacy for state legislation supporting immigrants
Council Member Aviles presses MOIA representatives on the city's advocacy for state legislation supporting immigrants. The exchange reveals limited information and some frustration from the council member. - MOIA representatives …
1:34:17
·
151 sec
Discussion on communications plan and budget for informing immigrant communities
Council Member Sandy Nurse inquires about the communications plan and budget for informing immigrant communities, specifically asking about radio, print billboards, and signage. Commissioner Manuel Castro responds that they are …
1:36:49
·
56 sec
Importance of diverse media platforms for immigrant outreach
Council Member Sandy Nurse emphasizes the importance of saturating various media platforms to reach immigrant communities effectively. She suggests using multiple channels to disseminate information about immigrant rights and services. …
1:37:46
·
17 sec
Educating non-immigrants and consequences for violating sanctuary laws
Council Member Sandy Nurse discusses the importance of educating non-immigrant New Yorkers about immigrant rights and inquires about consequences for public servants who violate sanctuary laws. Commissioner Manuel Castro explains …
1:38:04
·
126 sec
Investigation of ACS incident involving potential sanctuary law violation
Council Member Sandy Nurse inquires about a specific incident at ACS (Administration for Children's Services) involving a potential violation of sanctuary laws. The MOIA representatives are unable to provide specific …
1:40:09
·
46 sec
Consideration of tracking mechanism for sanctuary law violations
Council Member Sandy Nurse suggests implementing a tracking mechanism to monitor potential sanctuary law violations. MOIA representatives acknowledge they don't currently have such a system but are open to considering …
1:40:55
·
36 sec
Proactive engagement with agencies to ensure compliance with sanctuary laws
Council Member Alexa Aviles emphasizes the need for proactive engagement with agencies to ensure compliance with sanctuary laws. She highlights existing evidence of law-breaking and calls for more robust validation …
1:41:31
·
52 sec
Engagement with industries and advocacy groups regarding potential ICE raids
Council Member Alexa Aviles inquires about MOIA's engagement with industries like hospitality and construction, as well as advocacy groups, regarding potential ICE raids. Commissioner Manuel Castro explains their collaborative efforts …
1:42:25
·
115 sec
NYPD's participation in joint task forces and compliance with local laws
Council Member Alexa Aviles questions the administration's measures to ensure NYPD's participation in joint task forces with federal authorities doesn't violate local immigration laws. MOIA representatives provide limited information, citing …
1:44:22
·
103 sec
Administration's commitment to maintaining trust with immigrant communities
Commissioner Manuel Castro reaffirms the administration's commitment to maintaining trust with immigrant communities and upholding sanctuary laws. He emphasizes the importance of this trust for effectively serving immigrant populations. - …
1:46:04
·
55 sec
Council Member Hudson questions MOIA on immigrant advocacy and sanctuary laws
Council Member Crystal Hudson engages in a Q&A session with representatives from the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs (MOIA), focusing on their engagement with immigration advocates and the city's stance …
1:47:01
·
4 min
Council member expresses concerns about mixed messaging on immigrant protections
Council Member Shekar Krishan raises concerns about mixed messaging from City Hall regarding cooperation with the Trump administration and compliance with sanctuary laws. He emphasizes the need for clear communication …
1:51:46
·
137 sec
Commissioner outlines MOIA's efforts to ensure compliance with sanctuary laws
Commissioner Manuel Castro responds to concerns by outlining steps taken by MOIA to ensure compliance with sanctuary laws and provide clear messaging to immigrant communities. - Castro mentions sending written …
1:54:04
·
123 sec
Discussion on details of agency trainings for sanctuary law compliance
Council Member Krishan and Lorena Lucero engage in a Q&A about the specifics of agency trainings on sanctuary laws and immigrant protections. - Lucero reports that over 70 agencies attended …
1:56:07
·
84 sec
Inquiry into confidentiality of training content and council member's closing remarks
Council Member Krishan inquires about the confidentiality of training content and agency questions, followed by his closing remarks on the importance of transparency in the city's efforts to protect immigrants. …
1:57:32
·
43 sec
Council member Brewer discusses TPS concerns and alternative pathways
Council Member Gale A. Brewer expresses concern about the future of Temporary Protected Status (TPS) under the new administration and inquires about alternative options for immigrants. Officials from MOIA and …
1:58:20
·
141 sec
Council member Brewer inquires about ICE enforcement at sensitive locations
Council Member Gale A. Brewer raises concerns about ICE enforcement at sensitive locations such as faith-based institutions and schools, asking for clarification on protocols. MOIA Commissioner Manuel Castro responds by …
2:00:44
·
106 sec
Discussion on immigrant rights training for faith-based institutions
Council Member Gale A. Brewer and MOIA officials discuss the need for targeted immigrant rights training for faith-based institutions. Brewer expresses concern about the urgency of the situation and the …
2:02:31
·
58 sec
Council member Brewer discusses cost and retention of migrants in New York City
Council Member Gale A. Brewer raises concerns about the significant financial investment in supporting migrants and questions the policy of encouraging them to leave New York City. She seeks information …
2:03:29
·
133 sec
Clarification of exceptions to sanctuary laws and detainer policies
Council Member Alexa Aviles seeks clarification on the exceptions to sanctuary laws, particularly regarding criminal carve-outs for detainers. Rebecca Engel from MOIA explains the current detainer law, which allows honoring …
2:05:44
·
107 sec
Asylum application help center's preparation for policy changes
Council Member Alexa Aviles inquires about how the asylum application help center is preparing to adapt to potential policy changes, particularly regarding Temporary Protected Status (TPS) applications. Molly Schaeffer from …
2:07:31
·
112 sec
Proactive outreach and appointment scheduling for immigrants
Molly Schaeffer from OASO discusses their proactive approach to reaching out to immigrants and scheduling appointments for legal assistance. The office uses centralized data to identify eligible individuals and facilitate …
2:09:23
·
73 sec
Plans for funding and restructuring legal representation for immigrants
Molly Schaeffer from OASO outlines plans to restructure and fund legal representation for immigrants in the coming year. The office is working with the state to reinvest in and modify …
2:10:37
·
61 sec
State and federal advocacy efforts for immigrant rights
Molly Schaeffer and Kelly Yzique Zea from OASO discuss their ongoing state and federal advocacy efforts for immigrant rights. They outline their focus areas and strategies for both current and …
2:11:40
·
64 sec
Compliance with laws restricting access to non-public areas and protecting immigrant information
Molly Schaeffer from OASO explains how they ensure compliance with laws restricting access to non-public areas and protecting immigrant information in the context of the shelter system for immigrant newcomers. …
2:12:46
·
131 sec
Training of shelter staff on access policies and privacy laws
Molly Schaeffer from OASO discusses the training of shelter staff on access policies and privacy laws, highlighting the differences between DHS and non-DHS systems. - Training responsibilities vary, with MOIA …
2:14:57
·
84 sec
Privacy measures for mail handling in immigrant shelters
Molly Schaeffer from OASO explains how they ensure compliance with privacy laws in the context of mail rooms for newcomers in shelters. - The same privacy system used for all …
2:16:24
·
41 sec
Request for December data on 60-day notice requests
Council Member Alexa Aviles inquires about the missing December data for 60-day notice requests, which the administration has been providing to the council on a monthly basis. - The council …
2:17:05
·
21 sec
Transition of immigrants from non-DHS to DHS shelter systems
Molly Schaeffer from OASO discusses the plans for transitioning individuals and families from non-DHS shelters to the traditional DHS shelter system. - OASO is working with both DHS and non-DHS …
2:17:33
·
48 sec
Communication issues between shelter staff and residents regarding relocation
Council Member Alexa Aviles raises concerns about alarming messages being communicated to residents in non-DHS shelters regarding relocation. Molly Schaeffer from OASO responds to these concerns. - Aviles reports receiving …
2:18:23
·
77 sec
Council member inquires about Moya's efforts for Know Your Rights workshops and community outreach
Council Member Shekar Krishan questions Commissioner Manuel Castro and Chief Policy Advisor Lorena Lucero about the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs' (MOIA) efforts to inform immigrants of their rights through …
2:19:41
·
5 min
Discussion on funding and support for legal services organizations
Council Member Shekar Krishan inquires about efforts to fast-track funding for legal services organizations in anticipation of increased caseloads. Commissioner Manuel Castro responds by describing current efforts and acknowledging the …
2:24:54
·
146 sec
Inquiry into future plans for OASO and legal representation
Council Member Shekar Krishan seeks clarification on the future plans of the Office of Asylum Seeker Operations (OASO) regarding legal work and incorporation of legal service providers. Director Molly Schaeffer …
2:27:20
·
73 sec
Council member inquires about documentation of shelter staff training on privacy laws
Council Member Alexa Aviles requests documentation on the number of employees trained at sites regarding their duties to follow privacy laws. Molly Schaeffer from the Mayor's Office of Asylum Seeker …
2:28:33
·
20 sec
Clarification on legal support centers and Action NYC program
Council Member Alexa Aviles seeks clarification on the relationship between immigration legal support centers and the Action NYC program. Commissioner Manuel Castro explains that they are moving away from the …
2:28:55
·
3 min
Funding distribution for immigration legal support centers
Council Member Alexa Aviles inquires about the distribution of $18 million for immigration legal support centers over a 3-year plan. Commissioner Manuel Castro explains that each provider will receive approximately …
2:32:38
·
123 sec
Selection process for providers of immigration legal support centers
Council Member Alexa Aviles inquires about the selection process for the 25 providers of immigration legal support centers. Commissioner Manuel Castro explains that the selection process is ongoing and that …
2:34:44
·
19 sec
Services provided by immigration legal support centers
Council Member Alexa Aviles inquires about the specific immigration services that will be provided under the new legal service program. Commissioner Manuel Castro explains that the services will include a …
2:35:05
·
30 sec
Funding for existing legal service providers and transition period
Council Member Alexa Aviles inquires about funding for existing legal service providers during the transition period and in light of expected increased workload. Commissioner Manuel Castro explains that existing contracts …
2:35:41
·
117 sec
Council Member Brewer discusses security measures for community spaces during immigration enforcement concerns
Council Member Gale A. Brewer inquires about recommended security measures for community spaces, particularly faith-based communities, in light of increased immigration enforcement concerns. She discusses the idea of using RSVP …
2:37:38
·
96 sec
Council Member Alexa Aviles delivers closing remarks on immigrant protections
Council Member Alexa Aviles concludes the hearing by emphasizing the need for strong and unambiguous protection of immigrant communities in New York City. She calls for clear language and policies …
2:39:18
·
56 sec
Testimony by Assembly Member Catalina Cruz, New York State Assembly, on Immigrant Rights and Legal Representation
Assembly Member Catalina Cruz testified on the importance of two key pieces of legislation: the Access to Representation Act (ARA) and the New York for All Act. She emphasized the …
2:43:17
·
7 min
Council member praises legislation and city-state partnership
Council Member Alexa Aviles expresses strong support for Assembly Member Cruz's legislation and the partnership between New York City and State in protecting immigrant rights. She emphasizes the importance of …
2:51:11
·
71 sec
Call for statewide coverage and continued support for immigrant protections
Council Member Aviles emphasizes the need for statewide coverage of immigrant protections and expresses the city council's commitment to supporting state-level efforts. - Aviles stresses the importance of ensuring the …
2:52:22
·
37 sec
Testimony by Claudia Valdivia, Member of the Public, on Immigrant Community Concerns
Claudia Valdivia, speaking through a Spanish interpreter, expresses deep concern about the impact of the incoming Trump administration on immigrant communities in New York City. She emphasizes the importance of …
2:54:11
·
7 min
Testimony by Dhaliem, Youth Leader from Make the Road New York
Dhaliem, a youth leader from Make the Road New York and a senior at International High School, testified about the need for immediate action to support and protect immigrant youth …
3:02:21
·
4 min
Council member expresses gratitude and agreement with youth leader's testimony
Council Member Alexa Aviles responds to Dhaliem's testimony with strong support and agreement. She acknowledges the impact of police presence in schools and the importance of resources over increased policing. …
3:06:48
·
78 sec
Council Member Brewer questions youth leader about school safety and ICE preparedness
Council Member Gale A. Brewer engages in a Q&A session with Dhaliem, a youth leader from Make the Road New York, about safety measures and ICE preparedness in schools. Dhaliem …
3:08:09
·
3 min
Testimony by Ximena Bustamante, Representative of Undocumented Women's Fund
Ximena Bustamante from the Undocumented Women's Fund testified about concerns regarding the lack of protections for residents in the parallel shelter system for recent arrivals. She emphasized the need for …
3:14:55
·
3 min
Testimony by Kelvin Arrocha, Immigrant Detainee, read by Rosa Cohen-Cruz, Attorney from The Bronx Defenders
Kelvin Arrocha's testimony, read by his attorney Rosa Cohen-Cruz, recounts his traumatic experience with NYPD and ICE collaboration, leading to his unjust arrest and detention. He highlights violations of sanctuary …
3:18:45
·
3 min
Council member's response to testimony on NYPD and ICE collaboration
Council Member Alexa Aviles responds to Rosa Cohen-Cruz's testimony on behalf of Kelvin Sarita Arrocha. She acknowledges the violation of law and lack of accountability in the case of NYPD …
3:22:03
·
25 sec
Brief Q&A on NYPD-ICE relationship and additional recommendations
Council Member Alexa Aviles begins a brief Q&A with Rosa Cohen-Cruz about the NYPD-ICE relationship and potential recommendations, but decides to postpone it for Rosa's full testimony later. - Aviles …
3:22:28
·
40 sec
Testimony by Garfield Green, Member of the Public
Garfield Green, a member of the public, shares his deeply personal and emotional experience with immigration detention and its impact on his family. He describes the hardships he faced, including …
3:23:11
·
4 min
Council member acknowledges Mr. Green's testimony and expresses empathy
Council Member Alexa Aviles responds to Garfield Green's testimony with empathy and appreciation. She acknowledges his presence since early morning and expresses admiration for his bravery in the face of …
3:27:56
·
31 sec
Council member addresses broader immigration issues and offers support
Council Member Alexa Aviles discusses the broader context of immigration issues in the country and offers support to Mr. Green. She acknowledges the challenges ahead and expresses determination to effect …
3:28:28
·
42 sec
Testimony by Abou Cissé, Asylum Seeker from Mauritania
Abou Cissé, an asylum seeker from Mauritania, testifies about his concerns regarding the new administration's potential policies on immigration and asylum. He pleads for the opportunity to retain work permits …
3:29:53
·
4 min
Council member Aviles responds to testimony on immigrant contributions
Council Member Alexa Aviles responds to Mr. Cisse's testimony by highlighting the economic contributions of undocumented immigrants. She emphasizes that immigrants are not a drain on resources but rather provide …
3:34:02
·
42 sec
Testimony by Miral Abbas, Health Partnerships Coordinator at Coalition for Asian American Children and Families (CACF)
Miral Abbas from the Coalition for Asian American Children and Families (CACF) testified about the Access Health New York City initiative, urging the council to include $4,000,000 in funding for …
3:35:53
·
179 sec
Testimony by Justin Srey, Southeast Asian Defense Project Coordinator at Mekong NYC
Justin Srey from Mekong NYC testified about the challenges faced by Southeast Asian refugees in New York, particularly the threat of deportation under potential future Trump administration policies. He urged …
3:38:55
·
3 min
Testimony by Aracelis Lucero, Executive Director of Masa, on Immigrant Protections and Resources
Aracelis Lucero, Executive Director of Masa, testified about the impact of anti-immigrant policies on immigrant communities and urged the City Council to take swift action to protect immigrant New Yorkers. …
3:42:10
·
3 min
Testimony by Cresenciana Morales, Community Advocate at Mixteca, on Immigrant Community Concerns and Protection
Cresenciana Morales, a community advocate at Mixteca, testified about the increasing concerns and fears within the immigrant community following the recent presidential election. She highlighted the need for stronger protections …
3:45:28
·
145 sec
Testimony by Kulsoom Tapal, Education Policy Coordinator at Coalition for Asian American Children & Families (CACF)
Kulsoom Tapal from the Coalition for Asian American Children & Families (CACF) urged the New York City Council to strengthen protections for immigrant communities in light of rising anti-immigrant sentiment. …
3:48:05
·
146 sec
Testimony by Airenakhue B. Omoragbon, New York Policy Manager of African Communities Together (ACT)
Airenakhue B. Omoragbon from African Communities Together (ACT) testified on the urgent need for the New York City Council to protect immigrant communities in light of potential threats from the …
3:51:00
·
4 min
Testimony by Deborah Lee, Attorney in Charge of Immigration Law Unit at Legal Aid Society
Deborah Lee from the Legal Aid Society emphasizes the importance of reaffirming and strengthening sanctuary city laws in New York City. She argues for robust funding for immigration legal representation …
4:03:58
·
134 sec
Testimony by Leidis De La Rosa, Organizing Coordinator at La Colmena
Leidis De La Rosa, Organizing Coordinator at La Colmena, testified about the organization's work supporting immigrant communities on Staten Island and the challenges they face. She emphasized the need for …
4:06:18
·
98 sec
Testimony by Ellen Pachnanda, Director of Immigration Practice at Brooklyn Defender Services
Ellen Pachnanda, Director of Immigration Practice at Brooklyn Defender Services, testifies about protecting New York City's immigrant communities. She highlights the harmful effects of entanglement between criminal and immigration legal …
4:08:03
·
141 sec
Testimony by Jennifer, Immigrant from Venezuela
Jennifer, an immigrant from Venezuela, shares her traumatic experience of having her confidential information shared with ICE by local agencies, leading to her detention and separation from her children. She …
4:13:21
·
4 min
Q&A on collusion between city agencies and ICE
Council Member Alexa Aviles engages in a Q&A session with legal service providers about the extent of collusion between city agencies and ICE. The providers discuss the difficulty in quantifying …
4:17:37
·
83 sec
Testimony by Tania Mattos, Executive Director of Unlocal
Tania Mattos, Executive Director of Unlocal, emphasized the importance of New York City remaining a sanctuary city and highlighted the challenges faced by immigrants, including fear and uncertainty in shelters. …
4:20:46
·
3 min
Council member inquires about Action NYC contract issues
Council Member Alexa Aviles inquires about the repackaging of Action NYC and contract issues with Moya, particularly regarding increased workload without additional compensation. Tania Mattos from Unlocal responds that their …
4:24:11
·
31 sec
Testimony by Ingrid Rojas, Delivery Worker
Ingrid Rojas, a Guatemalan immigrant and mother of two, shared her experiences as a delivery worker in New York City. She described challenges faced during the pandemic, including alleged wage …
4:25:12
·
118 sec
Testimony by Wendy Veintimilla, Member of the Public, on Immigrant Experiences and Concerns
Wendy Veintimilla, an immigrant from Ecuador, shared her personal story of fleeing her country due to torture and threats, and her experiences as an undocumented immigrant in the United States. …
4:27:18
·
4 min
Testimony by Garly Poso, Member of the Public, on Labor Abuses and Immigration Concerns
Garly Poso, speaking through a Spanish interpreter, shared her experiences of labor exploitation and abuse as an immigrant worker. She described poor working conditions, including long hours, low pay, and …
4:32:01
·
3 min
Testimony by Antonio Solis, Member of the Public
Antonio Solis, speaking through a Spanish interpreter, provides brief testimony on the challenges faced by immigrant workers in New York City. He emphasizes the need for continued efforts to protect …
4:35:17
·
3 min
Testimony by Lauren Migliaccio, Training and Legal Technical Assistance Director at Immigrant Justice Corps
Lauren Migliaccio from Immigrant Justice Corps testifies about the impending challenges for immigrant communities under the new administration. She emphasizes the urgent need for legal services, funding, and training to …
4:39:39
·
150 sec
Testimony by Thinley Wangchuk, Data Analysis and Communications Coordinator at Korean American Family Service Center (KAFSC)
Thinley Wangchuk from the Korean American Family Service Center (KAFSC) testified about the organization's work supporting immigrant survivors of gender-based violence and the challenges they face. He emphasized the need …
4:42:17
·
161 sec
Testimony by Lauren Reiff, Associate Director of the Immigrant Protection Unit at New York Legal Assistance Group (NYLAG)
Lauren Reiff from NYLAG testifies about the urgent need for action to protect immigrants in light of increased ICE enforcement and data collection concerns. She highlights the ramping up of …
4:45:04
·
3 min
Testimony by Rosa Cohen-Cruz, Director of Immigration Policy at The Bronx Defenders
Rosa Cohen-Cruz, representing The Bronx Defenders, testified about the urgent need for stronger protections for immigrants in New York City. She highlighted ongoing violations of existing sanctuary laws by agencies …
4:48:08
·
3 min
Testimony by Keighly Rector, Director of Immigration Project at Volunteers of Legal Service (VOLS)
Keighly Rector, Director of the Immigration Project at Volunteers of Legal Service (VOLS), testified on the importance of strengthening sanctuary policies, increasing support for long-term noncitizen residents, and addressing problematic …
4:51:33
·
5 min
Council member acknowledges tragedy of Yeremi's case
Council Member Alexa Aviles acknowledges the tragic case of Yeremi, expressing sympathy for the family's trauma and emphasizing the need for improvement in handling such situations. - Yeremi was connected …
4:57:09
·
36 sec
Council member addresses concerns of long-term immigrant residents
Council Member Alexa Aviles acknowledges the importance of supporting long-term immigrant residents, emphasizing the need for a comprehensive approach to immigrant support in New York City. - Recognizes concerns of …
4:57:48
·
22 sec
Testimony by Margaret Martin, Co-Director of Immigrant and Refugee Services Division at Catholic Charities Community Services
Margaret Martin, representing Catholic Charities Community Services, testifies about the organization's work supporting immigrant communities and expresses concerns about protecting immigrants in light of potential changes to sanctuary policies. She …
4:58:14
·
3 min
Testimony by Sierra Kraft, Executive Director of Immigrant Children Advocates' Relief Effort (ICARE)
Sierra Kraft, Executive Director of ICARE, testified on the urgent need for increased protections and resources for immigrant youth in New York City. She highlighted the importance of legal representation …
5:02:59
·
138 sec
Testimony by Zachary Ahmed, Senior Policy Counsel at New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU)
Zachary Ahmed from NYCLU addresses the upcoming Trump administration and Mayor Adams' stance on immigration policies. He emphasizes the importance of maintaining and strengthening New York City's sanctuary laws and …
5:05:22
·
176 sec
Testimony by Marie Mark, Executive Director of Immigrant Defense Project, on Sanctuary City Policies and Immigrant Protections
Marie Mark, Executive Director of the Immigrant Defense Project, testified on the importance of sanctuary city policies and the need for stronger protections for immigrants in New York City. She …
5:08:22
·
168 sec
Testimony by Mackenna Vickery, Paralegal at The Door's Legal Services Center
Mackenna Vickery, a paralegal from The Door's Legal Services Center, testified about the challenges faced by young immigrants in New York City and the potential impact of increased ICE enforcement. …
5:11:15
·
116 sec
Testimony by Ashley Peguero, Manager of Queen's Community Program at Violence Intervention Program (VIP)
Ashley Peguero from the Violence Intervention Program (VIP) testified about the challenges faced by immigrant survivors of domestic and sexual violence in New York City. She highlighted the need for …
5:13:16
·
148 sec
Testimony by Taina Wagnac, Senior Manager of State and Local Policy at New York Immigration Coalition
Taina Wagnac from the New York Immigration Coalition urges the City Council to act decisively to protect immigrant New Yorkers in the face of potential threats from the right wing. …
5:15:49
·
145 sec
Testimony by Sophie Dalsimer, Co-Director of the Health Justice Program at New York Lawyers for the Public Interest (NYLPI)
Sophie Dalsimer from NYLPI's Health Justice Program testifies on the importance of protecting immigrant communities from ICE enforcement to ensure access to healthcare for all New Yorkers. She emphasizes the …
5:19:25
·
166 sec
Testimony by Alison Wilkey, Director of Government Affairs and Strategic Campaigns at Coalition For the Homeless
Alison Wilkey's testimony focused on the challenges faced by new arrivals in New York City, particularly those living in shelters. She expressed concerns about the city's handling of shelter facilities …
5:22:28
·
150 sec
Testimony by Juan Diaz, Policy Associate at Citizens' Community for Children
Juan Diaz, a policy associate at Citizens' Community for Children, testified about the potential impact of the incoming federal administration's immigration policies on New York City's immigrant communities, especially children …
5:25:10
·
3 min
Testimony by Manuela Osorio, Digital Organizer at Latino Justice PRLDEF, on New York City's Role in National Immigration Landscape
Manuela Osorio, a permanent resident and digital organizer for Latino Justice PRLDEF, addressed the New York City Council regarding the city's role in protecting immigrants and the need for stronger …
5:28:38
·
146 sec
Testimony by Jade Vasquez, Director of Policy and Research at Women in Need Inc (WIN)
Jade Vasquez from WIN testifies on protecting immigrant communities from harmful policies of the incoming Trump administration. She outlines WIN's role as a shelter provider and presents recommendations from their …
5:31:09
·
176 sec
Testimony by Alexandra Millatmal, Community Organizer from Afghans For A Better Tomorrow
Alexandra Millatmal, representing Afghans For A Better Tomorrow, urged the NYC City Council to oppose Trump's proposed immigration policies and support resolutions protecting asylum seekers. She shared experiences of Afghan …
5:34:31
·
170 sec
Testimony by Carina Kaufman-Gutierrez, Deputy Director of Street Vendor Project, on Street Vendor Issues and Immigrant Protections
Carina Kaufman-Gutierrez, Deputy Director of the Street Vendor Project, testified about the challenges faced by street vendors, particularly undocumented immigrants, due to harsh enforcement actions and criminalization. She highlighted the …
5:38:02
·
171 sec
Testimony by Isis Mireles, Member of the Public from Food Vendors Organization
Isis Mireles, a Mexican immigrant who became a US citizen in 2018, shares her personal story of immigration challenges and advocates for immigrant rights and street vendor reform. She emphasizes …
5:44:03
·
174 sec
Testimony by Marlene Ansaldo, Street Vendor, on Street Vendor Challenges and Harassment
Marlene Ansaldo, a street vendor with 21 years of experience, appeals to city authorities and council members for help in obtaining licenses and permits, and to stop harassment from sanitation …
5:48:52
·
76 sec
Testimony by Ahmed Murad, Street Vendor, on Challenges Faced by Immigrant Street Vendors
Ahmed Murad, a street vendor since 2012, testifies about the challenges and fears faced by immigrant street vendors in New York City. He emphasizes the importance of vending for immigrants' …
5:50:43
·
4 min
Council member acknowledges current challenges faced by street vendors
Council Member Alexa Aviles acknowledges the current challenges faced by street vendors and the proposals on the table to address these issues. She recognizes the double challenge they face as …
5:54:50
·
50 sec
Testimony by Cynthia Katz, Managing Attorney at HIAS
Cynthia Katz, Managing Attorney at HIAS, provided testimony in support of proposed legislation to protect immigrant communities in New York City. She highlighted HIAS's long history of supporting refugees and …
5:56:40
·
129 sec
Testimony by Lisha Luo Cai, Advocacy Coordinator at Asian American Federation
Lisha Luo Cai from the Asian American Federation testified on the importance of strengthening protections for immigrant communities in New York City, particularly in light of the incoming Trump administration. …
5:58:56
·
3 min
Council Member Aviles acknowledges Asian American Federation's work and immigrant community challenges
Council Member Alexa Aviles expresses gratitude for the Asian American Federation's long-standing work throughout New York City. She acknowledges the significant challenges faced by immigrant communities and emphasizes the importance …
6:02:27
·
43 sec
Testimony by Kevin Lee, Member of Rev Com Corps for the Emancipation of Humanity and Revolution Books, on Immigrant Rights and Anti-Fascism
Kevin Lee from Rev Com Corps and Revolution Books delivers an impassioned speech about the plight of immigrants in New York City and across the country. He condemns the actions …
6:03:24
·
3 min
Testimony by Raul Rivera, TLC Driver and Advocate
Raul Rivera, a TLC driver and advocate, provided controversial testimony expressing strong anti-immigration views and criticizing the City Council. He voiced support for ICE enforcement and challenged the council members' …
6:08:50
·
136 sec
Testimony by Maggie Sanchez, Public Advocate Appointee to the Citywide Council on Special Education, on Immigrant Protections and Education Concerns
Maggie Sanchez, speaking in her personal capacity, expressed concerns about recent charter amendments granting more power to the mayor and reducing City Council oversight. She urged the Council to support …
6:12:06
·
175 sec
Testimony by Jonathan Lam, Community Organizing Coordinator of New York Refugee and Migrants Rights Task Force
Jonathan Lam, representing the New York Refugee and Migrants Rights Task Force, shared his family's refugee experience and urged the council to protect migrants and refugees in New York City. …
6:15:11
·
125 sec
Testimony by Darnell Benoit, Founder of Flanbwayan Haitian Literacy Project, on Immigrant Student Safety and Education
Darnell Benoit, founder of Flanbwayan Haitian Literacy Project, testified on the critical issues impacting immigrant students in New York City Public Schools. She emphasized the need for more accessible schools …
6:17:31
·
4 min
Testimony by Christopher Leon Johnson, Member of the Public, on New York for All Resolution and Immigration Enforcement
Christopher Leon Johnson testifies in support of the New York for All resolution, emphasizing the need to protect non-violent immigrant workers from ICE cooperation. He calls for better education among …
6:22:23
·
152 sec
Council member responds to testimony about Trump and immigrant deportation
Council Member Alexa Aviles responds to Christopher's testimony about Trump's potential deportation policies. She expresses disagreement with Christopher's optimistic view while acknowledging his support for the proposed resolutions. - Aviles …
6:24:55
·
13 sec
Council member closes the hearing with procedural remarks and final statement
Council Member Alexa Aviles concludes the hearing with procedural remarks and a strong statement in support of immigrant New Yorkers. She covers final calls for testimony, information on submitting written …
6:25:09
·
111 sec